• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Final Fantasy VII Remake vs. Final Fantasy XV

Vote for your Game Of The Generation!

  • Final Fantasy XV

    Votes: 56 17.3%
  • Final Fantasy VII Remake

    Votes: 268 82.7%

  • Total voters
    324
  • Poll closed .
A8AKyJs.gif


Final Fantasy XV has EPIC Summons

dsKNd5D.gif


rLYVMqe.gif


A wonderful and beautiful experience.
Definetly the best Final Fantasy game ever made in this generation, for me

ZKAqyyW.gif


Pheraps we will meet again, at daybrake

Man, you really have a lot of free time in your hands. Can you share?
 
And I'm annoyed by the haters of this game.
And this just because I love the game.
And I've already explained multiple times why, for me, Final Fantasy XV is a masterpiece.

Accept my opinion, for what it is.
Or ignoring it, if you prefer.
But stop this ridiculous attack against me and my love for the game
You're middle-eastern, aren't you?
 
I gotta post after the storm settled down. I had a good laugh for 7 pages with the statements of our Final Fantasy Avatar friend here. Thanks for the good time folks but I gotta stick with my opinion of FFVII Remake being the better game with Final Fantasy XIV being tied for me (enjoyment-wise).
 
A8AKyJs.gif


Final Fantasy XV rapresent for me the most beatiful experience I've ever had with a Final Fantasy game to date.
(and I've played them all)
This is the best openworld game I've ever played.
A spectacular Multimedia experience
With really wondefull charachters

otB3Jez.jpg


wQXNlTE.jpg


A beautiful and powerful story

QeydklX.gif


The best main charachters for a Final Fantasy game, for me.

V9wHyYW.gif


a really awesome brotherhood

nH0WXzb.gif


Final Fantasy XV has EPIC Summons

dsKNd5D.gif


rLYVMqe.gif


Literally AWESOME LORE

JPYCeOY.jpg


A majestic openworld to explore

6SyEK6F.jpg


W61vxPj.jpg


A really great graphics, animotions, and a fun battle system
(my favourite battle system for an action jrpg)

FAWsUiT.gif


and divine OST







A wonderful and beautiful experience.
Definetly the best Final Fantasy game ever made in this generation, for me.

No other game has managed to give me as many emotions and good moments as Final Fantasy XV

ZKAqyyW.gif


Pheraps we will meet again, at daybrake

Man, you really have a lot of free time in your hands. Can you share?

For Final Fantasy XV, I found the time

You're middle-eastern, aren't you?

Nope
 
I played both through to completion (XV without viewing any of the shit to give the story the context it desperately needed), and I have to say FFVIIR is the better game in all respects. However, I think FFVIIR wouldn't have been possible without the groundwork that XV laid down in terms of game design, combat, and its overall presentation, so credit should definitely go where it is due.
 
if you allow me to add something bit more about this ranking:

12th Place: Haurchefant Greystone (Final Fantasy XIV)----> MY BRO HAURCHEFANT IS MORE WIDELY LOVED AND POPULAR THAN PRINCE NOCTICS!
13th Place: Noctis Lucis Caelum (Final Fantasy XV)


also worth to mention that Emet-Selch is the only villain that made in top 10 with the rest character is full of main cast of good guy.



63rd Place: Ardyn Izunia (Final Fantasy XV)
Hauchefart is the only moron to truly die in all of FFXIV.
 
FFXV deserves a TON of praise for how it developed a story line in one game. The resolution of the endgame feels more satisfying than other FF games that multiple games. The culmination of the brotherhood is so damn satisfying.
 
Well done guys, you got him banned. Every single person who actually had fun triggering him by asking stupid questions like "tell me more" should have been banned as well.
 
Last edited:
Fucking Bullshit Ban. Absolute Bullshit. Nobody gives a fuck about this thread, or any FF thread. Let him have his fun. He wasn't toxic. He didn't post anything inappropriate. He didn't fucking lie through his teeth in a spec thread or console war in random threads.

All the man did was really fucking love a video game. That's more than apparently 99% of GAF can say and I guess it's ban worthy now.

If he gets 2 weeks the pathetic kids who baited him should get 2 months.
 
Well done guys, you got him banned. Every single person who actually had fun triggering him by asking stupid questions like "tell me more" should have been banned as well.
Hi.

Mod team asked D.final to please shorten their posts and to not use as many gifs.

Banter between users was not the cause of the ban, nor is it typically.
 
In a better world, sure.
But this is not the case.

Because one of the two games is polarized by excessive and largely unjustified or exaggerated hatred.
While another is honored, or slightly preferred, for its ancient history and solid fanbase.

For this reason the result was obvious already predictable from the beginning.
But in large part, probably, for the wrong reasons.
And therefore not fair competition.

Nah, the hate was totally justified and FFVII:R just had less to hate while FFXV was just a giant mess.

If FFXV had came out and was a masterpiece it would have had a chance but people just didn't like it as much as you did. No need to use longtime VII fans as an excuse for people thinking XV was bad, They just were more bothered by it's flaws that you were while they though those in VII were minor.
 
Fucking Bullshit Ban. Absolute Bullshit. Nobody gives a fuck about this thread, or any FF thread. Let him have his fun. He wasn't toxic. He didn't post anything inappropriate. He didn't fucking lie through his teeth in a spec thread or console war in random threads.

All the man did was really fucking love a video game. That's more than apparently 99% of GAF can say and I guess it's ban worthy now.

If he gets 2 weeks the pathetic kids who baited him should get 2 months.

I find him annoying. That said, the bans are out of control lately. People are getting banned for absolute trivial stuff. It's reminiscent of old GAF. There was no reason for aban from that post.

Then you see people getting banned for "console wars" where they really didn't say anything offensive, and the mods respond back console warring themselves.

For example, someone just got banned because teasing a console is off limits and the ban message from the mod is:

Clearly your last ban did nothing. All you can do is cry and derail all Microsoft threads, must be hard having no news about your beloved Playstation right?

On the other side, this guy got a permanent ban over this comment that I can't find a single thing wrong with:

Both consoles will be able to do limited Ray Tracing at best on AAA games, especially open world without cut backs in resolution, framerate, and all sorts of other graphical effects. It's just too demanding. People should temper their expectations. However, i do expect the more powerful console to be more ray tracing capable as is expected.
 
Last edited:
Ff7 remake gets my vote easily. FFXV is one of the worst ff game i've ever played. Pretty graphics and decent music. Below mediocre in every other area.
 
Fucking Bullshit Ban. Absolute Bullshit. Nobody gives a fuck about this thread, or any FF thread. Let him have his fun. He wasn't toxic. He didn't post anything inappropriate. He didn't fucking lie through his teeth in a spec thread or console war in random threads.

All the man did was really fucking love a video game. That's more than apparently 99% of GAF can say and I guess it's ban worthy now.

If he gets 2 weeks the pathetic kids who baited him should get 2 months.
Yeah, the ban is uncalled for. He can be a bit obnoxious, but he's cute in his insane love for that game. Wish I still had his childlike enthusiasm.

Free D.Final!
 
Well done guys, you got him banned. Every single person who actually had fun triggering him by asking stupid questions like "tell me more" should have been banned as well.

He had it coming, he didn't know when to stop, and those posts filled with gifs and bolded letter statements were quite annoying. He could have turned it down a notch. At least it wasn't a permaban.
 
I've found D.Final D.Final annoying, but, as I said earlier, there was no reason to ban over this. Something has changed over the last couple weeks, because people are getting banned over complete nonsense. This isn't how GAF has been since the RE breakup/creation.

I messaged EviLore EviLore directly with these concerns.
 
I also put lots gifs in my post about my favourite games, if D.Final got banned for that, shouldn't I get banned for the same reason?
 
Fucking Bullshit Ban. Absolute Bullshit. Nobody gives a fuck about this thread, or any FF thread. Let him have his fun. He wasn't toxic. He didn't post anything inappropriate. He didn't fucking lie through his teeth in a spec thread or console war in random threads.

All the man did was really fucking love a video game. That's more than apparently 99% of GAF can say and I guess it's ban worthy now.

If he gets 2 weeks the pathetic kids who baited him should get 2 months.
I'm pretty sure his obsession with FFXV is just a gimmick he plays up for fun.
 
I also put lots gifs in my post about my favourite games, if D.Final got banned for that, shouldn't I get banned for the same reason?
He did do it a dozen times in the thread though, not a couple, i don't think it's a fair comparison. I don't believe that's a reason to ban someonme, i like gifs even though some people with limited internet will argue otherwise.

He probably got banned because the admins asked him nicely to stop or keep it down a little and he still kept doing it.
 
Last edited:
Bad move from the mods. The guy was noisy, but he was just loving his game. Isn't that part of gaming culture? It reminds me of when I banned people from my old fansub's forum for the most pettiest things, but I was 15 year old kid who did stupid things.

Undeserved ban. 1984-esque.
 
1984-esque.
lol lets maybe pump the brakes on that. no one is dying

as for OP, im not shedding any tears over his ban. he was being fucking annoying. if anything i dont want a bunch of posters with 9 year old mentalities shitting up the boards making the rest of us look like morons along with them. and ignoring multiple warnings from mods... fuck em

i may not be exactly for the ban, buuuuut i definitely aint against it
 
I agree with the ban, I don't think it was an exaggerated reaction because it wasn't permanent, but he was being annoying on purpose, and that kind of crap shouldn't fly here.
 
Well done guys, you got him banned. Every single person who actually had fun triggering him by asking stupid questions like "tell me more" should have been banned as well.
Fucking Bullshit Ban. Absolute Bullshit. Nobody gives a fuck about this thread, or any FF thread. Let him have his fun. He wasn't toxic. He didn't post anything inappropriate. He didn't fucking lie through his teeth in a spec thread or console war in random threads.

All the man did was really fucking love a video game. That's more than apparently 99% of GAF can say and I guess it's ban worthy now.

If he gets 2 weeks the pathetic kids who baited him should get 2 months.
Yeah, the ban is uncalled for. He can be a bit obnoxious, but he's cute in his insane love for that game. Wish I still had his childlike enthusiasm.

Free D.Final!
The posts were too long and spammy. Passion is fine but a massive wall of gifs and several giant bolded "THIS GAME IS AWESOME" lines is too much. Plus the warning(s) on top of that.

I say this as someone who considers XV one of the better games in the series. As long as it's not a perm-ban, it's the right decision.
 
Bad move from the mods. The guy was noisy, but he was just loving his game. Isn't that part of gaming culture? It reminds me of when I banned people from my old fansub's forum for the most pettiest things, but I was 15 year old kid who did stupid things.

Undeserved ban. 1984-esque.
Relax, it's not a perm, and he didn't get banned for "just loving his game".

The reason he got banned was because he spammed out a bunch of text and gifs, was politely asked to stop by a mod, and decided to flaunt that request. ANYONE would get banned for that, regardless of subject.

Flagrant ignoring of mod request = ban

"1984-esque" = overreaction.
 
While I believe FF7 is way better, I feel like sometimes the game looked just awful. I'm not even referring to the mega bad textures, the game just looked off in daylight sometimes. FF15 was mostly consistent with its graphics, from what I've seen.
 
I had fun with the thread but that ban was unnecessary and uncalled, the guy just didn't back off when the matter was his favorite game, nothing wrong with that. Of course, he was a little too fanatic for his own sake and obnoxious but I feel bad for him to the point of feeling like my previous post seems like I'm mocking the person before they getting banned :messenger_persevering:.

Edit: My mistake, I saw the ban is temporary. Thought it was permanent, I just hope the guy reflects about not flooding posts with content when trying to prove their point.
 
Last edited:
Darn I forgot to ask D.Final what he thought about never receiving the final 3 dawn of the future dlc's we were supposed to get, do you think he cared?

I also put lots gifs in my post about my favourite games, if D.Final got banned for that, shouldn't I get banned for the same reason?

But you're the nicest person on this forum...
 
I had fun with the thread but that ban was unnecessary and uncalled, the guy just didn't back off when the matter was his favorite game, nothing wrong with that. Of course, he was a little too fanatic for his own sake and obnoxious but I feel bad for him to the point of feeling like my previous post seems like I'm mocking the person before they getting banned :messenger_persevering:.

Edit: My mistake, I saw the ban is temporary. Thought it was permanent, I just hope the guy reflects about not flooding posts with content when trying to prove their point.
It is temporary
 
Final Fantasy XV It's really a masterpiece for me.
And even for many others people around the world it's a really beautiful and great Final Fantasy game.

And I've said many times the reasons.

And this is a more than valid reason to be proud of my opinion on FFXV.
LOL
 
While I believe FF7 is way better, I feel like sometimes the game looked just awful. I'm not even referring to the mega bad textures, the game just looked off in daylight sometimes. FF15 was mostly consistent with its graphics, from what I've seen.
in this aspect XV has better support from devs team. while VIIR until now people still screaming for texture bug patch.
 
Bad move from the mods. The guy was noisy, but he was just loving his game. Isn't that part of gaming culture? It reminds me of when I banned people from my old fansub's forum for the most pettiest things, but I was 15 year old kid who did stupid things.

Undeserved ban. 1984-esque.
Is it so hard to read up on the ban thread or this?

This is the 3rd time guys does this.
 
Top Bottom