I doubt that it's the case but I thought it was still worth mentioning as I remember someone floating that theory at some point.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The Price Is Right MAFIA edition |OT| Come on down!!!
- Thread starter Sophia
- Start date
I doubt that it's the case but I thought it was still worth mentioning as I remember someone floating that theory at some point.
CornBurrito
Member
Fucking THANK YOU vigilante. At least someone fucking listened to me.
CornBurrito
Member
I floated that theory. I said Splinter was scum, and that I thought he was bussing WAMD hard. It is worth noting that despite pushing hard for Salva yesterday, Splinter ended up not placing a vote on Salva/WAMD. Which made WAMD's lynch less likely.
I am a lot less sure about that bussing theory today than I was two, or even one day ago though.
OceanicAir
Member
Wait, why? If you're saying that you can't be scum because of WAMD's rocky relationship with Splinter, then there is no way I can (or want to) believe Splinter and Kark's disagreement was staged towards the end of the last day phase.
StarSketch
Banned
This is what I was (trying) to talk about in that post spam I made earlier.
Why was ynnek7 a better target than Oceanic?
CornBurrito
Member
Well there's one reason that kind of jumps out.
StarSketch
Banned
Someone want to come up with other reasons why scum would pick Ynnek?
The scum team could have find out he won the vig shot, so they killed him.
melonrabbit
Member
OA is a scum and won the item for investigation.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
Oh wow, finally got our first scum member. But how did they figure out Ynnek7 was a vigilante? Did he breadcrumb anything?
StarSketch
Banned
He couldn't have. That Kitchen set was today's prize.
Either A) scum picked at random and just happened to hit Ynnek
or B) OA is scum and checked Ynnek for some reason and found he had Vig
StarSketch
Banned
I think the way bidding works is this: You stay eligible for bidding until you win something or die. OA would have known Ynnek was still eligible and would have been able to check him to see if he got anything this round.
OceanicAir
Member
I only find out about my investigation after night actions are locked in.
OceanicAir
Member
I would also know that literally everybody is either eligible or has already won an item, so ynnek wouldn't even be special.
Christina Mackenzie
Member
So who did you investigate last night?
Christina Mackenzie
Member
Also did you investigate anyone on Night 1? That's when you won the laptop if I'm not mistaken. I don't recall you mentioning any investigation of the sort.
OceanicAir
Member
Who said I can investigate still? I'm am (was) a 2-shot Role Cop. Why didn't I say anything before? Because my second investigation turned up vanilla which meant a whole lotta nothing/going in circles since either A) they are mafia and it's impossible to know or B) they are town and letting mafia know they are ordinary makes the possible PR pool smaller (of course that doesn't include the fact that they could win a product the next day but anyways...) I wanted to keep the shots unclear and was actually hoping that Magnum would steal the laptop from me in hopes that he could (maybe) get more shots and if not then oh well, he has a useless item.
Anyways N2, I looked at Kark.
StarSketch
Banned
The vote record. Town Salva seems like a fair assumption now. If day one vote was between two town members, scum could've done anything with their votes. Why put all their eggs in one or two baskets, the baskets being the townies being voted out, where they can easily be found? Day one especially allows greater vote spread than other days I feel. I would not assume we find all the scum among the Blarg V dragonz voters from day one.
Interested to hear more from nin, anything really would be nice. El Topo, now that Magnum is dead, what's your plan for today?
Hyperactivity
Banned
OceanicAir
Member
I'm definitely concerned about the voters of Magnum (specifically topo), mainly because they if they thought that he was the only person keeping me alive as a role cop, then why lynch him? You would be essentially be removing the role cop from the game because neutrals are scary.
buuuut
vote:Kalor
mainly for this post
Because under this assumption how I understand it, if Splinter didn't die then we would lose after 2 mislynches which would be 5-5. I was thinking about the scum team and if they were completely devoid of role powers then having an extra member could maybe compensate. This also goes back to why people could be so eager to lynch a neutral since it is a waste of a lynch for town. Is it a ridiculously weak argument, yes! But since nobody wants to talk about anything else today you're gonna have to deal with it.
buuuut
vote:Kalor
mainly for this post
Because under this assumption how I understand it, if Splinter didn't die then we would lose after 2 mislynches which would be 5-5. I was thinking about the scum team and if they were completely devoid of role powers then having an extra member could maybe compensate. This also goes back to why people could be so eager to lynch a neutral since it is a waste of a lynch for town. Is it a ridiculously weak argument, yes! But since nobody wants to talk about anything else today you're gonna have to deal with it.
OceanicAir
Member
I'm wondering if the double bid had any effect as to whether or not bidders could know anything about each other's items or who bid on them. Also, as an aside, if you really wanted to off someone with little to no impact I'd kill Stanley.
Off my head:
1) It might be helpful to look at people whose behavior (at the end of) D3 were detrimental to town, notably those that were causing a tie or distract us.
2) OceanicAir did not get killed during the night. That is odd, given his claimed ability, but on the other hand I doubt mafia would claim name cop this early.
3) The players that became Masons and let Dusk Soldier die. Surprised they did not vote the same/Kyanrute voted Dusk.
4) Is it just me, or has nin's voting been completely useless and bizarre?
5) Maybe just me, but I'm getting odd vibes from Sawneeks. She tried to start the whole WAMD/Splinter discussions minutes before the deadline on D3.
1) It might be helpful to look at people whose behavior (at the end of) D3 were detrimental to town, notably those that were causing a tie or distract us.
2) OceanicAir did not get killed during the night. That is odd, given his claimed ability, but on the other hand I doubt mafia would claim name cop this early.
3) The players that became Masons and let Dusk Soldier die. Surprised they did not vote the same/Kyanrute voted Dusk.
4) Is it just me, or has nin's voting been completely useless and bizarre?
5) Maybe just me, but I'm getting odd vibes from Sawneeks. She tried to start the whole WAMD/Splinter discussions minutes before the deadline on D3.
CornBurrito
Member
My top 3 right now: Oceanic, Star Sketch, Sawneeks.
OceanicAir
Member
Gonna give any reasons why?
I had plans to go after you today so this just makes it easier.
Vote: El Topo
I'm kind of curious to know which quote you're talking about actually.
And yes, I did bring up Splinter/Dragonz again because Dragonz/Salva was up for the lynch and there were far too many questions floating around for that lynch to really make any sense. The fact that nobody had addressed them was odd, specifically in the case of Splinter who I mentioned towards the end I would be fine with lynching.
I want to know why you found that weird/suspicious.
Why Stan and not Nin? Who has arguably contributed far less.
StarSketch
Banned
Top 3 what
CornBurrito
Member
You could read back for why Sawneeks and Sketch.
You are a new addition, and that's mostly due to you surviving the night over ynnk who seems really random as far as targets are concerned.
OceanicAir
Member
Oh definitely, nin is just a reasonable target as Stan. Also Stan hasn't even checked in today but I was really just giving an example.
Can you give me a reason as to why I'd come out as a role cop on D3 when I'd know I couldn't be NK'd under normal circumstances, especially with no provocation? Because as far as I recall nobody had even put a serious vote on me.
I am really thinking they could also just be going for the middle of the pack since the extremely low/high posters and PRs would be more suspicious as they continue to live. Kawl/LP/Ynnek aren't giving anything from a flip. When I get home I'm gonna go more in depth into Splinter's posts.
With Splinter flipping Scum not only am I confident in my reads again but it does give us a good starting point to look at other people.
For now I'm going back and re-reading everything knowing that Splinter is confirmed Scum and looking at the interactions there. More specifically, I'm looking at the past Days with an eye on Splinter and how he interacted with Stanley, Kalor, and El Topo.
Going to also split this into parts based on which Day phase I'm looking at to make this easier to keep track of.
Day 1
Early Day 1 is, well, early Day 1. Not much to note there interactions-wise.
First instance is when I ask Stan with a opening/prod vote what he thinks of the current festivities of Day 1.
Overall it's rather hand-wavey and doesn't really say anything one way or another.
Splinter has a fun habit of creating train tracks around people and setting up chain lynches.
Interesting thing to note here is Splinter knew Blarg was Town, so the two people he threw under the bus here wouldn't have been in his crosshairs later on since Blarg would never flip Scum. Kawl ended up being Town, not sure if I could say the same about Stan.
And the first true interaction between the folks I mentioned above.
For context, Splinter brings up 'evidence' suggesting that Kawl is protecting Blarg because they are both Scum. Stan calls it out and they have this quick little discussion here.
Honestly I don't lean either way on this conversation ( as opposed to some later on ) but for the sake of cataloging Splinter's interactions it's going here.
And now, Topo/Splinter.
Splinter laments that LP called voting for Blarg to be Scummy and wonders why everyone is being so defensive and not aggressive. Topo comes in and gives his thoughts and they both go back and forth for a bit, ending with Topo claiming a vote on Melon ( which i don't think he ever explained?? at least not yet in my reread ).
This whole conversation felt...odd. Safe? Reserved? I can't quite put my finger on it.
Could be prodding a teammate to get a vote in?
END DAY 1
(fake edit)
For some reason this interaction I didn't have marked when going through and finding quotes. So this will not be in order like the others are but hey, what can you do?
So this is what actually got Melon back on the radar for me when I reread Day 1. Originally I was not going to focus on her at all and instead look at simply Topo/Stan/Kalor. But read this conversation again, this time fully knowing Splinter is Scum.
I've called this conversation out before as feeling really odd but now with the context of Splinter's alignment this feels downright Scummy to me. Scum!Melon comes in to throw some shade on a teammate and then backs out really early from it because she was unsure how to keep it going. We also get the first kind thing Splinter has really said about anyone on Day 1 and it's towards some sort of gambit Melon is playing at. Not to mention that Melon goes from not seeing Splinter's point of view on Dragonz early day 1 to being on board completely towards the end.
Thoughts so far:
Remember how I said I was looking at how Splinter interacted with everyone? Notice a surprising lack of Kalor quotes here? Yeah, that's because they never talk or interacted once throughout Day 1. Unless I missed something they did not reference one another at all. And let me tell you, Splinter lashed out at nearly everyone on Day 1 to get them to talk but Kalor is never brought up.
If Topo is Scum I don't think Melon is and the same goes for the reverse of that. I'm thinking it might be one or the other.
Stan feels weird. Feels like he sits on the sidelines and his brief interaction with Splinter doesn't leave me feeling great. My most 'null' read of the four.
Expect day 2 soon-ish. I want to have some lunch first. :x
For now I'm going back and re-reading everything knowing that Splinter is confirmed Scum and looking at the interactions there. More specifically, I'm looking at the past Days with an eye on Splinter and how he interacted with Stanley, Kalor, and El Topo.
Going to also split this into parts based on which Day phase I'm looking at to make this easier to keep track of.
Day 1
Early Day 1 is, well, early Day 1. Not much to note there interactions-wise.
First instance is when I ask Stan with a opening/prod vote what he thinks of the current festivities of Day 1.
Overall it's rather hand-wavey and doesn't really say anything one way or another.
Splinter has a fun habit of creating train tracks around people and setting up chain lynches.
Interesting thing to note here is Splinter knew Blarg was Town, so the two people he threw under the bus here wouldn't have been in his crosshairs later on since Blarg would never flip Scum. Kawl ended up being Town, not sure if I could say the same about Stan.
And the first true interaction between the folks I mentioned above.
For context, Splinter brings up 'evidence' suggesting that Kawl is protecting Blarg because they are both Scum. Stan calls it out and they have this quick little discussion here.
Honestly I don't lean either way on this conversation ( as opposed to some later on ) but for the sake of cataloging Splinter's interactions it's going here.
And now, Topo/Splinter.
Splinter laments that LP called voting for Blarg to be Scummy and wonders why everyone is being so defensive and not aggressive. Topo comes in and gives his thoughts and they both go back and forth for a bit, ending with Topo claiming a vote on Melon ( which i don't think he ever explained?? at least not yet in my reread ).
This whole conversation felt...odd. Safe? Reserved? I can't quite put my finger on it.
Could be prodding a teammate to get a vote in?
END DAY 1
(fake edit)
For some reason this interaction I didn't have marked when going through and finding quotes. So this will not be in order like the others are but hey, what can you do?
So this is what actually got Melon back on the radar for me when I reread Day 1. Originally I was not going to focus on her at all and instead look at simply Topo/Stan/Kalor. But read this conversation again, this time fully knowing Splinter is Scum.
I've called this conversation out before as feeling really odd but now with the context of Splinter's alignment this feels downright Scummy to me. Scum!Melon comes in to throw some shade on a teammate and then backs out really early from it because she was unsure how to keep it going. We also get the first kind thing Splinter has really said about anyone on Day 1 and it's towards some sort of gambit Melon is playing at. Not to mention that Melon goes from not seeing Splinter's point of view on Dragonz early day 1 to being on board completely towards the end.
Thoughts so far:
Remember how I said I was looking at how Splinter interacted with everyone? Notice a surprising lack of Kalor quotes here? Yeah, that's because they never talk or interacted once throughout Day 1. Unless I missed something they did not reference one another at all. And let me tell you, Splinter lashed out at nearly everyone on Day 1 to get them to talk but Kalor is never brought up.
If Topo is Scum I don't think Melon is and the same goes for the reverse of that. I'm thinking it might be one or the other.
Stan feels weird. Feels like he sits on the sidelines and his brief interaction with Splinter doesn't leave me feeling great. My most 'null' read of the four.
Expect day 2 soon-ish. I want to have some lunch first. :x
melonrabbit
Member
The Splinter was half meta/half gambit that didnt really work out.
Ive explained a lot of this stuff to you already. Several times.
Dragonz acted strangely in her responses to me which is why I pursued her (and for the moment it seems due to external stuff out the game) with the Splinter flip Im looking at other people.
And, no, despite my constantly asking Topo has all but ignored me on that subject.
Day 2 Begins.
Splinter quiets down a lot this Day phase so I'm going to be pulling out conversations that involve Stan/Topo/Melon/Kalor on top of all the other stuff.
Just some more stuff as to why I really think that El Topo and Melon won't be Scum together. There's a WHOLE bunch of it in Day 2 but this is the start of it.
While I do think Topo/Melon won't be on the same Scum team it doesn't mean that I think it's impossible for that to happen. Would Splinter be so bold to protect his scum teammate here and throw Topo under the bus? Hard to say really but I find this post very interesting.
Splinter/Melon interaction. Quoting here for posterity.
THEY SPEAK! And it's the only one and it's not really a conversation, just Kalor giving his thoughts on something Splinter said.
Personally I don't like it, it feels like Kalor just responded for the sake of responding to Splinter at least once.
More Topo/Splinter. As time goes on the less I think Topo is Scum based only on these interactions.
More Stantastic thoughts from Stan himself. More 'not really' giving his opinion on Splinter while still talking about him.
Day 2 End
Not a lot here, most of it due to Splinter taking a step back in activity in this phase and mostly focusing on Dusk and Dragonz.
Kalor: Scummy Scum Scum Scum~
Melon: The way Melon and Splinter talk almost make me feel like they are trying to act like they don't care about each other but still realize that their teammate needs to be active. I'm really not feeling great about Melon
Topo: Where Melon is feeling more Scummy, Topo is feeling less. This is simply based on the interactions present. If Melon ends up not being Scum then I do think Topo is.
Stan: A lot of distance between Splinter and Stan. It's very odd.
Splinter quiets down a lot this Day phase so I'm going to be pulling out conversations that involve Stan/Topo/Melon/Kalor on top of all the other stuff.
Just some more stuff as to why I really think that El Topo and Melon won't be Scum together. There's a WHOLE bunch of it in Day 2 but this is the start of it.
While I do think Topo/Melon won't be on the same Scum team it doesn't mean that I think it's impossible for that to happen. Would Splinter be so bold to protect his scum teammate here and throw Topo under the bus? Hard to say really but I find this post very interesting.
Splinter/Melon interaction. Quoting here for posterity.
THEY SPEAK! And it's the only one and it's not really a conversation, just Kalor giving his thoughts on something Splinter said.
Personally I don't like it, it feels like Kalor just responded for the sake of responding to Splinter at least once.
More Topo/Splinter. As time goes on the less I think Topo is Scum based only on these interactions.
More Stantastic thoughts from Stan himself. More 'not really' giving his opinion on Splinter while still talking about him.
Day 2 End
Not a lot here, most of it due to Splinter taking a step back in activity in this phase and mostly focusing on Dusk and Dragonz.
Kalor: Scummy Scum Scum Scum~
Melon: The way Melon and Splinter talk almost make me feel like they are trying to act like they don't care about each other but still realize that their teammate needs to be active. I'm really not feeling great about Melon
Topo: Where Melon is feeling more Scummy, Topo is feeling less. This is simply based on the interactions present. If Melon ends up not being Scum then I do think Topo is.
Stan: A lot of distance between Splinter and Stan. It's very odd.
Yo CornBro, got a question for you.
Star and I have been in your Top 3 Scum list since early Day 2 ( the quote above ) and yet you never voted for either of us despite being in your Top list. Why? During the last day phase you even had a chance to vote for me and push for my lynch yet you didn't.
I know, I'm just pointing it out again since Splinter flipped Scum. Gives a new perspective on it.
Mind if I ask what other people you are looking at?
And Topo never fully explaining why he voted you is partially why I think he is Scum and even a little why I think you might both be Scum together.
melonrabbit
Member
Fair enough. How are you feeling about Kyan?
OA, Stan, Kark and yourself.
There's a few others coasting in the middle as well. But this is where I'm focusing for the moment.
What about that post makes you want to vote for me? You highlight part of it and discuss that assumption but I don't know what point you are trying to make.
Day 3.
Author's Note: I'm getting a little sidetracked with this one so I might have missed some stuff. Mostly looked at Splinter here since I was starting to get lazy as well. :x
More shade on Splinter via Topopopo.
Could be Scum teammate throwing shade on their teammate but, like I said in the day 2 analysis, I'm thinking Topo isn't Scum.
HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM.
The first active Defense from Splinter I've seen since Melon.
Scum in the inactives, maybe?
Melon more than ready to jump onto that Dragonz/Salva train.
This is in response to Splinter's explanation for why we should lynch Dragonz/Salva. Again, a lot of eagerness to follow Splinter into this lynch.
Shade +2.
This is one of the few things Splinter does after Kyan and I revealed we were Masons. Do note that Splinter does not actively discuss the Mason scenario AT ALL, something I find very weird. This is partially why I didn't go for Salva at the end of Day 3 because Splinter was really starting to act odd and not at all himself, it felt Scummy.
I also bring this up for the people who believe Kark might be Scum. If you don't believe Splinter would bus Scum!Salva, why would you believe he would go in attacking Scum!Kark?
And the vote that makes me hesitate. Or at least it's the vote that made Melon hesitate.
Hey Melon, can you explain both of these votes? If you had enough suspicion to vote for Splinter here why did you turn around and go for the person Splinter had been trying to get lynched all game?
Day 3 End.
Final Thoughts:
Scum list in order of most scummy to least:
Kalor ( If I have any say in it, Kalor gets lynched today )
Melon
Stan
Topo
I have already given my thoughts on Kalor the last Day phase when I went through his posts and my thoughts have only been reinforced by looking at his and Splinter's interactions.
Melon has held my suspicions off and on all game but after seeing how she and Splinter acted I'm more inclined to believe she is Scum. Her willingness to follow Splinter is rather odd and the vote on Day 3 towards the end is weird all around. Not to mention that Day 1 vote on Splinter just oozes scum to me.
Stan has been on the sidelines most of the game and his dodging of Splinter has caught my attention. I also noticed he and Kalor never interact really either, although I don't want to state this as fact until Kalor flips as I could be wrong.
Topo still feels odd to me. He typically plays against the grain and this instance is no different, yet I can't shake the feeling something is wrong here. I still think if Melon is Town then Topo is Scum or if Melon is Scum then Topo is Town. However, they could both be Scum and are simply fighting in order to keep distance on each other but I find this rather unlikely. The only reason I bring it up is because despite them both fighting on Day 2 there is never a massive push for either lynch, something which Scum could easily latch on to in order to cause a mislynch yet this did not happen.
Author's Note: I'm getting a little sidetracked with this one so I might have missed some stuff. Mostly looked at Splinter here since I was starting to get lazy as well. :x
More shade on Splinter via Topopopo.
Could be Scum teammate throwing shade on their teammate but, like I said in the day 2 analysis, I'm thinking Topo isn't Scum.
HMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM.
The first active Defense from Splinter I've seen since Melon.
Scum in the inactives, maybe?
Melon more than ready to jump onto that Dragonz/Salva train.
This is in response to Splinter's explanation for why we should lynch Dragonz/Salva. Again, a lot of eagerness to follow Splinter into this lynch.
Shade +2.
This is one of the few things Splinter does after Kyan and I revealed we were Masons. Do note that Splinter does not actively discuss the Mason scenario AT ALL, something I find very weird. This is partially why I didn't go for Salva at the end of Day 3 because Splinter was really starting to act odd and not at all himself, it felt Scummy.
I also bring this up for the people who believe Kark might be Scum. If you don't believe Splinter would bus Scum!Salva, why would you believe he would go in attacking Scum!Kark?
And the vote that makes me hesitate. Or at least it's the vote that made Melon hesitate.
Hey Melon, can you explain both of these votes? If you had enough suspicion to vote for Splinter here why did you turn around and go for the person Splinter had been trying to get lynched all game?
Day 3 End.
Final Thoughts:
Scum list in order of most scummy to least:
Kalor ( If I have any say in it, Kalor gets lynched today )
Melon
Stan
Topo
I have already given my thoughts on Kalor the last Day phase when I went through his posts and my thoughts have only been reinforced by looking at his and Splinter's interactions.
Melon has held my suspicions off and on all game but after seeing how she and Splinter acted I'm more inclined to believe she is Scum. Her willingness to follow Splinter is rather odd and the vote on Day 3 towards the end is weird all around. Not to mention that Day 1 vote on Splinter just oozes scum to me.
Stan has been on the sidelines most of the game and his dodging of Splinter has caught my attention. I also noticed he and Kalor never interact really either, although I don't want to state this as fact until Kalor flips as I could be wrong.
Topo still feels odd to me. He typically plays against the grain and this instance is no different, yet I can't shake the feeling something is wrong here. I still think if Melon is Town then Topo is Scum or if Melon is Scum then Topo is Town. However, they could both be Scum and are simply fighting in order to keep distance on each other but I find this rather unlikely. The only reason I bring it up is because despite them both fighting on Day 2 there is never a massive push for either lynch, something which Scum could easily latch on to in order to cause a mislynch yet this did not happen.
Better. After going through the game I noticed that both Splinter and Kyan never really agreed with one another and Kyan has been rather open about his Scum read on Splinter. However I also know Kyan is supposed to be able to play a very convincing Scum game so I don't think it's very indicative of anything, it more or less helps my gut read.
Can I ask why me and not Kyan? Also for Stan since I don't think you ever really gave your read on him. :x
CornBurrito
Member
Sure.
My top topmost scum was Splinter. I was less sure about you and even less sure about Star Sketch. Yesterday I did consider voting for you, as I noticed Splinter did not place a vote on you at any point. However I felt that getting rid of a neutral (who has no killing power) was a bad move, and given that I also thought Splinter was bussing WAMD/Salva, it made far more sense for me to vote for Salva than you.
CornBurrito
Member
But anyway, yeah.
Vote: Sawneeks
Vote: Sawneeks
melonrabbit
Member
My vote for Splinter needs a bit of context because it does look random. But suffice it to say that his behavior has felt a little off to me, very detached from the game at large and exiting that town leadership role he put himself in. It was hard for me to place what exactly was bothering me in towards the end of D3 and I throw the vote out because I had a gut feeling that I was reading the situation wrong prior. If our vig hadn't come through I would have splinter at the top of my scum today.
I should note I'm being a little vague because I don't know what is appropriate or not to say regarding the Mini Mafia II game that just ended.
I switched my vote because of the tie. I believed there was still a chance that maybe WAMD/Salva was scum too and to close that loop.
As I've said, I'm looking at other people for the moment.
Stan is definitely a blind spot and I'm starting to wonder if that is intentional.
As for 'why you, not Kyan' I'm not not looking at him -- you are just far more interesting.
I should note I'm being a little vague because I don't know what is appropriate or not to say regarding the Mini Mafia II game that just ended.
I switched my vote because of the tie. I believed there was still a chance that maybe WAMD/Salva was scum too and to close that loop.
As I've said, I'm looking at other people for the moment.
Stan is definitely a blind spot and I'm starting to wonder if that is intentional.
As for 'why you, not Kyan' I'm not not looking at him -- you are just far more interesting.
melonrabbit
Member
I thought you were voting Topo today why is he at the bottom of your list suddenly?
Honestly seems like you are trying to bus here.
OceanicAir
Member
That you may have more info on the makeup of the scum team? Because assuming that we have 5 scum is kinda strange.
So the Splinter vote was to.....?
He wasn't going to be lynched yesterday and with how late your vote was I'm trying to understand what you planned to accomplish with it.
D'awww stop it, you're making me blush.
Topo was my original target for today until I went back and reread everything. My feelings stemmed from his actions at the end of the previous Day phase and when I I tried to remember what he did I couldn't come up with anything. The only reason my vote is still on him is because I'm waiting to hear back and then I will go from there.
Can the bus have flames on the side and monster truck wheels?
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
woops i thought the day would start today, not yesterday.
yeah the obvious thing to take from Splinters flip is that that salva is town. which is a sentiment i agree with, but we have seen balls out full steam ahead bussing before (i can personally think of a game iv lost because of it) so ruling salva completely out is something i would urge people not to do.
im surprised that noone seems to even be mentioning nin, considering how conspicuously inactive he is.
.
i would be lying if I said i had any strong scum targets in mind, only vauge ideas on who to look at to try to get a better read on.
yeah the obvious thing to take from Splinters flip is that that salva is town. which is a sentiment i agree with, but we have seen balls out full steam ahead bussing before (i can personally think of a game iv lost because of it) so ruling salva completely out is something i would urge people not to do.
im surprised that noone seems to even be mentioning nin, considering how conspicuously inactive he is.
(Hi mr kettle, im pot!)
i would be lying if I said i had any strong scum targets in mind, only vauge ideas on who to look at to try to get a better read on.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
eh, scratch that.
VOTE: Sawneeks
VOTE: Sawneeks
Taking Kyanrute's picture, this is how nin ultimately voted:
D1: WAMD
D2: No vote
D3: No vote
From the active players he also has the third-least amount of posts. I had to look that up, because apparently Stanley and Kawl are in this game? Huh.
StanleyPalmtree
Banned
i have less than nin?
shit i didnt think it was that bad.
also isnt kawl dead?
shit i didnt think it was that bad.
also isnt kawl dead?
Similar threads
- Poll
- Poll