• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Why do women always say they're fat?

Status
Not open for further replies.
L4EfQcA.jpg

All dat food hnnnnggg
 
If a girl ever asks you if she's fat, the correct answer now and forever is "Yes, of course you are". When she inevitably breaks up with you, you'll have more time on GAF. Everyone is a winner.

I actually am a fan of this answer because it throws the whole question out the window and reveals itself for the farce that it is.

Same goes for "how old do I look?" "I dunno.... 67?"
 
Thanks for calling me weak. :) There isn't really an equivalent of this (in terms of looks) for men that I can think of, so yeah, I'm not surprised that you would fail to realize how this ends up happening.

Mind you, it's not just media. When you hear it from not only all the media you consume but people like your mother every day of your life, you start to believe it.

Pretty sure being bald is the equivalent, as much as people like to say "Bald guys are sexy!"
 
Your phrasing came off, to me, as dismissive because of their weight by just calling them "fat" girls. If that wasn't the case then I apologize and retract that. Sorry if I misinterpreted your tone.

Fat girls are fat. Fat guys are fat. If you're overweight you either own it or need to do something about it. Simple as that.

If you're clearly obese and telling everyone you have an average body then you lack confidence and that's doing a bigger disservice than the weight.
 
No, it's not about men handling criticism better. But hey if you want to think us women are just too sensitive and are making a bigger deal out of this than it is, then I don't know what to tell you. But just because you haven't experienced it personally doesn't mean it's not a problem.

Oh honey, I have experienced it. All through high school. Look me up in the acne threads here--spent 6 fucking months on the drug Accutane.

Every single day in high school I went to class with fresh acne on the bottom left corner of my mouth and whole face. I FELT ridiculed, but realized I just didn't have any confidence. Society didn't tell me anything. Because I wanted the acne gone.

I didn't go up to people saying "My skin sucks, do I look presentable?" I accepted the piece of shit looking human I was and fixed it by going to a dermatologist.
 
Compliments go a long way last two girlfriends did this and I figured out how to stop it quick enough. Compliments and good communication.
I asked in serious discussion why she asked me that when I clearly displayed frequently how attractive I thought she was. Making sure not to sound accusing.
then layed it on thick with pointing out that I would mention how good she looks everyday until she believed me.
Was already in habit of doing so as that is how I greet my partners eg good morning gorgeous.
if I get asked again I ask to point out any day that I haven't told her she is beautiful. That I mean what I say now as much as the first day I said it. Both times got a silly expression and followed by realization I'm not lying followed by me being the favorite of the day....week and good times :)
Problem solved from then on. Happy campers all round.
so corny but It works and its nothing I don't actually mean anyway.

of course a healthy intimate relationship with good communication always helps.
 
Fat girls are fat. Fat guys are fat. If you're overweight you either own it or need to do something about it. Simple as that.

If you're clearly obese and telling everyone you have an average body then you lack confidence and that's doing a bigger disservice than the weight.

Not disagreeing with you there. Just giving an explanation as to why some of those women are listing themselves as "average" weight when they may not be.
 
I've only seen this with women.

Don't worry, it's coming for men:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Muscle_dysmorphia
http://jmm.sagepub.com/content/4/3/219.short
http://journals.psychiatryonline.org/article.aspx?Volume=157&page=1297&journalID=13

Book - Body Image: Understanding Body Dissatisfaction in Men, Women and Children
By Sarah Grogan

And the list will go on and on if you want to start looking.

The short answer, as some of the women in this thread have pointed out, are societal definitions of beauty and media representation. And if you pay close attention to marketing and commercials, the field of male beauty products are beginning to be explored and are following the same disastrous hallmarks that plague self image for women. I fully expect these issues to start being an "everybody" problem pretty soon.

Edit: Like this:

I've known plenty of fit guys who say the exact same thing.
 
My girlfriend does and it's ridiculous. She's gained just a little weight since she went on the birth control pill and all the sudden she thinks she's a beluga whale (her words). The only thing I've noticed is that her boobs got a little bigger.

Her clothes probably feel different. It's an awful realization.
 
They are afraid to be fat.

My wife is almost 5'8 and 110-115 lbs (depends on time of the day? lol) and she think she's fat sometimes.

I just tell her that, sure, maybe you are.

She is complaining that she barely fits size 2, and that's US Size 2 lol
 
Since I belong to a mixed social circle of both men and women, women's wardrobes tends to be helluva expensive due to the vast quantity of clothes. For the self proclaimed 'fat' women, it may be more difficult to find the desired clothing their size and plus/women's size clothing tends to be more expensive.

Also Body Dysphoria runs deep in Western/developed culture. If someone fishes for compliments, there is sadly a self confidence issue. :(
 
lol I wasn't trying to go all Men's Rights or anything-I guess I was thinking that it's not just Patriarchy, it's dominance.

edit: I'm not trying to downplay the impact of patriarchy

Oh, I know, lol.

I don't mean to seem condescending - I'm in an odd sort of mood :P
 
I've known plenty of fit guys who say the exact same thing.

I say it all the time and I know I'm actually fairly fit. I just say it because I don't have abs yet, and that's the standard I hold myself to. Not sure if I hold that standard because of magazines, but it just feels really good to be fit. Feels a lot better than eating chips and soda, certainly.
 
Since I belong to a mixed social circle of both men and women, women's wardrobes tends to be helluva expensive due to the vast quantity of clothes. For the self proclaimed 'fat' women, it may be more difficult to find the desired clothing their size and plus/women's size clothing tends to be more expensive.

Well it's not just the price (I haven't noticed any just below plus), but clothes are generally designed with smaller frames in mind, so when someone larger wears them, they tend to not look right.
 
Since I belong to a mixed social circle of both men and women, women's wardrobes tends to be helluva expensive due to the vast quantity of clothes. For the self proclaimed 'fat' women, it may be more difficult to find the desired clothing their size and plus/women's size clothing tends to be more expensive.

Also Body Dysphoria runs deep in Western/developed culture. If someone fishes for compliments, there is sadly a self confidence issue. :(
on the flip side, women also have a lot more options than dudes at every level of the market. You can dress pretty fashionably hitting up target x whoever lines. not so much for guys.
 
When my wife asks it's more like she's asking if there's anything she's missed or if the outfit doesn't go together. She chose to wear it so she obviously thinks it looks decent but wants some reassurance. She never says "Do I look fat?" but will say " Does this look ok?" Basically I'm letting her know her undies aren't hanging out, the label on her top isn't poking up at the neck and there's no cat fur clumped somewhere unseen or she looks like one of the Golden Girls. She knows I won't bullshit her as well.


You're fucking fat if you eat rice from microwaveable dinners off the carpet with no hands and you are disgusting and smell like deli meats.

This is a bizzare thing to say.
 
Well it's not just the price (I haven't noticed any just below plus), but clothes are generally designed with smaller frames in mind, so when someone larger wears them, they tend to not look right.

Oh yeah, I can definately understand that. My good friend is a shorter person with a larger bust and she has a hard time finding clothes that fit her so she gets some clothes that match her bust but baggy in the waist area. She looks great in her clothes but I can see where she and other people coming from.
 
I personally like the fatties, no joke. I joined lovethesecurves in hopes of finding a chubby girl, no luck. The thing about bbws is that they are either super fat and use that to date/take advantage of bbw admirers, or they are chubby and if you say "I think you look stunning, just the way you are." they don't believe you, and start fighting.

Big tits, big ass, chub in the middle, and a round face....mmmmmmmmmm
 
I personally like the fatties, no joke. I joined lovethesecurves in hopes of finding a chubby girl, no luck. The thing about bbws is that they are either super fat and use that to date/take advantage of bbw admirers, or they are chubby and if you say "I think you look stunning, just the way you are." they don't believe you, and start fighting.

Big tits, big ass, chub in the middle, and a round face....mmmmmmmmmm
this will sound terrible but

seriously








go to urban/hip hop clubs
 
I personally like the fatties, no joke. I joined lovethesecurves in hopes of finding a chubby girl, no luck. The thing about bbws is that they are either super fat and use that to date/take advantage of bbw admirers, or they are chubby and if you say "I think you look stunning, just the way you are." they don't believe you, and start fighting.

Big tits, big ass, chub in the middle, and a round face....mmmmmmmmmm

Damn, now I wanna bone a BBW.
 
if you're in america, there's a 64% chance that they are. but then there's a 70% chance you are too, so i don't know why they're asking your flabby ass. go walk the dog, porkstuff.
 
Also Body Dysphoria runs deep in Western/developed culture. If someone fishes for compliments, there is sadly a self confidence issue. :(

^I have to say I agree that's it's mostly this. Maybe some women are fishing for compliments, but feeling insecure about your body regardless of weight or shape or size is very, very common.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom