So I'm more willing to talk about it now, but needless to say I won't be trading with anyone on r/amiiboswap ever again.
So, I bought an extra Gold Mario, with the intent to trade for the last wave 3 character I don't have, Meta Knight, I worked out a deal with a guy, and he just asked for two pictures, one of the figure new in the box, and one of how it will be packaged. I agreed, and shipped it to him.
I receive Meta Knight, no issue. He then sends be an angry email, saying that there are dents on the side of the package, saying I misled him, and that the amiibo is now worthless because of it. He sends me pictures of tiny imperfections on the sides of the bubble, with a gash down the middle...CLEARLY made by the box cutter he used. I apologized, and said that the issues must have happened during shipping. He said that was impossible, and as a true amiibo collector, I would agree that this would be unacceptable. He now wants me to replace the Meta Knight (which is impossible since I opened it like I do all my amiibo) or buy another Gold Mario and replace his, paying for both my and the return shipping.
This comes after:
1. He never said he cared about packaging condition any time during the dealings.
2. He was fine with everything that came before.
3. I GUARANTEE that if he was to put it on eBay he would still get $40-$50 for it.
Needless to say, he has been placed on my gmail ignore list, but knowing how...insane r/amiibo can be, I get the feeling I'm about to get permabanned. Sorry to vent, I'm just really pissed about the whole situation.