Support NeoGAF

[IbizaPocholo]

This Cyberpunk 2077 vs. GTA 5 comparison video showcases Gameplay, A.I. & Physics differences between the two games & map areas with a few funny bugs/glitches & moments in between.

We will be testing multiple gameplay elements like bullet impact, fire propagation, jumping from vehicles, NPCs behavior, vehicle collision physics etc.

Surprisingly, GTA 5 is better than Cyberpunk 2077 in most comparisons.

 

[Bonfires Down]

 

[jigglet]

But does GTA have more diverse relationship options?

 

[Tickle My Tendies]

SWEEP THE LEG, JOHNNY

 

[dyergram]

No shit rockstar are masters of open world games and have been making them for 20+ Years. Cyberpunk at least has better controls.

ps I think cb is fun.

 

[GHG]

The open world in Cyberpunk is a joke in terms of interactivity. It's all for show, don't even bother trying to interact with anything.




Luckily quests make up for it.

But the more I play this game the more baffled I am by the review scores it received.

 

[Woggleman]

GTA V isn't even better than GTA IV.

 

[Explosive Zombie]

I mean, if those are the things you want out of a game, sure.

 

[KormaChameleon]

 

[Guilty_AI]

I mean, if those are the things you want out of a game, sure.

 

[Edgelord79]

I've got about 30 hours in Cyberpunk on PC and love it. BUT...

It's nothing innovative or special. The more I play, the more I feel William Gibson's remarks regarding Cyberpunk 2077 a couple of years ago were more accurate than people gave him credit for.

A reskinned GTA 5 with an 80's theme... Not that it's a bad thing. It's just that's what it is for the most part

 

[Skifi28]

So we've established that San Andreas is better than Cyberpunk. I didn't expect this clicking this thread.

 

[Great Hair]

GTA4 > GTA 5 > CD2077

 

[TheKratos]

Lolno.

 

[sobaka770]

Not the same game... close this shitty thread.

 

[eot]

Do we get a "GTA2 is better than GTA:SA" one too?

 

[cudiye]

I mean, if those are the things you want out of a game, sure.

i guess they’re all better than Cyberpunk 2077.

 

[M1chl]

Game should be more advertised as Deus Ex spiritual succesor, than some open world GTA type of game, it's really not that. It's probably closer to what Mafia: DE is doing then to GTA. Which I welcomed, but there are a lot of elements missing to make the world and whole game better. Why the fuck no music outside of the vehicle? WHY? And that's like only like 10% of my complains about being imerssive, the interaction even with story characters is "woody" at best. Also why even have face, if you don't see it.

Also if you are naked, you wear underwear and shit like that. It's breaking my adventures : D

 

[The Cockatrice]

The open world in Cyberpunk is a joke in terms of interactivity.

What exactly is this interactivity you and "critics" talk about? Did you expect the npc's on the street to give you a blowjob? There's so many side quests and gigs that I feel like it just never ends and theres always soem random gang war or some shut stirring up. I don't understand what the fuck are you all smoking? Did you expect the world to change? Did you expect to see the balls of your character shrink?

I honestly think the atmosphere and level of detail besides the bugs and npc spawns which are messed up atm, is the best I've seen. The map feels huge and so far I've only done side quests and what not and every side quest made me visit some interior which is nuts considering how many side quests there are and how many interior palces a la Deus Ex there are. People rushing main quest are missing half of what makes Cyberpunks world amazing but oh no some random npc did not come by itself to talk to me on this huge ass city just like in that empty ass world that is RDR2 where it takes 5 minutes to pick up an object. Damn thats so interactive!

 

[Yoboman]

I can't wait for GTA6. One day

 

[Guilty_AI]

So we've established that San Andreas is better than Cyberpunk. I didn't expect this clicking this thread.

Although GTA SA is indeed better than a lot of stuff

 

[ItsTheNew]

Yeah, GTA IV was really a step back in the fun and variety department. Thank god we got Saints Row 2 as the spiritual successor.

 

[AsfaeksBR]

I can't wait for GTA6. One day

Why wait for GTA 6? Seeing by the videos posted above, it’s clear that GTA V > GTA 6

 

[THEAP99]

My own hand made experiences on the ps5:





Too much money spent on dude-bro socially degenerate marketing, influencers, and visuals, not enough substance. Underdeveloped NPC system, unfinished cop system, the world is nothing but fluff. I will try refunding again and pick up the game later for next-gen.

let's hope they're able to make a functioning open world on the 2nd try!

 

[Explosive Zombie]

Yeah, GTA IV was really a step back in the fun and variety department. Thank god we got Saints Row 2 as the spiritual successor.

 

[NathanDiego]

And it’s not even close, GTA V is remembered as one of the greatest and most important game of all time, Cyberpunk is just an overhyped disappointment.

 

[Woggleman]

GTA V was the only time Rockstar disappointed me. It comes across as one of those mass market type of things designed to appeal to as many people as possible without making any real artistic statement. It is not a bad game by any means but they made it to appeal to people who didn't like GTA IV without any real heart and soul and it shows. Cyberpunk for all it's technical flaws has an artistic heart that beats heavily.

 

[Hawking Radiation]

SWEEP THE LEG, JOHNNY

 

[Manus]

Isn't Rockstar like 3 to 4 times bigger than CD Project?

 

[Shane89]

yes

 

[lefty1117]

I think the backlash to CP77 is venturing into "cool to hate" territory, I quite like the game personally. But I'd also agree that GTAV is the superior game, no question. I agree with the sentiment someone posted that CP77 is closer to Deus Ex than GTA. In fact there are no rpg elements in GTA, no loot or skills system, etc. They are actually quite different games. Deus Ex or the Ubiworld games are more applicable in a comparison

 

[RyRy93]

Because if we've learned anything games are all about the technical details, not the controls or the story or gameplay... The one-to-one GTA comparisons are retarded.

 

[Topher]

That would require actually require liking GTA....wouldn't it? Not me. I'm a sucker for all the loot, skill trees, RPG crap (even when watered down). I've never understood the overall point of GTA. Money? Is that it?

 

[Enzo88]

They try to do really different things.

 

[Cherry Sonoshee]

GTA5 certainly was a technical marvel and I don't remember it running like complete shit on current gen consoles(PS3/360) at the time. But I mean it's just different priorities and resources. I mean it took all of Rockstar to get out GTA5 and then RDR2. Obviously both games are highly detailed to fault with an extreme focus on animation.

While Cyberpunk is by a smaller studio with probably less resources. Also probably not as focused on the minute details that GTAV was. It instead has a greater focus on art direction and world detail then I'd say GTAV has.

I don't know these kind of graphic comparisons really miss the point and nuance of games. Like both games are strong in thier technical side and achieve the goal of realizing the worlds they are trying to recreate.

 

[FunkMiller]

The main thing is that Cyberpunk 2077 appears to be a pretty standard RPG. Not quite the innovative next generation leap some were expecting. There’s nothing much about it that feels any more innovative than gta 5. Maybe that’s why people are comparing the two. And maybe finding gta the better game.

 

[Zombie9ers]

What about the genitalia customization comparison???!

 

[ItsTheNew]

Ps4 CP2077 performance with more stuff going on lol.

 

[Deleted member 17706]

Cool. Can we get Rockstar to make a proper Cyberpunk game in the style of GTA/RDR?

 

[Wunray]

1 excells at open world interactivity and the other excells at mission design and interactivity, there is no 1 perfect game that gets everything right.

 

[Deleted member 17706]

GTA V was the only time Rockstar disappointed me. It comes across as one of those mass market type of things designed to appeal to as many people as possible without making any real artistic statement. It is not a bad game by any means but they made it to appeal to people who didn't like GTA IV without any real heart and soul and it shows. Cyberpunk for all it's technical flaws has an artistic heart that beats heavily.

Agreed. I hated the characters of GTAV with a passion. Just couldn't get invested in the story at all and, as such, it's the only main series GTA game since 3 that I didn't finish. I did spend a ton of time just roaming the city in first-person mode. Incredible achievement of environment and world building.

 

[GymWolf]

lol no shit, nobody beat rockstar when it comes to micro details in open wolrd games, and rdr2 is even more crazier than gta5.

Cyberpunk is first of all an rpg not a city simulator.

 

[Nethernova]

I dunno about all of that but I didn’t really have fun with gta 5 but I’m having a blast with cp2077?

 

[Chris Walken]

Why is people so FUCKING obssesed comparing an action-rpg to a full sandbox game.

"Hey dudes, let's compare GTA V rpg elements against Cyberpunk.

What, it doesn't have? what a shitty game, Rockstar, i demand a refund you bastards!"

As you can see, it sounds ridiculous, well, this is what some "Nobel prizes" were doing 3 days in a row.

 

[Woggleman]

Every open world game set in present or future times does not need to be compared to GTA.

 

[Eric187]

2 different genres but they the similarities are they are both open world. GTA strengths will always be awesome physics, car and pedestrian AI and minute details. Cyberpunks strength are its rpg elements, characters and story. The world themself though seem pretty close. I’ve played about 30 hours and night city is massive and incredibly realized world and seems bigger than GTAV in surface area. Both are top tier IMO. Rockstar design is emergent gameplay that seems random to make the world feel more fleshed out and works incredibly well in that regard but these events happen to everybody who plays the game long enough to add to the illusion of a “real” world. I’ll say this though, I care a lot more about the characters in cyberpunk than I’ve ever in any GTA game and that is not ever a easy task so I think CDPR delivered on this promise.

 

[Kabelly]

Cyberpunk should have been third person.

 

[Fbh]

Haven't played Cyberpunk because all my hardware sucks.
But just talking exclusively about GTAV, I'd gladly give up most of those details for gameplay and missions that aren't dogshit

 

[vpance]

Cool. Can we get Rockstar to make a proper Cyberpunk game in the style of GTA/RDR?

Some studio will capitalize on this situation for sure.

The thirst for a meaty open world cyberpunk game is still unfulfilled. Wouldn’t be surprised if a couple contenders come out in 2-3 years time.

 

[Hawking Radiation]

Cyberpunk should have been third person.

Would've liked a field of view like in Division 2: