Forza Motorsport peaked at FM4......it was on X360 so it doesnt make it.
Forza Horizon has basically been GOTY nominee every year it comes out.
Gears 5 is so smooth and still counts as a Xbox One game right?
And while its campaign wasnt the best in the series.....Hivebuster very nearly is.
And the MP is top tier, yes there will always be "why doesnt it play like Gears2 or Gears3 critics", but at the same time the game needs to evolve so ofcourse it wont play exactly like Gears 2 or Gears 3. (Hell Gears 2 fans still fight with Gears 3 fans over which one is the better feeling game, IMO Gears 4 and 5 wipes the floor with both)
Halo 5 had amazing multiplayer and even when the community dropped out I could still find matches of the Warzone modes and had a blast.
Yeah the req system could break things, but i still actually really liked it if only for variants and those damn wasps.
Weird community actions also used to pop up with people spawning you wasps or manti just because.