only one on your list that i tried to like & failed (fuck the astral plane! - one of the ugliest places i've ever encountered in a video game, & that's where you spend half your time? fuck that!)...
both mgs4 & arkham knight i love. ffvii remake & forbidden west i actively disliked & never really expected to like them. the rest? i never really wanted to like them...
It had potential. I just hate how dumbed down it feels compared to other platinum/character action games. It's locked 30fps for petes sake! Then you have the atrocious gimmick sections which made me think B1s gimmicky parts weren't that bad after all. Stiff level design and movement as well like you can't even jump.
I wouldn't say it's really bad though it's just very mid tbh. It's saving grace is that the combat is still somewhat fun although very weak for a platinum title.
As for the others:
MGS4 - Only the first two acts I found enjoyable. The rest were just poorly designed gimmick sections and the plot gradually gets more and more overconvoluted and stupid with nanomachines basically being magic amongst other thigns.
Arkham Knight - Way too much villain monologuing. Spongey mobs, boring level design, boring gadgets, etc.
FF7R - Less than the sum of it's parts imo. Good gameplay, visuals and OST. I didn't mind the story either I just see it as it's own thing seperate from the original. I didn't like how there was so much filler as they had to bloat the midgar section out into a full game. And then there's lots of cinematic sections like where you're squeezing through rubble.
FW - Just ZD but weaker in every area besides graphics. Even the graphics didn't look that much better, it's only really noticeable in grassy areas and cutscenes and I played on PS5 too.
I think, there should be a cheat to spawn some GTA cars in it 
