• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

NeoGAF Ban Review/Justice Project

Status
Not open for further replies.

Keihart

Member
I just wanna say thanks to the mod that went in and cleaned the thread about Neil Druckman's quotes about the SSD, including my post which was complaining about the state of it.
Not like it's my favorite thread or anything, but at least it's mostly on topic now.
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
Jesus how is this even a conversation?

Big brain.

To nobody's surprise, when a semi-prominent member is banned, especially one that some people liked, for something as serious as pedo, there's going to be some discussion about it.

Nobody once excused what he posted; just offered possible reasons, knowing him, why he would even make a post like that, and even that was cast into more doubt as the convo went on.

Everyone respectfully talked, and came to the same conclusion in the end -- even if he did have some epic brain fart, what he said was not acceptable, and we can't open the gateway to those sort of people on Gaf.

That seems like a productive conversation to me. Moreso than the rabid, unprofessional yelling from users that goes on in here half the time, myself included.
 
Last edited:

-Arcadia-

Banned
Plenty of time to get hit with 2 weeks.

To be frank i doubt this show will be any good.
Most of their E3 shows were long but boring.

We wont see any frue next gen first party from them either as most game will be cross gen

I don't expect much from the show presentation itself, tbh. That's not a Microsoft thing, it's a gaming show post-2010 thing.

Sony's show was better, yet still agony for me, but when it was done, I still had a bunch of games I was really interested in, alongside a very positive view of what the PS5 could do, and I'm really hoping the same happens here.

They cannot have another show like that embarrassment a month or two ago, or it's over. The specs don't mean anything, if you can't show the mainstream customer how they're being put into practice.

In before Xbox Gaf hates me, lol, but understand I want the absolute best for Series X, and that's why I'm saying that.

Maybe if we go any further with this, we should take it to MetaGaf.

To get back on topic, year-long ban bets are dum. You guys should not do that. The ego battling so isn't worth it.
 

Jtibh

Banned
I don't expect much from the show presentation itself, tbh. That's not a Microsoft thing, it's a gaming show post-2010 thing.

Sony's show was better, yet still agony for me, but when it was done, I still had a bunch of games I was really interested in, alongside a very positive view of what the PS5 could do, and I'm really hoping the same happens here.

They cannot have another show like that embarrassment a month or two ago, or it's over. The specs don't mean anything, if you can't show the mainstream customer how they're being put into practice.

In before Xbox Gaf hates me, lol, but understand I want the absolute best for Series X, and that's why I'm saying that.

Maybe if we go any further with this, we should take it to MetaGaf.

To get back on topic, year-long ban bets are dum. You guys should not do that. The ego battling so isn't worth it.
That thread got filled with sjw's very quick so i called some of them out.
All they did is push their agenda that was unrelated to gaming but they thought it has its place there since tlou2 is their holy grail of identity politics.

I made my case as of why i believe tlou2 will hit psnow very soon due the shitty sales since week 2 as well as the hate it received from fans due to its bullshit story.

As well as its the end of ps4 cycle and sony needs to lure a lot of people in before ps5 so what better way to do that if not with a blockbuster title that people take notice.

So they wanted me to place a bet and i did.


Anyways as far as xbox goes i dont see them throwing a big show.
Yes you will have halo but that franchise is dead the past few years and i dint see them to do any better then previous titles.

Lockhart at 199 would be a big thing but even that wont happen.
 

Xaero Gravity

NEXT LEVEL lame™
That thread got filled with sjw's very quick so i called some of them out.
All they did is push their agenda that was unrelated to gaming but they thought it has its place there since tlou2 is their holy grail of identity politics.

I made my case as of why i believe tlou2 will hit psnow very soon due the shitty sales since week 2 as well as the hate it received from fans due to its bullshit story.

As well as its the end of ps4 cycle and sony needs to lure a lot of people in before ps5 so what better way to do that if not with a blockbuster title that people take notice.

So they wanted me to place a bet and i did.


Anyways as far as xbox goes i dont see them throwing a big show.
Yes you will have halo but that franchise is dead the past few years and i dint see them to do any better then previous titles.

Lockhart at 199 would be a big thing but even that wont happen.
You're right, MetaGAF is filled with SJW soy boy cucks
 

SleepDoctor

Banned
Im just wondering how there's a bait thread still open, basically saying 10tf > 12tf. And some guys with the "Xbox has no games bs" and "brute force" shit???

You can literally say some bs like all that above but if anyone says anything about the github leak, its instantly bannable. What's up with that?
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
This and "bottlenecks" are some of the worst baits I have seen.

Xbox is brute force, Xbox has no games and I forgot about the oft repeated Xbox bottle necks seem to be perfectly OK without anything to back those claims up and lots of proof to the contrary. But OMG don't even think about 9.2 tfs or mention the GitHub leaks because it's an insta ban.

To be fair, I will say other than the over sensitivity to 9tfs/GitHub I feel like moderation overall has been very fair and responsive the last several weeks and I also realize it's a thankless and probably super tedious job, especially with the election looming and the console warz heating up.

I appreciate everything all of you Mods and EviLore EviLore do to make GAF the by far my favorite spot on these interwebs. Thank you for all you do.
 
Im just wondering how there's a bait thread still open, basically saying 10tf > 12tf. And some guys with the "Xbox has no games bs" and "brute force" shit???

You can literally say some bs like all that above but if anyone says anything about the github leak, its instantly bannable. What's up with that?

What about the GitHub leak is instantly bannable?

I've talked and discussed the GitHub leak plenty of times here and I didn't have a problem. Although I will always state that the GitHub leak doesn't represent the current specifications of the systems because they changed since the leak.
 

All Hail C-Webb

Hailing from the Chill-Web
Because Gator Bait was about using babies to bait gators

So Coily received a permanent ban for this even though posts later in the thread show that this was in fact one of the reasons that the school is dropping the chant. The school President even said: "

"While I know of no evidence of racism associated with our 'Gator Bait' cheer at UF sporting events, there is horrific historic racist imagery associated with the phrase," Fuchs said. "Accordingly, University Athletics and the Gator Band will discontinue the use of the cheer."

Figure I'll also use this time to give the bitch-made mod who wants me banned the opportunity to make his dreams come true.

You either Jewish or Black you fucking prick?
Deleting part of my post and calling me a troll who will get permed if I ever make the comparison again, because I said that I imagine the pain that African Americans feel when they see a statue of a confederate leader is similar to the pain I would feel as a Jew walking through Germany if the Germans were assholes enough to have Hitler statues in the streets.
Nobody else had any issue with it. The other Jew I was discussing it with didn't take issue, but your hitler loving ass did.
It's a common discussion among Jews, and was recently brought up by the Rabbi at one of the biggest Synagogues in NY.

So, while I enjoy GAF and have been here probably since the 90s, I'm not going to kowtow to your bitch ass. Fuck hitler, fuck the confederate traitors, and fuck you too.
 

Jesus Carbomb

From Water into Guinness
Zkagpa8.jpg
 
Xbox is brute force, Xbox has no games and I forgot about the oft repeated Xbox bottle necks seem to be perfectly OK without anything to back those claims up and lots of proof to the contrary. But OMG don't even think about 9.2 tfs or mention the GitHub leaks because it's an insta ban.

To be fair, I will say other than the over sensitivity to 9tfs/GitHub I feel like moderation overall has been very fair and responsive the last several weeks and I also realize it's a thankless and probably super tedious job, especially with the election looming and the console warz heating up.

I appreciate everything all of you Mods and EviLore EviLore do to make GAF the by far my favorite spot on these interwebs. Thank you for all you do.

I think the issue is that some people are using the GitHub leak to confirm the PS5 as a 9TFs system. I know that Sony gave us 10.28 TFs that are variable. But you can't say that the system is 9TFs unless you have some sort of proof that it goes down that low.

I think that's what all the fuss about the 9TFs claims is about.

I think Bill O'Rights Bill O'Rights already explained this before.
 
Last edited:

Ornlu

Banned
So Coily received a permanent ban for this even though posts later in the thread show that this was in fact one of the reasons that the school is dropping the chant. The school President even said: "

"While I know of no evidence of racism associated with our 'Gator Bait' cheer at UF sporting events, there is horrific historic racist imagery associated with the phrase," Fuchs said. "Accordingly, University Athletics and the Gator Band will discontinue the use of the cheer."

Figure I'll also use this time to give the bitch-made mod who wants me banned the opportunity to make his dreams come true.

You either Jewish or Black you fucking prick?
Deleting part of my post and calling me a troll who will get permed if I ever make the comparison again, because I said that I imagine the pain that African Americans feel when they see a statue of a confederate leader is similar to the pain I would feel as a Jew walking through Germany if the Germans were assholes enough to have Hitler statues in the streets.
Nobody else had any issue with it. The other Jew I was discussing it with didn't take issue, but your hitler loving ass did.
It's a common discussion among Jews, and was recently brought up by the Rabbi at one of the biggest Synagogues in NY.

So, while I enjoy GAF and have been here probably since the 90s, I'm not going to kowtow to your bitch ass. Fuck hitler, fuck the confederate traitors, and fuck you too.

Crossroads GIF | Gfycat
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
So Coily received a permanent ban for this even though posts later in the thread show that this was in fact one of the reasons that the school is dropping the chant. The school President even said: "

"While I know of no evidence of racism associated with our 'Gator Bait' cheer at UF sporting events, there is horrific historic racist imagery associated with the phrase," Fuchs said. "Accordingly, University Athletics and the Gator Band will discontinue the use of the cheer."

Figure I'll also use this time to give the bitch-made mod who wants me banned the opportunity to make his dreams come true.

You either Jewish or Black you fucking prick?
Deleting part of my post and calling me a troll who will get permed if I ever make the comparison again, because I said that I imagine the pain that African Americans feel when they see a statue of a confederate leader is similar to the pain I would feel as a Jew walking through Germany if the Germans were assholes enough to have Hitler statues in the streets.
Nobody else had any issue with it. The other Jew I was discussing it with didn't take issue, but your hitler loving ass did.
It's a common discussion among Jews, and was recently brought up by the Rabbi at one of the biggest Synagogues in NY.

So, while I enjoy GAF and have been here probably since the 90s, I'm not going to kowtow to your bitch ass. Fuck hitler, fuck the confederate traitors, and fuck you too.

NGCoBxD.gif
 

haxan7

Banned
So Coily received a permanent ban for this even though posts later in the thread show that this was in fact one of the reasons that the school is dropping the chant. The school President even said: "

"While I know of no evidence of racism associated with our 'Gator Bait' cheer at UF sporting events, there is horrific historic racist imagery associated with the phrase," Fuchs said. "Accordingly, University Athletics and the Gator Band will discontinue the use of the cheer."

Figure I'll also use this time to give the bitch-made mod who wants me banned the opportunity to make his dreams come true.

You either Jewish or Black you fucking prick?
Deleting part of my post and calling me a troll who will get permed if I ever make the comparison again, because I said that I imagine the pain that African Americans feel when they see a statue of a confederate leader is similar to the pain I would feel as a Jew walking through Germany if the Germans were assholes enough to have Hitler statues in the streets.
Nobody else had any issue with it. The other Jew I was discussing it with didn't take issue, but your hitler loving ass did.
It's a common discussion among Jews, and was recently brought up by the Rabbi at one of the biggest Synagogues in NY.

So, while I enjoy GAF and have been here probably since the 90s, I'm not going to kowtow to your bitch ass. Fuck hitler, fuck the confederate traitors, and fuck you too.
Damn dude. You were clearly bottling that up inside for a while. Just don’t post here if it’s gonna cause you that much internal distress.
 

All Hail C-Webb

Hailing from the Chill-Web

Low Blow. Completely uncalled for. You need a time-out to think.... fuck, now I did it too. :(

Damn dude. You were clearly bottling that up inside for a while. Just don’t post here if it’s gonna cause you that much internal distress.

I actually wrote this up a while ago and didn't post it, but since I was back in the thread, figured I would be a pussy not to.
I enjoy posting here, and discussing shit with many of you who I disagree with. Some posters and posts are vile, but I quickly learned who not to take seriously, and that prevents the internal stress.
Not going to ignore a mod trying to erase and rewrite history though. :)
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
I think the issue is that some people are using the GitHub leak to confirm the PS5 as a 9TFs system. I know that Sony gave us 10.28 TFs that are variable. But you can't say that the system is 9TFs unless you have some sort of proof that it goes down that low.

I think that's what all the fuss about the 9TFs claims is about.

I think Bill O'Rights Bill O'Rights already explained this before.

That's fine we don't know how low it will go at this time.

But by the same token Sony fans shouldn't get a free pass on saying with impunity:
Xbox has no games just because they don't like the games

XsX is brute forcing everything just because it's more powerful when it has been shown XsX has so many customizations & optimizations - at LEAST as many as Sony has claimed

Xbox has all these alleged bottlenecks with nothing tangible to back it up
 

Jooxed

Gold Member
So Coily received a permanent ban for this even though posts later in the thread show that this was in fact one of the reasons that the school is dropping the chant. The school President even said: "

"While I know of no evidence of racism associated with our 'Gator Bait' cheer at UF sporting events, there is horrific historic racist imagery associated with the phrase," Fuchs said. "Accordingly, University Athletics and the Gator Band will discontinue the use of the cheer."

Figure I'll also use this time to give the bitch-made mod who wants me banned the opportunity to make his dreams come true.

You either Jewish or Black you fucking prick?
Deleting part of my post and calling me a troll who will get permed if I ever make the comparison again, because I said that I imagine the pain that African Americans feel when they see a statue of a confederate leader is similar to the pain I would feel as a Jew walking through Germany if the Germans were assholes enough to have Hitler statues in the streets.
Nobody else had any issue with it. The other Jew I was discussing it with didn't take issue, but your hitler loving ass did.
It's a common discussion among Jews, and was recently brought up by the Rabbi at one of the biggest Synagogues in NY.

So, while I enjoy GAF and have been here probably since the 90s, I'm not going to kowtow to your bitch ass. Fuck hitler, fuck the confederate traitors, and fuck you too.

tell us how you really feel.
 

Xaero Gravity

NEXT LEVEL lame™
So Coily received a permanent ban for this even though posts later in the thread show that this was in fact one of the reasons that the school is dropping the chant. The school President even said: "

"While I know of no evidence of racism associated with our 'Gator Bait' cheer at UF sporting events, there is horrific historic racist imagery associated with the phrase," Fuchs said. "Accordingly, University Athletics and the Gator Band will discontinue the use of the cheer."

Figure I'll also use this time to give the bitch-made mod who wants me banned the opportunity to make his dreams come true.

You either Jewish or Black you fucking prick?
Deleting part of my post and calling me a troll who will get permed if I ever make the comparison again, because I said that I imagine the pain that African Americans feel when they see a statue of a confederate leader is similar to the pain I would feel as a Jew walking through Germany if the Germans were assholes enough to have Hitler statues in the streets.
Nobody else had any issue with it. The other Jew I was discussing it with didn't take issue, but your hitler loving ass did.
It's a common discussion among Jews, and was recently brought up by the Rabbi at one of the biggest Synagogues in NY.

So, while I enjoy GAF and have been here probably since the 90s, I'm not going to kowtow to your bitch ass. Fuck hitler, fuck the confederate traitors, and fuck you too.
tell us how you really feel.
 

EviLore

Expansive Ellipses
Staff Member
All Hail C-Webb All Hail C-Webb : Coily’s post history is full of baiting and derailing, very low effort posts. That’s what he was banned for, hence the “multiple” and further explanation in the ban listing. Bill O'Rights Bill O'Rights may be able to explain what went down with that user more specifically.

I’m not aware of anyone on the team targeting you for banning. What set that off?
 

Nikana

Go Go Neo Rangers!
That's fine we don't know how low it will go at this time.

But by the same token Sony fans shouldn't get a free pass on saying with impunity:
Xbox has no games just because they don't like the games

XsX is brute forcing everything just because it's more powerful when it has been shown XsX has so many customizations & optimizations - at LEAST as many as Sony has claimed

Xbox has all these alleged bottlenecks with nothing tangible to back it up

The Microsoft doesn't even want to talk about Series S is getting tired as well. Sony talked about the PS5 in June...does that mean they didnt want to talk about it?

LIke wtf does that even mean?
 
That's fine we don't know how low it will go at this time.

But by the same token Sony fans shouldn't get a free pass on saying with impunity:
Xbox has no games just because they don't like the games

XsX is brute forcing everything just because it's more powerful when it has been shown XsX has so many customizations & optimizations - at LEAST as many as Sony has claimed

Xbox has all these alleged bottlenecks with nothing tangible to back it up

Maybe you should talk to EviLore EviLore about that if you feel like your not being treated fairly here. I've seen plenty of PlayStation fans get banned recently so they are definitely taking care of them.

Maybe use the report function to deal with the users that are causing the issue?
 

CatLady

Selfishly plays on Xbox Purr-ies X
Maybe you should talk to EviLore EviLore about that if you feel like your not being treated fairly here. I've seen plenty of PlayStation fans get banned recently so they are definitely taking care of them.

Maybe use the report function to deal with the users that are causing the issue?

Since YOU felt the need to explain to ME the problem with 9tfs, I wanted to take the time to explain to YOU why some people, myself included, feel equally dubious statements regarding the XsX should be handled in the same manner.

I 'm pretty sure I know how to navigate NeoGAF without instruction, but thank you anyway.
 
Since YOU felt the need to explain to ME the problem with 9tfs, I wanted to take the time to explain to YOU why some people, myself included, feel equally dubious statements regarding the XsX should be handled in the same manner.

I 'm pretty sure I know how to navigate NeoGAF without instruction, but thank you anyway.

I've seen people banned for those statements and called out for being console warriors.

I think moderation does work here but you need to bring the mods attention to what needs moderation.

It's almost like your suggesting that this site has a certain bias or something similar.
 

-Arcadia-

Banned
Do feel you should de-couple yourself a bit from the thread, MasterCornholio MasterCornholio

I don't think you're anything but a genuinely good guy that wants to help, but fuck if running to the Ban Review thread within ten posts, and being there all the time isn't the most glow-in-the-dark shit I've ever seen.

Not trying to be mean; explaining how it looks.

To some extent, I'm guilty of the same thing, and am trying to deattach a bit myself.

I think it's irksome when people come to talk to staff and they end up with you or me offering an unsolicited opinion instead. It's a bit like trying to talk to a Wal-Mart manager about a return, but customers keep pulling you aside and offering their opinions on Walmart's return policy instead.

We should all have a voice in this thread, but perhaps we should take care to make sure that voice doesn't get too loud.
 
Last edited:
Do feel you should de-couple yourself a bit from the thread, MasterCornholio MasterCornholio

I don't think you're anything but a genuinely good guy that wants to help, but fuck if running to the Ban Review thread within ten posts, and being there all the time isn't the most glow-in-the-dark shit I've ever seen.

Not trying to be mean; explaining how it looks.

To some extent, I'm guilty of the same thing, and am trying to deattach a bit myself.

I think it's irksome when people come to talk to staff and they end up with you or me offering an unsolicited opinion instead. It's a bit like trying to talk to a Wal-Mart manager about a return, but customers keep pulling you aside and offering their opinions on Walmart's return policy instead.

We should all have a voice in this thread, but perhaps we should take care to make sure that voice doesn't get too loud.

I can agree with that since I spend alot of time in the ban thread. I guess I should let people deal with their issues here instead of commenting on them all the time. I know that my behavior is just going to irritate some people here and that's not going to be positive for the community.

I need to just let the mods do their jobs and not interfere in their decisions or interactions with other members of this forum.
 
Last edited:

-Arcadia-

Banned
I can agree with that since I spend alot of time in the ban thread. I guess I should let people deal with their issues here instead of commenting on them all the time. I know that my behavior is just going to irritate some people here and that's not going to be positive for the community.

I need to just let the mods do their jobs and not interfere in their decisions or interactions with other members of this forum.

Like I said, you're a good guy. Your opinion is valued, and I don't ever want it to disappear from this thread, but some food for thought.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom