he's right you know id rather they do a game on their own , a new Ip with good ideas than "YET another silent hill"..
It's the same with Dmc for example or many Ip this gens.
Maybe silent Hill downpour would have been better received if it wasn't a Silent hill in the first place ??
I don't think that not being a Silent Hill game would solve the real issues the game has, those being the abysmal performance problems and terrible combat mechanics. There's a lot to like about the game, but the reception is to be expected for anyone that's played through it.