• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

My Girlfriend Has Seen Fifty Shades Twice But Hasn't Seen A Single Star War Film :(

Status
Not open for further replies.

diaspora

Member
I was going to show her this and say "See! The internet agrees with me" or something along those lines.

I know you guys are trying to help but I still think is important to me.

Lordy, he's digging his heels in. Star Wars isn't that important to her, it's not important to a lot of people.
 

Cheebo

Banned
Bobby Roberts hosts one of the most popular Star Wars podcast on the internet.

He interviews those from Lucasfilm and various Star Wars celebrities often on said podcast.

He was moderator of the official StarWars.com message board before it got shut down.

He posted in this thread and even he doesn't agree with you.
 

CHEEZMO™

Obsidian fan
I was going to show her this and say "See! The internet agrees with me" or something along those lines.

I know you guys are trying to help but I still think is important to me.

Yeah I'm sure the members of neogaf.com agreeing with you would be just the ticket to convince her
 
I'd also recommend an essay to make sure the themes were fully understood.


so your woman wanted to watch a guilty pleasure softcore woman porn-y film with you and... you declined.

and now you're forcing her to watch a nerdfilm out of pity.

bro

Don't worry, Boba Fett is sure to get her all steamy.
 
Bobby Roberts hosts one of the most popular Star Wars podcast on the internet.

He interviews those from Lucasfilm and various Star Wars celebrities often on said podcast.

He was moderator of the official StarWars.com message board before it got shut down.

He posted in this thread and even he doesn't agree with you.
OP, please start to gain some self-awareness now.

What you're doing was made fun of in an episode How I Met Your Mother. There is literally an episode where the main character goes nuts getting his girlfriend to see Star Wars. You are being a joke.
 
I want qualitative reasons and effects these movies have had on your life. I am honestly curious how a movie can make such a profound singular effect on your life

They helped me escape reality and showed me films are really able to transport you. I love writing because I want people to react and have emotional feelings towards my work. It had the perfect story to me.

Have you forced her to watch all of Kurosawa's films?

She watched one but she wasn't into it. She doesn't like films that are slowly paced and isn't interested in the art of film which is fine. Kurosawa changed my perception of film and got me interested in more films and the international market. Star Wars would be pure joy for her, I'm almost sure of it.
 
Do not edit down Star Wars. Just show her Episode 4. If she likes it, she likes it, if she doesn't, don't make her watch the rest. But whatever you do, do not edit down the movie to show her. You'll be making it worse than better.
 
this is like me trying to get my wife to read the xeelee sequence instead of those 'not porn' romance novels on her kindle, until I realized I benefitted much more from the status quo.
 

xxracerxx

Don't worry, I'll vouch for them.
Maybe OP should show her this thread and get even more pity. Then she will definitely 100% enjoy the films as much as he does, no lie.
 

CHEEZMO™

Obsidian fan
OP seems like the type to force his kid to play some old-ass Mario game from his childhood and get really upset when they'd rather play some facebook game
 

Cheebo

Banned
this is like me trying to get my wife to read the xeelee sequence instead of those 'not porn' romance novels on her kindle, until I realized I benefitted much more from the status quo.
Yep. My wife reads those trashy romantic novels too and I don't throw a fit and force her to read my "real" books.
 

Slayven

Member
CHEEZMO™;153846707 said:
OP seems like the type to force his kid to play some old-ass Mario game from his childhood and get really upset when they'd rather play some facebook game

I remember the guy who was going to edit roms so that his cousins could play the "correct" version of some game.
 
Comparing those two movies is like apples and oranges. As a movie lover and geek, why shouldn't I be upset by this? It's initially two hours of your life! Just watch it and see what happens.

And no, I didn't watch Fifty Shades with her, why would I? Everyone knows it's terrible, even her. She called it a guilty pleasure.

I in no way saw this response coming.

In no way.
 
Missed op-porn-tunity from not watching it with her.

The movie is laughable in spots and intentionally funny in others. It's like a Korean Drama directed by Pedro Almadovar but distilled for the Tween & Soccer Mom market.

The best parts are the passive aggressive e-mails between the two main characters, the actually good cinematography, the soundtrack (seriously this), and the ridiculously PC arguments over consent. Seriously, the whole first movie is the dude trying to get the girl to sign a contract.
The second and third movies are about his previous lovers or people who stalk the main female character trying to kill them, also they get married at some point.
.

The real problem with the movie is that it's not as artsy as other films that are semi-similar and almost as badly acted:
Nymphomaniac, Tie Me Up/Tie Me Down, Blue is the Warmest Color, and so forth.

Let's be honest here, the whole argument that it's unhealthy is kind of moot when Irreversible and Salo exist. The movie isn't even as scandalous as something like The Brown Bunny.


But eh... all relationships require you to give a little sometimes... maybe you should have seen 50 shades with her. It seems rude not to.
 

davepoobond

you can't put a price on sparks
They helped me escape reality and showed me films are really able to transport you. I love writing because I want people to react and have emotional feelings towards my work. It had the perfect story to me.


That's a product of the medium at hand. Choosing Star Wars as your "portal" as it were seems more serendipitous than anything profoundly impactful such as learning life lessons from the writing or the story.

It's fair to get a "love of writing" (really, its a love of storytelling, since we are talking about a movie) with the intent to be able to have people have emotional feelings toward your work, but there's still a disconnect here with the general culture of Star Wars and what you are trying to convey here. Star Wars in tandem with, say, your love of Kurosawa films might make more sense in context, but pushing your girlfriend to watch a movie you are essentially doing it to make her "understand you" rather than having her enjoy a film.

There's something in film you should really take to heart that is said a lot:

"Show, don't tell."

You are essentially telling your girlfriend to love you by watching a movie and loving it rather than showing her actual reasons to love you.
 

Cheebo

Banned
imagine how scarier this would be if it were about his child
You see topics like this on the gaming side of those who seem outright ashamed of kids for preferring to play tablet games over "real" games. Like they joined some kind of satanic cult.


Lesson 101 for everyone. Your significant other and kids are not going to like or be interested in the same things as you.
 
Originally Posted by Kaneda Shotaro
why shouldn't I be upset by this? It's initially two hours of your life! Just watch it and see what happens.

Originally Posted by Kaneda Shotaro
And no, I didn't watch Fifty Shades with her, why would I?

This is what assholes are made of. OP, strike a mutually beneficial deal.
 

Cheebo

Banned
It is crazy how unaware how downright insane he is coming across. He is being told he is acting irrational by hardcore Star Wars fans even.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom