-
Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!
Best Clones/Copycats/Rip-Offs in gaming?
- Thread starter Sinatar
- Start date
CadetMahoney
Member
streetfighter 2 had loadsa cloney-ish types at it's heels.
Mexen
Member
What are your personal favourites from those?
CadetMahoney
Member
Anything copying the shoto (fireballs/dragons) in an iconic blue or red attire type thing going on. . . (world heroes and some others I can't remember) but none are my favorites except kof series. Capcom made Dan as a parody of Robert/Ryo cos they were pissed.
AtomicShroom
Member
Neutopia II. I'll let you guess what it's a clone of...
-016.jpg)
Unreal Champ
Banned
Mario Kart is a rip off of Power Drift which was basically the first kart racing game.
PuppetSlave
Member
Calling Alundra an clone is doing the game an injustice imo. It has a lot of similarities sure, but it's not really an clone. The focus on puzzles is much heavier then Zelda for example.
SlipperyFishes
Banned
Was going to say Age of Empires to Star Wars Galatic Battle Grounds...
You read my mind.
Doesn't count considering the same company developed both games
Melkezadek
Member
I enjoyed it more than any God of War game.
Conkerkid11
Member
The Battlefront series was pretty much just Battlefield. Same devs made a Lord of the Rings clone of Battlefield as well.
Funniest part is when the Battlefield devs in turn ended up making a bad version of Battlefront, because it wasn't similar enough to their own game.
Overwatch is a better TF2, Hearthstone is a better Magic, Planet Coaster is a better Roller Coaster Tycoon, Cities: Skyline is a better SimCity, Stardew Valley is a better Harvest Moon... I'm sure there's more.
Diddy Kong Racing, Sonic & All-stars Racing Transformed, and Crash Team Racing are also worthwhile mentions.
Funniest part is when the Battlefield devs in turn ended up making a bad version of Battlefront, because it wasn't similar enough to their own game.
Overwatch is a better TF2, Hearthstone is a better Magic, Planet Coaster is a better Roller Coaster Tycoon, Cities: Skyline is a better SimCity, Stardew Valley is a better Harvest Moon... I'm sure there's more.
Diddy Kong Racing, Sonic & All-stars Racing Transformed, and Crash Team Racing are also worthwhile mentions.
Damn right.
I enjoyed it more than any God of War game.
NightShift
Member
I think that Saints Row 2 and, to a lesser extent, Sleeping Dogs are better than any GTA game.
GeekyDad
Gold Member
Funny, I was gonna list God of War as a clone, but it borrowed from a number of games, really, not one in particular I can think of. Definitely some Rayman in there, Zelda, but it comes together to be very much its own thing.
It's a great Legend of Zelda clone.
If there's one thing I want to come out of From Software being on that list of partners for the Switch, it's a sequel to that.
Please.
matrix-cat
Member
Of the two Wolf Zelda games released in 2006, Okami was the better one.
Conkerkid11
Member
Super Monkey Ball is Marble Madness though.
Both came out the same year, with Twilight Princess coming out after. Neither could possibly be clones of one-another.
Spieler Eins
Member
Devil May Cry -> Ninja Gaiden Xbox ? (soon followed by Souls -> Nioh)
HYDE
Member
No...Ninja Gaiden is an Onimusha 1 clone (even down to the talisman of rebirth). I played Onimusha 1 for the first time just recently, and was shocked with how many ideas it ripped from this game. Souls to Nioh is a yes for sure though.
Original
Crash Bandicoot
![36714-Crash_Bandicoot_2_-_Cortex_Strikes_Back_[U]-7.jpg](http://199.101.98.242/media/images/36714-Crash_Bandicoot_2_-_Cortex_Strikes_Back_[U]-7.jpg)
Rip off :
M&M's game on PS1 ;
https://youtu.be/c6ZhYXvw1W4?t=51s
Also, not a good game xD
Wasn't there some Donald Duck game that came out on multiple platforms that was also sort of a Crash rip-off?
People already mentioned Alundra and 3D Dot Heroes as 2D Zelda rip-offs, I recall there being one game like that for Master System but I can't remember the name, it was kind of neat actually.
Crash Bandicoot is a 3D SMB1 clone. It has essentially nothing in common with Sonic.
There are actually very, very few games that'd qualify as a Sonic clone. It's a surprisingly difficult game to copy.
Original: Sonic
Clone: Jazz Jackrabbit
You were a cool rabbit with a bandana and you had guns and it was far superior to this Sonic trash
And another clone: Freedom Planet
Jazz Jackrabbit also doesn't qualify imo. In JJ you go from zero to 100% at the press of a direction (no momemtum at all, let alone pinball physics), you avoid touching enemies at all, you have a gun... the only things they have in common is the character is fast and the sprite for running is similar.
Freedom Planet is pretty much the only game I can think of that has any merit in being labelled a Sonic clone, and even that is like 50% Zool also.
I really enjoyed Salt and Sanctuary and Lords of the Fallen, and they're both shameless Souls clones. Lords of the Fallen got some negative press, but it's by far the closest another studio has come to emulating the Souls style of action RPG. Once I got over the "it's not as good as Souls" mentality I got a lot of enjoyment out of playing it for what it was.
I see what you did there.
Chromium.Wings
Member
I'm not going to deny that Cold Fear feels a lot like RE4, but the game came out 2 months after RE4. Is that enough to call it a clone?
TheRedSnifit
Member
Resident Evil is probably the most extreme example. I don't think there are many people who think the Alone in the Dark games are anywhere near as good.
I'd hesitate to call Metal Slug a Contra clone, unless we're going to say that all run 'n guns are automatically Contra clones.
I'd hesitate to call Metal Slug a Contra clone, unless we're going to say that all run 'n guns are automatically Contra clones.
likedamaster
Member
Saints Row was probably the biggest(and best) clone of all time. EVERYTHING was copied straight from GTA... well, except the driving was way better and it pioneered the online multiplayer for that type of game.
Also, wasn't Final Fantasy a clone of Zelda?
Edit: Forgot about Quake --> Unreal
Also, wasn't Final Fantasy a clone of Zelda?
Edit: Forgot about Quake --> Unreal
Version 3.0
Member
No mention of Tekken?
It's the first thing that came to mind for me. Total Virtua Fighter rip-off, great game, and hugely successful.
It's the first thing that came to mind for me. Total Virtua Fighter rip-off, great game, and hugely successful.
Yea, Tekken's a good nomination. Not close the "rip-off" status of something like Dead or Alive though.
Tekken's director/designer Seiichi Ishii was actually designer on Virtua Fighter originally.
Version 3.0
Member
Namco did a good job of making it a good and different game, but there's no question Virtua Fighter was the inspiration. Namco went hard after SEGA's arcade market back then, and then their home market, too, by going exclusive to PS1.
EvilKatarn
Member
Well, the over the shoulder shooting aspect of RE4 was revealed in 2003 I think. Cold Fear was announced a year later.
The game straight up felt like a budget version of RE4 but I'm not really knocking on it. I had fun with it.
FannyCabbage
Member
Pharah/Samus
Castef
Banned
Wait: can we finally say this without being beheaded?
Mister Wolf
Member
Lord of shadows is easily the best god of war clone. Damn good action game. Part two was a huge let down for me.
Visually Resident Evil games are of course better but Alone in the Dark 1-3 are really good games. They have good atmosphere and lots of crazy stuff in them. I don't think as games they are worse than RE at all.
To me that series was always the crappy off-brand GTA until they changed the formula in SR4. I loved that game. One of the crucial changes for me was that they made driving unnecessary by giving you superpowers.
All the SR games have a complete shit model for driving. SR2 is more like driving a train on rails while 3 and even 4 have just a poor arcade driving model where different cars don't have much feel to them. Meanwhile GTA was starting to move towards more realistic driving models (albeit with a rather slow, boat-like feel in stock GTA IV).
TheRedSnifit
Member
AitD2 is absolutely not generally regarded as a good game, AitD3 is pretty middling. We're talking about horror games best known for things like running around in a Santa suit beating dwarves to death with a frying pan.
The original is the only "classic" game in the series, and RE1 basically did the same thing but better.
boneyjangles
Member
Unreal did pretty well for being a Quake clone.