• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Next-Gen PS5 & XSX |OT| Console tEch threaD

Status
Not open for further replies.

Bo_Hazem

Banned
LOL every forum from Era to B3d has been talking about that $ 20 UHD cost for the past week lol. Sources, FFS.

They brought nothing to the table and just speculated on pricing, it was non technical and negative.

Curious to see those sources myself, and why this is the cheapest UHD Blu-ray at $268 if it's only a $20 to make:

 
Last edited:

husomc

Member
I just found their overall video very negative in tone, I am probably too sensitive in regards to this but their approach in that video surprised me, hard to put a finger on it, it just sounded rather downbeat.

for the excitement of new tech on the horizon i just expect more enthusiasm from them.
I felt the same way when I was watching that video as if they were trying to kill the hype. Digital Foundry is fast becoming like the Dictator who thinks they are treating their citizens very fairly.
 

IntentionalPun

Ask me about my wife's perfect butthole
Curious to see those sources myself, and why this is the cheapest UHD Blu-ray at $268 if it's only a $20 to make:

That's a full player though; going to have decoding chips and other processors.

Just a UHD BR drive on PC is like $130 or something.
 

TLZ

Banned
The 8$ is sonys extra cut from 3rd party sale on ps5 store, what about sony first party games....Sony get all the money. So DF were wrong on that, one first party game digital vs retail and compute that one.

Poor video.
Don't forget PS Plus subs, the stuff they sell in their store, etc.

Feels like Richard purposely left those out, but I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt and say he's forgotten about them when he mentioned the 4 games. This isn't 2006. We're in the digital services era now. He should know better, considering his whole DF business is on YouTube, a digital service platform.
 
T

Three Jackdaws

Unconfirmed Member
I just found their overall video very negative in tone, I am probably too sensitive in regards to this but their approach in that video surprised me, hard to put a finger on it, it just sounded rather downbeat.

for the excitement of new tech on the horizon i just expect more enthusiasm from them.
Yeah, I do my best to remain impartial and I usually like DF but when I was watching their video, it almost felt as if they were fear mongering about the PS5's size and price point, he literally spent the whole video discussing the potential issues consumers will face when buying the PS5, save that shit for tabloid gaming journalism and stick to deep tech analysis and reviews.

These are just my impressions personally, I won't hold it against them, I understand that they have to pump out videos every few days especially about the PS5 since they get the most views/engagements. There's more I can say but this a next-gen discussion and I rather not waste time discussing piss poor journalism.
 

Gamernyc78

Banned
I felt the same way when I was watching that video as if they were trying to kill the hype. Digital Foundry is fast becoming like the Dictator who thinks they are treating their citizens very fairly.

This is the biased shit ppl talk about if it was another console thy would have highlighted bs as positive.

It's annoying and transparent. It happens all the time.
 
Last edited:

12Dannu123

Member
If only Sony had a buzzword for this thing akin to "smart delivery"



We don't know what sort of integration to expect in next-gen Xbox. I suspect in the beginning it'll be similar to what you get on PlayStation, with dedicated share button now, streaming UI/interface should redirect you to stream via YouTube/Twitch/FB whatever it is.

Main takeaway is that they are cutting their losses, investment in that platform must have been in hundreds of million if not billions. Now, they seem to be going ultra deep with xCloud and their partnership with FB/IG. I don't know what to make of all this, Stadia announced partnership with YouTube for this sort of stuff and nothing came off it. So who knows?

IMO, this really leave PSNow in question for long term appeal. XCloud, Stadia and Amazon's service will be available on hundreds of Millions of people and Game Pass will be there to benefit from it. How does Sony fit into this picture? Sony is relying on their own proprietary hardware for Cloud Gaming so it makes it impossible to integrate XCloud, Stadia or Amazon Cloud gaming services with PSNow. As all three companies are relying on their own proprietary servers.
 
Last edited:

Bo_Hazem

Banned
So MS have shut down Mixer, and it seems like they are completely cutting their losses. Apparently, all big named streamers they signed in Shroud and Ninja got paid in FULL and are now free to stream elsewhere. Fair fucks to them for making bank but what a gigantic waste of investment from MS which could've been put elsewhere.



Really curious as to how they'll integrate streaming to next-gen consoles in conjunction with FB. I can already see continuous messages to have FB linked with Xbox Live.


I thought a youtube-like PS service would give Sony some favor? Something being 100% for gaming, not only PS as well. But I think it might be a big gamble to make.
 
Last edited:

SlimySnake

Flashless at the Golden Globes
I just found their overall video very negative in tone, I am probably too sensitive in regards to this but their approach in that video surprised me, hard to put a finger on it, it just sounded rather downbeat.

for the excitement of new tech on the horizon i just expect more enthusiasm from them.
i mean i have been telling you guys that this stuff isnt mind blowing to everyone. there isnt really that much to get enthused about since they showed pretty much nothing from a gameplay perspective. we got ratchet and some indie games showing last gen gameplay. ok.

its great that you guys think the ps5 games are the greatest thing since sliced bread, but a lot of us were expecting more. and i dont just mean better graphics.
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
I really liked The Order. It has some kind of really strong cinematic vibe. Shame that we will not see a sequel, it was one of the best looking games of generation IMO. A second part in style of the "The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen" would have been a blast.

Seems like it's still in Sony's hand anyway:

 

xacto

Member
The usual DF shilling, spread all kind of BS about the size and how it's hard to fit PS5 in a stupidly extremely tight fit that no one should use in current gen but not say the same about the XSX that makes it impossible in many benches.

Wasted 16 minutes of my life watching that, I would rather waste it on having fun elsewhere or learning something good.

So what's the TL;DW of that video again? It's been a long time since I've watched a DF video and had fun with it; lately it's like they're paid to polish turds and it's a bit pathetic.
 

xacto

Member
Seems like it's still in Sony's hand anyway:


Still I am a bit apprehensive of who's going to carry the torch for the next entry of this IP (if that's going to happen, anyway), it reminds me a bit of 2K in charge of the next Bioshock - Bioshock without Irrational Games and Ken Levine.
 

husomc

Member
i mean i have been telling you guys that this stuff isnt mind blowing to everyone. there isnt really that much to get enthused about since they showed pretty much nothing from a gameplay perspective. we got ratchet and some indie games showing last gen gameplay. ok.

its great that you guys think the ps5 games are the greatest thing since sliced bread, but a lot of us were expecting more. and i dont just mean better graphics.
Care to elaborate ? I'm quite curious to know what you were expecting ?
 

FeiRR

Banned
Well, (8x100)/60 = 13.33(3)%, that's how :)

I'm literally saying out of $60, 13% being the sum costs of selling that software is insane, especially when you add all those I described (i.e. printing, disc, shipping, storing, cut to the retailer). And I even didn't add VAT, so please insert that one somewhere in the equation. And before you say VAT is paid separately, that may be the case in the US, but at the very least in Europe it's part of the price, not a side thing.
It's included in the price but the price is higher (60 EUR is more than 60 USD). I heard from friends that in some European countries new games are even sold for 70 EUR.


Sony could still make a sequel to The Order since they own the IP, it's now just incredibly unlikely that RAD would be developing it.

Sony doesn't have a tradition of moving IPs around its internal studios for mainline games, but there have been rumors of the next Uncharted being done by a new SIE studio in San Diego, so who knows really.
New Uncharted, if it happens, will be a different game (characters, feeling, maybe even gameplay) so it only makes sense. I think ND are done with the franchise and that's good. Artists need to seek new inspirations or their creations become stale and predictable.

Probably. Match won't start unless everyone has completed their loading.
Depends on a game. DICE patched it in Battlefield because people with SSDs were occupying vehicles at the beginning of the round. But when I play, say, Division or Borderlands with friends, I can get quite far in a level while they still load and curse me ;).

Why would someone cheap out over $100 with an extremely underpowered console if it's not just an alternative console alongside PS5? And about digital, I'm not interested in physical at all, but would buy the regular one just in case, and I think the PS5DE will still sell strong. It's also a good way to slap "Starting at $399" for PS5, as most buyers end up buying the higher console, just like most high end phones and iPhone in particular with the ridiculous 64GB models and no memory extension options.
I don't use iPhones but I don't really care if my phone has 64 or even 32 GB. My photos upload to the cloud right after being taken, music I listen to is streamed. Even 32 GB is more than enough for the apps I use.

They will have to offer some lobby activities for next gen users so they can wait for current gen ones. :messenger_grinning_sweat:

You can spend this time in quality mode discussing other people's mothers.

DSC-4160.jpg
That Arab Sackboy is cute!

Curious to see those sources myself, and why this is the cheapest UHD Blu-ray at $268 if it's only a $20 to make:
A BD player isn't just the drive, it has other components. Also, if it were $99 nobody would want it.
 

xacto

Member
Curious to see those sources myself, and why this is the cheapest UHD Blu-ray at $268 if it's only a $20 to make:



You're paying for the brand, I guess?
 

FeiRR

Banned

zaitsu

Banned
On ANY platform... to DOUBLE the frame rate you must take more than a drop to 1440 from 4k.... you'll also need to reduce effects to DOUBLE the frame rate to a stable 60 from a stable 30 unless the game was already actually running like 45fps and the devs had it locked at 30 to reduce the tear.
Nit true at all. Beside game in performance mode is 4k dynamic 60fps
 
Welcome to using Windows; it's far from impossible though.

Also there's a Pioneer Blu-Ray drive in there at $133. So paying way less than that Sony drive posted earlier.
Sony could include the Media Remote with the PS5 to sell us the idea that we are buying a Home Cinema System too. It could even have its own UI and works without turn on the PS5.

This is why $499 and $399 makes sense to me.
 
Last edited:

azertydu91

Hard to Kill
Last edited:
I don't know if this was already discussed, but, while I was looking at some GPUs to help a friend of mine build a new rig, I noticed something odd:
1080TI: 3584 Shading Units, Base Clock 1481 MHz, FP32 performance 11.5 TFLOPS
2080: 2944 Shading Units, Base Clock 1515 MHz, FP32 performance 10.07 TFLOPS

So, we have two cards, one having more but slower compute units, the other has a smaller amount of compute units, just a bit faster.
The GTX 1080TI has a higher core count and a bigger TFLOPS count, meanwhile the 2080 has the only advantage of higher frequencies.
In most specialized benchmark, the 1080TI is always on top compared to the 2080.
But, try to guess, who's the one that runs better every game???
The RTX 2080!!!

Mind blown.

Imagine being this dense holy shit

You are comparing two different architectures. I know what you're alluding with your thinly veiled post but XSX and PS5 are both RDNA2 based. Compare the 2080 to a 2070 or a 2060 can come back with your findings.

And please stop helping anyone build PCs
 
Last edited:

FeiRR

Banned
Not necessarily a Sony TV as long as it has CEC or whatever the tech is called on your tv you can control your ps4 with the TV remote.

You can check here all the names that brand uses that is CEC.

Edit: Just be careful that your console is plugged on the right HDMI slot as some tvs nly have on one port.
Thanks for expanding on the thought. I didn't want to speculate on other brands as I haven't bought a different brand TV for over 20 years. I have 3 Sony TVs at home, the oldest is 14 years, I think, and none of them has ever had any fault. The first colour TV with a remote my family had lasted for 20 years with 2 minor repairs.

Unfortunately, today's electronics won't last that long because of RoHs compliance. Those SNES and PS1 consoles may still work well when most PS4 or Xbox One units go to the landfill. But that's politics disguised as ecology and quite off-topic.
 
Imagine being this dense holy shit

You are comparing two different architectures. I know what you're alluding with your thinly veiled post but XSX and PS5 are both RDNA2 based. Compare the 2080 to a 2070 or a 2060 can come back with your findings.

And please stop helping anyone build PCs

Your post is just as guilty in reality. In comparing RTX 20xx discrete GPUs for the purposes of benchmarking, it assumes identical architecture (and therefore CU occupancy, which is why you don’t compare peak teraflops) and identical drivers and graphics APIs.

XSX and PS5 both have GPUs that are derived from AMD’s RNDA2 technology, but both machines will be using very different graphics APIs, and PS5’s GPU has the ability to keep its CUs loaded with work as changes to system memory pages invalidate parts of its working cache.

It’s systems and incremental changes like this between GTX 10xx and RTX20xx that improve CU occupancy and make comparing theoretically calculated peak teraflop figures irrelevant.

Games typically only achieve around 30-40% CU occupancy, with a lot of time a CU spent waiting on something else to finish, or for a memory fetch to fill its working cache so that it can do useful work.

PS5’s Coherency Engines and GPU cache scrubbers could contribute an average of mostly fuck all to CU occupancy, or something quite significant. It might vary based on game or game engine. We don’t know.

This isn’t saying PS5’s GPU is suddenly better. This isn’t even saying PS5’s GPU is equal or has even appreciably closed the gap, either.

This is saying that although both are RDNA2 based, there are hardware and architecture differences that directly affect CU occupancy.
There are graphics APIs unique to each manufacturer that also indirectly affect how efficiently those CUs will be utilised.

So it’s neither comparing a GTX 10xx to an RTX 20xx, nor comparing an RTX 20xx to an RTX 20xx using the same Windows drivers and DirectX API.

The answer to how much difference between the two GPUs in real world code there is for anyone not working on a multi-platform title with both dev-kits is:

“I don’t know”.

The rumours from such sources say it’s closer than ever. The earlier rumours seemed to say it was the opposite of what a naive reading of paper specifications would say.

I think it’s reasonable to say we don’t know but it’s likely XSX has the edge over all.

Comparisons to tightly controlled PC benchmarks where the only thing being changed in CUs and clock-speed is irrelevant. That isn’t the only difference between the two systems, or even the two GPUs.
 

FranXico

Member
Sony could include the Media Remote with the PS5 to sell us the idea that we are buying a Home Cinema System too. It could even has its own UI and works without turn on the PS5.

This is why $499 and $399 makes sense to me.
That's a terrible idea. They are selling the PS5 as a game console, using their first party games as a selling point, and that's the correct thing to do.
No media BS.
 

K.N.W.

Member
Imagine being this dense holy shit

You are comparing two different architectures. I know what you're alluding with your thinly veiled post but XSX and PS5 are both RDNA2 based. Compare the 2080 to a 2070 or a 2060 can come back with your findings.

And please stop helping anyone build PCs
Nope my friend. You are the one saying dense fudness. The CUDA cores didn't change that much between the two generations. As you can see here, the older 1080TI, having 12,5% more Teraflops, has a rendering speed advantage around that value, so the efficiency is almost the same.
OWzUmkC.png

Anyway, I have an IT Engineering degree and another in Engineering Sciences, what about you??
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
Heartwarming sentiment from a responsible electronics owner.

Here's my bench, it's kinda messy, I know, my daughter keeps pulling the wires and biting them like a rodent, and while playing TLOU2 she keeps climbing me all the time to the bed behind me then comes again and repeats it as some kind of a game. Man, it was a torture to play the game that way. :lollipop_tears_of_joy: 55" 2016 Sony DX70 HDR 4K, might upgrade to 65-85" Sony XH90 depending on my brain state as I go crazy around electronics.

DSC-4169.jpg


Pardon the crappy quality, it's just to give an idea. I took off the shelf above it for better airflow, it tends to make some noise if kept inside those tight spaces, and you can place the shelf back when you're done. That way or in an open space is the best way for console longevity, and it's a very quite PS4. Got it day one in November? 2016, and gave my base PS4 with some physical disks (bought it in December 2nd, 2013, day one here) to a dear friend who's still unemployed, sadly, until now.

This console and the previous model spends long sessions up to my personal record of 51 hours playing MGS5.:messenger_dizzy: This one is the second version of PS4 Pro as I remember the complains, the second model/revision.
 
Last edited:

Bo_Hazem

Banned

You're paying for the brand, I guess?

That's a PC version, as IntentionalPun IntentionalPun explained, the one I posted is a complete system, that's why it's more expensive. The one you showed is better for comparison? Not sure.
 
Last edited:

Bo_Hazem

Banned
So what's the TL;DW of that video again? It's been a long time since I've watched a DF video and had fun with it; lately it's like they're paid to polish turds and it's a bit pathetic.

TL;DR PS5 is too big and can't fit in any bench, XSX is not. PS5 is too expensive at around $500, but XSX probably a $200 console as he makes it sound. If I speak from my ass I would make more sense that he did.
 

xacto

Member
TL;DR PS5 is too big and can't fit in any bench, XSX is not. PS5 is too expensive at around $500, but XSX probably a $200 console as he makes it sound. If I speak from my ass I would make more sense that he did.

So if I don't have a piece of furniture to fit my PS5 in, I shouldn't buy the PS5. Ok, that makes sense in DF's world. If I'd buy my electronics to fit my furniture I probably wouldn't buy that many anyways.

So they say that the fridge form factor is more furniture-friendly?
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
So if I don't have a piece of furniture to fit my PS5 in, I shouldn't buy the PS5. Ok, that makes sense in DF's world. If I'd buy my electronics to fit my furniture I probably wouldn't buy that many anyways.

So they say that the fridge form factor is more furniture-friendly?

Yup, a PS5 that's as high as PS3 with the extra stand horizontally is more problematic compared to the XSX that's slightly thicker than 2x Xbox One fat stacked. It's covid, they must make some money out of bullshit.🤷‍♂️
 

Sony

Nintendo
Seems like it's still in Sony's hand anyway:


I'm not sure if it's still in place, but Sony has a policy that if third/second party develop exclusively for PlayStation, Sony gets the ownership of the IP. It's one of the reasons Insomniac actually developed Sunset Overdrive for Xbox. Sony would have had ownership of the IP, Microsoft didn't. In highsight pretty funny now that Insomniac is a Sony first party developer.
 
Last edited:

Bo_Hazem

Banned
Yeah that's what's in the article, so I'm merely using their numbers ($60, $8 and 30/70 split).

The craziest thing for me is that almost 50% goes to retail, packaging, etc. And we are still always paying $60 for digital games... So up the prices for retail or lower digital prices to make it fair.

I really hope Microsoft will launch a digital license sales platform. They won't, but if someone would do it, it's them. It wouldn't be that difficult to create, the only issue is that everyone would buy their games there instead from their own store, so they should just take a cut to make up for it.

One out of the two must start it, like a used games trade and Sony/MS have a %5 cut or 10% (6 for studio and 4 for Sony, just like the store percentage?). Maybe some will think it's a high cut, but to most digital games owners it's a welcome change for many. I will sell all my freaking backlog (180+ on PS4) for 10 games on PS5 or even less.
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
I'm not sure if it's still in place, but Sony has a policy that if third/second party develop exclusively for PlayStation, Sony gets the ownership of the IP. It's one of the reasons Insomniac actually developed Sunset Overdrive for Xbox. Sony would have had ownership of the IP, Microsoft didn't. In highsight pretty funny now that Insomniac is a Sony first party developer.

Well, Sony paid a $229M in cold cash for that! And what a smart move that was. It still stings Sony that they lost the Crash Bandicoot IP, although it wasn't a first party game to begin with. It saddens me that the new one is still regressive and didn't develop and evolve like Ratchet and Clank for example. I'm not impressed with the new Crash game, and Activision is one of the most hated companies to me.

Insomniac seems like a wonderful studio for a better Crash Bandicoot, but a shit company as Activision they won't let the IP go. Naughty Dog lost it in a strange way.

Sunset Overdrive was one of the best games that made me consider Xbox actually, but I didn't sell my soul to the devil.:messenger_smiling_horns:
 

Brudda26

Member
Been looking at 4k monitors because my current 1080p one is dying. Any good recommendations, just browsing at the moment dont know if I'll be able to afford one yet. Though I could always sell my body to science to afford one 🤣 tho will suck if my monitor dies and I get ps5 and have no screen to play on
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
Been looking at 4k monitors because my current 1080p one is dying. Any good recommendations, just browsing at the moment dont know if I'll be able to afford one yet. Though I could always sell my body to science to afford one 🤣 tho will suck if my monitor dies and I get ps5 and have no screen to play on

What's your budget? And why not a TV? Nothing beats an incliner chair and 55" or bigger screen:

Colton-Incliner-Chair.jpg
 

Brudda26

Member
What's your budget? And why not a TV? Nothing beats an incliner chair and 55" or bigger screen:

Colton-Incliner-Chair.jpg
Not quite sure on budget yet its depending entirely on how the next few months go with the current situation and if I end up getting the flu putting me out of work. I prefer gaming on a monitor you get better response times and much greater PPI on a 27inch monitor compared to a big TV. I atleast 4k 60hz HDR monitor.
 

Bo_Hazem

Banned
Not quite sure on budget yet its depending entirely on how the next few months go with the current situation and if I end up getting the flu putting me out of work. I prefer gaming on a monitor you get better response times and much greater PPI on a 27inch monitor compared to a big TV. I atleast 4k 60hz HDR monitor.

You just don't know what you're missing, but if you are a hardcore shooter gamer then monitors would still be great for you for PC gaming. New TV's have VRR and 4K@120Hz if you've not been keeping up, and both PS5 and XSX support that with ALLM as well (HDMI 2.1 feature set).
 

Brudda26

Member
You just don't know what you're missing, but if you are a hardcore shooter gamer then monitors would still be great for you for PC gaming. New TV's have VRR and 4K@120Hz if you've not been keeping up, and both PS5 and XSX support that with ALLM as well (HDMI 2.1 feature set).
I've used a monitor for ps4 for the last 5 years and it gave me better experience than I got from a TV because there is a lot less lag and no heavy post processing features going on. Yeah a TV would like that would be nice but I dont have the budget for that I would have to sell my legs or summon to get one 🤣 monitors are cheaper options whilst offering up same features. Tho if I miraculously stumble across some cash I'll look at some of those juicy TV's
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom