Support NeoGAF

[Trigonometrize.]

OP, have you played FFVII thoroughly? Cloud's outfit is a standard uniform so that's why it might look boring and his sword is... well, not his. Those aspects of his design are a lot more relevant to his character than the design itself.

 

[Meowster]

Fang's entire outfit/design is impeccable. Probably my favorite from the series in some time until (XV late-game spoilers)

Spoiler

Noct's older model.

 

[jiggle]

Fang is the best part of xiii

 

[TDLink]

This is the OG.

Wrong. That was just his sprite in the original game. This is the original boxart:

It's also absolutely the design used in all modern in-game incarnations now.

 

[KingdomHeartsFan]

Like I expected, Zack gets no love

 

[TheGreatDirector]

Wrong. That was just his sprite in the original game. This is the original boxart:

It's also absolutely the design used in all modern in-game incarnations now.

True.

 

[chaosblade]

Best:

Seven looks almost exactly like Lightning with different clothes and dyed hair. Makes 2 and 3 kind of redundant, lol.

 

[Yabberwocky]

How has no one said Lulu

She has a dress made of belts for Christ sake

Yep, I would have loved Lulu's design if it wasn't for the belts. Lulu, Tidus, and Gladio are my least favorite designs. Shuyin is like superior Tidus with an upgrade, his outfit is so much cleaner with a better silhouette.

Fang, Yuna, and Amano!Faris are my favorites for the ladies, and Auron, Cecil, and Balthier for the gents. I also kind of like Snow's outfit, minus the beanie.

I also really like Amano!Celes. It's so hard to pick.

Playing the Zodiac Job System Edition made me realise that making Vaan a monk makes his outfit suddenly work.

Shin guards for brutal kicks, bare chest because he's a fucking monk.

I just went 'huh' out loud. That does actually make sense. I feel like I've had a Vaan epiphany.

 

[MoonsaultSlayer]

Guy's, Old Noctis is not a spoiler.

Not only is he featured in adverisements, but anyone currently playing has seen him straight away and anyone on the fence may be more inclined to play it after seeing him rather than being distraught over it being a "spoiler".

Just post it.

 

[kurahador]

Bad:
1. Vaan - FFXII
2. Tidus - FFX
3. Serah - FFXIII-2

Good:
1. Cloud - FFVII
2. Zidane - FFIX
3. Ramza - FF Tactics

 

[Sami+]

I was bored so I made pics to see if I was sure of mine

The Greats:

The Baddies:

Tbh though Noctis isn't nearly as bad as the other two he's lumped in with. He's eh. Not egregiously awful, but I still don't care about him.

 

[Pachimari]

Like I expected, Zack gets no love

Zack's the best, right after Noctis!

 

[jiggle]

Like I expected, Zack gets no love

Peasant cloud

 

[SolVanderlyn]

Oh shoot, I change my vote to Fighter

I love this design. It looks so cool, it's badass without looking overly frail like most FF protags do. He looks strong despite his glam factor, and has possibly the best hair in the series.

Warrior of Light robbed this man

 

[cackhyena]

How anyone adds Cloud to best designed...I'll never understand.

 

[MoonsaultSlayer]

I'm going to be honest, I prefer Squall's older, military-esque bottoms where they were looser and the leg bottoms were drawn tight more so than the tight and boot cut KH/Dissidia variety.

 

[Razgriz-Specter]

Best:

FF8 Squall

KH1 Squall

KH2 Squall

XIII-2 Lightning

FF8 Rinoa

Worst:
Dissidia Squall

Awful v-neck, awful fur belt, horrendous ass-cape.

Noctis

 

[Strings]

I absolutely love Firion from FF2.

I also really, really dislike Paine from FFX-2. But I pretty much hate that entire game, so...

 

[Fou-Lu]

I just went 'huh' out loud. That does actually make sense. I feel like I've had a Vaan epiphany.

THANK YOU! I've been saying this for over a year and no one listens! We are going to be the best of friends.

Plus you love Amano Faris. I love Amano Faris.

 

[Inuhanyou]

I am probably rare because i don't really find all that many FF designs bad or offensive in general, just those that are overtly stupid(like Yuna's ass shorts, who thought that was a good idea!?).

The rest are just ones you'd usually find in Japanese media, either anime or manga. Maybe you just have to like those kinds of designs in general and are not inherently critical of non pedestrian or non 'normal' designs.

 

[Vincent Alexander]

You know...I'm way less picky than I thought I was because looking through this thread I realize I'm actually pretty okay with most designs posted. There are minor gripes, but nothing huge is jumping out to me with everyone.

I am probably rare because i don't really find all that many FF designs bad or offensive, just those that are overtly stupid(like Yuna's ass shorts, who thought that was a good idea!?).

The rest are just ones you'd usually find in Japanese media, either anime or manga, maybe you just have to like those kinds of designs in general and are not inherently critical of non pedestrian designs.

Glad I'm not the only one.

 

[RDreamer]

Tidus, Zidane, and Selphie are the worst.

Squall, Lightning, and Vivi are best.

 

[WickedLaharl]

Playing FF14 and 15 I really wonder why the designers at SE hate asses so much.

Pancakes... Pancakes for everyone!!

 

[Mattakuevan]

Hmm, I guess my favorites are:

1. Fang - FF13
2. Aphmau - FF11
3. Terra - FF6

For worst...? Hmm..

1. Vaan - FF12
2. Basch (non-armored) - FF12
3. Tidus - FF10

 

[SDBurton]

Seven looks almost exactly like Lightning with different clothes and dyed hair. Makes 2 and 3 kind of redundant, lol.

Not really, and even then they still look better than most. *shrug*

 

[Thoraxes]

Needs more Y'shtola in here.

 

[Anura]

The funny thing about vaan is that he actually looks decent when he just puts a shirt on in tactics a2

 

[renzolama]

Wait, Noctis eventually changes out of his stupid boots and capris getup, right? I will quit playing FFXV right now if you tell me I can never change out of that. That's the big narrative payoff I've been collecting frogs and mushrooms for a week for.

 

[Asiratlan]

About Vaan and Penelo, I think Tactic A2 give them a far better look, mostly for Penelo

 

[PK Gaming]

Best

1)

The perfect showcase of "simple, but great." The blue / gold / white color scheme coupled with his chocobo hairstyle give him a "classic" look.

2)

Yuna's got a great design. From beautiful the pattern on her dress to her heterochromia, you can tell a lot of work was put into this design.

3)

Her outfit is beyond ridiculous, but in a good way. Also one of the prettiest FF characters, hands down. Green hair >>> blond hair.

Worst

1)

Mediocre design, and his abs are absolutely disgusting.

2)

He's a total mess. He looks even worse during FMV cutscenes.

3)

Blegh. What a downgrade

---

Oh yeah, not really a fan of the Nomura renditions. He misses the point on so many of the characters.

 

[RevolverRoden]

Still not sure why "jpop" is used an insult tbh
Noctis is dope. If only he wore pants not capris

 

[daevious]

Tidus has one of the worst designs I've seen in gaming period. Bruh, all they had to do is lengthen his overalls/pants/whatever to reach his shoes and make sure they're even. If they did that one thing he'd look MUCH better.

If you want to make an even better design, take away the chain attached to only ONE side of his clothing.
Why does he only have 1 gauntlet? Wtf.
What is that some sort of shirt shirt but why is it completely designed like-...bruh!!!

Tidus looks like someone who bought a lot of crap from Wish.com and just sewed that shit together.

Dissidia managed to make Tidus look a lot better, even found a way to make his asymmetrical pant-legs work.

A Final Fantasy X remake that changes Tidus' outfit to that is basically my dream Final Fantasy.

 

[Zomba13]

Yup, base your opinion of a character on an adaptation to another game.

Look at it. Just ugly. Tanktop/waistcoat thing with frills, cuffs with no sleeves, pretty much blue jeans. Only thing he has going for him is the monkey tail and Edward Elric hair.

It's just the costume looks worse when not on a super deformed character and really made me look back at how it was in IX and realise it was bad then too.

 

[Lanrutcon]

Can't take any list seriously that doesn't have Tidus at #1 worst. Noctis looks positively normal compared to that clown.

OP failed terribly.

 

[Mattakuevan]

Needs more Y'shtola in here.

Yeah, heavensward Y'shtola is pretty great.

 

[vaporeon]

Wait, Noctis eventually changes out of his stupid boots and capris getup, right? I will quit playing FFXV right now if you tell me I can never change out of that. That's the big narrative payoff I've been collecting frogs and mushrooms for a week for.

There are other outfits, don't worry mate.

 

[Vader1]

3) Cloud Strife - I guess we could start with the hair - it doesn't look good no matter how he is depicted. His outfit is actually really pretty boring and looks like it should be worn by a big warrior, not a thin man-boy. Also, what's up with the ginormous sword? It never really fit his character or design.

I've never played a Final Fantasy game, but Cloud is one of the coolest protagonist designs I've ever seen. The whole point is that his sword doesn't fit. Having a normal sized character wielding the Buster Sword was a great artistic decision in that it dramatically emphasizes the real strength and power of the thing. If the sword "fit," they would have to enlarge the character drastically, ironically decreasing the perceived power of the sword itself.

The long black coat is the sort of thing that could be rocked by anybody who isn't below-average height. And it actually goes better on leaner people, the length of it goes nicely with a "longer" body. His hair completes the look imo, the spiky aggressiveness of it really reflects the nature of the Buster Sword, which needless to say looks like an offensive weapon.

 

[Ishida]

The Best:

Old Noctis.

Squall Leonhart.

Terra Branford:

The Bad:

Luso Clemens:

Vaan:

Lightning (Mostly for being a shameless copy of Cloud):

 

[kurahador]

Look at it. Just ugly. Tanktop/waistcoat thing with frills, cuffs with no sleeves, pretty much blue jeans. Only thing he has going for him is the monkey tail and Edward Elric hair.

It's just the costume looks worse when not on a super deformed character and really made me look back at how it was in IX and realise it was bad then too.

He's a stage actor/thieves. His look oozes character, not just being an outfit.

 

[Zomba13]

Only knock against Heavensward Y'shtola is the booty shorts. Like, there is just a sliver of thigh between the boots and the shorts, why not just fill the gap in? It'd look so much better.

 

[privitsan02]

Best: Terra, Noct, Cloud, Sephiroth, Squall
Worst: the entire XII crew, the entire XIII crew.

Best wishes.

 

[Golnei]

Dissidia managed to make Tidus look a lot better, even found a way to make his asymmetrical pant-legs work.

A Final Fantasy X remake that changes Tidus' outfit to that is basically my dream Final Fantasy.

It was an improvement on the original, but I still preferred his 012 costume.

Hopefully it'll make it into the current Dissidia at some point.

Only knock against Heavensward Y'shtola is the booty shorts. Like, there is just a sliver of thigh between the boots and the shorts, why not just fill the gap in? It'd look so much better.

It'd ruin the entire design. That sliver of thigh is absolutely essential.

 

[cordy]

Dissidia managed to make Tidus look a lot better, even found a way to make his asymmetrical pant-legs work.

A Final Fantasy X remake that changes Tidus' outfit to that is basically my dream Final Fantasy.

It would look better that's for sure.

 

[Sterling's_Gold]

All I know is that FFX and X-2 are the epitome of horrendous character design for Nomura, this series, and for games in general.

1. Lulu has a dress made out of belts. wtf

2. Wakka's hair is ridiculous even by FF standards. How does he get it to stand up like that? What product keeps it like that playing an underwater sport?

3. What exactly is Tidus wearing? Some type of lederhosen? That yellow colored half hoody vest thing is hilarious.

4. Why does Auron keep his arm in a sling? Am I missing something here? Why is he the only person I see in sunny Spira that has obtained sunglasses?

5. I take back what I said about Wakka. Seymour has the worst hair of all time. Also, please tighten the belt on your kimono thing. Nobody wants to see that.

6. As bad as the above are, X-2 takes the cake. Leblanc's outfit is beyond revealing. How much double sided tape is she using?

7. Finally, there is Nooj. This guy has probably the single dumbest design of any character in history. I really don't even know what to say about it.

 

[Instro]

Mostly all downhill after Terra.

 

[RevolverRoden]

Best
King Regis FFXV

I liked his old design but this one is DOPE

Cloud

Sephiroth

I don't really have worst 3. Never thought about it. I guess onion knight from dissidia was lame

 

[butman]

Best

- Squall
- Cecil
- Terra

Worst (Coincidentally the worst FF era)

- Tidus
- Vaan
- Lightning

 

[Concept17]

Cloud is the best. It's easily the most iconic design in the series, and one of the most recognized in gaming in general.

Squall's is completely ruined by his shit personality. Design wise he's good, but holy hell I can't stand that guy.

The worst by far are Vaan and Tidus. There are some other lesser known characters out there, but those two make no sense to me.

I haven't played XV, but I really despise the shirtless jacket guy's design.

 

[tapedeck]

Best:
1. Auron
2. Shadow
3. Cloud

Worst
1. Zidane
2. Squall
3. Tidus

 

[Strings]

I haven't played XV, but I really despise the shirtless jacket guy's design.

Every single instance of Brotherhood Gladio is so much less painful.