fluffydelusions
Member
TBH it's hard to tell the difference in compressed youtube videos. They even work in favor of 360/PS3 versions of the game. Anyway, both next gen versions look fine to me
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
DF/JF: Battlefield 4 PS4 vs XB1 videos/screens (900p PS4, 720p XB1)
- Thread starter shinobi602
- Start date
TBH it's hard to tell the difference in compressed youtube videos. They even work in favor of 360/PS3 versions of the game. Anyway, both next gen versions look fine to me
Is there evidence of this?
ok i see.
So much crow for me to eat.
Absolutely. I'll be on the Inferior product playing with the friends I've had since Halo 2 days.
PS3 > Xbox360
PS4 > XboxOne
Still sticking with the tried and true for the friends.
I'd gladly pay $100 extra to see Denver dominate San Diego, just to chill with friends.
(oct2012 better not happen again)
Most early FXAA injectors had settings for sharpening settings to combat FXAA blurring. I don't know why people bother with FXAA anyway - at least try and get SMAA working satsifactorily instead. It's much better.
eddfromtheriver
Banned
OP should modify opening post and take out the useless DF comparison pics/videos and use Jackfrag ones instead. As they are a more accurate representation... my two cents.
NOT THREAD WHINING
bigboss370
Member
did anyone change their pre-order for either console because of this footage?
or did anyone change their pre-order of BF4 (getting it vs. not)?
or did anyone change their pre-order of BF4 (getting it vs. not)?
kingkaiser
Member
FXAA is the equivalent to what the PRON industry in the 60's did when an actor had bad skin...just put vaseline on the camera lens, lot of vaseline...
Dreams-Visions
Member
I mean, if BF multiplayer is your cup of tea, there aren't any games that can substitute for it. I assume one of the two will become your preferred multiplayer experience. I'd wager that will be BF, as DICE has been doing it well for a long time.
Agreed.
IdiotMyshkin
Banned
let's see how this is in reality:
PC
http://images.eurogamer.net/2013/articles//a/1/6/2/7/9/9/2/BF4_PC_023.jpg.jpg/EG11/resize/1920x-1
PS4
http://images.eurogamer.net/2013/articles//a/1/6/2/7/9/9/2/BF4_PS4_023.jpg.jpg/EG11/resize/1920x-1
Beside obviously lower resloution i don't see any usual FXAA crap like more blurry textures.
Imo DICE did amazing work with PS4 version and its AA.
Do we even know if it is FXAA ?
Maybe they are using MLAA variant?
I mean look at this how AA brakes in PS4 gif. It is obviously sub pixel problem that would point at MLAA variant instead of FXAA
At start there is something that looks like popin at left side at start. It is AA braking.
At the end of video at upper side of gix there is powerline that also pops which looks like AA switching on/off
Can someone explain how FXAA works compared to MLAA variant ?
edit:
i noticed in those 2 shots there are way less objects at bottom of those towers in PS4 version compared to PC. Same with grass.
Isn't that an xbone gif?
bigboss370
Member
who doesn't like sparks?
who doesn't like sparks?
Damn. Amazing.
Yes its annoying as fuck. I hated in Crysis and seems BF has it too.
Why the fuck someone would put it in game and thought : "it looks cool" No it doesn't. Our eyes doesn't show some weird orange cyan whatever that is in real life.
Syphon Filter
Member
Anything new since yesterday? The thread is way too big and i cant go to each page.
Arrogant Bastard
Banned
It does? Where does the framerate drop to the 30s?
Day planner, Google calendar, etc
Dreamgazer
Member
What are you doing in a vs thread then?
Agreed.
Great job all around. I'm going to have to keep an eye on his footage going forward.
Really impressed.
GameSeeker
Member
Yes, the JackFrags PS4 video is some of the best video captures around (far better than DF or IGN for sure).
If you look at only piece of BF4 footage on PS4, be sure you look at the JackFrags video. Note he has video of several different maps.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9oWkgNO2coc
WeAreStarStuff
Member
I think people are not clicking on the images, so they are only viewing them as small.
la flama blanca
Banned
No that was PS4 version
This is from Xbone version. God help your eyes:
But isn't this also cropped and zoomed in? Yes, it looks ugly, but framing it like that isn't completely fair.
velociraptor
Junior Member
Part of the reason it looks so good is because of downsampled GIFS.
That is actually not fair for the mods.
We should really get together and start Free Salvor Movement
How can these cruel mods take away our entertainment when COD comparison and Salvor posting
Yeah, the masses fall for many things. The TVs, Betamax vs VHS, Amiga vs PC, Color Mac vs PC, slighty louder perceived as better quality when buying audio equipment, etc etc....
No one will ever convince anyone else about which looks better. The innacurate picture, looks great to them.
The Jack frags MP PS4 video has no blur in it when watched at a 1080p. Looks fantastic. Why anyone would see that and think the PS4 single player would still be blurry is beyond me. Even Videogamer in one of their videos said their PS4 footage came out with a problem, they said they fixed it and THEN they did their comparison. If DF keeps making these errors, then you won't be able to trust them.
It's clear DICE did the best they could and I'm sure both purchasers of each console will be satisfied with the results.
People may think because the masses can't tell, are underestimating the desire to have the BEST. Many want the best they can get regardless. The PS4 is the best version of the consoles. That's what will be told to them by word of mouth by the opinion makers like on gaf. How anyone cane watch over 50% more pixels and more effects/post proccessing more fps and claim parity, is typical bullshit.
http://videogamescene.com/xbox-one-battlefield-4-edges-out-ps4-version-despite-lower-resolution/
lmfao. Even some"game journalists" are completely blind.
This website in particular has an anti-PS4 agenda though so its not surprising.
lmfao. Even some"game journalists" are completely blind.
This website in particular has an anti-PS4 agenda though so its not surprising.
Does he have an XB1 and PS4 side by side MP comparison video?
Amentallica
Unconfirmed Member
I completely agree. I look at both footages of gameplay and can't help but notice how much cleaner Killzone looks.
Turin Turambar
Member
It's not like most games are about real war... much less BF.
It probably will be Battlefield. I imagine it's going to have longer life too being that everything is already unlocked from the start in Killzone.
la flama blanca
Banned
Salvor was pretty amazing in his spin, I'll give him that.
Well it does technically "edge it out" if we're talking about the overblown sharpening that has basically created an effect similar to JPEG compression...
silver.tongue
Member
Not at all, man.
Both look good.
PS4 just looks better all around.
Some people just have trouble accepting that.
Weird is that it's going to be mostly the same people that got all pumped by PS360 comparisons this gen when the 360 got te upper hand a bunch of times.
See You Next Wednesday
Banned
yup. i really wish the DF footage would get banished and replaced with the JackFrags footage. it's so much better and gives you a clear idea of what to expect.
silver.tongue
Member
Ok, this is just ridiculous.
TrojanBlade
Member
THIS. Someone needs to do this.
Dude, I was actually clapping after seeing his skills with sniper rifle.
Psycho_Mantis
Banned
In light of DF's fumbling and ridiculous articles recently I have now reconsidered them as unreliable. I trust Jack Frags more:
let's see how this is in reality:
PC
http://images.eurogamer.net/2013/articles//a/1/6/2/7/9/9/2/BF4_PC_023.jpg.jpg/EG11/resize/1920x-1
PS4
http://images.eurogamer.net/2013/articles//a/1/6/2/7/9/9/2/BF4_PS4_023.jpg.jpg/EG11/resize/1920x-1
Beside obviously lower resloution i don't see any usual FXAA crap like more blurry textures.
Imo DICE did amazing work with PS4 version and its AA.
Do we even know if it is FXAA ?
Maybe they are using MLAA variant?
I mean look at this how AA brakes in PS4 gif. It is obviously sub pixel problem that would point at MLAA variant instead of FXAA
At start there is something that looks like popin at left side at start. It is AA braking.
At the end of video at upper side of gix there is powerline that also pops which looks like AA switching on/off
Can someone explain how FXAA works compared to MLAA variant ?
edit:
i noticed in those 2 shots there are way less objects at bottom of those towers in PS4 version compared to PC. Same with grass.
Isn't that an xbone gif?
That's what I thought too. Wrong platform there.
There is nothing unfair about it.
PS4 version gif i posted also was zoomed in and cropped at exactly same position.
edit: apperently there was no zooming in either version just cropped image from 1080p youtube footage
Naturally Xbone version doesn't have that much evident aliasing as in that gif because it is as you said zoomed but aliasing is TERRIBLE on Xbone version especially in motion where aliasing crawling is destroying image quality.
No that was PS4 version.
Here is Xbone version of same gif:
I believe incendiary grenade.