Don't give a shit what the universe thinks. The stars ain't going anywhere suddenly. And i highly doubt the universe would care if they'd be gone suddenly either, it ain't conscious. We are the closest damn thing to a consciousness the universe has. (Yeah, sure, if the stars were gone suddenly, we'd go "oh shit" and then die out, thereby getting rid of the issue, even if the end wouldn't be very satisfactory for us)
Observers give value and relevance to things, nothing has intrinsic value.
EDIT and i highly doubt humanity, or its descendants would last anywhere near the heat death. It is so far away.
Well yes, you're right too of course. The universe does not technically care if
any life came into being. So, given that essential equality that we both would agree to, then we can start assigning values based on each objects essential contributions. If we agree intelligence is a net "zero" to the universe, and that anything else existing is also a "zero" to the universe, then we describe the importance based on the function each thing provide. The function humans provide can pretty much be described as a net benefit only to other humans (or thinking creatures). The function
stars provide can be described as a net benefit to every object in the universe that requires elements they produce.
Given this, you really think humans are more important than stars, or even equivalent? We really are irrelevant in the grand scheme of the universe. Which isn't to say we aren't awesome, amazing creatures who can, given enough time, do astonishing things. But they are not things the universe needs to continue functioning as-is. If we die, we're like a fart in the wind.
Amazing farts though
Amir0x, my question is more like. Will we ever be able to detect, from earth, ourselves 20k ly away from us. Meaning finding our twin earth 20k away. Lets say you are on earth A and I am on Earth B. Will you be able to find my planet? Will you know that life is there and that its intelligent? How will we communicate over the vast distance? Lets say you hit the jackpot and send me the signal at the precise direction. I am in awe 20k years later and send you a reply of "you have GAF there too?" Will you remember your initial message and where you sent it in space and wait for my reply from the same spot 40k years later? This is why I think we'll never find ET
Oh, I get it. Well, if that planet is 20k light years away, it'd have the same problems communication as that ship that was 20k light years away. If the humans on the ship were smart enough to maintain the information about Earth's location and the channels they'd be communicating through (and you'd think they'd keep that sort of information in an important, locked place), they'd be able to aim their communications in the right direction. But it'd be "communication" in only the loosest sense... 20,000 years later some humans, if they are still alive on Earth, would receive it, translate it (since the language would likely be near indecipherable to whatever the modern dialects were), and then if they still had the capacity would send something back. But the time lag would be so vast there'd be no way to meaningfully act on the information. It'd be posterity more than function.
So some human leader on the planet can say 'we have established a colony on another planet, and have confirmed it has and sustains life! The possibilities of our universe have just expanded 10,000 fold!'
But not to say 'make sure you start mining unobtainium, so we can build more weapons'. There'd be no point.
Barring any amazing discovery n the interim that allows communication that could bend spacetime and arrive in reasonable human timeframes, we really are fucked on communication at that distance.
But I would think humans would at this point understand the necessity for striking out, and would think of it in cold, rational terms: 'in order to guarantee our continued survival for the species, we need to put ourselves down in as many places as possible. Even if we don't see the fruits of our labor, we know the work started on Earth can continue out there somewhere.'
Wouldn't it be fascinating though to be able to study the way a human society completely independent from any further Earthly influence would crystallize and become completely unique in ritual and action? It'd be a remarkable thing to study.
I think the best we'll get is that planet X might have life in it after carefully observing it. Not knowing if its micro, animal like or intelligent
Edit: oh and i forgot to add that I need to hit the jackpot too for listening from your direction
Well, there will be ways in the future to determine whether a planet's chemical signature are consistent with those that have life (like our planet). Since our planet has a unique signature that those looking for life would be able to mark out as proof of life, we're pretty sure eventually we'll have the tools to read similar chemical signatures at a distance. Of course, if we pick up those signatures a million light years away, what are the chances that life is still around? That's what makes the whole idea so complicated. But amazing!
I always love the thought experiment of there being just one other solitary planet out there with intelligent life, some 6 billion light years away. And this planet would never be able to contact with us. Yet, every element of it is unique. Imagine all the movies they have created that we will never see - their geniuses like Martin Scorsese or Stanley Kubrick's or Steven Spielberg's. Imagine the vast works of art, with perceptions completely unique, creating entirely new approaches to canvas work, bizarre periods like the ones artists on our planet went through, but with entirely unique motivations based on entirely unique religions or leaders or concepts. Imagine if they had just one brilliant painter like Leonardo DaVinci or Vincent Van Gogh's! Imagine what work we've missed out on! More closely, imagine their versions of videogame industries (their iconic Mario's or Master Chief's or Kratos, but approached from angles you could only imagine if you were part of that completely distinct culture). Their cultural Renaissance. Their wars, their diplomatic squabbles, their natural disasters. Their history, all of it!
Just think of what we are missing out on if there is even
one other planet with intelligent life. And even this thought experiment is very human-centric. What did they invent that we cannot even conceive of because their perspective on life is so different (say, for example, their days lasted 36 hours instead of 24. Imagine what impact that alone would have on the way people thought).
So, I'd be perfectly satisfied to find even one Dinosaur planet out there. But if there was an intelligent life planet... and they were even offset technologically by ten thousand years... the things we'd be able to witness. It blows the mind.
haha, exactly.
Hopefully by the time we are at this stage (if we don't kill ourselves first) we would have cracked
quantum entanglement therefore sending data will be instantaneous no matter how far away you are.
Sadly, most scientists believe this cannot be used in this way. However, I do not give up hope that they may come up with something... just because I and they cannot comprehend what that something is now means relatively little in the grand scheme of thing. We've only really been using the scientific method in full blast in the past 200 years.