Yeah, I tend to agree. I enjoyed his style of humor, but it eventually got to the point where he was just making the same jokes/complaints again and again.
"I don't like shooters."
"I don't like RPGs."
"I don't like multiplayer games."
"I don't like motion controls."
"I don't like Nintendo and their rehashes."
He was never really able to break out of that and once I sort of caught on, he lost me. I think what's worse is that, while I'd certainly never call him a legitimate video game reviewer or critic, he used to make some really good points and criticisms about games that spoke to me as a fan. They weren't the same kind of complaints you'd see in actual game review, and they were usually exaggerated a bit, but I felt they were just as valid. Eventually, though, he went from exaggeration to just plain "Internet fanboy hyperbole" when it came to criticizing games.