I agree with this thread.
When you think about it critically, how many games from this gen would seriously go on your "of-all-time" list?
For me, I'd say Persona5 and Zelda BotW would both find places in a personal top 50 of all time.
Maybe Horizon ZD, Overwatch and Doom2016 also?
Witcher3 and Bloodborne are both strong candidates on other peoples lists also, sure.
That's not much.