Spill the beans, do you think it's fun to keep everyone waiting? If you have my alignment drop the info. If you have ANYTHING useful HELP us. It's so frustrating to play with you.
What are you waiting for?
First light on the fifth Day
▶
VOTE: Crab
UNVOTE: Crab
VOTE: Crab
UNVOTE: Crab
VOTE: Crab
UNVOTE: Crab
VOTE: Crab
UNVOTE: Crab
VOTE: Crab
Behold the simple truth.
The players involved:
- 10. [m] Gorlak MINISTRY OF MAGIC; Undersecretary Dolores Umbridge, Neutral or 3rd-party? Survivor/Marker-Roleblocker/Lover❤Crab.shipping... claimed D4 {{spellstruck twice on N2; was Cruciated by Hyperactivity, was Stupefied by ??? for duration of D3}} >>N1: punished Lone_Prodigy, but failed, had been +roleblocked.DementorAura+ >>N2: punished roytheone, marked and roleblocked target >>N3: punished Christina Mackenzie, but failed, had been +roleblocked.ExpelliarmusSpell+ >>N4: punished Kalor, marked and roleblocked target
11. [m] Hyperactivity DEATH EATER; Bellatrix Lestrange, Mafia-aligned Name Interrogator (lynched D3) >>N1: Cruciated Blargonaut, learned his Role-name >>N2: Cruciated Gorlak, learned his Role-name- 18. [m] Crab HOGWARTS; Caretaker Argus Filch, Town-aligned Bad stuff Inspector/Lover❤Gorlak.shipping... claimed D3 >>N1: checked Swamped for Bad stuff, found nothing Bad >>N2: checked Lord of Castamere for Bad stuff, found nothing Bad >>N3: checked Enker for Bad stuff, found nothing Bad >>N4: checked TheAwesomePossum for Bad stuff, found nothing Bad
Take another look at the Nightly Events of D1 and D2:
---
D1 elapsed
N1 Events¬unordered
- Retroid chooses to refrain from action.
- Rynam watches Swamped for visitors.
- Rynam sees Crab visit Swamped.
- Swamped is attacked by ???; player eliminated.
- TheWorthyEdge fails to steal anything from Lord of Castamere; no item found.
- Gorlak fails to punish-mark-roleblock Lone_Prodigy, had been roleblocked by ???_'DementorAura'.
- Hyperactivity Cruciates Blargonaut; learns Blargonaut's Role-name.
- Burbeting's only action?
- Crab checks Swamped for Bad stuff; nothing Bad found.
- Crab is swapped with ??? by ???.
- Blargonaut investigates kingkitty; discovers enemy player.
- Blargonaut is Stupefied by ???; vowels erased from speech for one Day.
- TheGoddamn chooses to refrain from action. Is notified of Miracle's swap of Rynam and Burbeting.
- Lord of Castamere defends Hyperactivity; yet no one attacked, so shot was unspent, 3/3 shots left.
- Miracle swaps Rynam with Burbeting.
- Sawneeks gives Hyperactivity the 'Sword of Gryffindor'; equip fails, as Hyperactivity is not Town-aligned. The 'Sword of Gryffindor' returns to her.
- Sawneeks is poisoned by ???; will perish on N3.
D2 elapsed
N2 Events¬unordered
- Retroid fails to roleblock Miracle, had been roleblocked by ???.
- Rynam watches Blargonaut for visitors.
- Rynam sees TheGoddamn visit Blargonaut.
- TheWorthyEdge steals the 'Marvolo Ring Horcrux' from Blargonaut.
- TheWorthyEdge is poisoned by ???; will perish on N4.
- Gorlak punishes roytheone; marks and roleblocks roytheone that Night.
- Gorlak is Stupefied by ???; vowels erased from speech for one Day.
- Hyperactivity Cruciates Gorlak; learns Gorlak's Role-name.
- Burbeting is attacked by ???; player eliminated.
- Crab checks Lord of Castamere for Bad stuff; nothing Bad found.
- Crab is swapped with ??? by ???.
- Blargonaut commands destruction of 'Marvolo Ring Horcrux'; destruction fails, as it is stolen by TheWorthyEdge before command takes effect.
- TheGoddamn swaps Blargonaut with Burbeting; swap successful, takes priority over Miracle's swap.
- Lord of Castamere defends Blargonaut; successfully intercepts attack, shot spent, 2/3 shots left. With the 'Ninja' Role-modifier, his visit is unseen by Rynam.
- roytheone is marked and roleblocked by Gorlak's punishment.
- Miracle swaps Blargonaut with Gorlak; swap fails, as TheGoddamn's swap takes priority.
- Sawneeks gives the 'Sword of Gryffindor' to ???; equip successful, as ??? is Town-aligned.
---
Note these, in particular:
N1 Events¬unordered
- Rynam watches Swamped for visitors.
- Rynam sees Crab visit Swamped.
- Swamped is attacked by ???; player eliminated.
- Hyperactivity Cruciates Blargonaut; learns Blargonaut's Role-name.
- Crab checks Swamped for Bad stuff; nothing Bad found.
- Crab is swapped with ??? by ???.
D2 elapsed
N2 Events¬unordered
- Gorlak punishes roytheone; marks and roleblocks roytheone that Night.
- Hyperactivity Cruciates Gorlak; learns Gorlak's Role-name.
Hyperactivity was the scum investigator, via the Cruciatus spell. He Crucio'd me on N1... but then who did he Crucio on N2?
None other than Gorlak.
Umbridge.
That means scum knew who Umbridge was before D3 even started.
And when did Crab make his first apparent breadcrumb, the breadcrumb that he quoted right after his Role-claim, that hinted that he was apparently Argus Filch? Keep in mind, that Crab made his Argus Filch Role-claim on D3, as I've linked up, up above.
Okay, let me put it this way. There is a specific reason it would be bad for me to role-claim. I'm not going to say why, because then mafia know what to do and what not to do. What I will say is this: I have very carefully alluded to my role in enough ways a particularly observant person can make a good judgement as to an important part of it. If you reread my posts in this day carefully, you'll notice I'm actually really glad under suspiscion, and also that I know who someone is. That should be enough.
^This breadcrumb was posted during D3 itself.
Not a breadcrumb on D1. Not a breadcrumb on D2. Posted on D3 itself, the same Day of his Role-claim later on, when by that time, Hyperactivity had already discovered on N2 that Gorlak was Umbridge. Hyperactivity had undoubtedly relayed this info to the rest of the scum team, and that gave them time to formulate a fake Role-claim for one of their members in the form of Argus Filch, friend and Lover to Umbridge. Crab is a fraud.
Why else would Gorlak state that he had no knowledge of Filch in his own Role PM? Because Crab is a fraud, and scum fabricated the Umbridge-fake Filch Lover connection from their surprisingly in-depth knowledge of the lore, considering that they knew of the lore Filch's appreciation of Umbridge's strict disciplinary measures during her time as Headmistress in the books. They based this fake association around their knowledge of Gorlak being Umbridge and their knowledge of the lore, and used these both to attach Crab to Gorlak like a parasite, neatly ensuring that we would not lynch the Neutral Roleblocker out of a fear of simultaneously eliminating a "Town-aligned" investigator.
Which brings me to Crab's claim that he is a "Dark Magic item" detector; a power-claim that, I might add, only came AFTER I had outed the existence of the Horcruxes at the beginning of D3, when I had stated that the Ring Horcrux was stolen from me (by who we now know was TheWorthyEdge). Both Crab's "breadcrumb" and "Role-claim" came much later in the Day, you could say, after scum had time to weave in this knowledge of the Horcruxes' existence into his fake Role and conveniently attributing his fake power to the lore Filch's once-upon-a-time assignment of checking Hogwarts students for Dark Magic. Again, revealing a rather in-depth knowledge of the lore.
Crab is a fraud, and his power is fake; an ability pieced together out of snippets of lore and the Horcrux info revealed by me, tailored in an attempt to make himself appear useful to our secondary Win condition.
Crab's list of targets is fake and fabricated. He never investigated anyone at all, and it's so easy to claim that you investigated someone for "Dark Magic" and "Dark Magic accessories" and then state that you didn't find anything, because it is inherently understood that the Horcruxes would be fairly rare, so Crab having absolutely no positive nor useful results to share after every single Night he was "investigating" would seem believable. It's a beautifully-crafted fake Role-claim, but it is fabricated nonetheless.
And, remember most importantly of all; we still have not solved the mystery of Swamped's death, despite Rynam having witnessed Crab being the sole visitor to her that Night, N1. I have always believed and continue to believe that the simplest explanation is exactly that; that Crab killed Swamped on N1.
tl;dr: Crab is a fraud with a fake Role-claim. There's far too much convenience in timing surrounding his Role-claim, considering that Hyperactivity, therefore the scum team, knew that Gorlak was Umbridge before D3, the Day of Crab's Role-claim, dawned. There are also unexplained events surrounding him, namely him being the only visitor to Swamped before her death on N1. Crab is so obviously a Death Eater, and I regret not having seen these links before.
I have to yet to explore who else is guilty-by-association, but I believe that
Lord of Castamere may also be in on it, seeing that Crab helped to seemingly exonerate him from lynching with his claimed "power" on D2?, was it? Lord of Castamere's own Role-claim is also highly-suspect, and I really doubt that he's protected me at all, considering that I've been confirmed-by-prank-PM swapped during both Nights he claims to have defended me from a second attack/second NK'er, of which there is no evidence of either.
I also have reason to believe, that
bananaspaceprincess is also a Death Eater, owing to the rather in-depth lore snippets used to fabricate Crab's fake ID. It would also relatively explain her absence, having to maintain scum's use of lore towards deception from the base of the scum thread.
Vote out Crab, then Lord of Castamere, then bananspaceprincess. Also, I still retain my suspicion towards flatearthpandas.
UNVOTE: Crab
VOTE: Crab
~
TABLE OF CONTENTS
- The Profit of Regret, Pt. 1, Pt. 1 (Article 4 Breakdown, Pt. 1)
- The Profit of Regret, Pt. 1, Pt. 2 (Article 4 Breakdown, Pt. 2)
- The Profit of Regret, Pt. 2 (Article 3 Breakdown)
- The Profit of Regret, Pt. 3 (Article 2 Breakdown)
- The Profit of Regret, Pt. 4 (Article 1 Breakdown)
- Overworld Summary v2.0
- Your Designated Hit List for the Future (ft. NameclaimzZz) ((I still need them, keep them coming))
- Rustle Jumpscarecrow
Will there be time for everything? I fear not.
