Because its good enough and has no serious issues. Why punish a game for existing as part of a genre? Scores below 5 in Edge come from simply bad design choices that are detrimental to gameplay.TheHeretic said:Why does a derivative, playable game have to be a 5 or more? If a game isn't worth buying it should be a 1. Edge are still stuck in the "report card" system of reviewing that IGN fester in tirelessly.