Support NeoGAF

[3dmodeler]

I'm always surprised people list the fade first, if you ask me I thought the Deep roads was much more annoying.

 

[RytGear]

You need the lull after The End so that you can calm down after that amazing boss fight and also so that you can have a bit of quiet time before The Fury. Without it the next boss fight would come too quickly and although it wasn't "fun" having the snake eater theme in the background made it far less boring.

 

[BouncyFrag]

The recent Dungeon Keeper release for iOS/Android. Francis doesn't like this one bit:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LtD-P6Baf8E

 

[CurlySaysX]

Asscreed 4. The part where you go into some sort of an office.
I want to be a pirate! If I wanted to be in an office I'd go to work innit?

 

[genbatzu]

guacamelee tule tree top

 

[BouncyFrag]

Asscreed 4. The part where you go into some sort of an office.
I want to be a pirate! If I wanted to be in an office I'd go to work innit?

Don't forget stealthy following a big ass ship in your own big ass ship missions.

 

[Deleted member 57681]

Silent Hill 2 made you run around in a seemingly neverending dull and foggy enviroment at the start to make you feel isolated right from the beginning.

 

[Benzychenz]

Raids in WoW.

Designed to further your loot addiction, but are either painful, boring, or a hideous combination of the two. Ain't nobody ever gone raiding for a good time.

Wut.

Raiding is the only reason to play WoW, shits fun as hell.

 

[VanquishUK]

The entirety of Outlands in WoW. It's so dull and depressing I feel like it was intentional.

 

[Delta Assault]

The Library in Halo CE.

I'm sure of it.

 

[Nose Master]

You can dash from bonfire to boss in like under two stamina bars. The area before this was a lot worse.

 

[ChawlieTheFair]

Any elevator ride in game. I mean, by defenition all you are doing is riding a damn elevator, possibly while the game loads, how can it in anyway be fun?

 

[NingenJanai]

guacamelee tule tree top

Yeah, I got stuck there, and since there was no way to get out, I quit the game and haven't finished it.

 

[Cozmogramma]

guacamelee tule tree top

But that was fun though. Frustrating and challenging, but also fun. One of the best parts of the game.

Yeah, I got stuck there, and since there was no way to get out, I quit the game and haven't finished it.

Can't you just jump down from where you came? Been a long time since I played it though so maybe not.

 

[Toparaman]

The recent Dungeon Keeper release for iOS/Android. Francis doesn't like this one bit:
www.youtube.com/watch?v=LtD-P6Baf8E

LOL. They're not even trying to be subtle about it.

 

[SolVanderlyn]

It's never intentional, but ice/movement puzzles aren't ever fun.

You know, these:

The ladder from MGS3 is the best example I can think of. Like others have said, though, it isn't dull, or bad. It's not engaging and it's not thrill inducing, and its purpose lies in reasons other than having "fun".

 

[Salsa]

guacamelee tule tree top

*pic*

this was the most fun part of the game

the only thing I can think of is something like Flower, Sun and Rain

game purposefully made you do boring tasks and the like. Literally run to and back from 2 characters through the same path to say stuff to each other. More of an experience than a game, it was interesting.



responses here are terrible and it's like people are not reading the OP. Maybe the thread title should read "intentionally designed to not be fun" or something. It's an interesting idea for a thread but everyone's just posting parts of games they didnt like.

 

[HK-47]

The entirety of Pathologic and The Void

Suffering and futility in video game form. They are oppressively bleak

 

[Joei]

That tunnel part in FF13.

That's the part of the game where you realize you just got punked.

 

[MetroidPrimeRib]

The Scorpion Hunting Levels in No More Heroes 2 are there as a joke. Suda heard the complaints about them in the first game and decided to make the framerate worse and stick it in the same game as well.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MnY9FszRjN0

Goddammit this, screw you Suda

 

[Synth]

You know... I don't feel like many people are really understanding the topic here. It's supposed to be areas the are INTENTIONALLY not fun. Not areas that the devs intended to be fun, but completely screwed up on. Nearly all the examples I'm seeing are of the latter.

 

[sector4]

The nightmare segment in Max Payne. Slow, crappy platforming where you sort of need to know where the end is or you just fall to a slow, painful death.

This is the first one I agree with in this thread, that stuff was actually painful.

Edit: but yeah in light of the post above, it probably wasn't intentional

 

[Whiskeymatt]

guacamelee tule tree top

This is the best and most fun platforming section in Guacamelee. The teleporting platforms section was awful, though.

 

[NingenJanai]

Can't you just jump down from where you came? Been a long time since I played it though so maybe not.

No, you just die and respawn at that hellish location

 

[Souldestroyer Reborn]

Wut.

Raiding is the only reason to play WoW, shits fun as hell.

This. I used to spend pretty much every night in raids on WoW. Loved that shit.

The entirety of Outlands in WoW. It's so dull and depressing I feel like it was intentional.

Outlands is my favourite area :I

The whole vibe of the place was perfect, for what it was trying to accomplish. The raiding scene was awesome at that time too.

You are not prepared....

 

[moniker]

guacamelee tule tree top

Disagree. It was the best part of the game.

 

[Mistel]

Blighttown or lost izlath in dark souls.

 

[HK-47]

You know... I don't feel like many people are really understanding the topic here. It's supposed to be areas the are INTENTIONALLY not fun. Not areas that the devs intended to be fun, but completely screwed up on. Nearly all the examples I'm seeing are of the latter.

I dont think many people have played games with areas that arent intentionally fun, mainly because most people probably dont even realize there are games whose goals arent to be fun. Its so often touted around as the most important factor in a game.

 

[Hatchtag]

Yeah, I got stuck there, and since there was no way to get out, I quit the game and haven't finished it.

Wrong. Wrong wrong wrong wrong wrong.
Tule tree is fun.
The fucking DLC challenge where you have to get the chicken to the end of a little maze thing by hitting it around is not.

Spoiler

Still Platinumed the game and got all DLC trophies tho.

 

[Synth]

I dont think many people have played games with areas that arent intentionally fun, mainly because most people probably dont even realize there are games whose goals arent to be fun. Its so often touted around as the most important factor in a game.

Yea, I realise its a difficult topic to actually come up with examples for.

 

[striferser]

don't know if this section was considered "fun." I am not saying this section is bad and shouldn't exist.

The ladder: What a thrill...
I say lot of part in heavy rain . it just you waiting for something to happen. It's definitely not fun

 

[VanquishUK]

This. I used to spend pretty much every night in raids on WoW. Loved that shit.



Outlands is my favourite area :I

The whole vibe of the place was perfect, for what it was trying to accomplish. The raiding scene was awesome at that time too.

You are not prepared....

I didn't mind it at first, but when I was on my 3rd or 4th playthrough, I couldn't stand it any longer.

 

[Steiner84]

stealth bf4 thread?

 

[TuckingFypo]

guacamelee tule tree top

I had much more trouble with the teleporting platforms, can't remember what it was called

 

[dog$]

You know... I don't feel like many people are really understanding the topic here. It's supposed to be areas the are INTENTIONALLY not fun. Not areas that the devs intended to be fun, but completely screwed up on. Nearly all the examples I'm seeing are of the latter.

It's because the thread's premise is broken from the start.

I'd feel safe in betting my life savings that no design team ever reached a point in designing their game by saying "OK, now how do we make this part of the game not fun".

 

[Prophet Steve]

Pacing.

You need the lull after The End so that you can calm down after that amazing boss fight and also so that you can have a bit of quiet time before The Fury. Without it the next boss fight would come too quickly and although it wasn't "fun" having the snake eater theme in the background made it far less boring.

Yes, it is intentional for a reason, he isn't even saying it is bad.

Also this seems to be about the only example I can agree with. There might be some deliberate endless amount of enemies though in a game that is supposed to tire you out.

EDIT: Oh wait, Nier too, it opens some options if I don't think of it as boring mechanics only.

Of Spec-ops I am convinced they did not try to create a boring shooter. I think they tried to make the shooting itself as fun as they could make it, it would strengthen the message of the game. Of course what it conveys through the rest of the aspects of the game is something entirely different.

 

[MBR]

That whole chapter is the game saying "You want to play the good parts? Sure, just do this 1,5 hour fetch quest first."

 

[Cutreman]

The entirety of Spec Ops: The Line

Agree. Ok, game's narrative is cool, disturbing sometimes, but as a TPS is mediocre.

 

[strangedopamine]

The Spring Mario sections in Super Mario Galaxy.

 

[Jucksalbe]

Climbing the stairs in Final Fantasy 7's Shinra building.

 

[Mman235]

Demon's Souls Valley of Defilement. Everything about it is designed to take you out of your comfort zone and rethink your tactics

Spoiler

right down to how the last boss fight makes you rethink the entire nature of your mission in the first place

and it does it perfectly.

 

[Dr. Buni]

Water Temple in Ocarina of Time. Also, most areas in Mario 64. Also, 99% of water levels in most games.

Also again, the Valley Of Defilement in Demon's Souls... I am not entirely sure if that area was supposed to be fun? Because it really wasn't to me.

 

[BPoole]

Lost Izalith
Valley of Defilement
The Gutter
Black Gulch
Dragon's Shrine

 

[Conor_Fool]

Maybe mopping in GTA 5? That sucked

 

[Salsa]

this is the worst thread failure i've seen in the gaming side of gaf

I'd feel safe in betting my life savings that no design team ever reached a point in designing their game by saying "OK, now how do we make this part of the game not fun".

there are examples here where that has already been proven wrong. Heck there's one in the actual OP (no russian)

even if we didnt have examples to list, what OP's talking about would be a more interesting discussion to have. certainly more so than "not fun? oh that part in X game where it got hard"

 

[Converse]

It's not an area, per se, but in the BIT.TRIP games, if you perform poorly you enter a state called the Nether. Basically, if you're playing well, the music grows more full and the graphics grow more colorful and rich; if you're not playing well, the graphics become more simple and the music less full until you enter the Nether, which is black and white, blurry and aurally tinny -- on the Wii, all of the sound is reduced to Atari 2600-like bleeps from the Wii remote's speaker. You can get out of the Nether by playing better, and it feels really rewarding to do so.

EDIT: Oh, and I'm not sure if I agree, but you could make a case for the overworld and job-themed mini-games in the first No More Heroes being intentionally monotonous, as sort of a satire of the player who spends his time in a pale reflection of the real world, or as a send-up of both video game monotony and low-wage employment monotony.

 

[funkystudent]

In red dead redemption near the end when u herd cattle

 

[davepoobond]

Games aren't always meant to be fun.

they can be a test of endurance, a test of a patience, etc etc etc.

 

[TheVampire]

Those tunnels underground water plant thing in Vampire Bloodlines.

 

[Sgtpepper89]

Like every underwater level I've played.. and the modern day parts in Assasins creed games.. really doing their best to kill the atmosphere.