• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Nerd Attack: Are Goku and Superman really that different?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Unidentified said:
There are much stronger than Goku. Even in Dragonball Z there was stronger characters.
There were characters that were stronger than him at some point, but by the end I think he was pretty clearly tops. Well, unless we compare him to a theoretic fusion he could create with someone else, in which case he can never match up to Himself+Extra.
 
Really...why the fuck would they be fighting anyways? These are two of the most genuinely nice characters in existence. Both of them did pretty much everything they could to help the people in their respective universes. I'm not familiar with a lot of Superman storylines but he didn't seem to really hate anyone. The only grudge Goku was a part of was between him and Vegeta (And that was one-sided...Goku wasn't the one that kept that one alive).
 
CrushDance said:
LOL what? Saiyans can breathe in space. Vegeta did it, Nappa did it and I believe Goku did as well before.
Not canon I think, since the only time I remember seeing them breath in space was on a filler anime episode.
 
Prime crotch said:
Yeah I doubt Goku could hold his breath long enough to beat Sups on outter-space.

Goku would only need touch Superman and he could use instantaneous movement to teleport them both to any place of his choosing.

wait wut
 
Prime crotch said:
Not canon I think, since the only time I remember seeing them breath in space was on a filler anime episode.
What about when Freeza destroyed planet Vegeta? The saiyans were in space no?

And Brolly would destroy either of them anyway.
2utt8nd.png
 
I like Superman a lot, I like good old straightforward supers.

But he definitely has no idea how to summon the Spirit Bomb.
 
CrushDance said:
What about when Freeza destroyed planet Vegeta? The saiyans were in space no?

And Brolly would destroy either of them anyway.
2utt8nd.png

No. The saiyans that survived were on ships. I believe Goku was either in transit to Earth or had already arrived; Vegeta and the others were on Frieza's ship our deployed to other planets.

Broly has been pwned so many times. He's the roid freak of the Dragonball universe.
 
CrushDance said:
What about when Freeza destroyed planet Vegeta? The saiyans were in space no?
Spaceships, even Goku used one after Namek blowing up.
Freshmaker said:
Instant transmission. Supes wouldn't be able to keep Goku in space that long.
Kinda hard to do with your arms busy fighting.

This whole thread feels like one big déja vu.
I think we should stick versus threads to characters of the same universe though.
 
CrushDance said:
LOL what? Saiyans can breathe in space. Vegeta did it, Nappa did it and I believe Goku did as well before.

The whole reason Frieza blew up Namek was that he could breath in space while Goku couldn't. He knew he couldn't beat Goku after he became a super saiyan.
 
CrushDance said:
What about when Freeza destroyed planet Vegeta? The saiyans were in space no?
That was the filler anime episode. The guys who did the show decided to do their own story arc while waiting for the manga writers instead of resorting to the typical "expand one page into twenty episodes by having characters grunt and 'charge up' the entire time" method, and that's the Garlic Jr. saga.
 
goku>superman

but thats just me :)

still, live action movie wise....

I am sure without a doubt

superman > dragonball
 
Ye, Superman can. Goku couldn't beat him. Don't make me list all of the shit that modern Superman has survived again. Blowing up a planet is nothing.
 
WickedAngel said:
No. The saiyans that survived were on ships. I believe Goku was either in transit to Earth or had already arrived; Vegeta and the others were on Frieza's ship our deployed to other planets.

Broly has been pwned so many times. He's the roid freak of the Dragonball universe.

Broli survived by using his raw energy to make himself a life bubble to safety.

and Goku could be Superman if you really want to get into the brass tax of things. Goku could directly teleport Superman into hell where his only chance of escaping is to wait for some shitty non-canon arc in GT or the awesome non-canon movie 12.

Prime crotch said:
Kinda hard to do with your arms busy fighting.

Goku can teleport away easily without the use of his arms. Only reason he puts his fingers to his forehead is to concentrate and to find a specific ki. For example, the cell arc had him teleport while using the kamehameha without using his fingers.

man, I remember too much about this series.
 
kIdMuScLe said:
see that thing is, each dragonball z episode constitutes to 1 minute in the real world.
Are you saying that, relative to Goku, Superman is moving at 1/60th of his normal speed?

Goku winner confirmed.
 
BlueTsunami said:
Superman is actually better than Goku since Superman could be considered to always be in a super Sayian state. Ergo, Vis-a-vis, Concordingly


fixed.

Matrix_architectsittingandchatting.gif
 
WickedAngel said:
Broly has been pwned so many times.
What LOL NO. I have seen bits of broly saga in my friends house and i remember vagitas dad didn't want him in this sayan space ship because he was TOO powerful, So he was sent to a planet with these special stones on him which would keep him under control and all the AMV ive seen i remember people had to gank him to actually take him down. I have never seen him get pwned, i bet he got pwned at the end tho
 
Linkzg said:
Broli survived by using his raw energy to make himself a life bubble to safety.

and Goku could be Superman if you really want to get into the brass tax of things. Goku could directly teleport Superman into hell where his only chance of escaping is to wait for some shitty non-canon arc in GT or the awesome non-canon movie 12.



man, I remember too much about this series.
:lol Superman has been to hell. he's fought and defeated demons in Asgard! Darkseid could teleport him directly into hell if he wanted to. But what the hell is hell to a guy who can thrive in the heart of the sun?
 
genjiZERO said:
I'll say it again... Goku is stronger than God... that says a lot

Hell, Kuririn would probably beat Superman in a fight

He's stronger than the DBZ universe God, who is, quite frankly, a wimp.
 
Pureauthor said:
He's stronger than the DBZ universe God, who is, quite frankly, a wimp.

No way he's super strong... and even more so when he re-fuses with Piccolo.

And Goku is stronger than Dai Kaio and the everyone else in the afterlife, and he's stronger than East Kaioshin (who Piccolo wouldn't even fight) and Rou Dai Kaioshin.

Really though it's not fair to compare Goku and Superman's strengths - the limitations of their worlds aren't at all similar.
 
karasu said:
:lol Superman has been to hell. he's fought and defeated demons in Asgard! Darkseid could teleport him directly into hell if he wanted to. But what the hell is hell to a guy who can thrive in the heart of the sun?
He can always hurl an entire galaxy to Goku, if Superboy dragged one pretty sure Sups could do it.
Xabora said:
Ugg, might as well throw a curveball in this.


Goku + Superman FUSION Thingy...


There have fun.

Superman's taller than Goku, it wouldn't work. Unless they used the special earings I guess.
 
Pureauthor said:
He's stronger than the DBZ universe God, who is, quite frankly, a wimp.

Goku wins by:

Superman's death due to lack of sun
Superman's death due to kryptonite taking on the form of a kamehameha energy blast.

Goku is more interesting anyway.
 
genjiZERO said:
No way he's super strong... and even more so when he re-fuses with Piccolo.

And Goku is stronger than Dai Kaio and the everyone else in the afterlife, and he's stronger than East Kaioshin (who Piccolo wouldn't even fight) and Rou Dai Kaioshin.

Really though it's not fair to compare Goku and Superman's strengths - the limitations of their worlds aren't at all similar.

In early issues of JLA, Superman (and the rest of the JLA...wonderwoman, GL, aquaman, etc) took on and defeated the combined forces of heaven, INCLUDING God's most powerful general/angel, which superman took and defeated hand to hand. hell, that guy's strongest attack did absolutely nothing to superman.

He's a good bit more powerful now than he was then in the late 90s. The "more powerful than god" argument isn't going to help goku here.
 
Prime crotch said:
Superman's taller than Goku, it wouldn't work. Unless they used the special earings I guess.

Goku and Vegeta fused without the Potara, and Vegeta is much shorter than Goku.
 
Prime crotch said:
Oh come on, I love both characters and their universes but how can you say that with great titles like All Star Superman?


Character development is more prevalent due to the fact that Goku did 10,000 one fingered hand-stand pushups in 100x gravity.
 
Snaku said:
Goku and Vegeta fused without the Potara, and Vegeta is much shorter than Goku.
Again not canon, it was on a movie and GT. I can't recall if this height rule is true or I'm just remembering wrong though, I'll check the manga when I have the chance.
Solaros said:
Character development is more prevalent due to the fact that Goku did 10,000 one fingered hand-stand pushups in 100x gravity.
Superman had a furry phase. How's that for character development.
 
Solaros said:
Character development is more prevalent due to the fact that Goku did 10,000 one fingered hand-stand pushups in 100x gravity.

100x earth's gravity?

Superman hangs out in the middle of the sun for fun, and can escape the pull of a black hole under his own power.

100x earth's gravity is not even close :lol

I love this stuff. makes me nostalgic for the days when I was really into comics :D
 
Manmademan said:
100x earth's gravity?

Superman hangs out in the middle of the sun for fun, and can escape the pull of a black hole under his own power.

100x earth's gravity is not even close :lol

I love this stuff. makes me nostalgic for the days when I was really into comics :D

That was just in Goku's early days.
 
Solaros said:
That was just in Goku's early days.

Superman's done that stuff all throughout his entire career. The ridiculous stuff superman was pulling off in his pre-crisis days would blow your mind.

sneezing away a galaxy?
time traveling under his own power?
mind control of pretty much everyone via "super hypnotism?" :lol

Superboy prime (who pretty much was precrisis superman, brought into the modern day) was moving entire planets around the galaxy...at lightspeed.
 
Manmademan said:
Superman's done that stuff all throughout his entire career. The ridiculous stuff superman was pulling off in his pre-crisis days would blow your mind.

sneezing away a galaxy?
time traveling under his own power?
mind control of pretty much everyone via "super hypnotism?" :lol

Superboy prime (who pretty much was precrisis superman, brought into the modern day) was moving entire planets around the galaxy...at lightspeed.


Goku > Superman

Besides, if the Japanese write it Goku would probably win; if Americans write it, Superman would probably win.
 
Solaros said:
Goku > Superman

Besides, if the Japanese write it Goku would probably win; if Americans write it, Superman would probably win.
And if gaf writes it we all lose
 
WickedAngel said:
Really...why the fuck would they be fighting anyways? These are two of the most genuinely nice characters in existence. Both of them did pretty much everything they could to help the people in their respective universes. I'm not familiar with a lot of Superman storylines but he didn't seem to really hate anyone. The only grudge Goku was a part of was between him and Vegeta (And that was one-sided...Goku wasn't the one that kept that one alive).

To prove who is the strongest on a GAMEFAQS poll, duh.
 
Prime crotch said:
Again not canon, it was on a movie and GT. I can't recall if this height rule is true or I'm just remembering wrong though, I'll check the manga when I have the chance.

Bu-bu-but Toriyama did sketches of Gogeta! :P
 
CrushDance said:
:lol

Nah. Goku I still probably the strongest character in manga history. Alucard and co just have high dexterity, half of them aren't even that great fighting wise. I'd be strong too if I wasn't afraid of getting hurt badly.

Dark Schienider from bastard is waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay more overpowered than goku.
 
Solaros said:
Besides, if the Japanese write it Goku would probably win; if Americans write it, Superman would probably win.
This is the new Godzilla vs. King Kong. We must get this. I would buy FIVE copies of each version.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom