• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Difference in food between Europe and USA

Hm, nope. As soon as you add such ingredients to your dough, the product is classified as pastry and not bread any more. French law is veeeeery strict about what you're allowed to call bread. Bread is flour, water, yeast and salt. And sometimes some additional grains.

Curious. How do the French get the yeast to activate without adding a bit of sugar?

And yes I understand the point that many America mass production breads have added sugar beyond what is need by the yeast to make those wonderful air pockets.
 
I've traveled Europe extensively and have a European wife. We have everything you have. The only significant difference is the portion sizes. And it is significant.
I think there's way too much talk about quality and too little about the economics of food when it comes to these threads.

I'd probably go bankrupt if I lived in America and tried to buy 1 kg of Spanish ham every couple of weeks like I usually do or the amount of fresh produce I get each weekend at the market. Conversely, American beef is cheap. It's actually hard to believe how little it costs compared to where I live.

Pricing and availability can make a world of difference, even if we have pretty much the same kind of ingredients.
 
in my travels I did find the 'american kitchen' to serve big portions; and be a bit on the fat side (sweet as well). I'm not saying that their arent places that serve normal portions; it's just my impression of a few restaurants and diners I've visited. Also, 'junk food' is WAY TO CHEAP.

As for Europe (disclaimer; I'm Dutch, our kitchen sucks and I wouldnt really recommend it to anyone except for some mashed dishes); I would say the 'best', most healthy and varied cuisine comes from the mediterranean countries, so Spain, Portugal, Italy, Greece, etc.

Other cuisines have their highlights but they get samey quick. I've visited a lot of Eastern-European countries and meat/processed meat and potato-based meals are a mainstay the further you go east. Pierogi's are awesome tho :) I've got a buddy in Munich, so when I'm there its a lot of Bavarian food (pork legs, organ meat, potatoes, and beer :P)
 
Jesus Christ I never realized the extent of European ignorance of American food. You should be embarrassed.

I'm sure it goes both ways but it does seem like it's a common thing for people outside the US to have very strong opinions about what happens here and it's generally uninformed or based off American sitcoms or something.

I'll give it a pass though as I can understand the world being very upset with us over Trump.
 
I don't know why so many Americans on GAF take it so personally when people make comments about the food. I'm basically American (I'm from Canada) and I hate how huge companies control and distort people's palates to maximize profit, and I hate how many people prioritize price over all else when it comes to food, even when they can afford better. We have a problem in our attitudes to food and could benefit from a little humility when comparing ourselves to Europe and Asia.
 
Some American food (all were invented in America and are readily available in almost any area)
20140328-general-tsos-chicken-recipe-food-lab-1-thumb-1500xauto-422309.jpg

la_mission_burrito.jpg

philly-cheesesteak-ck-x.jpg

california-rolls1.jpg

buffalo-wings-100-680x614.jpg

how-to-make-sweet-tea-09.jpg

ad9aaa54-543b-4c20-aaf0-7cad8b4f1d88.jpg

DBA-BBQPlate.jpg

It's almost like Americans have varied diets and eat food inspired by other countries, but are distinctly American.
 
Curious. How do the French get the yeast to activate without adding a bit of sugar?

And yes I understand the point that many America mass production breads have added sugar beyond what is need by the yeast to make those wonderful air pockets.

I think it would be through fermentation of the dough for one or two days. Or using "masa madre", I don't know how to translate that. Bakeries have a "mother dough" they keep pretty much forever by adding flour and water. They pick portions of that dough and mix it with the new fresh dough to kickstart the fermentation process.

Or it could be something else. I don't know wtf I'm talking about.
 
I've traveled Europe extensively and have a European wife. We have everything you have. The only significant difference is the portion sizes. And it is significant.
I mean, not EVERYTHING, unless you count hard to find imports.
I'd be surprised to find locally produced surströmming, horse Leberkäse, or stuff like that. Stuff that's even rare where it comes from.


That doesn't really make sense to me at all. At what point does the division occur? How far back does it need to go? All food is just local variations of ancient stuff - "Heat meat, grind grains, gather plants. Mush together. Eat."

America doesn't have unique cuisine (except barbeque which is technically a Caribbean style brought to what would be the modern US by Spanish colonists) because it's only existed as a unique cultural entity for like 200 years. American culture is just a weird mashup of various immigrant cultures. The actual unique, aboriginal cuisine of the continent was exterminated and coopted.
It's not about how far back it goes, it's about how much was changed.
Like I said, in my eyes, deep dish is unique enough to qualify as American.

In Austria, we love our apple strudel.
Supposedly, it was invented by trying to copy Baklava. Nobody would call it {whereever baklava actually was invented} food, because it's so so different.

And as someone else pointed out, adding your own twist to Chinese food in your American kitchen, you'll probably still call it Chinese food.

But in the end, as previously stated, it's semantics.
I guess to me, the recipe origin is the deciding factor, unless it's changed beyond recognition.
 
Curious. How do the French get the yeast to activate without adding a bit of sugar?

It reacts with the small amount of sugar in the flour, but it's a very slow process, which is why the dough has to rest for several hours. Adding sugar would certainly speed up the process, which I suppose is why it's done with US bread, but it's not allowed here (just like it's not allowed to add sugar to wine for similar purpose).
 
You're not going to find better pizza in the US than in Naples

Let's be honest, how you view something is going to be down to what you are used too.

When I am in Italy, I never think the Pizza is great, simply because I am more used to what I get at home, it would be the same the other way round too.
 
Also, from my experience, this:

azAvMrm_700b.jpg

Literally every single supermarket near me offers that among like 30 different types of breads including their own in-house baked loaves. I honestly don't know a single person that buys this Wonder Bread toast at this point.

Not aimed at you, Nightfall:

As a European living in the States, I'm always amazed by the amount of weird assumptions people make about this place. The big difference is that it's easier to accidentally buy shitty foods in the States, but it's not like the options aren't there and very readily available. It's absurd nonsense to assume every American shops exclusively at Wal-Mart and eats Twinkies and junk food all day.
 
Curious. How do the French get the yeast to activate without adding a bit of sugar?

And yes I understand the point that many America mass production breads have added sugar beyond what is need by the yeast to make those wonderful air pockets.

You don't need sugar if using quality/reliable yeast. The flour itself contains maltose and glucose which is sufficient to feed the yeast. You only need 4 ingredients flour, yeast, water and salt.

I think it would be through fermentation of the dough for one or two days. Or using "masa madre", I don't know how to translate that. Bakeries have a "mother dough" they keep pretty much forever by adding flour and water. They pick portions of that dough and mix it with the new fresh dough to kickstart the fermentation process.

Or it could be something else. I don't know wtf I'm talking about.

.
 
Only Pfeffersoße is acceptable on a Schnitzel.

My go-to Schnitzel at the restaurant I go to has a Schnitzel with schlemmer-sauce, peach, and cherries and I'll be damned if that's not the best thing ever.

I love my Wiener, Jaeger, Zwiebel and Pfeffer-schnitzel, but that weird combination is just amazing, fuck the purists.
 
I think there's way too much talk about quality and too little about the economics of food when it comes to these threads.

I'd probably go bankrupt if I lived in America and tried to buy 1 kg of Spanish ham every couple of weeks like I usually do or the amount of fresh produce I get each weekend at the market. Conversely, American beef is cheap. It's actually hard to believe how little it costs compared to where I live.

Pricing and availability can make a world of difference, even if we have pretty much the same kind of ingredients.

That's a good point. Sure if I wanted to buy some Jamón Serrano it is much more expensive here. Same with something like Parmigiano Reggiano. They are still in almost every halfway decent grocery store.

I mean, not EVERYTHING, unless you count hard to find imports.
I'd be surprised to find locally produced surströmming, horse Leberkäse, or stuff like that. Stuff that's even rare where it comes from.

Fair enough, we do have a massive German population but stuff can still be real rare. A better way to put it is stuff you would typically eat on a normal day we have.
 
Literally every single supermarket near me offers that among like 30 different types of breads including their own in-house baked loaves. I honestly don't know a single person that buys this Wonder Bread toast at this point.

Not aimed at you, Nightfall:

As a European living in the States, I'm always amazed by the amount of weird assumptions people make about this place. The big difference is that it's easier to accidentally buy shitty foods in the States, but it's not like the options aren't there and very readily available. It's absurd nonsense to assume every American shops exclusively at Wal-Mart and eats Twinkies and junk food all day.

You can only compare what is common in the USA and in the various European states. In our connected world you can get most stuff from everywhere, it's just way more expensive.

Wal-Mart didn't become such a dominant company in the USA because no one is getting their food from it.
 
I didn't mean to offend anyone with my (obviously a bit exaggerated) take on american bread.

What I experienced was that even breads which look more like traditional european style bread are still full of artificial sweeteners and sugar and whatnot. They all tasted kinda... fake.
I'm sure you can get good bread at a lot of places in the US, but there's way more shitty bread.
 
Americans typically have their teeth white and aligned

Europeans have endless vacation time, and eat more organic food
 
You don't need sugar if using quality/reliable yeast. The flour itself contains maltose and glucose which is sufficient to feed the yeast.

Yup. We used to run a bakery many years ago, my dad (the baker) was one of the few bakers in our town who kept using adatives to an absolute minimum, even if it could increase production. Maybe also why (and the rise of supermarkets with in-store bakeries) we had to give up on the store at a certain point, heh :p
 
Who in their right mind likes German food? It's just a bunch of nasty meat. Boring food. Sure I've had some good roasts in Germany. But, I don't think cuisine that consists of mostly of Shnitzels and sausages is very good at all. Relative to America, the food is boring and bad.

Dutch food? Lmao.

This thread is difference between food in Europe and in USA. The cuisine in USA is super global, so you have to include what you find normally, which is also a shit ton of Asian food. Korean and Thai food is everywhere in America. A good American bbq joint puts to shame any European roast, as well.

European food is like European culture. Old and a bit boring. Food in Belgium is dire! Omg. Horrible and boring. Just meat and fried carbs. In both Antwerp and Brussels, yeesh. The food you find in Europe is legit mediocre compared to America. Not even a comparison, imo.

Food culture is so vibrant and exciting in the cities of America. S. American, Mexican and Asian cuisine, as well as the more usual staples, and new trends and types of foods at a dizzying pace.
 
Whilst I agree a little bit with this statement I also largely disagree. I live in New York City considered one of the best restaurant towns in the world but I just got back from a trip to Germany and Italy and the food is simply better and less 'rich'

The example I will give is that in a little town in Umbria I went to a gas station to fill ip my rental, ran into the shop to grab something to eat. Inside the same dude who was pumping gas a second ago was making a cappuccino and placing a fresh cannelloni on a real ceramic plate for another customer who was waiting for his full tank.

Think about where in the USA could a gas station attendant make you a real cappuccino and bakery fresh dessert?

I understand the OP' question even though it sounds 'trolly' because It is possible to eat in the simple but artisinal way that the Europeans do but it's fooling yourself to say that it's easy and/or common.

Yep...judge an entire country's food by their gas-station offerings...this fucking thread, man.
 
As an American who has been living in France for 12 years here is my take:

I think it's best to divide this up between 'home' and 'restaurant'.

At home, I find that meals in France are prepared with fresher ingredients bought from markets and are usually much simpler. We have the same meals as in the states: pastas, couscous, ratatouilles. Casseroles aren't really a thing though. Everything is brought out in bits instead of a buffet style as in the states. Meals in France usually end with cheese and perhaps a little dessert. Heavy snacking is frowned upon. I've visited some families in the States who were just like: 'Hey grab what you want, when you want it!'. In France, you eat your main meals and perhaps a 'goûter' (snack) between lunch and dinner.

In the States, there isn't easy access to fresh produce and everything is bought in supermarkets. I do feel like people don't like preparing meals as much, so here's some meat, some green beans and some applesauce. Something easy to put together. I've also found food to be more expensive in the States as well. I'm not just talking about fancy cheeses, but something like breakfast cereal or carrots. While I'm on the subject of cheese... God, the cheese is so good in France. And it's inexpensive. I once saw 15 dollars for a slice of Brie in the States. WTF? Same goes for wine: it's a much more important staple in France, whereas in the States, it's seen as something more 'fancy' so it's priced higher.

Now let's talk about restaurants.

In France, restaurants are very very traditional. Unless it's a cool new place set up by bobos (hipsters), you're always going to get the same thing: coq au vin, steak frites, saucisses, blanquette de veau, etc etc etc.

While it's delicious, it can get a bit boring after a while.

The States has a very vibrant restaurant scene, especially in urban areas. Sure there are big chains like Applebees or TGIF, but you can find delicious local places that aren't afraid to mix things up and create weird fusions between different types of cuisine. Some of my most memorable meals have been in places like this (Northstar in Columbus for example has THE best veggie burger).

This goes hand in hand with my opinions on beer: France pretty much only makes lagers and wheat beers. Nothing against lagers, but man I really really realllllly miss the selection of beers at any decent bar in the States. (but free health care definitely makes up for that :D )
 
I think it would be through fermentation of the dough for one or two days. Or using "masa madre", I don't know how to translate that. Bakeries have a "mother dough" they keep pretty much forever by adding flour and water. They pick portions of that dough and mix it with the new fresh dough to kickstart the fermentation process.

Or it could be something else. I don't know wtf I'm talking about.

Nope, that is helpful. I know (a little bit) about mother dough.

I just getting into bread baking (of celiac reasons) and am trying to trouble shoot why it take my yeast so long to rise even with sugar. lol.
 
You can only compare what is common in the USA and in the various European states. In our connected world you can get most stuff from everywhere, it's just way more expensive.

Wal-Mart didn't become such a dominant company in the USA because no one is getting their food from it.

Wal-Mart is super popular because lots of people in the US live paycheck to paycheck and don't give a flip about artisanal cheeses. Also if you live outside of a big city then lots of the ridiculous assumptions about the US in here actually slowly become true.
 
Who in their right mind likes German food? It's just a bunch of nasty meat. Boring food. Sure I've had some good roasts in Germany. But, I don't think cuisine that consists of mostly of Shnitzels and sausages is very good at all. Relative to America, the food is boring and bad.

Dutch food? Lmao.

This thread is difference between food in Europe and in USA. The cuisine in USA is super global, so you have to include what you find normally, which is also a shit ton of Asian food. Korean and Thai food is everywhere in America. A good American bbq joint puts to shame any European roast, as well.

European food is like European culture. Old and a bit boring. Food in Belgium is dire! Omg. Horrible and boring. Just meat and fried carbs. In both Antwerp and Brussels, yeesh. The food you find in Europe is legit mediocre compared to America. Not even a comparison.

I don't know if this is supposed to be an "ignorant American" caricature, but..

ImperfectAgonizingFlounder-max-1mb.gif
 
This thread makes it seem like europeans eat like poor americans when they visit there

People are exposed to their surroundings, and while fine dining restaurants are not rare, there's an overabundance of low quality and fast food restaurants all over America. So you are not wrong, but it's also easy to understand why some visitors get funny ideas about American food. The same is also true if you are an American visiting the usual European tourist trap, since those restaurants are all about serving quickly and cheaply or so-so at grossly inflated prices.

Tourists are also prone to have bad experiences with food since many of them just want something cheap and quick/on the go unless they are eating at their hotel/having a night out. Many of them don't mingle with the locals. And unless you are visiting some town in Southeastern Asia or other place with a strong culture of street food, you are just setting yourself for disappointment.

You don't get to truly appreciate local cuisine until you've lived somewhere for a while.
 
DirtyLarry said:
So yes, the bottom bread is not the best bread out there, but it also serves a utilitarian purpose.
The "Europe" bread on the picture is utilitarian cheap stuff(by local standards) for most part as well, not some high end produce. Which probably sums up most of the arguments in this thread really - you can mostly find 'any' food in developed countries but what's cheap local stuff in one can be premium in another.
 
US food isn't bad because you can buy European stuff somewhere.

Well... I'm not sure I understand that argument.

It's almost as if a country of immigrants brought recipes from where they originated...

You can only compare what is common in the USA and in the various European states. In our connected world you can get most stuff from everywhere, it's just way more expensive.

Wal-Mart didn't become such a dominant company in the USA because no one is getting their food from it.

Wal-Mart is what it is because they offer cheap bullshit that priced local companies out of the market. In some rural parts of the country it can be the only option for miles, but that's in no way indicative of the norm.
 
Who in their right mind likes German food? It's just a bunch of nasty meat. Boring food. Sure I've had some good roasts in Germany. But, I don't think cuisine that consists of mostly of Shnitzels and sausages is very good at all. Relative to America, the food is boring and bad.

You never witnessed Spargel season, I take it. We have lots of nice stuff besides meat!

Imma also gonna give you some facts:

German restaurants have become the world's second-most decorated after France.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/German_cuisine
 
Let's be honest, how you view something is going to be down to what you are used too.

When I am in Italy, I never think the Pizza is great, simply because I am more used to what I get at home, it would be the same the other way round too.

Pretty much different foods with the same name. Equally good in their own right.

Who in their right mind likes German food? It's just a bunch of nasty meat. Boring food. Sure I've had some good roasts in Germany. But, I don't think cuisine that consists of mostly of Shnitzels and sausages is very good at all. Relative to America, the food is boring and bad.

Dutch food? Lmao.

This thread is difference between food in Europe and in USA. The cuisine in USA is super global, so you have to include what you find normally, which is also a shit ton of Asian food. Korean and Thai food is everywhere in America. A good American bbq joint puts to shame any European roast, as well.

European food is like European culture. Old and a bit boring. Food in Belgium is dire! Omg. Horrible and boring. Just meat and fried carbs. In both Antwerp and Brussels, yeesh. The food you find in Europe is legit mediocre compared to America. Not even a comparison, imo.

Food culture is so vibrant and exciting in the cities of America. S. American, Mexican and Asian cuisine, as well as the more usual staples, and new trends and types of foods at a dizzying pace.

Food in the US is full of shit , that's why it tastes good to you. If we ate like that on a daily basis we'd have all the same health epidemics.

And for the record German food is fucking great, you don't know what you are talking about. Except currywurst, that shit is rank.
 
The food is so damn rich in the USA. So easy to put on fat. I'm in Russia now and the proportions are smaller and what you are eating is often nutrient rich and "clean" like fish, chicken and then some whole milk.

I wouldn't even say that all the healthy food I'm having here isn't available in the USA, it's just that there isn't as much junk food and sugar filled drinks everywhere you go here. You can still eat healthy like this in the USA it's just harder with the temptation and habit of junk food easily available everywhere.
 
Top Bottom