Sure, Jan.
Also, there are no inconsistencies in my claim. Just facts that you don't want to believe! Wahey!
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Gafia 2: The Bride of Gafia |Mafia OT| One Wedding, Many Funerals
- Thread starter RetroMG
- Start date
Sure, Jan.
Also, there are no inconsistencies in my claim. Just facts that you don't want to believe! Wahey!
Terrabyte20xx
Junior Wrestlemania XXX Champion
What. The. Hell.
No seriously in what world does one scum player bus another scum player when there is a clear scapegoat right in front of them AND neither of them are the hidden scum player!?!
I get you aren't directly calling me scum, but come on!
Xamtheking
Member
*werewolf 1 flashbacks*
I also can see you being scum if launch is scum
I had almost forgotten about this, but it reminded me of the town read I gave of her. It wasn't that strong so I didn't feel super confident, but I still found it really weird for her as scum to make that late vote on a townie D1 when the lynch was sort of settled. Usually scum stays out of possible trouble.
This is what initially got me suspicious of Scrafty. A good breadcrumb would have settled the deal and I knew she had been pushed in NV for a hard to understand breadcrumb.
Later when I thought about I didn't understand her insistence on holding the target hidden. Even if scum killed them she'd still learn whether the second target was scum.
I also really didn't like the clearing of Bronx. Not because it itself looked fishy, but because I felt like I had a comfortable lead and all of a sudden that got turned upside down. My comfortable opinion for a long time after that was Scrafty was scum covering another scum. Occam's Razor makes it painfully obvious that it probably wasn't the case, but it had the path of least resistance and helped keep me suspicious of Scrafty.
------------------------------------
I didn't interact a lot with Wee and never made a read of her. My gut impression was that she stuck out a lot and I always lean town with people that do. She also felt more involved than in Batman where she was neutral.
Before Scrafty claimed I had a short conversation with Wee FWIW. I tried to argue why I thought her vote was townie and didn't understand Wee's position. I didn't make much of a read on her and mainly just scratched my head.
You're not trying either. I tried to contact you D1 in response to the vote, but you never replied.
Hidden scum player as if main scum would know? Anyway, I do not think you are scum, burb asked me to pick one and my read on the situation depends heavily on Launch's flip.
I am most suspicious of the AB and Xam votes on wee, but don't think either are on the scum team with you for obvious reasons.
Sorry if you've already clarified this, but what pushes Terra up if Launch flips scum?
I sort of doubt it, Retro had 3+1 in Night Vale, and people complained afterwards about the balance being too skewed towards town.
Who do you think those three still alive are?
I believe they are in the list of 10 people who haven't claimed yet. Can't pinpoint closer yet, but I do tHinksey that list will overlap with the people who either tried to save weemadarthur, or was absent during D2 end.
There might obviously be scum within claims too. Launch is most suspicious in that list, followed by xam. I can buy there being two motion trackers.
Mostly process of elimination.
Well, actually the list is 9 people after Camjo claimed.
I just can't see a situation where scum would actively try to lynch their godfather, which leaves AbsolutBro out. Roy and Ty4on I town read for now. Salva seems little unlikely as well. So that leaves BSP, Timeaisis, CzarTim, Fireblend and Seath.
I just can't see a situation where scum would actively try to lynch their godfather, which leaves AbsolutBro out. Roy and Ty4on I town read for now. Salva seems little unlikely as well. So that leaves BSP, Timeaisis, CzarTim, Fireblend and Seath.
My scum list is launch, time, BSP, and then maybe seath or a wild card like Roy fwiw
I'm not happy about how he jumped on Salva D2 just as things started to look little bad for Weemadarthur. That's assuming Salva is town, obviously.
So:
Fireblend (Salva)
Seath (AFK)
BSP (AFK)
SalvaPot (AFK, can't self vote)
Timeaisis (AFK)
Maybe me (I doubt I would have been able to vote in the last minute)
Are on the top for either being unavailable or on Salva? I guess we could add Ourobolus (Salva) as well. Who knows, making that a scum role would be kind of clever.
where is salva ?
Xamtheking
Member
VOTE: LaunchpadMcQ
He's been coasting pretty hardcore lately.
That's the idea. I know there is lot of AFK folk in there, but it could explain why weemadarthur wasn't saved that day. Most of Salva voters have claimed a role so far.
In regards to Salva, I'm bothered that why Kalor didn't vote for him to save weemadarthur.
What makes Terra poke through if Launch is scum?
I have the same read. He was my only real town read into D2, but hasn't made much of an impression after that.
I'd love to hear more from him because I can genuinely see him being town, but his vote on D2 was obviously suspicious.
Fuck, I forgot to add that. Thought the same thing when I looked back at the votes.
It's because my lunch is always fish or berries. Things can get little monotonous after a while, diet wise.
You're missing the context of the question asked of me.
I was asked to assume there was a scum voter on wee.
I find xam and ab's vote most suspicious given they came right at the end, but I do not think either are on the scum team with Launch. I also think Launch is scum. So in this scenario, by process of elimination, I think tb would most likely be scum. If I had to pick one of the md's as scum, it would be tb. But generally speaking there are people I find far more scummy than tb so it's moot.
^^^^^^^^^^^^ Do you think we're moving away from a Camjo lynch?
Sorry for being dense. I even remembered that question >.>
Vo-ting... What's that?
I might have heard if it, but I don't think I participate in it.
On a more serious note I think D2 of Love Boat is a tale of the risks, but also the rewards of holding a turbo back.
FOUR LEGS GOOD TURBO BAD
What if we make Camjo the neutral as he claimed (heck, could be a Tanner
) and, say, Launch into the scum?AbsolutBro
Member
not a mod but
launchpadmcq (4)
terrabyte20xx 2275
nin1000 2343 (2413)
absolutbro 2364
xamtheking 2622
camjo-z 2631
timeasis (0)
nin1000 2291 (2343)
absolutbro (0)
launchpadmcq 2296 (2360)
czartim (0)
xamtheking 2315 (2572)
bananaspaceprincess (2)
burbeting 2327
seath 2569
camjo-z (7)
ourobolus 2359
launchpadmcq 2360
timeaisis 2372
roytheone 2408
bananaspaceprincess 2410
nin1000 2413 (2461)
camjo-z 2525 (2631)
xamtheking 2572 (2622)
czartim 2574 (2591)
nin1000 2617
czartim 2633
seath (1)
ty4on 2459
czartim 2460 (2565)
nin1000 2461 (2617)
launchpadmcq (4)
terrabyte20xx 2275
absolutbro 2364
xamtheking 2622
camjo-z 2631
timeasis (0)
absolutbro (0)
czartim (0)
bananaspaceprincess (2)
burbeting 2327
seath 2569
camjo-z (7)
ourobolus 2359
launchpadmcq 2360
timeaisis 2372
roytheone 2408
bananaspaceprincess 2410
nin1000 2617
czartim 2633
seath (1)
ty4on 2459
Who's scum then?
What if we make Camjo the neutral as he claimed (heck, could be a Tanner
nah fam
3p killers gots to get got
I agree.
Town isn't rational. I'm not for a turbo right now, but the rationale is that even with a confirmed bad guy town can still talk themselves out of it and vote someone else out.
Another thing is people can get bored and discussion can die out. I remember in Danganronpa we knew 100% someone were scum, but didn't turbo them. While we obviously voted them out I think that day ended up demotivating people because nothing really happened. Town had also lost a town leader, but it felt like that day removed some of town's morale for the rest of the game.
I'm not really for a turbo because I don't feel like the conversation has halted.
Tsk tsk tsk...full disclosure: I also want to play stellaris in peace tomorrow
You mean peace to meticulously reread the thread?
Also, reminder that this "confirmed bad guy" will, if not killed today:
- still be around tomorrow
- only kill two people maximum without further dousing (a neutral who will leave anyway and a guy who still hasn't claimed or been confirmed)
- potentially continue to be roleblocked
- possibly be killed by paranoid maf
When the flip happens, please make sure to lynch all the schmucks who've been trying to convince the rest of town that this is not the case, starting with the scummiest ones first of course.