You already are misinterpreting it.
I said from the beginning, people can like whatever. But that doesn't mean you can't objectively criticize games, or movies, or books.
For starters, you kept mixing up facts and taste, you're assuming if something is a fact lots of people need to agree with it, which makes no sense from a logical perspective.
Let it go.
I don't even fucking think this game deserves Game Of The Year, my own comment states I personally don't think so, but theses are SUBEJCTIVE ideas, thats it...... I never once argued a fact, as taste bud. Not even remotely. So shit, you can factually state what ever you feel like it regarding a game.
It will not change how someone else feels about that.
I'll even say that I agree to a DEGREE with what you are saying regarding The Witcher 3, simply not in the areas you state.
Look at your post closely.
"Nah, witcher 3 is definitely overrated too. There is heavy objective criticism that can be made towards it, from broken game systems and
poor quest design to some weird nonsensical gameplay decisions."
So shit, I can say I agree with disliking many things this game does, anyone who knows me, knows just how overrated I feel the Witcher 3 is, I even agree with all that you are saying here, I don't how ever agree that its a objective view, even if I fucking agree its shit.
The quest design is shit....its literally an entire run around, do this to find where Ciri is, oh she not here, but do this and we'll tell you, go to place...she not there, do mission to find her last place she was at, repeat etc. This is shit design and boring as hell....
Look at how many people praise that shit, look at how many GOTY awards it won, look at how many people will disagree with us.... soooooooo its subjective. Even me agreeing with you that its shit, doesn't mean its NOT subjective.
Better objective criticism would be the sound cutting out, the horse not being able to cross the bridge, people's faces missing, people randomly flying in the air, a quest that can't start, corrupt saves. Not 100%, but shit 99% of people are not playing the game for that and think their save failing is fun or the horse can't cross the bridge is fun that they can't continue the game or something lol.
So better examples exist.