yeah.Is the same critic i made.The lack of apropiated physic reaction to shoots,above all with the pistol, is what makes shooting lack punching and is why i understand some of the criticism to shooting mechanics.In TLOU this was not the case.Shooting was satisfying, because enemies were less bullet sponges and so there were faster reactions to bullet impacts(i dont rember if there was also blood splashes).
He shoots the guy 4 times, and 3 of those times hit him in his vest and the other on his shoulder.
edit: I am sure a headshot would have taken the guy down in one.