• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Experimental Ebola treatment was used on the two patients brought to the US

Status
Not open for further replies.

rSpooky

Member
Hope the cure works/holds..


If so most importantly they live and so will many others in the future..




Also.. it will probably be a book/movie thing , which I hope they can use to bring some awareness to the people that suffer most from these kind of epidemics as well as poverty , war etc.
 

Quixzlizx

Member
This could look bad, in Africa. There is already paranoia and ignorance about the virus and the aide workers have been blamed for the outbreak. Spin: Africans aren't worthy of the experimental treatment? Conspiracy: Cure for cancer being hidden.

It's OK, the people who are afraid of Western medicine would probably claim that the medicine is some sterilization conspiracy anyway.
 

Jenov

Member
Wow, amazing! Hopefully they can mass market a vaccine very soon and help more people. Interesting that the military has so many little secret stuff like that.
 

TheOMan

Tagged as I see fit
So we don't have to nuke Atlanta?

Let's not call off the strike just yet...

Actually, let me ask this, will it affect Destiny coming out? No?

Then, let's give it a day or 3.

Seriously though, this is great news!

Also, experimental drugs? Pretty sure this is how the Zombie Apocalypse starts up.
 
Last I heard, researchers felt they were maybe 2-5 years away from having a workable vaccine. I hope these are prolific first steps in combating this infection.

Also:
32iaK3W.gif
 
That's awesome. Hopefully, the results are verified and will last. Then comes the task of getting more advanced trials and getting the medicine into the field.
 

CDX

Member
Hope it works and removes it completely. Would be scary if they felt fine, but were still contagious.

I've read somewhere recently, if you're a male and if you're lucky enough to survive, supposedly the ebola virus will still be in your semen for the next 2 months.
 

Burt

Member
Wow, the onion was spot on.

That's amazing though, progress is progress!
It is strange that a company that's likely invested years and tens of millions of dollars, if not hundreds of millions, into developing a treatment couldn't/wouldn't find a single person in the entire outbreak to run a trial with it until two Americans got infected. Not saying that The Onion was actually right, but waiting for infected Americans doesn't make much sense on the company's part.
 

Terra

Member
Hope it works and removes it completely. Would be scary if they felt fine, but were still contagious.

Apparently, you can be contageous for about two months after symptoms cleared. Someone, feel free to correct me if I am wrong.
 
Knowing his dose was still frozen, Brantly asked if he could have Writebol's now-thawed medication. It was brought to his room and administered through an IV. Within an hour of receiving the medication, Brantly's condition was nearly reversed. His breathing improved; the rash over his trunk faded away. One of his doctors described the events as "miraculous."

Awesome. Imagine the feeling of knowing you're going to die (from experience), taking a last-ditch experimental treatment and it actually working! Miraculous is the word - what a lucky guy.
 

U2NUMB

Member
Awesome news... I was wondering what was happening to these two doctors. Going to be VERY interesting to see how they recover and exactly what their future looks like.
 

Kurdel

Banned
Awesome. Imagine the feeling of knowing you're going to die (from experience), taking a last-ditch experimental treatment and it actually working! Miraculous is the word - what a lucky guy.

Yeah, if this incredibly dramatic account is accurate, holy shit.
 
Brantly began to deteriorate and developed labored breathing. He told his doctors he thought he was dying, according to a source with firsthand knowledge of the situation.

Knowing his dose was still frozen, Brantly asked if he could have Writebol's now-thawed medication. It was brought to his room and administered through an IV. Within an hour of receiving the medication, Brantly's condition dramatically improved. He began breathing easier; the rash over his trunk faded away. One of his doctors described the events as "miraculous."
That sounds like something out of a movie.
 

MThanded

I Was There! Official L Receiver 2/12/2016
Well played CDC.
It is strange that a company that's likely invested years and tens of millions of dollars, if not hundreds of millions, into developing a treatment couldn't/wouldn't find a single person in the entire outbreak to run a trial with it until two Americans got infected. Not saying that The Onion was actually right, but waiting for infected Americans doesn't make much sense on the company's part.
Much harder to limit extenuating factors outside of the heavily controlled environment here.
 
That's awesome I'm glad to hear it's working so far but I'm in the group of people who wonder why we haven't tried it on others who had to die and only waited for these two to be infected.

Well that doesn't matter anymore since its out there now,I hope we find out soon how effective the drug is in curing ebola so maybe we have signs of hope for the people in Africa.
 

andycapps

Member
That's awesome I'm glad to hear it's working so far but I'm in the group of people who wonder why we haven't tried it on others who had to die and only waited for these two to be infected.

Well that doesn't matter anymore since its out there now,I hope we find out soon how effective the drug is in curing ebola so maybe we have signs of hope for the people in Africa.

I'm wondering if the CDC wasn't quite happy with these vaccines before testing them on these patients, but that when news of some Americans getting infected became news, it moved their plans up. Having access to all the medical care at Emory which is almost one of a kind, and the way things came together to transport them here safely.. I'm sure those had something to do with who was chosen.
 

GaimeGuy

Volunteer Deputy Campaign Director, Obama for America '16
That's awesome I'm glad to hear it's working so far but I'm in the group of people who wonder why we haven't tried it on others who had to die and only waited for these two to be infected.

Well that doesn't matter anymore since its out there now,I hope we find out soon how effective the drug is in curing ebola so maybe we have signs of hope for the people in Africa.
Probably because we need both the country and the individual permission to administer the treatment? What country is going to say yes to letting a foreign country administer untested drugs to its ill?
 
Testing experiment treatments? Yeah, that's about what I figured as to why those two were/are being flown into Emery.

Its good that it seems to be working, and hopefully stemming from this an effective treatment that can be mass-produced.
 

P44

Member
That's awesome I'm glad to hear it's working so far but I'm in the group of people who wonder why we haven't tried it on others who had to die and only waited for these two to be infected.

Well that doesn't matter anymore since its out there now,I hope we find out soon how effective the drug is in curing ebola so maybe we have signs of hope for the people in Africa.

Experimental, looks bad if you use it on other citizens and it fucks up and probably a shit ton of permissions needed that only came through recently.
 
http://arstechnica.com/science/2014...ent-for-ebola-may-have-saved-two-us-citizens/

Despite its fearsome behavior, Ebola is a fairly simple virus, with only seven genes. The gene that is essential for the virus to attach to human cells, called Ebola glycoprotein, has been identified previously. Antibodies that stick to this protein would be expected to block infection of new cells and target any virus circulating in the blood stream for destruction. The problem appears to be that an effective antibody response comes too late for the patients. (The virus also takes steps to tone down the immune response.)

The people at Mapp decided to do the immune system's job for it by making antibodies that can then be injected into infected individuals to perform the same function. The challenges are making the right ones and making enough of them.

To get the material they needed, the researchers turned to a well established technology called monoclonal antibody production. They injected mice with the Ebola glycoprotein, then fused individual antibody producing cells with a cancer cell. This produced a cell that continued to divide in culture, producing a single type of antibody. Some of these probably recognized cold and flu viruses, so the researchers had to screen for cells that made Ebola-specific antibodies. They identified three that stuck to different parts of the Ebola glycoprotein.

The problem at this point was that the antibodies were from mice. If injected into humans, the human immune system would recognize them as foreign and start an immune response against the treatment. So, the people at Mapp cloned the genes for these antibodies then swapped out parts, replacing parts of the mouse version with the human portion of the same gene and carefully avoiding alterations in the parts that recognize the Ebola protein.

Then, they needed to produce them in large quantities. So they managed to insert the genes into cells from a tobacco plant, which can be grown in large numbers with little fuss. The potential therapy was ready for testing.

Thanks genetic engineering!
 

GaimeGuy

Volunteer Deputy Campaign Director, Obama for America '16
Experimental, looks bad if you use it on other citizens and it fucks up and probably a shit ton of permissions needed that only came through recently.
Also this. The cdc undoubtedly had to request tons of waivers and emergency permissions for its actions that required the director's approval, as well as from the Dean of medicine at the hospital. Imagine having to involve diplomats from each country, other departments, and maybe even Congress. It's a mess
 

GungHo

Single-handedly caused Exxon-Mobil to sue FOX, start World War 3
Why didn't they try it on any African people?

Because they can get legal consent from American medical professionals who are willing to live in a controlled environment and who are willing to sign away their right to sue in case it turns them into a morlock.
 

Raist

Banned
Modern science is mind-boggling. The tools they're using now were science fiction, in the earliest stages of development, when I was growing up. Nice job, CDC.

Actually that technology is fairly old. Around 20 years in its modern form, but even older for simpler versions. Most antibodies used in the clinic these days were developed in the same way, and there are some pretty old ones, like Rituximab which has its patent expiring next year.
 
I can't believe what I'm hearing here. What has medical science been doing all this time?

If our immune system kills them, then just come up with a drug that does what our immune system does. That's just simple logic. Or how about blasting them with radiation or something? That's another idea right there.

Honestly, I'm feeling really let down by medicine right now.

http://arstechnica.com/science/2014...ent-for-ebola-may-have-saved-two-us-citizens/

The people at Mapp decided to do the immune system's job for it by making antibodies that can then be injected into infected individuals to perform the same function.

I'm basically House.
 
I'm basically House.

Except House didn't spout random ideas, including a fuckton of plainly stupid ones. He had medical knowledge and used that to reach a logical conclusion. You aren't like House.

And you were treating your idea as something that would be incredibly simple to produce, which it isn't.
 

GaimeGuy

Volunteer Deputy Campaign Director, Obama for America '16
I'm basically House.
How did you think vaccines work?

your body contains trillions of randomly generated shapes of antibodies. a foreign agent such as a virus has antigens which your body attempts to find an appropriate antibody for. Until it finds the antibody which binds to the antigen, it uses other, more primitive, brute force methods of containing the virus... raising its internal temperature to cook the virus, and also basically carpet-bombing the site of infection (this is why you typically get a sore throat with many cold viruses: The throat is the site of infection, and your body's immune system attacks parts of throat itself as collateral damage of taking out the infection).

Once the body finds the antibody which binds to the antigen, it very quickly begins producing them in mass quantities until the virus/bacteria/foreign agent is eliminated (this is why when you get an infection/virus, you "get better" rather quickly compared to the timeframe it takes you to get worse. You'll get sick over the course of 3-4 days, and then it takes only a day for you to get better, once your body finds the appropriate antibodies to attack the virus.

That's not all, though: After an antibody is found to be useful, the body maintains higher concentrations of the antibody in the blood to protect against future infections of the same virus. It remembers what the infection looked like and how it dealt with it and modifies its defense mechanisms to more quickly respond to the same line of attack in the future.

A vaccine is typically a completely harmless mix of dead cells spliced to have the antigens (binding sites/markers) of the actual dangerous agent. Your body learns how to attack the agent structurally, and then remembers it when an actual infection occurs.

If your body takes particularly long in locating the antibody for the harmless vaccine cells, you may experience some symptoms of illness (your body will raise its temperature and attack parts of the body the vaccine was injected at), but that just means your body happened to have a difficult time figuring out what to do.
 

Nivash

Member
The most amazing thing about genetical engineering is just how insane it sounds if you don't know anything about it. Pluck a random person from 1964 and tell them that 50 years from now we're going produce a treatment for a horrible viral disease by infecting mice with it, drawing their blood, mixing their blood with cancer cells, alter the DNA from mouse to human and inject it into a tobacco plant.

They'd laugh their asses off at you and call that the most stupid idea for a science fiction flick since Plan 9 from Outer Space. 1960's mad science has nothing on modern real science! It's awesome!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom