• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Blu-Ray.com reviews Xbox One's Blu-Ray Player functionality

Metallix87

Member
For those of you who missed the site's review of the PS4's Blu-Ray Player, check HERE.

Blu-Ray.com review of Xbox One

The Xbox One's Blu-ray player certainly isn't one for the home theater enthusiast. Picture is solid and sound is excellent, but it lacks precise tuning adjustments. Such audiences will want a dedicated player in their rack. However, the Xbox One just may be the perfect family room Blu-ray playback device for both the casual viewer or family or even the enthusiast who wants a capable second player outside of the home theater. Voice commands are a dream and they work very well at a high percentage rate of accuracy. The failure to navigate disc menus with verbal commands or hand gestures is disappointing, and that the Kinect more often than not fails to recognize commands during loud playback can be an annoyance. These issues, however, are much less likely to plague the casual living room experience, which seems to be Microsoft's target, anyway. Considering the smooth experience, fast access, the absence of glaring glitches, the terrific and intuitive SmartGlass remote app, the awesome Kinect interface, and all the other things the system does well right out of the box, the Xbox One is the clear winner over the PS4 in terms of overall entertainment integration and, more specific to this site and its audience, Blu-ray playback. There's no doubt the PS4 will eventually play catchup and at least rival the Xbox One, but Microsoft has certainly taken the lead and embraced the Blu-ray experience, once its rival, with open arms and an advanced, enjoyable, and accurate interactivity that's nothing short of a terrific experience all round. Oh, and it also plays some great video games. The Xbox One comes very highly recommended.

The Xbox One seems to fare a heck of a lot better than the PS4 did and ends up being the superior Blu-Ray playing device. It's a bit odd, given that the BD is a Sony creation, and also given Sony's major push for the format last generation.
 
so both PS4 and Xbox One are bad Blu-ray players.

Sony BDP S5100 is $90/80 and it's one of the best blu-ray players in the market, how in hell these $400 and $500 "all on one entertainment machines" don't have good blu-ray players and features and adjustments in them :/
 
I wish there was an option to have the Xbox One automatically pause a movie when you get up and walk away.

I just watched my first Blu-ray this weekend (Pacific Rim). The audio seemed a little better than DVD on my 7.1 system, but I couldn't notice much difference in picture quality on my 1080i TV. I need to get a new TV though. Honestly I would have no trouble going back to DVD on this TV set.
 
With all the streaming going on I don't think BD is that important to Sony or MS. Its no longer a selling point for the PS4 like how it was for the PS3.
 
The failure to navigate disc menus with verbal commands or hand gestures is disappointing, and that the Kinect more often than not fails to recognize commands during loud playback can be an annoyance. These issues, however, are much less likely to plague the casual living room experience, which seems to be Microsoft's target, anyway. Considering the smooth experience, fast access, the absence of glaring glitches, the terrific and intuitive SmartGlass remote app, the awesome Kinect interface, and all the other things the system does well right out of the box, the Xbox One is the clear winner over the PS4 in terms of overall entertainment integration and, more specific to this site and its audience, Blu-ray playback.

Uhm... Did they just completely contradict themselves AND slam Xbox users as "casuals"?
 
Sony went backwards with the bluray features because it doesn't have kinect......? Or is the ps4 bluray player worse than dirt?

How can a disc video player be bad? Sounds weird in 2013.
 
They liked the voice commands.
No 3D support

It's ironic that PS4 loads games faster than the Xbone, but the Xbone loads Blu-rays faster than the PS4, lol.
 
Sony went backwards with the bluray features because it doesn't have kinect......? Or is the ps4 bluray player worse than dirt?

How can a disc video player be bad? Sounds weird in 2013.

Go read their review of the PS4. They had some major issues playing some pretty major releases. The Xbox One apparently is just a better player (right now, at least), and Kinect seems to help with that a bit, but is not solely responsible.
 
Why in the world would someone want to spend 500 bucks on a second blu-ray player because it has nice voice commands. What an idiotic review.
 
Also if you don't want to rely solely on Kinect commands or using a controller, if you have a Harmony remote the XB1 is in their device database and you can control it with that.
 
Why in the world would someone want to spend 500 bucks on a second blu-ray player because it has nice voice commands. What an idiotic review.

Please tell me where in this review they said that people should buy one for it to be their second Blu-ray player.
 
For those of you who missed the site's review of the PS4's Blu-Ray Player, check HERE.

Blu-Ray.com review of Xbox One

The Xbox One's Blu-ray player certainly isn't one for the home theater enthusiast. Picture is solid and sound is excellent, but it lacks precise tuning adjustments. Such audiences will want a dedicated player in their rack. However, the Xbox One just may be the perfect family room Blu-ray playback device for both the casual viewer or family or even the enthusiast who wants a capable second player outside of the home theater. Voice commands are a dream and they work very well at a high percentage rate of accuracy. The failure to navigate disc menus with verbal commands or hand gestures is disappointing, and that the Kinect more often than not fails to recognize commands during loud playback can be an annoyance. These issues, however, are much less likely to plague the casual living room experience, which seems to be Microsoft's target, anyway. Considering the smooth experience, fast access, the absence of glaring glitches, the terrific and intuitive SmartGlass remote app, the awesome Kinect interface, and all the other things the system does well right out of the box, the Xbox One is the clear winner over the PS4 in terms of overall entertainment integration and, more specific to this site and its audience, Blu-ray playback. There's no doubt the PS4 will eventually play catchup and at least rival the Xbox One, but Microsoft has certainly taken the lead and embraced the Blu-ray experience, once its rival, with open arms and an advanced, enjoyable, and accurate interactivity that's nothing short of a terrific experience all round. Oh, and it also plays some great video games. The Xbox One comes very highly recommended.

The Xbox One seems to fare a heck of a lot better than the PS4 did, it seems, and ends up being the superior Blu-Ray playing device. It's a bit odd, given that the BD is a Sony creation, and also given Sony's major push for the format last generation.

i find it interesting that PS4 they complained about No Remote and No 3D, while here it is ok.
 
So how exactly does xbox one give better Blu-ray playback? Kinect, controls etc. mean nothing. I am talking pure performance, IE playback and they gave not 1 reason on how it's better.
 
I wonder if ms are as quick to offer updates for new br playback issues, sony were pretty good at keeping the ps3 up to date that i never once hit a disc that had issues playing.
 
i find it interesting that PS4 they complained about No Remote and No 3D, while here it is ok.

Xbox One supports remotes.

So how exactly does xbox one give better Blu-ray playback? Kinect, controls etc. mean nothing. I am talking pure performance, IE playback and they gave not 1 reason on how it's better.

They specified it loads discs faster, at least as far as movies are concerned, and didn't have any playback issues.
 
i find it interesting that PS4 they complained about No Remote and No 3D, while here it is ok.

Also wouldnt your tv remote work ok with it if your tv was hdmi cec?. I know you can control the xmb with a tv remote so doing so with br playback shouldnt be an issue.
 
PS4 had some playback issues with major releases and the XBO loads faster.

I'm actually pretty happy with it as my BRD player and unhooked my dedicated one.
 
so both PS4 and Xbox One are bad Blu-ray players.

Sony BDP S5100 is $90/80 and it's one of the best blu-ray players in the market, how in hell these $400 and $500 "all on one entertainment machines" don't have good blu-ray players and features and adjustments in them :/

Because is not their focus?

Physical media for movies is a dying breed no reason for Sony and Microsoft to develop great players that nobody will use a couple years from now.

They are serviceable, it's good enough.
 
Because is not their focus?

Physical media for movies is a dying breed no reason for Sony and Microsoft to develop great players that nobody will use a couple years from now.

They are serviceable, it's good enough.

"A couple years from now" is a bit naive. Maybe in a decade or so, and even then, there will always be a market for physical media, simply because some people prefer to actually own something they know is there's. If anything, the people who desire physical media moving forward will become much more tech-savvy, and find these offerings undesirable.
 
Physical media for movies is a dying breed no reason for Sony and Microsoft to develop great players that nobody will use a couple years from now.

Ugh, no. Do people forget that the vast majority have either garbage internet speeds and/or data caps? Physical media for movies is not going anywhere for the foreseeable future.
 
I still don't get it. Was it supposed to be another tired Xbone joke?

It just appealed to my slightly surreal sense of humour. If anything I took it as an expression of being fed up at all the meta commentary about pros and cons of all the systems in every little minutae over the past months, and just go straight for the Hitler joke right away.

Then to pair that with a muted response 'doesn't sound too good' line just got me.

I wasn't thinking about it too deeply.
 
Plays BDs well, for starters, and loads them faster. On top of that, the device offers enhanced functionality via Smart Glass and Kinect.

Does the ps4 not play bluray movies good or something ?

I watched watchmen a cpl days ago on ps4 and it worked perfectly fine.
 
Top Bottom