• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Manga News/Discussion |OTY| Creatively Bankrupt

Status
Not open for further replies.

360pages

Member
One hell of a ride, wasn't it?

Aiko was poisonous but Punpun also had some hand in that with how he saw her up as the idol of reprieve from either droll monotony or all the trauma he had amassed by the time they really got a shot together. Aiko's death left a very weakened Punpun behind however and were it not for Sachi finding him, he'd probably have died in a manner far darker than his "Goodnight Punpun" attempt.

Yeah, the series made me think a lot more I guess. Actually a big part of the series is how we see others and how others see us. Punpun himself is the poster child for this. Though it is super messed up what his aunt did, combined with his troubles it was going to happen. Aiko herself isn't a bad person at all, she is a person, nothing less nothing more.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
[QUOTE="God's Beard!";151358948]Why would Viz need an official stance on scanlators? Scanlation is stealing, pretty simple.[/QUOTE]

I mean....yeah.

Just pay for it if you have the opportunity guys.
 

Lain

Member
Just saw this interview with Toshio Maeda released by the Italian manga site I check.
I'm posting it here because, while it is done by Italian people and as such they talk in Italian, Toshio Maeda answers in English and the questions are also given to him in English, so those of you that might be interested in what he has to say can follow it.
 
Quick, I need a panel from Punpun to convince someone to start reading it!

7seedssdu32.png
 

Rhapsody

Banned
What could Japan do to globalize anime and manga digitally?



Zweizer, the trend setter MangaGaf needs and deserves.

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=151087475&postcount=813

Oh, good job Zweizer lol. That's one way to get people interested.

I just realized that I need to start on Solanin. I ended up reading A Girl by the Sea instead which I didn't like too much. The scale of it wasn't that large, which is fine, but the ending to that manga was really weird.


Edit: Nice save on editing the watermark lol
 
Punpun and Taiyou no Ie are the longest ones, at around a dozen volumes each:

  • Goodnight Punpun: The life and times of a protagonist depicted as a poorly drawn bird...
  • Tasogare Otome x Amnesia: The story of a ghost haunting the grounds of an academy, and how the legends surrounding her came to be.
  • Taiyou no Ie: A house that used to be filled with love breaks apart. Now, several years later, how will its inhabitants mend its wounds? Still ongoing, but ends the next chapter.
  • Once Again: A short story about how a work-obsessed man rekindles his inner flame after the death of his wife.
  • Endo Hiroki Tanpenshuu: Small collection of short stories with a pretty big focus on human emotions and nature.
  • Kanojo wa Sore o Gaman Dekinai: Dogsuit smut.
  • Uwagaki: Following his rejection, the protagonist has to seduce the (very much literal) clone of his crush.

Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun (long, but amazing)
Vahlia no Hanamuko (4 oneshots, first one is the best)
Nemuru Machi no Futari (oneshot)
Strong Chase Weak Animato (oneshot)
Hanseishite Kameda-kun (oneshot)
Boku no Kotori-san (oneshot)
Petite Peche (2 chapters)
Yotteke! Otoko Mura (4 chapters)
Hakamori Majo Bianca (5 chapters)
Kami-sama ga Uso o Tsuku. (5 or 6 chapters)
Shinonome Yuuko wa Tanpen Shousetsu o Aishite Iru (11 chapters, based on a LN)
Ootagawa Junjou Lovers (4 chapters + a oneshot)
Atashi no Banbi (3 chapters, same author as above)
Sugars (compilation of oneshots, first volume isn't as great as the other)
Okobore Hime to Entaku no Kishi (based on a LN, I think 10ish chapters?)
Vivid Cherry (4 chapters)
Junjou Drop (4 chapters)


I don't know what you've already read but here's a few.

Bonnouji
Itoshi no Kana
Game Over (Mizutani Fuka)
Ane Doki
Sayonara Piano Sonata
Hatsukoi Limited
Henkoi!
Prunus Girl
Suki mo Yoi

These are all 4 volumes or less, execpt maybe Prunus Girl but I don't remember how long that was.

Thanks for these suggestions guys! This should keep me busy for a while.

I've read Tonari no Kaibutsu-kun (loved it) and following Horimiya and Taiyou no Ie. I'll start with the one shots and work my way up.
 
Boku no Hero Academia 28-29

Class B will rise!

Boku no Hero Academia 00

Wow, that was pretty bad. What an amazing transformation into the current thing.
 

BatDan

Bane? Get them on board, I'll call it in.
That failed...everyone just wanted to talk about Persona....

Anyway, I should start One Piece, or Hero's Academia

My Hero Academia is only 29 chapters now, much shorter. You'll get it done in a weekend and be caught up.
Buuuut you should still read One Piece.
 

Rhapsody

Banned
Had no idea that JJBA was getting hardcover releases in the US with color pages.

First one comes out this month. Might end up buying it if it's actually nice.
 
Minamoto-kun Monogatari 68 - 98
Third girl's definitely been easiest target for Terumi so far. Still liked Aoi more than Hanada, and I almost thought somehow the girl from Terumi's middle school would be third girl, but it wasn't. Only there for Terumi to deal with his trauma from back then.

Looking forward to seeing the fourth girl in action.
 

kewlmyc

Member
Oyasumi Punpun 11-67


No one told me this would be depressing as all hell. I had to give up for the night when
his freaking mom died of cancer.
This is one of the best and most emotional growing up stories I've read in a manga which is odd considering the protagonist and his family. Thanks for telling me about this series MangaGAF.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Trying to lead the people in the hilarious Terra Formars live-action thread onto the path of holiness, yes the path of Aunt Tits!

I'm not even joking when I suggest not mentioning "aunt tits" anywhere that isn't this thread. I couldn't stop you guys from mentioning it in here constnatly, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if you get banned if you try and convince people in OT proper to read a softcore porn rag about a dude sucking his blood related aunt's tits.
 
Drifters Vol.02

B5t7Q0Ml.jpg


Toyohisa is really such a great protagonist. Hell, Nobunaga and Yoichi are great too. I'm really liking the mix of great and bloody action scenes and silly comedy scenes and how they easily shift from one to the other.

Nice to see more historical characters appear. It's pretty interesting to see all of them so far are their correct genders!
 
I'm not even joking when I suggest not mentioning "aunt tits" anywhere that isn't this thread. I couldn't stop you guys from mentioning it in here constnatly, but I wouldn't be surprised at all if you get banned if you try and convince people in OT proper to read a softcore porn rag about a dude sucking his blood related aunt's tits.

It would also be nice if Aunt Tits was actually googleable without getting an eyeful of "HOT BIG BOOBS AUNT JERKS NEPHEW".

This is the ONLY place on the internet that actually calls it Aunt Tits.
 

kasane

Member
It would also be nice if Aunt Tits was actually googleable without getting an eyeful of "HOT BIG BOOBS AUNT JERKS NEPHEW".

This is the ONLY place on the internet that actually calls it Aunt Tits.

yeah we should call it

the manga on how to pick up girls based on a historical standpoint.

that said i googled aunt tits and lmao
 

360pages

Member
Oyasumi Punpun 11-67



No one told me this would be depressing as all hell. I had to give up for the night when
his freaking mom died of cancer.
This is one of the best and most emotional growing up stories I've read in a manga which is odd considering the protagonist and his family. Thanks for telling me about this series MangaGAF.

If you think that's depressing It gets
worse
 

Laughing Banana

Weeping Pickle
Damn, Terra Formars got pounded hard on that off-topic thread.

Didn't realize it's such a hated piece of work. I find it entertaining to read.
 
Damn, Terra Formars got pounded hard on that off-topic thread.

Didn't realize it's such a hated piece of work. I find it entertaining to read.

It doesn't really make a good first impression.

Personally I still think the cockroach designs are more based on Neanderthal or Cromagnon but there's no way I'm going to defend it. Same with the "perfect human being" and Chinese shit.
I also recall there are two German members named Adolf and Eva which is just silly

I don't really know why I'm even still reading it, I can only remember one character's name (Michelle) which is bad even for me and I don't actually think it's all that enjoyable. It's just habit I guess, it doesn't really take long to read an entire volume when one comes out.
 

Laughing Banana

Weeping Pickle
It doesn't really make a good first impression.

Personally I still think the cockroach designs are more based on Neanderthal or Cromagnon but there's no way I'm going to defend it. Same with the "perfect human being" and Chinese shit.
I also recall there are two German members named Adolf and Eva which is just silly

I don't really know why I'm even still reading it, I can only remember one character's name (Michelle) which is bad even for me and I don't actually think it's all that enjoyable. It's just habit I guess, it doesn't really take long to read an entire volume when one comes out.

Hahaha well, I suppose I am just a sucker for a manga with high body-count, where the main guy's girlfriend got killed right at the 1st chapter. That shit was crazy.

It's more entertaining to me than Gantz, so far. At least in TF we don't get tears and TAE-CHAN every 5 seconds.
 
It's kinda entertaining in a SyFy schlocky way but I really have no idea how it got so popular

In any case it's something that will probably never catch on here, when the anime was starting up people were saying it would be the next Attack on Titan and that didn't happen.

The next Attack on Titan will probably be something like Seraph of the End


I'm almost caught up to Aunt Tits, how long is this going to be? 150 chapters and Terumi hasn't really conquered any of the girls (is he going to cycle back, or only for the cousin?) and it's only half way through, if some of the other girls like the middle school bully, the artist and the Aunt aren't going to count which I don't really believe. I guess I could just look up the Genji Monogatari but that'd spoil the fun, I already know a lot about Kingdom's overarching plot from that sort of thing.
 

Tacitus_

Member
It doesn't really make a good first impression.

Personally I still think the cockroach designs are more based on Neanderthal or Cromagnon but there's no way I'm going to defend it. Same with the "perfect human being" and Chinese shit.
I also recall there are two German members named Adolf and Eva which is just silly

I don't really know why I'm even still reading it, I can only remember one character's name (Michelle) which is bad even for me and I don't actually think it's all that enjoyable. It's just habit I guess, it doesn't really take long to read an entire volume when one comes out.

I usually shrug off OTs "they're racists" schlock since they tend to view everything through USA coloured lenses, but...

C6zlx.jpg


That's just too blatant, :lol
 

kasane

Member
hey i find seraph better than aot

aot's core is basically

all these shouting

all these ' intense ' fights

muh mysterious titans

that manga is shit shiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiit
 
It doesn't really make a good first impression.

Personally I still think the cockroach designs are more based on Neanderthal or Cromagnon but there's no way I'm going to defend it. Same with the "perfect human being" and Chinese shit.
I also recall there are two German members named Adolf and Eva which is just silly

I don't really know why I'm even still reading it, I can only remember one character's name (Michelle) which is bad even for me and I don't actually think it's all that enjoyable. It's just habit I guess, it doesn't really take long to read an entire volume when one comes out.

I just like the non-roach character designs, the creative abilities and the fights. There's some actual good choreography and damn good power explanations, which I've always been a sucker for. Utilizing bugs when determining that stuff is such a cool concept.

Also why Arachnid is totally boss.
 

Shengar

Member
Soma 103-105
This arc wrapped better than I expected, it's nice to see how the author handled the rivalry of the trio :D
Also new arc does will look fun. Adding a familiar yet not well known character seems to hyped me the most.
But, why does every customer from that restaurant bring case and bags? lol
 
Oukoku Game 01-16

Supernatural death game between high school students. Each group of seven forms a Kingdom with three roles: one King, three Aristocrats, three Plebeians, with each being able to completely order around those of a lower standing. Roles are randomized every midnight, and the dynamics between each kingdom, at least internally, is chaotic, as expected. A lot of what happens is pretty interesting, albeit somewhat predictable. Character dynamics play a big role in this, as all the protagonists don't really see eye-to-eye, and it muddles even more when they have to deal with other kingdoms. I'm looking forward to seeing where it goes in later chapters.
 
It's kinda entertaining in a SyFy schlocky way but I really have no idea how it got so popular

In any case it's something that will probably never catch on here, when the anime was starting up people were saying it would be the next Attack on Titan and that didn't happen.

The next Attack on Titan will probably be something like Seraph of the End


I'm almost caught up to Aunt Tits, how long is this going to be? 150 chapters and Terumi hasn't really conquered any of the girls (is he going to cycle back, or only for the cousin?) and it's only half way through, if some of the other girls like the middle school bully, the artist and the Aunt aren't going to count which I don't really believe. I guess I could just look up the Genji Monogatari but that'd spoil the fun, I already know a lot about Kingdom's overarching plot from that sort of thing.

But Seraph of the End is so generic, like I couldn't get past the first few chapters. At least Attack on Titain's premise and begining was actually great, but Seraph of the End is like combining all the cliches you can think of in one whole thing. It's pretty mediocre and the only thing good about it is the art.

Man if this series gets as popular as Attack on Titan the world is truly dead. 😌
 

bigkrev

Member
Boku no Hero Academia 1-15

Figured it's getting close to a "now or never" in terms of chapter count, so I decided to take the plunge. It's pretty good, and by far the best part are the color cover pages that are in the style of American comic books.

Frog Girl is prime waifu material as well, I guess
 

Lain

Member
From The New World Volume 7 [END]
5Anb.jpg


I didn't like the little skips toward the end (during Squealer's trial, for example, or when Satoru is going to reveal the truth about the morph rats and what he says is skipped over only to be revealed some pages letter in a flashback as Saki is wondering if Squealer knew the truth). some of them work with the narration, some others feel a bit cheap.

The manga had a lot of yuri fanservice that could have been shortened without losing much but it didn't really cheapen the worth of story. In a way it helped to also highlight how the tampering with the youngster still left them a bit fucked up, though one could also argue that maybe it wasn't needed. Still, it was nice eyecandy.

I never realized, while watching the anime, that Maria and Mamoru's child was a boy. The long hair and cute face had me believe he was a she. Felt like a surprise actually.

I really disliked Squealer watching the anime, but after reading the manga, I felt like I could understand him a bit more. He did despicable things but then, which person doesn't commit despicable things during revolution? As usual, it's the winner that decides who's wrong and who's right (and in this case it's even more true because of the past as well). Squealer lost, so he was in the wrong, but I have to admire the sort of dignity he still kept while proclaiming I'm neither an animal nor your slave! We are human. Did he know the truth? I think he just understood it, more than knowing it.

I didn't completely get the last page. Is Saki speaking to me, the reader? Is the person taking up her manuscript supposed to be me, the reader? I'm not sure, but it's a nice way to conclude I guess. Personally I prefer it when an end isn't too open, but I'm gonna be OK with this.

The reunion between ghost Maria/Mamoru and their son was great.
 
Iberiko Pork 3
B9flXV_CMAAoEo5.png:large


Pretty great second story in this anthology. Sure its not as crazy as the earlier folks in their breeding pen but its a really good stalker type story that has a great and fun outcome. Yoshimune is really attractive and I love that he is willing to go this far for a friend. I also love their final big scene. He looked incredible.
 
Damn, Terra Formars got pounded hard on that off-topic thread.

Didn't realize it's such a hated piece of work. I find it entertaining to read.

Terraformars manga is incredible and the anime is pretty good since animated Marcos and Alex K Stewart gave it the best moments. Ah and KENN voiced Alex K Stewart.

But I find much of the series entertaining parts are just in the human v human affairs. Roaches were good for the first arc or so but I think they are kind of limited in their importance. They dont exhibit the human condition so they are pretty boring after awhile. I think they will only get spiced up if we ever get an arc in which they leave Mars and come to Earth.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom