• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Why is film snobbery so openly tolerated?

Status
Not open for further replies.
GAF has moulded me into a kinda film snob.

And I don't regret it... Well, maybe a little bit. It's harder to enjoy comic book movies now and I find myself longing for a slow paced Doctor Strange film that doesn't have large action sequences.

Send help.
 
Worse. He's a marvel fan boy.
What's sad is I know you actually think being a marvel fan is a diss. That's truly pathetic, and goes to show how small minded you really are. I mean, fuck, you're posting on neogaf and have a star wars avatar.
 
GAF has moulded me into a kinda film snob.

And I don't regret it... Well, maybe a little bit. It's harder to enjoy comic book movies now and I find myself longing for a slow paced Doctor Strange film that doesn't have large action sequences.

Send help.

You're on the right path. Don't let the plebs tell you otherwise.
 
Who doesn't like all three of those movies?
I've seen plenty of people talk shit about Forrest Gump.
You're on the right path. Don't let the plebs tell you otherwise.
But I was living the dream! Comic movies as far as the eye can see... and now I don't know if I want them to keep coming at such a fast rate post-Infinity War.

I just hope Phase 3 is really good and different from previous stuff save Guardians and Cap 2.
 
Spoken like a true plebian that only watches trite marvel comic-book fluff because you can't appreciate what real cinema looks, feels, and sounds like. I'd recommend Interstellar, it's only the greatest cinematic work of the 21st century made by the greatest auteur of the 21st century.

You should have picked a better example, there is a strong anti-Nolan group on GAF that feels everything he does is faux-intellectual/cinematic. You should have used something like "Tree of Life," if you aren't a Terrence Malik fan then you are a plebian who enjoys eating popcorn off the dirty floor with the rest of the Marvel nerds and Nolan fans.
 
You should have picked a better example, there is a strong anti-Nolan group on GAF that feels everything he does is faux-intellectual/cinematic. You should have used something like "Tree of Life," if you aren't a Terrence Malik fan then you are a plebian who enjoys eating popcorn off the dirty floor with the rest of the Marvel nerds and Nolan fans.

I still wanna see what it would've been like if Terrence Malik directed Man of Steel.
 

JmkG2kz.gif
 
More common on GAF than the real world? Every single person I know that watches movies will shit talk what they don't like.

Snobbery is the result of discovering your own taste. Considering how many people watch movies there's a ton of movie snobs.

Pretty much, there are "snobs" for pretty much every film, book and music genre out there.

Some people only watch big budget film and still hate Micheal Bay at the end of the day.

I don't see how loving something critically acclaimed is any worse.
 
I think snobbery is pretty important when it comes to art. Most people don't know what's good from a creative standpoint, and if snobs didn't exist, we'd only pay attention to works that appeal to basic interests.

Snobs are the reason why Birdman was discussed as much as Transformers 4.
 
What I find more annoying is people who demand those who dislike something to thoroughly explain themselves (as if short quick post aren't cool or allowed), but don't do the same for those who do like what they like even if their posts are just as empty.
 
Condescension and open conceit feels like the norm on GAF...

Or am I wrong altogether and people tend to be snobs about everything all the time?

I don't know that you're necessarily wrong, but it seems like that opener is an admission that you recognize there are a lot of users (not just GAF, but any form of social media) who tend to approach any possibility of disagreement with - if not outright hostility - a general defensiveness that assumes someone absolutely wants to fight you at all times.

Condescension is just one of the pre-emptive defensive moves people employ without really thinking about it, or why they're doing it. But if they can put on the front like "it's not really even worth your time to try fighting me on this because it's fairly obvious I'm like, a hundred times smarter than you on this subject" to dissuade that fight, they'll do it.

It's all a matter of the mindset with which you enter into any bullshit session: Are you looking to share opinions/ideas, even if you disagree with them? Or are you looking for someone to be wrong about something so you can cave their shins in?

I like learning shit I didn't know before I opened my fat mouth, personally. I can do without people being rampant assmouths about it, (and I could do better about the shit dripping from my own tongue, really) but if I find a "film snob" on this forum, I tend to pay attention, because it's possible I'm about to learn some shit I didn't know before.

It's happened more often than it hasn't.

What I find more annoying is people who demand those who dislike something to thoroughly explain themselves

Yeah, that one's weird.

"Why do people like this movie I didn't like as much as a bunch of people who obviously love the living fuck out of it?"

It's like general consensus doesn't exist for some people, isn't a researchable, understandable thing, unless it comes out of a thread they started. There isn't an easily findable, thoroughly explained set of answers just waiting to be read, until they themselves think to ask the question.

Of course, usually they don't really give the smallest fuck about any of those answers, because the real purpose of asking that question is to make sure people understand how sharp the edges on their precious, individual snowflake really are.
 
Honestly I get the feeling that there are a lot of fans that can't separate personal enjoyment from quality. If you want to watch captain iron avenger or whatever then fine, but the pretension that these films, for example, are the greatest movies by any metric other than sales is absolutely silly.
 
I think snobbery is pretty important when it comes to art. Most people don't know what's good from a creative standpoint, and if snobs didn't exist, we'd only pay attention to works that appeal to basic interests.

Snobs are the reason why Birdman was discussed as much as Transformers 4.

But they're both shitty movies, one just realizes it.
 
No I am the guy making fun of you with the rest of the coworkers and taking bets on how long it takes you to bring up "religion is stupid" again.

Oh, you must have me mistaken for someone else.

But since you are clearly catching feelings, I'll explain it to the cheap seats. My comment presented an example of an even more extreme level of snobbery that that of mere film taste. The example is more common and there is general acceptance of it. In comparison, having ones taste in art mocked is small potatoes.
 
I make it a personal goal not to shit on something unless it really really warrants it. I rather celebrate the shit I love.
 
What I find more annoying is people who demand those who dislike something to thoroughly explain themselves (as if short quick post aren't cool or allowed), but don't do the same for those who do like what they like even if their posts are just as empty.
giphy.gif

Snobbery is the reason why the Oscars exist.

It ain't called "the Academy" for nothing.
Which is funny because the Academy is usually full of shit.
 
I can't stand it. It's especially suffocating in the Movie Thread.

If I'm more experienced in a field than someone else, I use the opportunity to share what I love with them. Being a jerk about it is just.. pointless. I wouldn't judge someone over their favorite movie or what movies they hate or how they'd enjoy them. I'm just happy about sharing perspectives!

And if they're uninterested, that's okay too! People don't exist to be educated on a subjective view of what good taste is.
 
What's sad is I know you actually think being a marvel fan is a diss. That's truly pathetic, and goes to show how small minded you really are. I mean, fuck, you're posting on neogaf and have a star wars avatar.

Insecure: The Post

I've seen plenty of people talk shit about Forrest Gump.

But I was living the dream! Comic movies as far as the eye can see... and now I don't know if I want them to keep coming at such a fast rate post-Infinity War.

I just hope Phase 3 is really good and different from previous stuff save Guardians and Cap 2.

Nothing wrong with liking the high and lows of a medium. I enjoy crap all the time. Like I watched 70's Godard and enjoyed some of them. In the end just like what you like.
 
what's wrong with snobbery in terms of artistic endeavor? if anything, film should have clear lines dividing low and high, especially considering the numerous technological revolutions (3d, frame rates, computer imaging) the art form has found. there's a pretty big gulf between a cohesive, original work like avatar and derivative, cynically produced films like furious 7 or all those superhero movies. of course some films somewhat straddle the line, like mad max.
 
But they're both shitty movies, one just realizes it.

I don't think Birdman is shitty, but it definitely got more praise than it deserved. In a world without any snobbery, nobody would have heard of it.

This goes for music, literature, food, television... We need snobs to give artistically profound work the attention they deserve! If not for film snobs, I would have never seen Aguirre, Man With a Movie Camera, Once Upon a Time in America, Amelie, Touch of Evil, etc...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom