• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

underappreciated horror movies

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nappuccino said:
Um... I think this is why people are asking for a good, actually scary movie. They are not exactly a dime a dozen.
`
This genre is 95% cliche and meh. You have to really dig for the good ones.

edit: Exorcist III might be my vote for scariest, even with the crap ending.
 
Despera said:
I trust that you guys know your horror films. So let me ask this...

What is the scariest horror film of all time?

And I'm not talking gore or cheap scares. I'm talking a movie that's genuinely scary.
For me I'd say [REC]
 
icarus-daedelus said:
Were you actually scared by Antichrist and Irreversible, or disturbed? 'Cause there's a huge difference.

Scared, not disturbed. I didn't have a clue what was got going to happen, they scared me in the same way The Shining did. I don't find monsters and ghosts and goblins scary, to me that's more disturbing.

Human horror > Body horror > Supernatural horror imo.
 
Yeah scare is very subjective.
For example i can't, for the life of me, find scary pretty much anything that has to do with the Devil.
Be it the Exorcist or Rosemary's Baby.

I mean as a concept, ofcourse some scenes are scary regardless (like the nun scene in the Exorcist 3) but it really isn't something that stuck with me, while a more religious person may freak out at the random possessed kid.

I think Martyrs and The house of the laughing windows are the two horror films that disturbed me the most, in my life; the former 'cause it's fucking brutal, the latter because i was a kid, like 8 or so, when i first watched it with my brother (who was around 11).
Were you actually scared by Antichrist and Irreversible, or disturbed? 'Cause there's a huge difference.
To me the
mutilation
part wasn't really disturbing; i mean, not more disturbing than something you see in Martyrs, Inside, Frontiers and such,
just because it dealt with genitalia, that wasn't really a factor for me
.
But i found very unsettling all the prior parts (reason why i liked the movie, unlike most of the people here).
 
If it's been mentioned before, I'm sorry.

7oOEt.jpg


bdpOG.jpg


Love this movie, but I love most of Clive Barker's stuff.
 
OuterWorldVoice said:
The Keep.

Michael Mann directing.

Jurgen Prochnow, Ian McKellen, Gabriel Byrne and Scott Glenn.

Nazis. Demons. Angels.


Tangerine Dream soundtrack?


ALL OVER MY PHASE

Oh, you want to watch it right now in HD?

http://movies.netflix.com/WiMovie/The_Keep/70153886?trkid=2361637


ur welcome

It's nowhere near as good as the book and is generally a substandard movie. Come at me bro.
 
sleepaway-camp-3-large.jpg



Clever Kills and just overall great slaser flick.


phantasm4.phantasm4.jpg


Most Phantasm fans don't like this one. I however thought it was good telling of the Tall man's origins. The Tall Man offering Mike lemonade was a classic moment in the series. :lol
 
Well, here are my picks.

JLVB8.jpg


This movie is campy as hell, but it's got Levar Burton, who makes everything fun to watch.
Oz3hJ.jpg
 
BattleMonkey said:
While I enjoyed the series, thought 2 was so much better than 3.

Most fans say this, but I think part 3 is under appreciated in it's own right, which is why I mentioned it.
 
mrmarioman said:
600full-session-9-poster.jpg

If you haven´t seen it you should, there are no monsters, no gore or anything like that in the film, its a psychological horror movie and one of the best Í´ve seen
I second this. It is by far my favorite horror movie. The twist haunted me in a way I never expected.
 
icarus-daedelus said:
I tend to like more grounded/real-world horror better too, but it's usually sickening and disturbing rather than actually scary to me. I just feel sad and sorry for the protags, lol.

And The Shining is totally a ghost movie, dude. A very good one, but still :p

Actually, it could be argued, that Kubrick's Shining isn't a supernatural film at all, but dealing with a psychosis. Although Stephen King's The Shining mini series has worse actors, and as a whole it really can't compete with Kubrick's movie, I like it more as it's more faithful to the original story. I always found Mr. Torrance's road to madness in Kubrick's film odd, as he seems to snap all of a sudden, without any reason. Suddenly he's just standing there with a blank stare in his eyes, when a minute or two ago he was ok. It just feels stupid.

I usually enjoy supernatural horror films far more than "realistic" ones, they just tend to bore me to death. I couldn't care less about slashers and such.
 
Melchiah said:
I always found Mr. Torrance's road to madness in Kubrick's film odd, as he seems to snap all of a sudden, without any reason. Suddenly he's just standing there with a blank stare in his eyes, when a minute or two ago he was ok. It just feels stupid.
Well first of all, it's hinted/discussed enough that Jack already had issues before ever going to the hotel, and second of all, they've already been there a month or two. Also, didn't he already snap out at Wendy before the "blank stare" scene? There's certainly a descent into madness, but it's not shown very explicitly. I don't think it needed to be shown. Besides, I personally already felt a feeling of tension and dread from the start, even during his interview with the owner of the hotel.


Anyway, did you ever end up watching AM1200? I recommended it to you some time ago.
 
Dascu said:
Well first of all, it's hinted/discussed enough that Jack already had issues before ever going to the hotel, and second of all, they've already been there a month or two. Also, didn't he already snap out at Wendy before the "blank stare" scene? There's certainly a descent into madness, but it's not shown very explicitly. I don't think it needed to be shown. Besides, I personally already felt a feeling of tension and dread from the start, even during his interview with the owner of the hotel.


Anyway, did you ever end up watching AM1200? I recommended it to you some time ago.

Well, he was edgy, but there's a long way from edgy to hacking your family to pieces with an axe. I think that part of the story was handled better in the newer version. And I also think, that Nicholson's typical portraying of a madman goes too comical at times. It may fit Batman and such, but it felt out of place in a horror film.

Ah, completely forgot that one. Thanks for reminding me. =)
 
I just watched Triangle (2009) after the recommendations in here...

... That was one big mind f*ck.

In principle, it was a real simple idea, executed in a way, that everyone would be able to follow the unfoldings.

It wasn't a masterpiece and I didn't expect it to be. There wasn't much horror, which I expected though. I don't mind having watched it, Triangle was a solid movie. =)
 
Coxy said:
Threads: This probably isnt underappreciated but some of you might not have heard about it, it's more documentary/drama than horror but a genuinely horrific tale of nuclear war

Everyone should watch this movie. Everyone.

It's kind of lost it's impact with the end of the Cold War, but we were still made to watch it in high school (Scotland.) There are numerous scenes
(obviously the bit with the cat)
that are just shocking, and the classic Zero-Budget Britishness of it just adds to the realistic horror.

The American equivalent - The Day After - is just too much of a "disaster movie" for my liking. Threads on the other hand is unflinchingly realistic. Thank fuck we don't live with the spectre of full nuclear war hanging over us anymore.


Goreomedy said:
Ceme2.jpg


Cemetery Man, aka, Dellamorte Dellamore. Imagine if Pedro Almodovar made a zombie flick.

I genuinely thought I was the only person who knew about this movie. I saw it about ten years ago or so on Channel 4 (UK) and it was incredible.
 
Despera said:
I trust that you guys know your horror films. So let me ask this...

What is the scariest horror film of all time?

And I'm not talking gore or cheap scares. I'm talking a movie that's genuinely scary.

martyrs.
 
Watched Alexandre Aja's Mirrors the other day. So-so movie. Some of the locales are extremely similar to what you'd expect in a Silent Hill game.
 
parrotbeak said:
Well, I guess this qualifies since people told me it sucked. But Insidious scared the crap out of me.

50lfv.png


I think it'll get more recognized later; seems like a lot of people either disliked it or didn't bother seeing it. I think I'll be able to watch it again right now, it would scare me again and I would probably see things I missed.

I just watched this movie last night. The first half was perfect and had a brilliant air of menace. Once they started explaining shit, and once
the dad went into the ghosts' world
it fell apart quickly imo.
 
I've heard "Hardware" is good, but I haven't seen it. Story about post apocalyptic wasteland in which a robot called MARK13 kills and eats humans:

ibvdLVVQq6zwsP.jpg


Mohonky said:
That movie was horrifying in terms oh how bad it was. My mate ans i watched it and agreed it was probably the shittest thing we had ever seen. The goat was lol worthy though.
Ah crap, now I'll have to remember to not listen to anything you say about anything - ever.
 
industrian said:
I just watched this movie last night. The first half was perfect and had a brilliant air of menace. Once they started explaining shit, and once
the dad went into the ghosts' world
it fell apart quickly imo.

That's a problem with most horror movies for me. I like it when there's no rational explanation, just bad stuff happening. Makes it that much creepier for me. Also I think happy endings don't go well with horror movies. That's why I like Drag me to Hell, Insidious or Trick 'r Treat. It's like a happy ending ruins the whole mood a movie has been building...
 
Nymerio said:
That's a problem with most horror movies for me. I like it when there's no rational explanation, just bad stuff happening. Makes it that much creepier for me. Also I think happy endings don't go well with horror movies. That's why I like Drag me to Hell, Insidious or Trick 'r Treat. It's like a happy ending ruins the whole mood a movie has been building...

The problem is that Joe Public don't want to leave a cinema saying "I didn't understand that" so movies like this are plagued with overexplanation in order to be marketable. Human beings are fundamentally afraid of what they don't understand, which makes these kind of movies work so well and the reason why they shouldn't be explained at all.
 
industrian said:
I just watched this movie last night. The first half was perfect and had a brilliant air of menace. Once they started explaining shit, and once
the dad went into the ghosts' world
it fell apart quickly imo.

While I don't like how it was executed I actually enjoy the idea of
astral projection/lucid dreaming it's crazy, because if you lucid dream in real life, it can get really scary in there real quick... it's almost like being caught in a dream with Freddy.

Mohonky said:
That movie was horrifying in terms oh how bad it was. My mate ans i watched it and agreed it was probably the shittest thing we had ever seen. The goat was lol worthy though.

2 things about this. 1 if you really believe this is the worst you've seen then you DEFINITELY haven't seen much. 2. It appears what it was supposed to be went completely over your head.
 
msdstc said:
While I don't like how it was executed I actually enjoy the idea of
astral projection/lucid dreaming it's crazy, because if you lucid dream in real life, it can get really scary in there real quick... it's almost like being caught in a dream with Freddy.

Do you watch The X-Files? There's a brilliant episode called "The Walk."
 
I thought I would drop a recommendation off for this little movie: Scarecrows

scarecrows_title.jpg


I saw this on VHS when I was about 15 or 16 and it scared the bloody shit out of me. Has sort of followed me my entire life since then, it still sometimes pops up when I am alone in the dark.

Well it is on netflix insta-watch so I watched it in the dark today and it still is pretty creepy! I recommend it quite a bit.

scarecrows-1988--630-75.jpg
 
Petrichor said:
poster_triangle-3.jpg


Triangle (2009)

Truly excellent film. The acting is passable at best, but the narrative is so intricate and nuanced that it easily outweighs the sometimes shoddy acting and dialogue. Everyone I show it to falls in love with it and a thirty minute conversation about what actually happened in the film often ensues.

I'm running through a lot of horror movies in this thread and just watched this movie. It's not what I expected at all. Really good movie.
 
Saw. F-ing Saw.

Mention that name to anyone and you are immediately dismissed as a torture porn loving masochistic weird person.

But the first Saw movie is legitimately good and one of the few examples the entire film industry has to something I would actually consider calling a horror movie. (I differentiate horror movies and "Boo!" movies)
 
Ventilaator said:
Saw. F-ing Saw.

Mention that name to anyone and you are immediately dismissed as a torture porn loving masochistic weird person.

But the first Saw movie is legitimately good and one of the few examples the entire film industry has to something I would actually consider calling a horror movie. (I differentiate horror movies and "Boo!" movies)
A good movie that ruined its good name with idiotic sequels(who earned the "torture porn" moniker imo). It also borrowed a lot from Cube and Seven.
 
Cosmic Schwung said:
Anyone else seen this?

R-Point_film_poster.jpg

i
It's been a while but I remember enjoying it.

This movie kicks ass...a war/horror movie. I enjoyed every second of this movie.


Goreomedy said:
Ceme2.jpg


Cemetery Man, aka, Dellamorte Dellamore. Imagine if Pedro Almodovar made a zombie flick.
Ive been wanting to own this movie for the longest time, its next on my netflix, im think about just keeping the dvd.
 
NEOPARADIGM said:
But aside from that, The Mist is one of the worst movies I've ever seen.
No way. It's phenomenal. Incredible to see with a packed theater. It has so much replay value. Anytime it rains I want to pop it in.

But scary is the hardest mood to achieve in film, even more then funny, and most horror movies are far less scary the second time around. One of the most intense film watching experiences recently was El Orfanato, and some said it's not really good horror movie. I stopped looking to horror movies to scare a longtime ago. It doesn't affect my opinion on whether a horror film is good or not.

I'll throw in Clive Barker's Nightbreed.
 
ive mentioned this is the other movie thread but i really enjoyed Yellow Brick Road. One of the more creepy movies ive seen in a while. Just to give perspective on my taste in horror movies i view Session 9 as my all-time favorite.

TqaWS.jpg
 
icarus-daedelus said:
Great. Someone said The Exorcist, which is in my opinion not particularly scary at all and belongs in the overappreciated horror movie bin along with the original Texas Chainsaw Massacre.

Your lack of taste should be a criminal offense. Or is this just a cry for attention?

Love this movie, but I love most of Clive Barker's stuff.

Great flick but its not a horror movie.
 
Just watched "The Signal" ... someone in this thread considered it a horror movie?!

On to Session 9 now.
 
I only like horror movies that aren't gory. Gore for shock value is repulsive to me. I'm glad this thread is here, because there are a few that seem like they're truly suspenseful and scary without gratuitous violence.
 
ReBurn said:
I only like horror movies that aren't gory. Gore for shock value is repulsive to me. I'm glad this thread is here, because there are a few that seem like they're truly suspenseful and scary without gratuitous violence.

do not watch bad taste than so much gore lol but it is funny very funny
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom