Methinks you are over-analysing a tad there
I really hope I'm not here. I wish I could make a thread about Kratos and his development as a character and the potential that this title has. I mean lets just look at Kratos as a character. The first God of War was a solid tragic story.
*spoilers for people who have not played the original trilogy*
We are introduced to Kratos as a man so depressed that he is ready to just end his life, but then we are taken back to how he got to this point. We see that he is angry because he lost everything and he just wants to be left alone. He lost his family, he lost his comrades, he has nothing left to live for. Then we go further into the story and find out that its essentially his own fault that his family died, his obsession with victory, domination and power led him to literally and figuratively lose his bond to his family. He gets used by the gods to defeat Ares, only so he doesn't have to suffer visions of what he did, to have reminders of what he's done. As the player, we feel bad for him, therefore we don't feel gross about ripping the eye out of a cyclops or gutting a minotaur. The game ends with him not being able to be at peace even after doing what the gods asked him to do.
We can say "he's suffered enough, he has had 10 years to think about what he did and to regret his actions" so we feel bad that he's going to kill himself, but it makes sense in the context of the story, I mean he killed a fucking
child. Does he deserve to even get redemption from that? Then when the gods appoint him as the new god of war, we're supposed to be happy about this, but look at his fucking face when he sits on that chair. He's not happy about it--this is actually a sad ending because he has power, but it means nothing. God of War 2 and 3 is just basically him being mad at Zeus, mad that he was manipulated, mad that he was depowered, just mad all around, and again we're supposed to trust that he has a good reason for being so angry at the world around him. Afterall he was betrayed by the gods. But by the time GOW3 rolls around, he's driven by his lust for revenge to the point where his fight with the gods ends up killing literally every human. How do you empathise with a character like that? what has he actually
learned? how has he grown as a character? he hasn't. He's right back to square one, except now he's even lost the POTENTIAL to move on.
*/spoilers*
With this new God of War, there is potential for us as players to stop and examine our actions, ask ourselves if violence is the only way. Kratos now fights to protect his family, he's someone who has somehow managed to try and put his past behind him, who has been able to slowly heal enough to trust another person and start a family. He's a character who can lose it all again, and is probably scared to death of that. He wants his son to be hard, but at the same time, does he want him to grow up to be a child murderer? does he want his boy to become so consumed with victory and power that he ends up ruining the world? we can see that in how he carries himself and responds to his son. He keeps him at a distance, telling him the journey isn't for kids but at the same time he wants his son to be able to protect himself and we can see how he is conflicted about this. We've seen kratos as a sad and angry individual, but we haven't seen him as someone who is scared. We haven't seen him exhibiting a fear of loss, we haven't seen him as someone with empathy either. The old kratos would have just jumped at that serpent and tried to rip its eye out. This new Kratos
asks questions before acting, he wonders if he can change, if people can change, if he deserves a chance to change and deserves redemption, do his enemies as well?