• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

How does PopGAF deal witht the fact that...

Status
Not open for further replies.
They shouldn't call it pop music they should call it popular music.

iZJmU5JjekI45.gif
 
PopGAF is like the most colourful and threatening mafia I've ever encountered.

Fierce is the word, which in this case can mean two things.
 
You're supposed to feel great that you made yet another contribution to OT GAF that's along the lines of "how come people like shit I don't like and do things I don't do and generally enjoy a type of art or entertainment that I'm not interested in."
 
But so are you. So is everyone in this thread. I don't get it. It took me about two minutes to make this thread.

But YOU made the thread, we're all just here exposing the flaws in your argument, actually unbothered, and you have been proven wrong and dragged for the past two pages, and you are bothered, constantly hitting refresh attempting to save face, and still have relevance when you have neither.
 
You're supposed to feel great that you made yet another contribution to OT GAF that's along the lines of "how come people like shit I don't like and do things I don't do and generally enjoy a type of art or entertainment that I'm not interested in."

No lies.
BaOxhEN.png
 
But you guys didn't prove me wrong because pop artists still don't write their own songs, which was the initial argument. Am I talking to five year olds? Posting a bunch of animated GIFs doesn't make someone right.
 
But you guys didn't prove me wrong because pop artists still don't write their own songs, which was the initial argument. Am I talking to five year olds? Posting a bunch of animated GIFs doesn't make someone right.

Kimbra
Lana Del Rey
Natalia Kills
Sophie Ellis-Bextor
Ellie Goulding
AND MANY OTHERS write songs so if your eyes are not right go back and read the thread. Sure there are some that don't write but there are many that write too.
 
Kimbra
Lana Del Rey
Natalia Kills
Sophie Ellis-Bextor
Ellie Goulding
AND MANY OTHERS write songs so if your eyes are not right go back and read the thread. Sure there are some that don't write but there are many that write too.

Stop, you're going to shatter the illusion that PopGAF is a community revolving around four Top 40 artists.
 
Kimbra
Lana Del Rey
Natalia Kills
Sophie Ellis-Bextor
Ellie Goulding
AND MANY OTHERS write songs so if your eyes are not right go back and read the thread. Sure there are some that don't write but there are many that write too.

Thanks for the good response. I actually don't mind Lana Del Ray. I also noticed someone else with a Grimes avatar, who I like. I guess my big beef is with artists who just straight up don't, yet are most popular.
 
Thanks for the good response. I actually don't mind Lana Del Ray. I also noticed someone else with a Grimes avatar, who I like. I guess my big beef is with artists who just straight up don't, yet are most popular.

Do you think that writers who don't sing aren't talented?
 
But you guys didn't prove me wrong because pop artists still don't write their own songs, which was the initial argument. Am I talking to five year olds? Posting a bunch of animated GIFs doesn't make someone right.



After 5 pages you failed to realize

A) It doesn't matter as long as the music is good.
B) Even the gold standards in Music didn't write their own music.
C) Writing your own music does not mean that you are anymore better than someone who doesn't.
D) You are expecting us to tell you something that none of us near the artist can inquire about, but at the end of the day doesn't matter because of (A). And yet you remain complacent in generalizing "pop" stars.


How hard is the concept for you grasp? And then you have the nerve to say "Am I talking to five year olds".

I mean really now?

iLQyxKScnlBXB.gif
 
yikes


pop gaf is really strange/scary


edit: also are most of them guys or girls? I don't get the "sis" thing... does this come from an azealia banks song or something??
???
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom