Serious question- If this thread isn't about Bro culture and jokes then what makes Dudebro any different than Duke Nukem? I'm not trolling, it's just you gotta be consistent. This thread gained so much momentum because Dudebro was a dude that bro's want to be, so by definition you have to embrace the "bro" lifestyle. But now you guys are trying to just make him a parody of the badass/machoman character type with the witty one-liners and women falling at his feet and that's already been done a dozen times over.
You started with something original and now it's just become Duke Nukem with a hat and a beard:
Jocchan keeps saying I'm trolling this thread but for the first 15 pages or so I was totally behind the concept of Dudebro and thought it was hilarious. It's just that as this thread has trudged on you guys have lost focus of the initial appeal of Dudebro. This is a community meme and the only way it's going to stay funny for more than a week is if you let the community shape it. You can either have a game where people go "Oh hey it's that little game some Gaffers made, it's kinda funny" or you can have a game where they go "Holy shit, Natty Ice health packs, that was my idea!".
I see a lot of funny material posted here and I see you guys turning it down because it doesn't match "the creators" image of Dudebro- well, that's fine, you five guys PM or email each other and make your game, but let the rest of NeoGAF have fun with our Dudebro.