• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

What if? Sonic Died? And Shadow Lived?

Shadow really should have stayed dead after SA2.

Also, SA1 > SA2 by a long shot. Even though SA1 still isn't great.

Agreed. SA1 was a much better game outside of the Chao Garden. The fact you're forced to do shitty emerald hunting and shooting before even doing more running stages in SA2 is what ruined the main game for me.
 
Top Comments
should have had car insurance.
ffdgh1 1 hour ago

Third timeline. 
TheArruined 59 minutes ago



Okay, which of you guys posted those? I spit my damn soda on my desk after reading the first one.
 
Man, the series would've been way better. It would've had swearing, gore, boobies, guns, cars, online multiplayer, dlc, and more boobies.
 
Sometimes I regret being a Sonic fan. Fuck the awful fanbase. Fuck SA2 (no matter how good the game is). Fuck Shadow. Fuck Iizuka. Fuck melodramatic stories. Fuck Sega. Fuck fuck fuck FUCK.


i need to go ly dow
I relinquished my association to the words "Sonic fan" ever since they turned the Sonic Cycle from a joke to a freakish reality.
 
It's times like these that make me wish Sonic never had a voice.
 
b8hkt.gif
 
I just sent the video to my roommate, and could hear him cursing me as he watched it. My job for the day is done.
 
I would love to know as well. So many dumb Sonic threads. The OT's start good then evolve into only God knows what.
Generations and CD threads seem to be okay. Though I suppose it's because they're OTs.

The only good non-OT/non-game announcement Sonic thread on GAF is the "what if Sonic ran like an idiot" thread.

Edit: I picked the wrong time to pop into this thread. omg...
 
Reminds me of little big planet for some reason.
KuGsj.gif


Only difference is that the Sonic gif is actually entertaining

I never made it past the beginning tutorial of LBP before I got bored. Jumping physics were shit too.
Yep.

And it doesn't really get much better than the tutorial level in both LBP or LBP2, btw. In fact, come Chapter 4 in LBP2, the game stops being solely a platformer, and the final boss is meh. I look at it more as a tool for creativity and user level design than anything else.
 
Wait a fucking second. Sonic dies?! FFFFFUUUUUUCCCCKKKK!!!

Holy shit! That's a disaster! The worst possible case scenario! That means that if SEGA makes a hedgehog game , it will be COMPLETELY IMPOSSIBLE TO NOT PLAY AS A SHITY FRIEND!!! Truly tied to the bonds of crap forever!

Not to mention that us folk who live in Canada need the blue hedgehog to prevent the polar ice caps from melting!

How the hell does this not have its own huge media campaign yet? That's an apocalyptic scenario!
 
Wait a fucking second. Sonic dies?! FFFFFUUUUUUCCCCKKKK!!!

Holy shit! That's a disaster! The worst possible case scenario! That means that if SEGA makes a hedgehog game , it will be COMPLETELY IMPOSSIBLE TO NOT PLAY AS A SHITY FRIEND!!! Truly tied to the bonds of crap forever!

Not to mention that us folk who live in Canada need the blue hedgehog to prevent the polar ice caps from melting!

How the hell does this not have its own huge media campaign yet? That's an apocalyptic scenario!

That's not funny, he was banned after that
 
This is the plot of my new Sonic erotica. Amy becomes really broken down and in need of emotional support. All of her friends were really Sonic's friends, so when he died she was left alone in the world. Shadow steps in and gives her the emotional support she needs, with his penis.

But Doctor Robotnik won't let her newfound happiness with Shadow last too long. After all, he wants Amy for himself. He's into bestiality.
 
This is the plot of my new Sonic erotica. Amy becomes really broken down and in need of emotional support. All of her friends were really Sonic's friends, so when he died she was left alone in the world. Shadow steps in and gives her the emotional support she needs, with his penis.

Actually all of his shitty friends suffer horrific injuries from the accident that kills Sonic and they have to go to that boarding school for disabled kids.

KATAWA SHOUJO 2: SONICU DESU~
 
Top Bottom