Support NeoGAF

[.Pennywise]

This match is part of the Game of the Generation Tournament. For rules, details and current brackets go to the Tournament thread (Click)

 

[yunkaiza]

Fallout 4 is only good with mods. FF7R is my personal GOTY.

 

[jshackles]

Anyone who votes for Fallout 4 should be ashamed of themselves.

 

[Pagusas]

FF7R is my game of the generation, Fallout 4 is my most disappointing game of the generation.

 

[Altares13th]

FF7r

 

[Ellery]

Easy FF VII R vote for me, but I didn't think Fallout 4 was that bad. Though well below many other great games in the tournament.

 

[martino]

none of them gotg for me
but i choose ff7r over fallout 4 without a doubt.

 

[Grinchy]

Fallout 4 for me. And no, I'm not ashamed.

Playing it on the Survival difficulty made it a pretty great game, despite any shortcomings in story and dialog trees. FF7R was filled with so many more shortcomings.

 

[SlimeGooGoo]

.

 

[The Fartist]

Fallout 4 in one gif:

 

[Aggressive Carrot]

I voted for Final Fantasy VII Remake. For a game that was just part one I ended up sinking a lot of time into it, twice.

 

[Airbus Jr]

Fallout 4 for me bcause FFVII is still a 1/4 game atm

 

[Newly Vacant]

Warts and all, I still played Fallout 4 for over 500 hours.

 

[yunkaiza]

Fallout 4 for me. And no, I'm not ashamed.

Playing it on the Survival difficulty made it a pretty great game, despite any shortcomings in story and dialog trees. FF7R was filled with so many more shortcomings.

My god survival was the worst shit ever. I dont know why I forced myself through that with the constant crashes and shitty save system. I need to try some survival mods at some point tho...

 

[SpiceRacz]

Fallout 4 for me. Got as much out of it as any single player game this generation.

 

[Barnabot]

gaf, don't let the weebs get away with another weeb game again.

Anyway I've played Fallout 4 and it sucked. That's why I'm voting for FFVIIR.

 

[Fuz]

Can I vote against both?

 

[JORMBO]

Fallout 4 was really disappointing after I really enjoyed Fallout 3. FF7R is my favorite game this year so far.

 

[Grinchy]

My god survival was the worst shit ever. I dont know why I forced myself through that with the constant crashes and shitty save system. I need to try some survival mods at some point tho...

Was it a console issue? I played on PC and don't seem to remember any crashes, or at least not enough to leave a lasting impression.

The worst thing from my memory was all the settings that had to be changed in the ini files because of Bethesda being inept developers who still can't even figure out how to properly implement mouse settings in PC versions after all these years.

And the way that loading screens were tied to framerate, so you'd have to fully unlock the framerate to make the loading screens run at 600fps lol. What a shitty, ragged engine. And we get to keep using it for their newest games!

 

[Vawn]

FFVII Remake was incredible. I can't wait for the next one on PS5.

 

[Danjin44]

Currently FFVIIR is my GOTY(that will change once 13 Sentinels comes out), so thats a easy choice for me.

 

[Arachnid]

Neither. I don't like how FF left turn based behind, and Fallout 4 was the most boring entry they've put out. I guess I'll vote for Fallout though since it seems to be the underdog here.

 

[Camreezie]

Easiest vote yet and I'm not even a final fantasy fan , fallout 4 shouldn't even be in this competition it was dog shit

 

[yunkaiza]

Was it a console issue? I played on PC and don't seem to remember any crashes, or at least not enough to leave a lasting impression.

It more than likely was. I played on PS4 and on many occasions I lost hours of gameplay because of completely random, inexplicable crashes. It's definitely been way smoother for me on PC now though, maybe because of the unofficial patch.

Bethesda really need to get their shit together with their engine. Those FPS problems on PC were annoying as fuck but thankfully the community fixed their game for them.

 

[Entroyp]

Oh boy, I didn’t like either so I’m sitting this one out.

 

[Birdo]

Tough choise, but Fallout 4 has FAR more replayability than FFVIIR.

 

[TheInfamousKira]

Loved FFVIIR, haven't played Fallout 4. Was scared away by initial reviews.

 

[Dynasty8]

FFVIIR is my GOTY. No game has hit me harder with nostalgia. Even though it's not perfect, it did so much right. The combat, the music, the characters/story (not the side quests though)...they knocked it out of the park. Also enjoyed Fallout 4, but there's definitely something special about FFVIIR.

 

[GymWolf]

Hard to decide the shittier game here...

 

[Lionel Richie]

If I'm being honest with myself, I had more fun with Fallout 4 despite the jank. FFVIIR was nice, but very forgettable and the meta spin they inserted into the narrative was fucking retarded.

 

[GymWolf]

Fallout 4 in one gif:

FF7 "remake" in one gif

(with the lady being the original ff7)

 

[Arkam]

Loved FF7R!! Was definitely a few flat bits with worthless fetch quests. And another great example of Square Enix poor level design with this rats nest. BUt aside from those it was just awesome. Combat was fun, character models were superb, the cutscenes were enthralling. Just a great package. Fallout 4 was... ok. Probably better than I give credit, but I bought on sale and didnt feel the need to play more than 2-3 hours. Felt like a step down from New Vegas.

 

[scydrex]

My god survival was the worst shit ever. I dont know why I forced myself through that with the constant crashes and shitty save system. I need to try some survival mods at some point tho...

Playing it for the first time in survival. I start playing it this quarantine. Had a couple ot crashes but not constant. Still the base game sucks big time. It look awful, a lot of LOD, pop in, the dialog sucks, a lot of loading. You are in the world map, enter a room a loading, then enter to the building another room so another loading... the graphics look like New Vegas.

This is no contest to me FF7R.

P.S. I'm glad i brought it for $20 with all the dlc and everything.

 

[TheContact]

Anyone who votes for Fallout 4 should be ashamed of themselves.

i've beaten ff7 on the psx upwards of 10 times since it came out, and I loved FF7R, but FO4 is the better game imo. not ashamed.

 

[Plague Doctor]

FFVII Remake doesn't need fan mods to make it playable.

 

[MrS]

Abstained from voting on the grounds that both games are woeful.

 

[LaughingStock]

I had more fun playing fallout 4.

 

[The Fartist]

FF7 "remake" in one gif

(with the lady being the original ff7)

Yeah, you can use that .gif for Fallout 4 as well.

 

[Pejo]

The whole base building/recruiting aspect of Fallout 4 killed it for me before I even really got started. It was just busywork, and while I'm sure some people enjoyed the absolute freedom of building bases, I wish it was more grid-based and menu driven than making me try to drag stuff around and place it manually. I heard you can ignore the base stuff, but it seems like every quest I got was related to "save this mini town and then rebuild it". Plus they give you power armor right at the first few missions, kinda stupid. It's really a shame, because I loved Fallout 3 and the DLC, but couldn't get in to either NV or Fallout 4.

Anyways, I guess with my disappointment, I voted for FFVII remake just because I like the cast. I hate the shit they're doing with the story, so far. If they're going to fuck it up, I'd like them to fuck it up big and make some drastic changes.

Spoiler: spoilers

Aerith better live and end up happy with Zack (who also better live - fuck time/causality ghosts!)

 

[ZZZZ]

No need to even make an effort here, FFVIIR will win by a landslide.


Bethesda needs to get it together, i'm sick of them and their B.S.

 

[Zekra Dezivad]

Despite weird changes in the last chapters, I loved FF7R.
If it will have an upgrade patch on PS5 I will gladly do a new run.

 

[GymWolf]

Yeah, you can use that .gif for Fallout 4 as well.

Same for the jim carrey gif used for ff7 Rerape, the story changes are nothing less than vomit inducing.

 

[The Fartist]

Same for the jim carrey gif used for ff7 Rerape, the story changes are nothing less that vomit inducing.

FF7 is a remake, Fallout 4 was supposed to evolve the franchise and ended up doing the opposite, but you're entitled to your opinion and vote.

 

[GymWolf]

FF7 is a remake, Fallout 4 was supposed to evolve the franchise and ended up doing the opposite, but you're entitled to your opinion and vote.

And where i said that fallout 4 was a better game exactly? read my first post in this topic.
The rape of fallout started with f3, and because that game had a good success they did f4 in the same way but even more streamlined and shitty.

 

[Bonfires Down]

I always feel like I should loot everything I see in Fallout 4, which gets boring as fuck. And managing the inventory is a complete disaster without mods. But I haven't played FFVIIR so I'm not voting.

 

[DarkestHour]

Fallout 4 was great outside of the weak writing. Never had issues with it and put 150 hours in to the game. Didn't play FF7R because I already played FF7 enough that I'm quite sick of it.

 

[Spukc]

final farce demake 1/7th was even worse then fallout 4

grats everyone loses.

 

[Radical Dreamer]

Easily FF7R. My avatar has nothing to do with it.

 

[The Fartist]

And where i said that fallout 4 was a better game exactly? read my first post in this topic.
The rape of fallout started with f3, and because that game had a good success they did f4 in the same way but even more streamlined and shitty.

Ok, dude.

 

[CrysisFreak]

FF7R Part 2 hopefully with less low quality filler, less tech issues and 60fps please, thanks in advance.