• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

American Idol X|V |OT| Please Be Excited

Status
Not open for further replies.
*yawn* haven't watched this flop show in years. The hell, the judges are still JLow, Keith Kidman and Will & Grace's husband? That's the best they could wrangle together? Ugh.
edit: LOL I see they fired Randy WHEN did that happen????

maybe I'll stick around for the snark (and hope Leona posts in this season's OT, love ha commentary)
 
this guy is bad. like the gay bully from glee bad.

tumblr_m3fn2oZwNp1rohhuc.gif


EDIT:

First guy is an actor
Second person is an actress

starting to see no trend here.
 
send her through she's pretty

she won't make next round anyways

EDIT: Yay! Enjoy your next (last) round Miss Eye Candy
 
ok they've shown her child so she's through

EDIT: single mom, maybe she'll get two golden tickets
 
Let it be known that the first critique of technical singing ability was offered in jest to a contestant's daughter.
 
DMPrince said:
YES YES. WE NEED MORE LAZZZIES THIS SEASON.

Scott MacInTyre got his vision back i see.

but sacrificed his voice for it.

Speaking of blind guy. look at what they just did.
Click to expand...

Please no. He's not even fun awful, unless you love c-rate versions of hotel lounge music featured in the background of a scene in Empire.

Your next American Idol, everyone. Let's go home.
 
as a gay guy alex shier is cute.

fuck off harry. this is why the ratings are tanking. get a guy both guys and girls can thirst over.

EDIT: Cody Fry looks like if Ryan Gosling and Tom Felton had a baby.

girl looks like Keshia Pulliam aka miranda aka Rudy Huxtable
 
MIMIC said:
Just got in. What's the guitar count? I literally turned on the TV and the next guy to play had a guitar.
Click to expand...

i didn't count but pretty sure 80% so far had guitar. they eve decided to show a scene at the guitar repair shop where a guy was tuning a guitar.

also Savion Wright was back. but he's not going to do a Candice Glover, nope.
 
DMPrince said:
too bad she didn't make it hollywood going by the TOP 24 Reveal Video
Click to expand...
S H O C K I N G

enigmatic_alex44 said:
maybe I'll stick around for the snark (and hope Leona posts in this season's OT, love ha commentary)
Click to expand...
Can't make any guarantees, this shit is literally painful to all my senses XD

EDIT: I'm going to need Savion to sing "Change the World" in full if he makes Top 24 though. That was pure and pristine and brilliant~
 
Leona Lewis said:
S H O C K I N G


Can't make any guarantees, this shit is literally painful to all my senses XD

EDIT: I'm going to need Savion to sing "Change the World" in full if he makes Top 24 though. That was pure and pristine and brilliant~
Click to expand...


Leona sis I gave up after 45 minutes lmao, I just couldn't take it anymore. Maybe I'll give it another chance next week if nothing else is on...
 
there's not enough Asian singers this year. judges be racist (lol) or they are just not into singing. the one guy that made it through the audition was meh. i know there's a few asian girls auditioning but we need some diversity.
 
Damn near everyone played an instrument on last nights auditions. And that last young girl Lovey already has a music video out? I guess idol doesn't care if you're formerly signed anymore
 
tj hazuki said:
Savion Wright was my favorite audition from the last two episodes.
Click to expand...
Yes - he sings so effortlessly and joyfully. My only minor quibble is that he slightly truncates the end of words, so the transition into the next line isn't as smooth as it could be.

Killer chord choices, too. Much better than the brainless strumming you hear from 99% of these guitar-toting flops.
 
Sooooo.....there was actually some good news, ratings-wise. Not only did Idol hold on to its viewers from Wednesday, but for the first time since the first season, it actually IMPROVED upon its Night 1 to Night 2 viewership

The improvement was small, but hey....it's a victory! =p

Deadline:
Fox’s American Idol may have made a case for putting more competition reality series on demand shortly after they air on TV. Last night, Part 2 of the veteran singing show’s two-night premiere drew a 3.0 in adults 18-49 and 11 million viewers in the fast nationals from 8-10 PM. That was down -21% from last year’s Night 2 of Idol premiere in the demo. But in an encouraging sign, that was down just a tenth (-3%) from the Wednesday opening in 18-49 (fast nationals to fast nationals) and up a fraction (100,000) in viewers, the first Night 1-to-Night-2 gain (albeit minuscule) in Idol history*.
Click to expand...

*this stat is wrong, according to Wiki. In Season 1, the series debuted with 10 million viewers, which grew to 11 million in the second episode.
 
*watching the NFC playoff*

Lambert is a guest judge? -_____-

EDIT: I missed the first hour of night 2 so I'm watching it now. Piper is without a doubt the best singer they've had so far, IMO. And shockingly enough, she didn't have a guitar! @_@
 
MIMIC said:
*watching the NFC playoff*

Lambert is a guest judge? -_____-

EDIT: I missed the first hour of night 2 so I'm watching it now. Piper is without a doubt the best singer they've had so far, IMO. And shockingly enough, she didn't have a guitar! @_@
Click to expand...

she won't make top 24 since she doesn't have a guitar.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

XIX Chopin Competition - Eric Lu from the US wins 1st prize, second American, first in 50 years
|OT| 
10
631
Unknown Soldier replied
Oscars 2026 |OT|
2 3
149
2K
DKehoe replied
American Primeval (Netflix)
|OT| 
4
2K
I collect VHS tapes replied
X-Files Reboot
2 3 4
164
2K
jason10mm replied
  • Locked
Trump X 6ix9ne
5
334
Coconutt replied
Top Bottom