Gut reaction:
'Welcome to PS3/360 games with 'innovations' we haven't fully figured out ourselves yet.'
That's what the message felt like.
And the latter is the biggest surprise for me - there was no strong central message around what this controller was going to do for games. I think Nintendo's still figuring out use-cases. They focussed on convenience of remote play, video sharing, web browsing, video chat - but not actually much by way of game orientated use-cases (other than a Zelda inventory, lol). With Wii, it was immediately obvious, at least to me, what the potential was (and check the record - I gushed over it immediately). This seems like a much less obvious and incomplete picture.
On a side note, I guess it shouldn't be surprising that Nintendo can't coax third parties into a generational transition wrt content, but it leaves a big big question for me - will this stand up to the next gen, or will it be a late-game snack between Playstations and Xboxs. If I had confidence in the former I'd feel a lot more interested in this.