MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Dunno, the raunchy adult animation movie that underpaid animators so they could afford having 20 big name stars to half-ass their voice acting would be a good representation of how much people care about animation
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
A Record 27 Animated Feature Films Vie For the Best Animated Feature Oscar.
- Thread starter lightskintwin
- Start date
- Status
Dunno, the raunchy adult animation movie that underpaid animators so they could afford having 20 big name stars to half-ass their voice acting would be a good representation of how much people care about animation
DrunkShogun
Member
Haven't seen moana yet but want your name to win only because it's been a while since a Japanese anime movie resonated so well and might kickstart more quality from them. Zootopia and Kubo are worthy winners if it goes their way. Honestly a decent lineup of worthy winners.
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Disney put out two good movies this year though. If Pixar wins this year then you know they really dont give a shit
They make great films is the reason. Their output this year has been insane and I say this is not really much of a disney fan and even i was besotted with Zootopia.
Yeah, Dory was a good movie but definitely not the best; and shows that the OScar voters still haven't fixed their problem and just vote for whatever they've heard the most of instead of watching them.
TangoAlphaLima
Member
Both Zootopia and Moana were great. Both are deserving. I wonder if Lin-Manuel Miranda will give Moana the edge with Academy voters, though. You'd think Moana will win for Best Original Song.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
It can be both. Disney (and to a lesser extent Pixar) are essentially synonymous with animation for a lot of people, but they make good stuff traditionally. I wouldn't be upset at Moana winning because its a good movie in a category that is seen as lesser.
RatskyWatsky
Hunky Nostradamus
True, but do you really think they really deserve to win every year?
MetroidPrimeRib
Banned
Of course not but thats just how it is. The judges hardly care about the category to begin with, so the least you could expect is they would pick a good movie.
I'm just mad salty I can't watch it yet. :'(
SargerusBR
I love Pokken!
Kingsglaive should win just for GAF reactions.
Psychological Intellect
Banned
Zootopia was mediocre.
The real reason (unfortunately) is people vote on what their kids drag them to, and don't give a shit about any other films. There are numerous years where greatly superior films lost to popular Disney/Pixar films (though not this year, fortunately).
Disney makes great films, absolutely; I adored Zootopia and Moana. However, Disney films for their level of quality win far too often. Animation is the one category where a single company takes home the award 90% of the time.
The Academy of Motion Picture Arts & Sciences, an organization whose general membership is aggressively indifferent towards animation, hands out three annual animation-related Oscars without following the criteria. One of these members outright admitted that he ignored the actual criteria to vote for the movie he liked best, and another like the short film 'Feast' because "He likes dogs."
The problem is that these judges don't even want to waste time on animated movies from small companies. And this is not fair to anyone. Disney, or any of the big-name western animation studios, shouldn't have their films automatically win because of their name recognition. It's not fair to the other nominees if they aren't even given a chance!
The problem is that these judges don't even want to waste time on animated movies from small companies. And this is not fair to anyone. Disney, or any of the big-name western animation studios, shouldn't have their films automatically win because of their name recognition. It's not fair to the other nominees if they aren't even given a chance!
I keep forgetting it came or this year
ryutaro's mama
Member
MOANA
MOANA
MOANA
MOANA
MOANA
UnemployedVillain
Member
It's always a Disney or Pixar movie. Why people get their hopes up for them actually giving a shit, I'll never understand
Aztechnology
Member
Zootopia wins for story/writing, but Kubo for animations and effects. They're both good, but Kubo was amazing in terms of setting a new bar for stop motion. I watched The Nightmare Before Christmas and Kubo last night.
This. They will probably see the ones that have "a puppy on the cover" and vote for it.
BronsonLee
Member
Not like this
Spyder_Monkey
Banned
It'll probably be Zootopia, Moana, Finding Dory, Kubo, and The Red Turtle.
starchild excalibur
Member
Zootopia was my favorite animated film this year, followed by Kubo.
Didn't care that much for Moana, actually.
Didn't care that much for Moana, actually.
ElBoxyBrown
Banned
I can't think of a single good reason for Finding Dory to get nominated.
Infinite Stars
Member
Nah, Last place should have been Boxtrolls, Lego movie should have been on the shortlist, etc.
It beat Kaguya right? What a joke.
mortal
Gold Member
I don't understand what's so funny though? The storytelling wasn't amazing, but as far as technical animation goes. It's incredible work. Definitely worth of some recognition.
It's sort of annoying how people can be so dismissive of the amazing effort that goes into a project like that, just because they didn't like the story.
You really think a mediocre offering like Big Hero 6 deserved to win over Princess Kaguya? This is the only year in which their win would feel deserved; and I say this as someone who has seen all the front runners including Your Name and The Red Turtle.
You want a joke, read what many of the Academy voters had to say about Kaguya. Some of that shit was straight up racist garbage.
Fucking lol at Kingsglave being on the list.
Also part of me is mad that Your Name is being considered just because it played in a few LA theaters and no where else. RELEASE IT NATIONWIDE ALREADY DAMMIT.
Anyway, I see Zootopia winning but wouldn't mind a surprise win from Kubo. Though I don't remember the last time a non-Disney film won an Oscar for best animated. Spirited Away was distributed by Disney.
Also part of me is mad that Your Name is being considered just because it played in a few LA theaters and no where else. RELEASE IT NATIONWIDE ALREADY DAMMIT.
Anyway, I see Zootopia winning but wouldn't mind a surprise win from Kubo. Though I don't remember the last time a non-Disney film won an Oscar for best animated. Spirited Away was distributed by Disney.
Rango (2011), Happy Feet (2006), Wallace and Gromit: Curse of the Warerabbit (2005), and Shrek (2001) are the four movies that won the award and were not from Disney in some way.
This is not a list of nominations. This is a list of animated films of the year being submitted for consideration which qualify base on guidelines. This just shows how under-represented animation has always been. 27 films being considered in a year is a "record". For most categories, it's not even worth mentioning because it would be hundreds at least.
There is zero chance Kingsglaive will be a nomination so...
hosannainexcelsis
Member
UberTag
Member
Pretty much what everyone expected. Zootopia should take this in a walk.
That said, I was pleasantly surprised to see that Visual Effects Oscar nom for Kubo and the Two Strings. It might actually be able to take home a consolation prize.
I mean, it's probably going to get beat out by The Jungle Book... but at least it's a possibility.
Incidentally, this is now 4 years in a row for a GKIDS nomination... they've got quite the little awards lobby, don't they?
BronsonLee
Member
It should be Kubo, it will probably be Zootopia, which isn't as good as Moana
Pretty cool. Ma Vie de Courgette, The Red Turtle and Kubo are all worthy of the Oscar. That said, one of the two Disney films (probably Zootopia) will obviously win.
Hyperactivity
Banned
So can Your Name qualify for next year or no?
It probably got screwed over by having next to no releases in NA yet. Plus this year just being so damn strong for animation
It probably got screwed over by having next to no releases in NA yet. Plus this year just being so damn strong for animation
- Status
Similar threads
- Locked
- Locked