clay_ghost
Member
You guys are forgetting that the Mods hinted P5 for PS4.
I forgot too.
I forgot too.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Atlus: "Fans will be happy" about Persona teaser site
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
- Status
Magicpaint
Member
Why did Atlus make Persona 4 Golden on Vita then? The sales ceiling for a game like Persona 5 is probably say, 400-500k, something that is easily achievable on a PS3.
Anyway I can't wait for the game to be announced; first, it's loooong overdue, and second, the platform speculation can finally be put to bed.
Magicpaint
Member
Actually now is a fantastic time to release Persona 5 on PS3. The userbase is mature and software sales have been consistent all year. Persona 4 was released in 2008. Persona is also hardly a major system seller like FF or DQ.
clay_ghost
Member
P4 came out AFTER the ps3 was out lol.
Its possible for it to be anywhere (IOS !) outside of xbox360 or xbone exclusive
.If that's the case, PS3 & Wii U.
flatearthpandas
Member
What does that have to do with what I was saying? I was responding to people saying SMTxFE didn't exist or would be shitcanned. SMT/FE relationship is commercially still alive.
While we're on Persona though, is Persona 4 the last original game Atlus developed exclusively for Sony?
Edit: in fairness, I hadn't quoted anyone
Velcro Fly
Member
I just don't think the install base is going to be there for it to be PS4 right off the bat. Makes more sense to be PS3 with a probable Vita port coming in a year or two.
There's no reason at all to cancel the project or re-do it for 3DS, so why would they? I'd worry more if it wasn't Nintendo developing, but they tend to release games they officially announce, and both franchises have pretty dedicated fans. Pretty silly thing to worry about.
What I'm saying is that Atlus' relationship with Nintendo is kind of unknown, to a point. They've put out a lot of exclusive games, but outside of SMT4 (Which even then, was seemingly very low budget) none of them have shown any commitment other than Atlus' commitment to niche content. It doesn't say anything for SMTxFE at all, particularly as that would have to be a much larger budget title.
And the last exclusive game was technically P4G. The last proper game was P4 though, yes. Keep in mind there's also been Arena and Catherine though.
Goddamn they need to release that shit on the 3DS so I can witness the Internet shutting down in a rage. But I also agree with a previous poster: if it was released exclusively on the Xbone... My god the fucking salt lol.
kenji_sama
Member
After playing Catherine, so disappointed if P5's on 3DS
I didn't forget. Things just changed.
3DS is right up there with the worst scenario right above iOS and Android.
I'd much rather have PS3/Vita where the game doesn't look like ass ala SMT4
dark_prinny
Banned
Persona 5 PS3.
flatearthpandas
Member
Of course the only certain things in life are death and taxes, but there is really no reason at all to assume SMTxFE isn't happening.
Golden was an updated port, neither PERSONA Arena nor Catherine were exclusive. Last original exclusive game was P4 in 2008. P5 platforms have not been announced. The last original Persona branded game was multiplatform. The only HD game developed by Atlus was multiplatform. Index said the sale would not affect announced titles. SMTxFE was announced. Within the last few months, 3DS owners who purchased SMTIV and Fire Emblem Awakening were rewarded for their purchases.
Are these all facts?
Do they point towards a Sony exclusive P5?
Do they point towards SMTxFE being cancelled?
I believe he was saying that he wouldn't be surprised if SMTxFE was cancelled because the Wii U isn't selling and the project was seemingly extremely early in development.
Also, disregarding Catherine and Arena because they're on two platforms is silly. They weren't on Nintendo platforms, which is the important part.
I was under the impression that the Persona team was the smaller of Atlus's two R&D groups? They put out far fewer releases at least, it's basically the Persona group versus the "everything else" group.
I still feel like they'll be making their Nintendo debut with a 3DS Persona 3 conversion. Persona 5 will be 360/PS3, but not Wii U.
What a shitty logic.
flatearthpandas
Member
Disregarding them? I'm not disregarding them. The fact that they were MULTIPLATFORM is a very important part of what I'm trying to say. I'm disregatding them as Sony exclusives, sure. Because they were not Sony exclusives
Wii U sales don't translate into any kind of evidence that SMTxFE has been cancelled.
As long as we can agree on the obvious facts that I stated, we can all use our common sense to categorize the various theories.
Prince Vultan
Banned
Haha... why would it be on Wii U?
I don't get that as well, but it would be pretty cool.
DidntKnowJack
Member
Jesus. The top of this page I read:
Without the context of knowing it's someone wishlist. God dammit.
Without the context of knowing it's someone wishlist. God dammit.
I brought those hints up before and was basically told things change by Aeana. I think the only way we'll see P5 on next gen is as a cross gen title.
Samurai_Heart
Member
Hey guys what's going on? Why's this thread still going...
Oh God it's the Persona hardware prediction cycle:
XD
Oh God it's the Persona hardware prediction cycle:
XD
sörine;87543433 said:
The Persona Team is basically one big team that works on everything together. The other R&D group works on lots of smaller projects. That's pretty much my point. (There's also crossover between them. A lot of the members of the Trauma guys have worked on Persona, for example.)
clay_ghost
Member
SMT4 looks as good as P4..... Unless you are talking about the 2D battle? The art looks good in 2D and battle are faster too. Not really sure what you mean by looking like ass when P4 the golden ook about the same as SMT4 in dungeons.
VS
Ya no native screen but its looked slimilar on my vita
Lol no.
SMT4 looks as good as P4..... Unless you are talking about the 2D battle? The art looks good in 2D and battle are faster too. Not really sure what you mean by looking like ass when P4 the golden ook about the same as SMT4 in dungeons.
VS
Ya no native screen but its looked slimilar on my vita
clay_ghost
Member
? Why no ? I played both to hell and feels that they looked in the same range park outside of battle. With SMT4 dungeons looking much better than P4 boring pattern repeating dungeons.
I am serious..........
lol man... maybe you need some glasses.
Seriously, Persona fanbase was always associated with Playstation, since the beggining. I don't understand the Nintendo port begging on this thread. SMT IV? Persona Fighter and Catherine being multiplatform gives you hope?
It won't happen.
Samurai_Heart
Member
? Why no ? I played both to hell and feels that they looked in the same range park outside of battle. With SMT4 dungeons looking much better than P4 boring pattern repeating dungeons.
I am serious..........
You know most of P4 stages were randomly generated outside of some levels within each dungeon?
Edit: Also should use more accurate native screens, such as:
vs
DidntKnowJack
Member
Man I thought I had terrible eyesight. The difference is night and day.? Why no ? I played both to hell and feels that they looked in the same range park outside of battle. With SMT4 dungeons looking much better than P4 boring pattern repeating dungeons.
I am serious..........
? Why no ? I played both to hell and feels that they looked in the same range park outside of battle. With SMT4 dungeons looking much better than P4 boring pattern repeating dungeons.
I am serious..........
I agree with you. The only reason why Persona 4 looks better is because it's HD on the Vita and has way less detail. People just don't want P5 on the 3DS. I don't wither but I would play it so what ever.
? Why no ? I played both to hell and feels that they looked in the same range park outside of battle. With SMT4 dungeons looking much better than P4 boring pattern repeating dungeons.
I am serious..........
Well if it isn't on a glorious OLED screen it's automatically shit :/
You know most of P4 stages were randomly generated outside of some levels within each dungeon?
Edit: Also should use more accurate native screens, such as:
vs
It looks much better in motion on the 3DS XL, most 3DS screens are usual shit and hardly do it's games justice.
clay_ghost
Member
Not from me , i am just saying there is a small chance of P5 on WIIU. LOL noway its not on a sony platform. Remember, i predict that the announcement will be P3:darkness for vita !
And i still think SMT4 looks as good as P4
? Why no ? I played both to hell and feels that they looked in the same range park outside of battle. With SMT4 dungeons looking much better than P4 boring pattern repeating dungeons.
I am serious..........
Persona 4 is hardly an amazing looking game (Far from it, really). But the textures, the meshes... everything is better than SMT4. I mean, in that screenshot you posted, there is literally one single character model on screen. And it's all so muddy. It fits SMT, but that's not my point.
clay_ghost
Member
Of course i know , part of the reasons i like SMT4 > p3/4 is because of that .
Still look in the same park range of decent graphics for me :/
flatearthpandas
Member
I remember being chased out of a P5 thread for having the audacity to question a treasured insider who claimed P5 was Sony exclusive. Have the platforms been announced? No? So is it confirmed Sony exclusive? No? Interesting.sörine;87543964 said:
Persona threads demonstrate difficulty with these things.
Where P5 is one hundred percent confirmed Sony exclusive still and SMTxFE is probably cancelled despite a very recent SMT/FE cross-promotion.
Okay, that makes more sense. Persona has the largest singular team but it's the smaller overall R&D group.
I thought the Trauma series came from the Persona team too but I guess not?
I don't want P5 have battle system in first person view (because that's atlus lazy way for accommodating weaker system) or hearing Meguro's OST in crappy 3DS speaker.
They better announce Devil Survivors 3DS fast, so nintendo fan can be satisfied... the series is arguably modern persona game with superior gameplay despite cheaper aesthetic anyway.
They better announce Devil Survivors 3DS fast, so nintendo fan can be satisfied... the series is arguably modern persona game with superior gameplay despite cheaper aesthetic anyway.
Not at all. I think people are just really interested in a Persona game with amazing grahpics because there has never been one.
SMT4 looks as good as P4..... Unless you are talking about the 2D battle? The art looks good in 2D and battle are faster too. Not really sure what you mean by looking like ass when P4 the golden ook about the same as SMT4 in dungeons.
VS
Ya no native screen but its looked slimilar on my vita
No the game looks a lot better on Vita, even if its because of the screen to a degree. Also silly 2D battles and an over world where you move around this little weird cursor thing is just not what I think most people want from a new Persona game's city structure.
TooOldForGames
Neo Member
Persona 5 on the PS3, pretty please!!
clay_ghost
Member
catherine looks good. People want persona to look as good.
- Status