• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Winter 2012 Anime Thread of Roundcats Up in This

Status
Not open for further replies.

iavi

Member
Well, I guess not every thread can be as visually pleasing as Infinite Nine's efforts.

Lol, in all seriousness, the thread will look a million times better than that. However, I will, in all likeliness, be asking for the assistance of a fellow animugaf photoshop/gimp genius. Because, sadly enough, while that's a bad joke, that's also a pretty good representation of my photo editing skills.
 

Thoraxes

Member
Elfen Lied END

Well that sucked. I read through some old threads on the show and someone posted that the ending was hopeful. wtf.
The research facility continues to flourish and the whole species of whatever will live on through the CEO and his son's research assistance.
How anyone could get emotional when this show is throwing pure fecal matter in your face in the form of awful characters is beyond me.

Yeah, I totally agree. I just thought it was terrible overall and it was one of my earlier experiences of things I just didn't like.
 

Soma

Member
Lol, in all seriousness, the thread will look a million times better than that. However, I will in all likeliness be asking for the assistance of a fellow animugaf photoshop/gimp genius. Because, sadly enough, while that's a bad joke, that's also pretty good representation of my photo editing skills.

If you need a hand with anything photoshop-wise, I totally can help out. You probably might have some other options available but I enjoy helping out with things like this. :)
 

iavi

Member
If you need a hand with anything photoshop-wise, I totally can help out. You probably might have some other options available but I enjoy helping out with things like this. :)

Definitely, and thx for the offer. The season begins around the beginning of April or so, so I won't be starting just yet, but will definitely let you know what things are looking like when I do.
 

Instro

Member
So I just looked at animesuki and I see a bunch of people talking about how "awesome" episode 2 of BRS is.

crying.JPG

You just don't get the complex emotional drama going on in the series man.
 

wonzo

Banned
supposedly it's Oshiitastic for like when he's directing and like something something for the other episodes.

Been on my backlog for ages too.
It's pretty great and you should give it a try. Does it sound less daunting if I say you only have to watch the first 106 Mamoru Oshii episodes? That's like, only half the whole show!
Are the non-Oshii episodes supposed to be bad or something as I've seen this pop up quite a lot.

200+ is an exaggeration; it's actually 195.
Well, that changes everything! I'll probably check out the series after I catch up on Gintama and get around to watching LoGH.

A Knight in the Area 6

http://i.imgur.com/Owmlil.jpg[img]

Somehow the fat dude lost all his weight in a week or however long it was since the last episode took place. Why make him a fat dude in the first place?[/quote]
Because it's a bad show with bad writing.

[quote="Branduil, post: 35036417"]So I just looked at animesuki and I see a bunch of people talking about how "awesome" episode 2 of BRS is.

[img]http://dl.dropbox.com/u/12082922/glass%20fleet/crying.JPG[img][/quote]
[quote]This show does have minor problems but I don't care, after this episode I can easily say I fucking love it. Couldn't look away for a second and my interest was completely swept up in all of what was happening.

I didn't expect the issue with Kagari to resolve itself so soon though. I thought she'd be the antagonist for the whole run of the series. When she cut that heart-shaped scar into Yomi with the needle, she was starting to become one of those cold-hearted ruthless villains where seeing them finally get their comeuppance would be so satisfying. It's a shame her psychosis was cured so soon and easily. Quite disappointing. I kind of wish Mato or Yomi would've decked her at least once and then maybe I'd be a little more content with that.

Action in the Otherworld scenes were brilliant here. BRS didn't take that shit no more and brought out a big-ass gatling gun against Chariot's mount. Not to mention the way she finished off Chariot by decapitating her. That was so goddamn cool. We need more female characters this awesome in anime.

And Black Gold Saw appears for the first time interrupting what was happening. I wonder if she even has a real-world counterpart? I wonder what that scene was supposed to mean...

I'm looking forward to seeing where this will go next and how it'll all come together.~ [/quote]
[IMG]http://i.minus.com/ibg85EBNANjnsg.gif

there's probably worse but I can't bring myself to do anything other than skim through animesuki

edit:

I like this show. I come down firmly on the side of "unconventional," as opposed to "inept." Not everything has to be dead normal. Fortunately. I think the depth is there, just not in a clear and rational way. It comes in feeling. Maybe that makes it deeper than a normally "well-directed" show. And maybe not, lol.

If I had to choose, I would choose the TV series over the OVA, so far. But I liked the OVA, too.
apparently the writing's just unconventional. no way it could just be really fucking bad! well, maybe i cant appreciate it's depth because i'm not feeling it maaaan.
 
Cosmic's post from earlier makes me want to watch Air Gear. How bad is it? What's wrong with me?

I actually have not seen the anime, but the manga basically boils down to pretty art, cool looking battles, and incoherence. I do think the anime covers the part when it still made sense though.

Hyouka, u mean.

And I was looking forward to a shonentastic OP. :(

Don't worry, Summer will be shounentastic. Most mustache show will get top billing.

Though for those wondering, Spring wouldn't have been all bad. Saint Seiya Omega would at least be up there. Apollon on the other hand would have gotten a really small pic in the corner of a haly made banner. No description or anything.
 

Soma

Member
Definitely, and thx for the offer. The season begins around the beginning of April or so, so I won't be starting just yet, but will definitely let you know what things are looking like when I do.

Looking forward to it!

Kare Kano 2-6

Jeez I've had the OP stuck in my head for the past two nights.

Anyhow, I'm really enjoying how this show is developing. Yukino is still awesome and cute, her family (especially her dad) are hilarious, and I'm starting to warm up to Arima. I wasn't really interested in his character until Episode 3 or 4. Man, speaking of Episode 4, the ending to that was great.
After spending an entire episode trying to get her feelings for him out there, I thought that was a great way to "say it".

I can forsee some trouble brewing ahead with Arima's lack of confidence in himself so I'm looking forward to see how their relationship continues... and not so looking forward to the forewarned budget issues in the latter half :(
 

madp

The Light of El Cantare
The show uses so many METAPHORS, it all goes over my head. I'm like a little bird in a cage that can't see the world of colors.

In a colorless world, there are no ugly macaroons. Maybe someday we'll understand exactly what Kagari was trying to say, but it's all so impossibly deep and meaningful and subtly woven into the dialogue and imagery. Truly for only very serious scholars.
 
Though for those wondering, Spring wouldn't have been all bad. Saint Seiya Omega would at least be up there. Apollon on the other hand would have gotten a really small pic in the corner of a haly made banner. No description or anything.
Thank you based Miri.
Don't worry, Summer will be shounentastic. Most mustache show will get top billing.
Fuck, if no one has actually claimed the summer thread I'll do it.
 

Jex

Member
Lol, in all seriousness, the thread will look a million times better than that. However, I will, in all likeliness, be asking for the assistance of a fellow animugaf photoshop/gimp genius. Because, sadly enough, while that's a bad joke, that's also a pretty good representation of my photo editing skills.

I didn't actually think the thread would look like that.
 
Yeah, Cosmic's given up dibs on the spring in exchange for the summer. That'll be his fort.
Oh well, the OP can't be worse than this thread's. How exactly does this "dibs" thing work? If it's straight forward, then I call dibs on the fall thread. Watch it turn out to be a crappy season. >_>
 

Jex

Member
Are the non-Oshii episodes supposed to be bad or something as I've seen this pop up quite a lot.

They're not bad by any means, they're just a lot more rote than the Oshii directed stuff. They stick pretty closely to the manga where as Oshii is a lot more experimental.
 

Dresden

Member
Oh well, the OP can't be worse than this thread's. How exactly does this "dibs" thing work? If it's straight forward, then I call dibs on the fall thread. Watch it turn out to be a crappy season. >_>

I called dibs on the fall thread a while back, but I'm willing to sell the rights for about two hundred bucks.
 

wonzo

Banned
While you're wondering about that let me know what you think of this sample of the upcoming thread. I've already finished a bit, and am pretty proud of it if I do say so myself.

-----

http://dl.dropbox.com/u/58148/Banner.jpg[img]



[img]http://dl.dropbox.com/u/58148/God.png[img]


Now all I have to do is get the listings and pictures for said product and we'll be good to go.[/quote]
i know you're joking but you should seriously do the op like that
 

Jex

Member
Thank you based Miri.

It would probably have just prompted someone to make an Apollon thread. Actually, I imagine someone still will make an Apollon thread, and because it will have Watanabe in the title it will be really popular when the show first airs. As people realise that it's not going to be another Cowboy Bebop or Samuari Champloo the thread will slowly get less and less active.
 
It would probably have just prompted someone to make an Apollon thread. Actually, I imagine someone still will make an Apollon thread, and because it will have Watanabe in the title it will be really popular when the show first airs. As people realise that it's not going to be another Cowboy Bebop or Samuari Champloo the thread will slowly get less and less active.
Slowly? I think you underestimate GAF.
 

Branduil

Member
Why do you hate people disagree with you?

I actually wouldn't mind them disagreeing if their analysis was actually interesting and substantial. At least then you can learn something even if you can disagree. But when the analysis amounts to "this show is unconventional," referring to how the show's writing depicts everyone as totally insane and unbelievable, it's painful to read. Some of them don't even seem to notice there is anything problematic about the script, or that someone might think it is.
 

Risette

A Good Citizen
I actually wouldn't mind them disagreeing if their analysis was actually interesting and substantial. At least then you can learn something even if you can disagree. But when the analysis amounts to "this show is unconventional," referring to how the show's writing depicts everyone as totally insane and unbelievable, it's painful to read. Some of them don't even seem to notice there is anything problematic about the script, or that someone might think it is.
That's what happens to people when the only thing they watch is anime. Animesuki forums and the like are painful to read.
 

Defuser

Member
Denpa Onna ep 13

I maybe late but ryuuuko is hnnnnnnnnnnngggghhh. Over 10 min of moe overload of ryuko.

Inu x boku ep 5
Man Tomokazu Sugita makes every show soooo goood. Sadist! M! M! Sadist!
 

BluWacky

Member
It's replacing Inu x Boku SS on MBS Thursday nights. So yes, it's a 2am show and will probably be filled with crappy fan service and other garbage. But it's not the "big" slot that Persona 4 is on. It's after that. Lol.

Ahahaha. I guess Natsui-iro Kiseki or Sankarea will take the main slot then!

:(
 

Jex

Member
That's what happens to people when the only thing they watch is anime. Animesuki forums and the like are painful to read.

It's even worse when people who've only watched anime go on to create anime. I mean, the older generation directors were directly influenced by film, which made their knowledge of the craft far more robust and well rounded. When a director's main inspiration is 'anime' I'm always rather concerned about what they will produce.
 

wonzo

Banned
Soredemo 4



Sucks that this series is only 12 eps. How else am I gonna get my Omigawa fix??

They're not bad by any means, they're just a lot more rote than the Oshii directed stuff. They stick pretty closely to the manga where as Oshii is a lot more experimental.
a'ight, i'll keep that in mind when i get around to watching it.
 

Steroyd

Member
Knight of the Area - 06

3 things that struck me during this episode.

A Knight in the Area 6

Owmlil.jpg

First was the amazing Slim Fast Araki used, he should patent that stuff, he'd be a bilionaire.

The other was.

Rf09Y.jpg


I'm sorry didn't they spend practically the entirety of episode 1 highlighting how much Kakeru sucks with his right foot, and he's really a lefty?

By the way he successfully scored a goal with a "bullet shot" with that foot by the way.

The 3rd thing is how they're constantly running away with this "heart" concept, it'd be more tolerable in smaller doses but it's going to be constantly popping up in every episode isn't it? :|
 
Knight of the Area - 06

I'm sorry didn't they spend practically the entirety of episode 1 highlighting how much Kakeru sucks with his right foot, and he's really a lefty?

By the way he successfully scored a goal with a "bullet shot" with that foot by the way.
:|

Because he got not just the heart of his brother but the right leg of a too dark skinned south-american too.
 

Brazil

Living in the shadow of Amaz
Elfen Lied END

Well that sucked. I read through some old threads on the show and someone posted that the ending was hopeful. wtf.
The research facility continues to flourish and the whole species of whatever will live on through the CEO and his son's research assistance.
How anyone could get emotional when this show is throwing pure fecal matter in your face in the form of awful characters is beyond me.

You're supposed to read the manga, not watch the anime, though.

The anime cuts off at basically the manga's halfway point.
 

Jex

Member
After watching Ueki, I can confidently state that curves like that are the sign of a storyboarder who wants to make the visuals interesting but has no clue how to do so.

It's kind of like a wide angle shot - but it's not affecting him at all, and as he's near the centre of the frame he should be distorted as well. It's pretty lame.
 

Envelope

sealed with a kiss
Denpa Onna ep 13

I maybe late but ryuuuko is hnnnnnnnnnnngggghhh. Over 10 min of moe overload of ryuko.

Inu x boku ep 5
Man Tomokazu Sugita makes every show soooo goood. Sadist! M! M! Sadist!

Erio >>>>>>>>>> Ryuushi. Not that Ryuushi is bad, but Erio is practically hnnnnngh and moe incarnate.
 

Brazil

Living in the shadow of Amaz
Yes, but why would you want more Elfin Lied?

Stop calling it "Elfin" Lied, dude, haha.

The manga does have some extra random shit you wouldn't dream of by watching the anime, but at least it brings closure.

I liked it.
 

Haly

One day I realized that sadness is just another word for not enough coffee.
Denpa Girl Rankings:
Maekawa -> Erio -> Meme -> Ryuukoshi -> Loli Alien.

(Although the way Erio refers to Makoto as "cousin" is just so HNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNGH)
 

Defuser

Member
Finally decided to watch Another to see what is all about and the pacing is sooooo slow. MC is stubborn and dumb on what he was doing, although I got a feeling it's going the way of M.night. But nonetheless,it's intriguing to think about it.
 

firehawk12

Subete no aware
YuriHidaSketch SP1
Finally remembered that I should watch these. Anyway:

Wide?
7liT2l.jpg


Wider!
KR7wYl.jpg


WE HAVE TO GO WIDER!
LFUFql.jpg


Looking forward to season 4, whenever that happens.
 

NewFresh

Member
I was afraid of that. :( It intrigued me too, and then I watched it. Kinda probably gonna rewatch Avalon, try to ignore the ugly yellow filter, and pay more attention this time.

Jexhius: There's a reason why no one ever talks about those other non-Jin-Roh Kerberos movies that Guerilla ripped off the Helghast designs from...

How do you do this? I've tried and it's impossible.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom