Support NeoGAF

[Jack Remington]

I've been getting into comics a lot more lately after getting a Marvel Unlimited subscription and finding some good DC stuff. A big part of the appeal comes from the battles. Comics can often give you some pretty great fights.

What are your favorite individual battles in a comic book?

Batman vs Superman in The Dark Knight Returns is pretty high up there and might be the GOAT for me. With that said, it's a pretty easy choice, so I want to list a few dark horse contenders.

The Avengers vs The Black Order in Infinity #6

After reading this issue, I had to sit back for a minute and take it all in. It's most of the Avengers team vs Thanos and his most elite soldiers, who are called The Black Order. These people are not to be fucked with, and this fight has just about everything. Out of context scans don't really do it justice, but here are a few of my favorites:

Iron Man vs Mallen Round 2 in Extremis

This is one of the best choreographed comic battles I've seen, and coming at the end of a pretty awesome story, the battle has a lot of weight.

As I'm just scratching the surface of what comics have to offer, I'm sure there are tons of others that eclipse these (although I think we can all agree that Batman vs Superman is pretty goddamn amazing).

 

[ComputerMKII]

Every fight in Scott Pilgrim

 

[Escape Goat]

Daredevil #49 had a pretty brutal beatdown, verbal and physical, of Bullseye.

 

[bjork]

Scourge vs ~20 scrubs in Captain America #319.

 

[E the Shaggy]

Batman vs. Captain America

 

[Stinkles]

Every fight in Fist of the North Star. But Ken walking through a collapsing building because he didn't give a shit was formative.

 

[BruceLeeRoy]

Its not the most epic fight but I have always loved how Superman is introduced in his fight with Doomsday.

 

[richiek]

Batman vs. Captain America

You left out the best part:

 

[Cpt.Underpants]

Thor vs The God Butcher, you should get this story arc op

 

[Tatsumaki Senpuukyaku!]

Wolverine and sabretooths second fight in mutant massacre

That Alan Davis art

 

[Parallax]

American eagle, the relative unknown putting the boots to bullseye medium style, and overall making the thunderbolts look like chumps after civil war.

 

[E the Shaggy]

You left out the best part:

This fight really was perfect and gave us the definitive answer of who would win.

 

[Mudcrab]

Miracleman vs. Kid Miracleman.

 

[zeemumu]

This fight really was perfect and gave us the definitive answer of who would win.

I'm not sure if "probably" is definitive.

 

[Parallax]

Miracleman vs. Kid Miracleman.

That ending. Fuck.

 

[Ophelion]

The fight between Invincible and Omniman near the beginning of Invincible was one of the most epic beatdowns of all time. I remember thinking at the time that I'd never seen a hero get his shit kicked in that hard without dying before. It's brutal.

Edit:

Miracleman vs. Kid Miracleman.

Also a contender.

 

[Gentleman Jack]

Miracleman vs. Kid Miracleman.

Have more than a few thousand people had the chance to read this yet?

 

[Sambrez_]

Superman vs Doomsday.

But for some reason, I really loved a fight that occured during the 52 after Infinite Crisis. It was between The Guardian and Deathstroke.

 

[massoluk]

This fight really was perfect and gave us the definitive answer of who would win.

huh? That what you get with the word "Conveivable" in the sentence?

 

[Blader]

I'm long overdue for a Miracleman re-read.

 

[Palette Swap]

In recent memory, Avengers World #3 (Hickman/Caselli) has an awesome Shang Chi vs Gorgon fight. It's pretty much the entire issue.

My all time favorite is probably that Orion issue (17 or 18 IIRC) by Walt Simonson dedicated to an Orion vs Darkseid fight.

 

[woodypop]

The post-Civil War beatdown that Thor gave Iron Man was cool.

 

[Escape Goat]

Nothing can stop the Juggernaut except every time he gets stopped.

 

[Mac the KNife]

Spidey v Morlun was pretty memorable.

 

[Jack Remington]

The post-Civil War beatdown that Thor gave Iron Man was cool.

Can you even call this a fight? There wasn't really a "fight" to speak of. Thor with the full power of the Odinforce against an Iron Man who was written as a complete idiot. IIRC, Iron Man launches one completely ineffective attack and then gets brutally dismantled. This one felt like a spite battle.

 

[BeatResetsTheWorld]

huh? That what you get with the word "Conveivable" in the sentence?

You mean you actually took it literally? That was Batman begrudgingly admitting he wouldn't win the fight. Relative to Batman, Cap's stamina is limitless while his very much will run out at some point

 

[.GqueB.]

You left out the best part:

I wonder how Nolan bats would've done...

 

[Poodlestrike]

It lacks the epic scale of a lot of these, but I've always been fond of Jaime Reyes vs. The Reach (pre New 52). For a hero that generally got by on brute force and leaning on the AI in the suit, seeing him go full guile hero was a nice touch.

 

[Dicer]

Not a huge fight per se, just an epic moment...

 

[Sinatar]

Thanos vs. *everybody* in 'The End'.

 

[guek]

Thor vs The God Butcher, you should get this story arc op

+1

This is one of my favorite arcs ever and is pretty new too

 

[Tatsumaki Senpuukyaku!]

Can you even call this a fight? There wasn't really a "fight" to speak of. Thor with the full power of the Odinforce against an Iron Man who was written as a complete idiot. IIRC, Iron Man launches one completely ineffective attack and then gets brutally dismantled. This one felt like a spite battle.

The strangest thing about that fight was that it took place in new orleans two years after hurricane Katrina but it for some reason was still flooded

 

[Wag]

lol

 

[SquiddyCracker]

Marvelman was some cool shit, will there ever be more?

 

[Fuu]

Cosmic Marvel comics have crazy epic shit going on most of the time. One particular battle only showed the involved hugeass entities frozen in place because the brains of humans/lesser beings couldn't process the information.

The scale is usually deliciously ridiculous in general. Transition panels will have a "Meanwhile, a few light years away from there..." blurb like it's nothing.

 

[rbenchley]

Miracleman vs. Kid Miracleman.

Winner winner, chicken dinner. Just an absolutely brutal look at what would happen to ordinary people when superhumans fight, and as someone else pointed out, not many people have had an opportunity to read it, as Miracleman 15 is ridiculously scarce due to Eclipse Comics' warehouse sustaining heavy flood damage. Fortunately, the Marvel reissue is due out next month.

Another candidate would be Thanos vs everyone from the Infinity Gauntlet series. In addition to Thanos tearing through every Marvel cosmic entity, it has a top notch scene where Captain America make a heroic, if futile, stand against Thanos:

 

[Mr. Poolman]

I'm long overdue for a Miracleman re-read.

I came to this thread to post this.

Awesome moment!

Also, Dick Rider vs Annihilus at the end of Annihilation!

 

[bengraven]

Spidey v Morlun was pretty memorable.

Ugh, that last page. My most memorable part of that run, outside of crying Doom.

The one good thing J. did. Saying goodbye to Aunt May on what you believe is your last day. Heart-wrenching.

 

[geomon]

Batman vs. Predator I

 

[MC Safety]

I have a few:

Fantastic Four #12 -- Hulk vs. Thing. This is the first battle between Hulk vs. Thing and it is awesome. It's a two-parter, and done way before Hulk became a mindless brute with almost unlimited strength. It's Lee and Kirby, so it's absolutely brilliant.

Amazing Spider-Man # 270- Firelord comes to Earth for a slice of pizza and gets into a huge brawl with Spider-Man. What works well here is showing exactly how capable and determined Spider-Man is.

Daredevil #181 - Bullseye vs. Electra and then the winner goes on to fight Daredevil.

Defenders #151 and #152 - Manslaughter and the Interloper join the New Defenders for their final battle against Moondragon. This was a wonderful end to a magnificent monthly book.

Daredevil #3 - Daredevil holds off the Sub-Mariner. Almost.

(I'm not sure I got all the issue numbers right.)

 

[rbenchley]

Marvelman was some cool shit, will there ever be more?

Yes! As soon as Marvel is done reprinting the existing material up through issue 24, Neil Gaiman and Mark Buckingham are supposed to finish up The Silver Age storyline that was interrupted by Eclipse's bankruptcy and then Neil will write one more arc called The Dark Age (not sure if Buckingham is doing art for that one as well or if someone else will take over once The Silver Age is done).

 

[super-famicom]

Thor vs The God Butcher, you should get this story arc op

This was all sorts of awesome.

 

[woodypop]

Marvelman was some cool shit, will there ever be more?

The Miracleman annual coming out this month includes new material from Grant Morrison/Joe Quesada and Pete Milligan/Mike Allred.

 

[Tedesco!]

I've always like this one...

 

[Jack Remington]

Also, Dick Rider vs Annihilus at the end of Annihilation!

I just want to be sure I understand you and that this isn't a typo.

Dude's name is Dick Rider?

 

[Parallax]

I just want to be sure I understand you and that this isn't a typo.

Dude's name is Dick Rider?

Richard rider. Dick is a nickname for richard. Like dick grayson.

 

[E the Shaggy]

You mean you actually took it literally? That was Batman begrudgingly admitting he wouldn't win the fight. Relative to Batman, Cap's stamina is limitless while his very much will run out at some point

Yeah this is how I took it.

Batman admitted he would lose while still trying to save face.

 

[Stinkles]

Not a huge fight per se, just an epic moment...

my man.

 

[Jack Remington]

Richard rider. Dick is a nickname for richard. Like dick grayson.

Sure, but you would think a man named Richard with the last name Rider would never, ever go by the nickname of Dick. Because... well, come on.

 

[Mighty Chin]

I have a few:

Fantastic Four #12 -- Hulk vs. Thing. This is the first battle between Hulk vs. Thing and it is awesome. It's a two-parter, and done way before Hulk became a mindless brute with almost unlimited strength. It's Lee and Kirby, so it's absolutely brilliant.

Amazing Spider-Man # 270- Firelord comes to Earth for a slice of pizza and gets into a huge brawl with Spider-Man. What works well here is showing exactly how capable and determined Spider-Man is.

Daredevil #181 - Bullseye vs. Electra and then the winner goes on to fight Daredevil.

Defenders #151 and #152 - Manslaughter and the Interloper join the New Defenders for their final battle against Moondragon. This was a wonderful end to a magnificent monthly book.

Daredevil #3 - Daredevil holds off the Sub-Mariner. Almost.

(I'm not sure I got all the issue numbers right.)

Always loved Thing vs Hulk. Ben knows he's got no shot but does it anyway.