I agree somewhat with him,the originals atmosphere,ambient soundtrack and cinematography are all superior to the remake in my opinion.Probably his worst video, and the first one where it seems he's nitpicking just for the sake of it.
And according to the initial feedback, that's what most other people think as well.
its like an essence, ethereal yet tangible in all the known ways...What is "soul" in a videogame?
Is that like nostalgia?
its like an essence, ethereal yet tangible in all the known ways...
The problem with this video is the title and description. If he had just left it as a comparison piece without bias(like some of his best older videos), it would be received much better.Probably his worst video, and the first one where it seems he's nitpicking just for the sake of it.
And according to the initial feedback, that's what most other people think as well.
it's compressed to shit and simply louder. Very cheap trick using as A/B type "comparison" against a dynamic low RMS remake audio, but clearly gets the job done looking at the comments.Man the original just blows the ambience of the remake out the water.
Kind of. For the purpose of the thread I'll take your post seriously. For some games it's when developers go the extra mile to make sure that barely any part of it is left untouched.What is "soul" in a videogame?
Is that like nostalgia?
Actually people in this thread are threatened by Remake being questioned. But GAF loves consuming products. Give it 10 years, the pendulum will swing back to the correct side. Just gotta wait on some Youtuber to form their opinion for them.ITT: This video sucks, it's threatening my nostalgia for one of the most overrated games of all time and doesn't validate my purchase
At least know what's happening in a topic before you embarrass yourself.ITT: This video sucks, it's threatening my nostalgia for one of the most overrated games of all time and doesn't validate my purchase
What is "soul" in a videogame?
Is that like nostalgia?
First one? He's always been that way.Probably his worst video, and the first one where it seems he's nitpicking just for the sake of it.
And according to the initial feedback, that's what most other people think as well.
This 'must play' or 'absolute garbage' mentality when it comes to judging remakes, let alone video games, is detrimental. Some people like it a lot, some don't. Both sides will have to live with that. It won't matter either way in 10 years.Actually people in this thread are threatened by Remake being questioned. But GAF loves consuming products. Give it 10 years, the pendulum will swing back to the correct side. Just gotta wait on some Youtuber to form their opinion for them.
"They made the boss floor wood, game ruined."waiting for "demons souls remake is souless too"
waiting for "demons souls remake is souless too"
And dead space, wait someone already mentioned that onewaiting for "demons souls remake is souless too"
And dead space, wait someone already mentioned that one
Lol come onI prefer the remake in pretty much every single one of those instances.
I disagree, but they are my favorite games so far this year, dead space remake is fantastic. my bad for misinterpreting your post.I said that because Dead Space remake shits on RE4 remake.
my bad for misinterpreting your post.
The original will always be one of the greatest games of all time,the remake is just another third person horror game.but the original pales in comparison in every way. Accept that fact, let it go and move on.
True,he was always carried by his editing in previous videos.The negative reaction to his newest comparison only goes to show that most of his videos were only ever lukewarm observations or peddling consensus like “buggy game is bad, Ubisoft downgrades their games and new game bad, old game good”. Him criticising RE4R is going against what most of his audience thinks of this remake.
Nothing looks cohesive in the remake in my opinion. Also missing the ambience.The original is looney toons in comparison to the broody thick atmosphere of the remake