• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

The Spoony Experiment

Yeeeaaaaah, when someone points a rifle directly at your face point black, there's not much time for decision. You take the shot.

I think the sheriff's statement is the most apt for this situation: "The guy comes out of a house with all that firepower and gets in a car and points a gun at my deputy. What was he (the deputy) supposed to do?"
 
Still, the taking of a human life, no matter how justified, could be (arguably, should be) something that shakes him up. Hope they both get back on their feet eventually, because he is definitely my favorite comedic reviewer.
 
Sooo. Decided to try the FFX video. Intro has a much thinner version of him hitting everything, because that's what internet guys see themselves as.

Then not even six minutes in and a ton of criticisms about the game (and IX) have been that it's "faggy".

I am really not impressed with this guy.

your loss, pal.
you just missed out on countless hours of painfully unfunny stuff.
 
your loss, pal.
you just missed out on countless hours of painfully unfunny stuff.

To be honest, I would prefer Spoony over 90% of the TGWTG (ThatGuyWithTheGlasses) people by a significant margin. He's hit or miss, but I have to give him credit; he's pretty funny when he gets that hit off (ie, not relying on crossovers, characters, storylines, etc, etc).
 
To be honest, I would prefer Spoony over 90% of the TGWTG (ThatGuyWithTheGlasses) people by a significant margin. He's hit or miss, but I have to give him credit; he's pretty funny when he gets that hit off (ie, not relying on crossovers, characters, storylines, etc, etc).
That's not exactly a high bar to cross...
 
I like alot of Spoony's stuff, but I felt he really started to go downhill when he had that incredibly stupid war with the people that made Deadliest Warrior.

While his content can often be very funny, he's the least likeable amongst his peers, AVGN, TGWTG, etc.

James is really smart, because he VERY rarely comments on new games, and knows not to share any of his views on any current franchises, etc. Just always says, "I'm more into Retro stuff."

While Spoony does the opposite, and it draws attention AWAY from his work by shouting at anyone and everyone that their opinion is wrong on game ____ and it winds up doing a huge disservice to him.
 
In addition, AVGN is smarter in the sense that he tries pretty hard to not let any facet his real life bleed into the AVGN persona.

On the alternative, almost everybody on TGWTG loves doing that, and usually it is for the worse (e.g., including his view on current games, everybody on the internet knowing about Spoony's relationship and clinical depression issues).
 
While Spoony does the opposite, and it draws attention AWAY from his work by shouting at anyone and everyone that their opinion is wrong on game ____ and it winds up doing a huge disservice to him.
I don't follow him on twitter or anything, so I don't really see him arguing, which if it is childish is bad, but I'd rather have him give his opinions on topical movies/games rather than not. Even when I disagree, he usually supports his points well.
 
To be honest, I would prefer Spoony over 90% of the TGWTG (ThatGuyWithTheGlasses) people by a significant margin. He's hit or miss, but I have to give him credit; he's pretty funny when he gets that hit off (ie, not relying on crossovers, characters, storylines, etc, etc).

can't argue; ive a few friends who adore guy with glasses retro shit and my comment was more aimed at that. i watched the FF VIII thing, and it had its funny bits - just, whenever the camera is off the game, 99% of the time it's failing pretty hard for me.
 
Yeah, I skip past all the costumed, overarching storyline stuff. It's just way too cheesy. It's a shame, for all the time he seems to put into those, but I find it unwatchable.

As for what he thinks about Zelda or other games? Why give a crap? Unless he's racist, misogynistic or a homophobe or whatever his opinions outside of any given video I watch are unimportant. I feel like some people want him to 'manage his brand identity' better, or something.

That being said, public whining about your ex is never a good idea. For anyone.
 
I must've missed the videos where he was whining about Scarlett, I didn't even know they broke up. I love Spoony's vids like those about Robowar and Strike Commando and so on.

I like his movie reviews sometimes.

I think I like Brad Jones more now, but I don't care for the horror movies he reviews, which is why I don't really watch Pheleous either. But when he reviews other 80's movies or stuff as 80's dan he's hilarious.
 
Had no idea he was doing so badly. Hope things get better for him.

Personally I have grown tired of his reviews in the style of the FF X ones. For some reason my favorites by him are his VLOGs and his movie reviews. I think when he is just sitting in front of the camera talking he is at his best. Hell, I even love hearing him talk about stuff I have no interest in such as when he unboxed his table top games.
 
The Ultima 8: Pagan review is up.

Yes, Ultima VIII, the point where the mainline Ultima series was pretty much pushed off a cliff. At least until Ultima IX fished it out to push it off again and elbow-drop it to the bottom of the freakin' sea.
 
Lately I enjoy his movie reviews immediately after seeing them with his brother. The casual atmosphere, no production values, just giving their impression.

Of course they're ridiculously spoiler heavy, so it either has to be a movie you've seen or one you're sure you won't be seeing/don't mind having spoiled for you.
 
The Ultima 8: Pagan review is up.

Yes, Ultima VIII, the point where the mainline Ultima series was pretty much pushed off a cliff. At least until Ultima IX fished it out to push it off again and elbow-drop it to the bottom of the freakin' sea.

Wow, new content for a change.

I LOLed when he posted a "Top 10 Spoony Moments in 2011" video. Has he even posted 10 videos in the last year? I'm not counting Vlogs or his re-posting of other people's content.
 
Just now got around to watching the review. Sheesh, this looks like such an incredibly frustrating game. My heart goes out to anyone that played it, looking forward to a really good followup.


The exploding chests bit and the explaining the game isn't satanic to his mom things were great, hahaha.
 
The Ultima 8: Pagan review is up.

Yes, Ultima VIII, the point where the mainline Ultima series was pretty much pushed off a cliff. At least until Ultima IX fished it out to push it off again and elbow-drop it to the bottom of the freakin' sea.
lol
Ultima IX wasn't as bad as VIII.
I enjoyed it after patching it up.
Never finished though.
 
Just now got around to watching the review. Sheesh, this looks like such an incredibly frustrating game. My heart goes out to anyone that played it, looking forward to a really good followup.


The exploding chests bit and the explaining the game isn't satanic to his mom things were great, hahaha.

That was my favorite part too, how he inserted the overblown explosion graphic into the Zelda game.
 
lol
Ultima IX wasn't as bad as VIII..
I think it's actually the other way around.
Pagan had its flaws but it was an amazing game overall.
Ultima XI was a broken, virtually unplayable mess. It used to run like shit for years and to look outrageously outdated when finally the hardware capable of running it decently was available.
 
So glad he is back on the Ultima reviews. Man, I remember shelling out for the voice pack as well for my floppy copy of U8. Never made it past a few hours of that trainwreck, but I was never a big Ultima guy anyway. Never knew the CD-rom patched the jumping as such, that is huge!

Looking forward to his UIX review as the sheer backlash it received at launch was enough to convince me to never touch it.
 
Part 3 of his FFX-2 review is up.

I'm not going to lie, I... actually had the same reaction after the 1000 Words scene.
 
Oh man, hahahahaha, I really liked this episode.

The concert was great, the doves when he gets his guns, and the "you are the sexiest woman I have ever seen!" were incredible. This was so worth the long wait.

Can't wait for the next entry in this series of FF videos. : )


The rambling about Shuyin/Tidus only helped to highlight why I can't get invested into the FF games. I have an even harder time following their story/logic than the MGS games.
 
I've never seen any of this guys stuff before, I'm watching FFVIII review right now, Video 4. I have to say I just about lost my shit at the Mentos moment.
 
The rambling about Shuyin/Tidus only helped to highlight why I can't get invested into the FF games. I have an even harder time following their story/logic than the MGS games.
Post VII Noumura Fantasies tend to do this, with ALL of the games he is involved in (or help produce).
 
I've never seen any of this guys stuff before, I'm watching FFVIII review right now, Video 4. I have to say I just about lost my shit at the Mentos moment.
I don't know how much you care for FMV/old computer games, but I really recommend watching his videos for Ripper and Phantasmagoria 2. They're probably my two favorite things he's done of all his content.
 
His playthrough of Phantasmagoria 2 was amazing and I highly recommend it.

So next is FFXIII, heh?
I think he should do FFXIII-2 now. :lol

Glad to see he's back though.

Part 3 of his FFX-2 review is up.

I'm not going to lie, I... actually had the same reaction after the 1000 Words scene.
Yep. Honestly, the 1000 Words's scene was rather poignant and very well-directed. Actual lip-sync and nice storytelling, indeed.
 
Holy shit, that was a good review, Lol at the lightning bolts in the concert and the power of love plan.

man,SpoonyYuna is just wrong, but yeah the entire Tidus/Shuyin ,dream Zanarkand is super confusing, I don't even think the writers of the games know what the hell is going with that.

So FFXIII next time, this will be sweet since FFXIII (and XIII-2) is full of stupid, Do we know if he got FFXIII-2 already? Anyway I hope for Ultima IX next month/soon,he does all that preparing and Ultima reviews just for it, it should be epic.
 
Awesome review very funny and very well done.
Can't wait for him to get to FFXIII and ow god FFXIII-2 lololol.

Also for future use :)
spoonyslap4mj2z.gif
 
Yesterday, Spoony said on Twitter that two fans in costume were outside of his house. That's... really fucking creepy. Made even worse is that Spoony's brother is a cop, these people can get arrested.
 
Yeah... that's pretty freaking creepy.


What am I watching? This movie looks so dumb, but not in a good way.
Maybe I spoke too soon. Rocket powered panda. I'm back on board.

Excellent!

edit: Wow, what did this movie turn into?
edit2: Don't say Sega CD and not expect me to want more! DO IT, NOAH.
 
Top Bottom