I mean if we're gonna go there, when segregating Reader's Choice out of the tally so far, Elden Ring has already surpassed TLOU2.
Elden Ring: Media outlets: 237
TLOU 2: Media Outlets: 208
Additionally TLOU2 won 50.1% of the total GotY awards given out in 2020 when all was said and done. Right now Elden Ring is sitting at 73.9%, and if the previous years were anything to go by, there's still roughly 100-150 still to come for Q1 2023. I don't think Elden Ring will beat out TLOU2 when it comes to the Reader's Choice total because there was a lot of fuckery in 2020 with random social media accounts being counted for GoTY, in additional to Playstation having a lot of fans, but I think overall Elden Ring is on pace to to pass TLOU2's total of 322.