http://i51.tinypic.com/6qzgqq.jpg[IMG]
[B][U]All Star Superman (2011)[/U] Directed by Sam Liu[/B]: Lemme get this out the way, I enjoyed it. The animation was fantastic with a decisively high-end anime fluidity and look to it which actually took a while for me to get used to. In any case, it's a damn fine looking piece of work. The story is also pretty good, and different in terms of what we usually get with Superman in these DC animated films. But there are some factors that held it back...
First of all, I don't know if they're forced by DC, or hesitant because these are "just" animated movies that children will inevitably see or whatever the case may be, but they NEED to make these films longer than 75 minutes. I felt this way a bit with some of the other DC Animated Movies, but this one in particular felt very rushed at multiple points throughout the movie. Even if it was just 15 more minutes to help flesh out some stuff, it would've helped the overall experience so much.
Secondly, the voice acting. Very, very flat. I don't what it was, but there was never a sense of urgency, real anger, or any other emotions from most of the cast. Superman in particular felt so wooden at times. This has never been an issue for me with these DC animated features, especially since they went PG-13, but this one wasn't right IMO. Luthor, and Lois Lane were alright, but I wasn't feeling almost everyone else.
A fan of these DC films will enjoy it, but I don't see anyone putting this over Under The Red Hood, Wonder Woman, Crisis On Two Earths, or even Superman Doomsday (which had terrific action sequences). Here's hoping Green Lantern's next flick, and Year One don't feel as rushed.[/QUOTE]
Just watched this last night, I agree on all accounts. Definitely should've been longer.