• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

I screwed up big... Part Deux

Status
Not open for further replies.
adamsappel said:
Relix, DO NOT TELL! You will be harming the sisters relationship for the rest of their lives. Either dump the girl now without revealing the truth, or carry it as a secret forever.

Maybe the dude she has been dating for 4 years deserves to know that she's having unprotected sex with her sister's boyfriend?
 
Relix said:
The option that makes more sense is not telling my girlfriend.

Look guys...
1)It will cause a family problem.
2) Break a perfect sister relationship.
3) Sister Break with long time boyfriend.
4) Me break with my GF.
5) Potentially screw up the future of them.

I am NOT going to tell her even if it burdens me. The aftermath will be far worse than the screw up.

Fuck that, #4 is the only one you really care about otherwise it would not have happened.

Stop trying to come across as a martyr, you're sounding more and more like a hypocrite. Admit you want to cover your ass and be done with it. Your clear conscience drama is not even as immersive as Al Pacino's 88 Minutes.
 
How awesome it would be to have to remind somebody the next day that the two of you had sex. You must be a regular Roger Staubach in the sack.
 
Relix said:
The option that makes more sense is not telling my girlfriend.

Look guys...
1)It will cause a family problem.
2) Break a perfect sister relationship.
3) Sister Break with long time boyfriend.
4) Me break with my GF.
5) Potentially screw up the future of them.

I am NOT going to tell her even if it burdens me. The aftermath will be far worse than the screw up.

The thing is, if she ever finds out (like if her sister gets spiteful), she'll hate you even more for NOT telling her, especially if a lot of time elapses.

I don't see why you'd even bother being in a relationship if you're not interested in being monogamous.

There's nothing wrong with sleeping around as long as it's not under false pretenses.
 
Don't tell her man.. but she deserves better then you. Might be better if you break up with her and give her the its me not you line. Hell you could probably tell her you cheated.. she deserves better... and don't DONT tell her it was with her sister.
then give me her number ;P jk
 
tahrikmili said:
Fuck that, #4 is the only one you really care about otherwise it would not have happened.

Stop trying to come across as a martyr, you're sounding more and more like a hypocrite. Admit you want to cover your ass and be done with it. Your clear conscience drama is not even as immersive as Al Pacino's 88 Minutes.

Wow :lol I seriously meant the other ones too, if you don't believe me I don't frankly give a shit.

Sho_Nuff82 said:
The thing is, if she ever finds out (like if her sister gets spiteful), she'll hate you even more for NOT telling her, especially if a lot of time elapses.

I don't see why you'd even bother being in a relationship if you're not interested in being monogamous.

There's nothing wrong with sleeping around as long as it's not under false pretenses.


I actually wanted to be serious with her, a proper relationship, guess it didn't go that way =/
 
I am NOT going to tell her even if it burdens me. The aftermath will be far worse than the screw up.

Oh god, look at your turning this around like you're a martyr for keeping this a secret. If anyone needed any more proof that you're a total douche...
 
bill0527 said:
wait.. is this the same guy that screwed the bartender like a month ago and then posted her pics at neogaf ?

2 months ago.

I am tired of arguing with some of you guys who only judge, judge and judge. If I am not man enough for her its up to her to decide.
Dr. Strangelove said:
*waits for a new thread to pop up in a month when the OP cheats on his girlfriend yet again*


Won't happen. This is a big enough trauma for me >_<
 
O.O you did this before? Wow man you will probably do it again anyway. Why are you even asking for advice on how to get out of this situation if your just gonna dig yourself back in again later?
 
Relix said:
Now, if she remembers... proceed to next plan: extortion. If she doesn't I can either refresh her mind or keep it that way. My GF? I will not tell her anything...
Mods, please let me post my file on this guy.
 
Having sex with someone behind your partner's back, classy. /sarcasm
Doing so unprotected, even more classy. /sarcasm
This type of behavior puts your partner at risk.

You are playing a game of Russian Roulette, and getting your partner involved (unwillingly) each time you do this type of behavior. Just because it was her sister, doesn't mean she was free from STDs.

It has already been said, but you really aren't mature enough to be in a regular relationship.
Stick to the single lifestyle, and stop jeopardizing your 'girlfriends' life.


Not even going to touch the morality of the fact that you did this with her sister.
 
Zeed said:
Mods, please let me post my file on this guy.

:lol I know what a Whois can do Zeed. BTW, wtf.... you really keep a "file" on users? Jesus you must really have no life at all >_>
 
Do not tell her, leave her if its that much of a burden or if the lil sis is pushing for more of the same. Word of warning if she ever finds out, I would say 50% chance she will, you are screwed and not in a good way.
 
Relix said:
2 months ago.

I am tired of arguing with some of you guys who only judge, judge and judge. If I am not man enough for her its up to her to decide.



Won't happen. This is a big enough trauma for me >_<

Once a cheater, always a cheater. Never fails.

And you have the nerve to claim she's a judge of how much of a man you are but refuse to tell her the truth. Sounds more like you're the real judge of it. Which, I can understand, considering her sister wouldn't even remember you being in her booboo the next day and you apparently need photos of girls to actually persuade them it really happened.
 
Call it quits on the relationship. You don't have to tell her you fucked her sister, but It's obvious you're not ready for a serious relationship yet. On the plus side maybe that bartender chick is available.
 
Sounds to me like you got the best possible result out of this. Don't worry about it, I've hidden much worse in my life. If they don't talk it doesn't matter. As for you, live and learn, and don't let it happen again.
 
You guys know what? Screw it. My GF just called me to pick her up. I am gonna tell her, probably show her this thread.

I fucked up, time to pay the consequences. I am such a fucking idiot. Oh well... time to man up and be single! ILL BRB!
 
pollo said:
AHHAHAHHAAH you believe her.
21al07o.gif
 
l_19fd7ba6ab4b06033d9a4e8e983f8887.jpg


Wow, and you really are an ugly bastard (stole this from your bartender sex thread). He's the dude on the left. This should invigorate GAF, cuz if this guy can get laid then your average GAFfer should be able to as well.
 
Relix said:
:lol I know what a Whois can do Zeed.
And if you think that's all I have, you're free to give me consent to post it all.

BTW, wtf.... you really keep a "file" on users? Jesus you must really have no life at all >_>
The result of approximately ten minutes of searching saved from this exercise in internet panhandling.

EDIT:
Relix said:
You guys know what? Screw it. My GF just called me to pick her up. I am gonna tell her, probably show her this thread.

I fucked up, time to pay the consequences. I am such a fucking idiot. Oh well... time to man up and be single! ILL BRB!
Well that was sudden.
 
I agree with OP.

Why confess something that will hurt people you care about? For your own selfish unburdening of conscience?

It meant nothing, both parties agree it was a mistake, it's better to just move on. No unnecessary stress and drama for the uninvolved parties. You moral highground guys who think otherwise watch too much TV.
 
Relix said:
You guys know what? Screw it. My GF just called me to pick her up. I am gonna tell her, probably show her this thread.

I fucked up, time to pay the consequences. I am such a fucking idiot. Oh well... time to man up and be single! ILL BRB!

Honestly what is the point just end it and say bye bye to the whole family or keep it to yourself.


DO NOT TELL HER.
 
*sniffs air* Smells like sociopath to me!


Or, at the very least, an internet-exhibitionist who likes to brag of his conquests to a group of (mostly) sex-starved guys who will read, fap, fantasize, condemn, or laugh at the posts generated by his exhibitionism.

In any case, the OP wins. This is exactly what he's looking for.
 
I'm going to throw in my two cents, personally I would probably end the relationship, especially since it's only 2 months old and you've cheated twice. I would not let her know it was her sister you fucked though, it will stir so much shit with that family, no need to for it. Just break up with her and if you need to get if off you chest just tell her you cheated, but don't reveal with who.
 
Relix said:
You guys know what? Screw it. My GF just called me to pick her up. I am gonna tell her, probably show her this thread.

I fucked up, time to pay the consequences. I am such a fucking idiot. Oh well... time to man up and be single! ILL BRB!


Don't do it, nothing good will come out of it. The consequence would be to have to live with it. Telling her is the easy way out.
 
Incognito said:
Don't ever admit it. Don't even tell your best friends. If no one knows beside you and the sisterAnd THE INTERNETS, you can paint her as some psychotic creature if she brings it up.

/fixed

But anyways, everyone has already posted the opinions, if you really are going to tell her today, wait until after her gig or recording or whatever she is doing tonight...otherwise your a dick. She is not going to take it well, and the least you can do is let her do her thing without the constant thought of you fucking her sister the whole time, but then you should realy just tell her you cheated on her, your sorry, and you think you should breakup, because you cant live with her and your mistake. I wouldn't say who you cheated on her with though.

BTW.... Gaf delivers again:D
 
wait wait wait

does that means he did that barmaid while he was with his girlfriend too? I swear to god I read somewhere in this thread that he had been with his current girlfriend for the past 4 years.

edit: nevermind, two months
 
Kestastrophe said:
l_19fd7ba6ab4b06033d9a4e8e983f8887.jpg


Wow, and you really are an ugly bastard (stole this from your bartender sex thread). He's the dude on the left. This should invigorate GAF, cuz if this guy can get laid then your average GAFfer should be able to as well.

That is fucking COLD, man! :lol :lol
 
Well your first issue of business is finding out what the chances are of her sister getting pregnant.

Your breaking up with your girl anyway unless she's extremely understanding, but I don't agree with the people in this thread. Its best to just be honest. You like this girl now, but if this thing keeps going by for a while and your further investing feelings into this girl while things get increasingly serious, then your only going to be more heartbroken when eventually the tale breaks.

I wouldn't trust the sister to keep her mouth shut. You know how girls are.
 
Everyone makes mistakes, Relix. The problem is that you don't seem to learn from yours. Obviously the guilt isn't bad enough to get you to mend your ways. If this girl is half as decent as you have described, you do not deserve her. Period.

The problem here is that she doesn't deserve to be hurt by your actions. Also, nobody be fooled, the sister is as guilty as you are in this situation....... and as painful as it will be for your EX, she does deserve to know that she's surrounded by snakes, disguised as loved ones. Hopefully it doesn't destroy her and she can push forward.

Being cheated on is one of the most terrible things someone who is in love can endure, this I know. Time spent in secrecy only makes it worse- personally, I couldn't believe I was so stupid and naieve to not see the (now obvious) signs. It ruins one's trust in humanity..... at least for a while.

She deserves to know the truth. You are young, she is young, and her sister is young. This will leave a scar, on all 3 of you. Another lesson of life learned. Do not forget this one, Relix, and hopefully time can heal everyone involved.
 
Kestastrophe said:
l_19fd7ba6ab4b06033d9a4e8e983f8887.jpg


Wow, and you really are an ugly bastard (stole this from your bartender sex thread). He's the dude on the left. This should invigorate GAF, cuz if this guy can get laid then your average GAFfer should be able to as well.

No fair he works for Goldman Sachs the average gaffer does not earn anywhere near as much I am sure.

Relix: If you must tell do me a favour take a camera and record her reaction.
 
Gabrius said:
Everyone makes mistakes, Relix. The problem is that you don't seem to learn from yours.

After reading the bartender thread and now this, it is apparent to me that Relix doesn't really give a shit about his GF. Otherwise, he would have already known that: Alcohol + Attractive Woman - presence of girlfriend = Pussy Galore. Anyways, she shouldn't be too heartbroken, since you've only been dating 2 months. Speaking of which, what is the amount of time together when one considers the relationship "serious"? I was with my fiance for 6 1/2 years before we finally tied the knot last month.

colinisation said:
No fair he works for Goldman Sachs the average gaffer does not earn anywhere near as much I am sure.

Yeah, I never took materialistic considerations into account.
 
I should make threads every time I get laid as well...seems to always end up 5-6 pages and the OP makes sure everyone knows HES ON GAF BUT HES GETTING LAID TOO!

anyway

tell the gf, break up w/her, your need to be single if your cheating on her twice already, and once w/her sister...end thread
 
Relix said:
You guys know what? Screw it. My GF just called me to pick her up. I am gonna tell her, probably show her this thread.

I fucked up, time to pay the consequences. I am such a fucking idiot. Oh well... time to man up and be single! ILL BRB!
you should have waited until after she did her singing...
 
Relix said:
2 months ago.

I am tired of arguing with some of you guys who only judge, judge and judge. If I am not man enough for her its up to her to decide.

You said you'd been serious for 2 months. You fucked a bartender less than 2 months ago. Which means you've been serious for more like a month and a half and decided to round up. Or you're backpedaling because people called you on it.
One week before that thread, you asked for advice on what to tell a girl you had mistakenly text messaged about wanting to have sex. A simple "Fuck, that was meant as a joke for someone else. Sorry about that." follow-up could have sufficed. The advice you wanted was how to make it sound like you hadn't sent it if it ever came up so you could keep your options open if she ended up being interested.
If you don't want to be judged? Stop creating these threads on GAF every few weeks.

Relix said:
Won't happen. This is a big enough trauma for me >_<

Riiiiight. So you're swearing off drinking since you seem to want blame alcohol and her sister more than man up for your own actions?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom