There is a defense force for everything sadly. Pretty sure there were people defending MS when they banned people for getting Halo 4 early as well.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
So Target shipped someone an Xbox One already? [Update: console-banned until launch]
- Thread starter CrunchinJelly
- Start date
There is a defense force for everything sadly. Pretty sure there were people defending MS when they banned people for getting Halo 4 early as well.
UberTag
Member
Just to note an interesting parallel, an identical situation unfolded around the Vita launch.
Amazon in Canada shipped out a bunch of non-First Edition Vitas prematurely due to a systems glitch.
In fact this was somewhat of an exploit because people were actively taking advantage of it after concluding that systems were shipping prematurely.
So myself and a bunch of other folks on Vita GAF were playing Uncharted, Wipeout, Hot Shots and Little Deviants on February 11th, 2012 well in advance of the system's "street date".
We were sharing screens of the OS. Screens of the games. Getting people hyped and excited.
And did any of these Vitas get banned or bricked? Not a single one.
He didn't get banned for playing it.
BumblebeeCody
Member
You'd think he'd not play it online.
What have I missed. Why did he get the ban?
RedNumberFive
Banned
It's pretty sad that this kind of behavior from Microsoft doesn't even surprise me anymore.
I'm going to take this as a public service to stay far away from the Xbone this generation. This is an early warning of their vision of the future that us consumers were too "simple" to understand.
I'm going to take this as a public service to stay far away from the Xbone this generation. This is an early warning of their vision of the future that us consumers were too "simple" to understand.
this is no normal situation here. Just wait for the 22 and we'll see.
Is it hard to understand what i am saying? Dont jump to conclusions.
Lunacy. I can't believe it.
cyberheater
PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
You're splitting hairs. He got banned for going online. What's the difference.
Posting YouTube videos.
they can unban him if they want.
^^^^ This. Microsoft is in for a world of hurt here. The consumer who is shipped a product has no knowledge of or binding to any agreement on street dates.
I'd file a lawsuit and get a lot more than just a new xbone out of it.
Impeccable
Member
Was there a specific mention the said user couldn't post videos of his own console?
Nemesis121
Member
Day one Patch denied.
No, he got banned for posting YouTube videos. He posted the CoD video earlier in the week as well as an unboxing.
Are youtube videos against the TOS?
I look forward to the circus of the 22nd in that case.
But Microsoft doesn't issue temp console bans. That's my point. Telling us to wait so that this news slips our mind is fishy. Why do you want us to wait? Why are we never allowed to jump to conclusions if we want to when the precedent has already been set where bans are bans on Xbox?
RedNumberFive
Banned
YouTube videos can only come from vetted and pre-approved sources that stay on message (99% of the gaming media).
Felsparrow
Neo Member
Target isn't out of this either. I do recall that many stores sign contracts where they get heavily penalized with fines for breaking street date in certain countries.
I do find it funny people are trying to equate this to other situations that aren't similar at all.
And yet another sign why we couldn't trust MS with that digital DRM system they tried dropping on us in the first place.
I do find it funny people are trying to equate this to other situations that aren't similar at all.
And yet another sign why we couldn't trust MS with that digital DRM system they tried dropping on us in the first place.
Better call the FBI...
Lots o bans for posting youtube videos of GTA 5 prior to release.
So what law did he break? Like others has said he legally bought a console, didn#t sign any NDA, so he can do however he pleases.
Lovely Salsa
Banned
Anyone reuploaded the video of the unboxing?
Well if you get banned for posting youtube videos. That is one more reason to not buy Xbox.
What game was that?
Yes they would. Because they gave you the keys. After the locksmith came and installed the lock on the door, and the superintended gave you the key then you are allowed to move in. They usually give you the key once the apartment/house is finished. If the super feels that the place is finished and you can move in even though the construction for other floors is still ongoing then you can move in and be enjoy the noises of all things construction.
Target shipped the console. Ms had no right to ban it. No warning signs. Logic has nothing to do with it. You paid for the product, ms should not have banned anyone for using the product early. Target should replace the product or MS should lift the ban. And if target is to replace the product, they should replace it asap and not after the product is released.
cyberheater
PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 PS4 Xbone PS4 PS4
I can't see how this would construe as a violation of the terms of service.
That's equally bullshit so I'm not sure why you're trotting that out as Defense. What TOS did GTA players agree to?
There is the TOS.
People have been unbanned, so what? How can you tell this ban isnt simply them keeping him out of live, till it's open for everybody?
simply we dont know yet.
Yeah...the word illegal doesn't mean what quite a few on here seem to think it means
Black Mantis
Member
He'd most likely have been fine if he didn't start uploading stuff to the web. If that's why Microsoft banned the console, I say fair enough. If they reinstate his console upon release, then no biggie as he can still play the games in the meantime.
He is free to return it to Target and possibly be compensated in some manner for the expenses involved in doing so. I don't see the problem. If Target has indicated that they would not accept it back, that's then there is a problem.
Alx
Member
The difference is that he owns the console, not the online servers. He can use the hardware as much as he wishes because he bought it, but if MS decides the additional services are not available, then they're not.
I'm going based on MS track record when it comes to banning. There is "some" recourse to console bans, but they're mostly permanent.
Who said he did anything illegal. You guys should look into what illegal means.
Did he breach the Terms of Service?
BronsonLee
Member
*wakes up*
Wait they actually banned him?!
OH COME ON
Wait they actually banned him?!
OH COME ON
That's the point though - as far as he's communicated, they've not told him either.
Clarifying at least that would be the decent thing to do
Impeccable
Member
Can you spend some time to defend your argument and find the specific mention in the terms of service which relates directly to the effective ban on pre-release gaming footage and a user's obligation to no upload said footage?
I'm actually curious.
I think that's a legitimate viewpoint, but it doesn't necessarily apply in this case.
He accessed those servers with MS's implicit permission because they allowed him access. They could block him without permanently banning his console, presumably. MS is punishing him for breaking the rules without divulging them first.
They also say customer service cant unban you.
What's there to tell people that they're not allowed to go into the stadium?
Hitokiri03
Member
Ban should be used only for extreme cases, like playing in a modified console.
Bad move from Microsoft.
Bad move from Microsoft.
Wait is this true? We no longer can post videos of things we own?
Why not just contact YouTube to get the videos taken down?