I still don't see it. And if anything it doesnt' seem coordinated at all:
Nomadic ask first:
Natiko voted:
You answered:
Natiko keeps pushing the discussion forward:
Nomadic drops it and change his vote:
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Love Boat 2 [Mafia] |OT| Electric Boogalove
- Thread starter Burbeting
- Start date
I still don't see it. And if anything it doesnt' seem coordinated at all:
Nomadic ask first:
Natiko voted:
You answered:
Natiko keeps pushing the discussion forward:
Nomadic drops it and change his vote:
I kinda sorta buy into Flush_monkey's assessment on their reaction to silence, and I kinda sorta buy Kark's argument on Trig4on
I'm looking back at the vote on D2 after all the flips and have some doubts:
DAY 2 FINAL VOTE TALLY:
kitsunelaine & flatearthpandas (9)
Ty4on 1893
franconp 2119
WhereAreMahDragonz 2278 TOWN
CrimsonFist 2351
Sophia 2411
Sorian 2544
nin1000 2551 TOWN
Trigger 2559
Xbro 2561
Sawneeks & Sorian (5)
flatearthpandas 2393 SCUM
Ourobolus 2435 TOWN
Darryl 2472 TOWN
Royal_Flush 2546
Verelios 2563 TOWN
Ourobolus & kingkitty (3)
Nomadic Sparks 2269
Sawneeks 2405
StarSketch 2564 TOWN
Darryl & nin1000 (2)
Muffin1611 2307
Samuraischnecke 2439
Trigger & Ty4on (2)
Natiko 1933
Karkador 2514
franconp & Dr. Worm (1)
kitsunelaine 2066 SCUM
Xbro & Karkador (1)
kingkitty 2321 TOWN
No active vote for Day 2: TsuXna, CzarTim, Dr. Worm (has previously voted)
This is the vote for D2 with all the aligments that we already know. Looking at that is most likely that there was some bussing on FEP/Kitsune. Or at least not a solid effort to save them. The other pair in the chopping block was Ouro/Kitty and most of the vote there was town. Besides FEP and Royal (who we still don't know the aligment) all of the rest are confirmed townies. Royal can you explain your vote there? If there was an attempt to save FEP/Kitsune has to be your vote there. Your vote made Kitsune/FEP with 6 vs Sorian/Sawneeks with 5 with 6 minutes left before deadline.
Sawneeks vote is also interesting. She voted Ouro to tie Kitsune. This vote was early and there was still lot of time left until deadline. Why didn't you move your vote when they weren't gaining any traction?
Both Muffin and Samurai voted Darryl and parked their vote there. Not much to do when both of them aren't here.
Natiko also made an early vote and parked it. Kark vote kinda make me feel better about him. He made a vote on Ty half and hour before day end and left it there even when there was no traction on that lynch. He posted several time after that (his last post was 5 minutes before day end). Also in his post he says that he prefer to see and Kitsune lynch than an Ouro lynch. This is a dangerous statement to do if you are scum. It prevents you to try to save your partner if you have the chance.
After that there is not much else. Kitsune voted for us. KK voted for Kark and he was town. Tsuna and Czar didn't posted and were replaced. I already know Dr. Worm aligment so I don't need to analize his vote.
DAY 2 FINAL VOTE TALLY:
kitsunelaine & flatearthpandas (9)
Ty4on 1893
franconp 2119
WhereAreMahDragonz 2278 TOWN
CrimsonFist 2351
Sophia 2411
Sorian 2544
nin1000 2551 TOWN
Trigger 2559
Xbro 2561
Sawneeks & Sorian (5)
flatearthpandas 2393 SCUM
Ourobolus 2435 TOWN
Darryl 2472 TOWN
Royal_Flush 2546
Verelios 2563 TOWN
Ourobolus & kingkitty (3)
Nomadic Sparks 2269
Sawneeks 2405
StarSketch 2564 TOWN
Darryl & nin1000 (2)
Muffin1611 2307
Samuraischnecke 2439
Trigger & Ty4on (2)
Natiko 1933
Karkador 2514
franconp & Dr. Worm (1)
kitsunelaine 2066 SCUM
Xbro & Karkador (1)
kingkitty 2321 TOWN
No active vote for Day 2: TsuXna, CzarTim, Dr. Worm (has previously voted)
This is the vote for D2 with all the aligments that we already know. Looking at that is most likely that there was some bussing on FEP/Kitsune. Or at least not a solid effort to save them. The other pair in the chopping block was Ouro/Kitty and most of the vote there was town. Besides FEP and Royal (who we still don't know the aligment) all of the rest are confirmed townies. Royal can you explain your vote there? If there was an attempt to save FEP/Kitsune has to be your vote there. Your vote made Kitsune/FEP with 6 vs Sorian/Sawneeks with 5 with 6 minutes left before deadline.
Sawneeks vote is also interesting. She voted Ouro to tie Kitsune. This vote was early and there was still lot of time left until deadline. Why didn't you move your vote when they weren't gaining any traction?
Both Muffin and Samurai voted Darryl and parked their vote there. Not much to do when both of them aren't here.
Natiko also made an early vote and parked it. Kark vote kinda make me feel better about him. He made a vote on Ty half and hour before day end and left it there even when there was no traction on that lynch. He posted several time after that (his last post was 5 minutes before day end). Also in his post he says that he prefer to see and Kitsune lynch than an Ouro lynch. This is a dangerous statement to do if you are scum. It prevents you to try to save your partner if you have the chance.
After that there is not much else. Kitsune voted for us. KK voted for Kark and he was town. Tsuna and Czar didn't posted and were replaced. I already know Dr. Worm aligment so I don't need to analize his vote.
hey_monkey
Banned
I dunno when Flush will be back but I know he's talked about that vote here and also in our chat. Mentioned it above too. He scumread XKark and so voted there and then silenced them. I would not have agreed had I been here I think but he was consistent and I know at the time had some uncertainty because in the chat he lamented the absence of a partner to discuss it with.
I'm sorry to answer for him but we are in way different time zones and I'm not sure when he goes inactive for the night but this is what I know and I'm sure he will clarify for you if you have questions or if I got something wrong.
I'm sorry to answer for him but we are in way different time zones and I'm not sure when he goes inactive for the night but this is what I know and I'm sure he will clarify for you if you have questions or if I got something wrong.
Looking at Kitsune's votes. I wont' add mine as I see no point to it. I already know my aligmetn. Besides that it's pretty obvious why I voted for them:
This was an early vote. Ty parked the vote there. It's mostly related to the WAMD vs Kitsune. Ty also voted for Kitsune day 1. Looking it like this it could easily be scum busing a partner.
Crimson voted here without much explanation. Looking back some posts he didn't adressed much about Kitsune before the vote. There were just a couple of light questions but never a real interest. His jumping on the lynch is weird.
Sophia votes after that and she claims that she is voting with her partner. Sophia did try to engage in a discussion with Kitsune. This vote is a little bit better than the one before.
Sorian claims self preservation. At the time of the vote was Kitsune 5 Sorian 4 so it's logic. This vote is NAI. Sorian went pretty hard on Kitsune and FEP but also tried to get Ouro lynched.
After this Nin voted and made a difference of 7-5
Trigger never adressed Kitsune or FEP. He also kinda jumps on the vote. At that point it was 7-5 with 3 minutes left in the clock. If scum hoped to save Kitsune this would be the time to do it.
Xbro also jumped on the lynch without talking about Kitsune before. This was the last vote almost at the same time as Trigger. At this point the lynch was a done deal so it can be an easy bus.
To me the most likely bus there are Crimsophia votes or Xbro vote. Ty could be an early bus but Trigger vote seems less likely as a bus (unless Sorian is scum and they just decided to lynch the one with the worst role).
This was an early vote. Ty parked the vote there. It's mostly related to the WAMD vs Kitsune. Ty also voted for Kitsune day 1. Looking it like this it could easily be scum busing a partner.
Crimson voted here without much explanation. Looking back some posts he didn't adressed much about Kitsune before the vote. There were just a couple of light questions but never a real interest. His jumping on the lynch is weird.
Sophia votes after that and she claims that she is voting with her partner. Sophia did try to engage in a discussion with Kitsune. This vote is a little bit better than the one before.
Sorian claims self preservation. At the time of the vote was Kitsune 5 Sorian 4 so it's logic. This vote is NAI. Sorian went pretty hard on Kitsune and FEP but also tried to get Ouro lynched.
After this Nin voted and made a difference of 7-5
Trigger never adressed Kitsune or FEP. He also kinda jumps on the vote. At that point it was 7-5 with 3 minutes left in the clock. If scum hoped to save Kitsune this would be the time to do it.
Xbro also jumped on the lynch without talking about Kitsune before. This was the last vote almost at the same time as Trigger. At this point the lynch was a done deal so it can be an easy bus.
To me the most likely bus there are Crimsophia votes or Xbro vote. Ty could be an early bus but Trigger vote seems less likely as a bus (unless Sorian is scum and they just decided to lynch the one with the worst role).
Actually I did mention kitsune earlier. This post:
is where I mentioned the scum lean prior.
Right now I don't have solid read on anyone. I find your partner scummy as he is trying really hard to not participate in any discussion. He seems extremely cautious for a townie.
Crimsophia is bugging me lately. They started really strong but lost force during the game. Right now Sophia is just jumping around and changing her reads and throwing shade around but it doesn't seem like scumhunting at all. Crimson kinda progressively dissapeared. He was very strong at the start but I can't remember anything about him after D2.
Racorhs is also playing really weak. I don't think they have said anything important in the game so far. The previous pair was also suspicious but the way they dropped the game looks more as frustrated townie than scum. But that's the only thing that I find kinda townie there, not enought to not scum read them.
Royal_Flush
Member
I feel like I explained this at least five times already. If you read the posts before the vote you'll see that I've been doubting everything and everybody. I had no clue what was the better lynch. So I "played the Sorian" by bringing the vote close to a tie. The motivation was the same that Sorian gave for his vote on Orb on D1, namely to force more people to vote.
A bit late to the party, but you came to essentially the same exact conclusion I did when I did this analysis and came in and voted for Sophia/Crimson D4 lol
Huh, didn't think I'd ever see nomad's unique style of play described as cautious.
Sorian/Sawneeks - who do you scumread beyond rac/acohrs? You may have said already and I forgot.
I missed that one.
I already read that explanation but I still don't like the vote.
I don't know if cautious is the word. I just think that he is avoiding any kind of confrontation. He comes, makes a few posts but never answer any question. Everytime someone tried to engage in a discussion with him he just keep going with his weird posts.
I feel better about you but if I learned anything about Persona is that I don't trust you.
But he does just play that way. Just like Star just plays her own way. That was kind of the point of yesterday. Don't think I quoted anymore from the Nomadic saga but as frustrating as he is being, bored townie is very clearly the answer.
I'm surprised no one else quoted this. You realize you don't really confirm either of those things? We already knew Flush silenced Ouro, that isn't new and you could just be copying info from the thread and saying that Darryl targeted me to be lynched is probably the most believable observation to make ever.
Are you insinuating that I haven't been blocking the people I said I have or just less believable in terms of alignment? I understand the second but you can't seriously be trying to still throw that weird shade pretending that I didn't really block Ouro two nights in a row.
I still see no world where Burb put four scum in the game. Four is the number I would try to fear monger on town if I was scum or neutral, that's what I did in Arkham (not saying you're scum, more saying that I usually have a good count for this type of thing).
Yes, but we both commented our thoughts on Star/AB, I don't think you did?
Not game related but it's really a good strategy, more people should do it.
Anything to foster more votes from this community is A+.
Anything to foster more votes from this community is A+.
Role cop looks likely imo.
I'm not sure that role cop off sets a town roleblock, a tracker, a virgin that can't be disabled by scum, a silencer, whatever Darryl would be classified as, and a mailman.
YesNOnoNOYes
Member
DAY 5 CURRENT VOTE TALLY:
hey_monkey & Royal_Flush (2)
acohrs 4234
Nomadic Sparks 4245
rac & acohrs (2)
Sawneeks 4091
Sorian 4098
No Lynch (1)
Natiko 4233
Sawneeks & Sorian (1)
rac 4264
Xbro & Karkador (1)
Ty4on 4235
Natiko & Nomadic Sparks (1)
franconp 4165
No active vote for Day 5: CrimsonFist, Dr. Worm, hey_monkey, Karkador, Royal_Flush (has previously voted), Sophia, Trigger, Xbro
Day 5 Postcount: acohrs 24, CrimsonFist 11, Dr. Worm 12, franconp 23, hey_monkey 32, Karkador 7, Natiko 25, Nomadic Sparks 22, rac 10, Royal_Flush 13, Sawneeks 11, Sophia 31, Sorian 23, Trigger 5, Ty4on 33, Xbro 11
Day 5 ends:
Automated vote tally here
9 votes for majority
hey_monkey & Royal_Flush (2)
acohrs 4234
Nomadic Sparks 4245
rac & acohrs (2)
Sawneeks 4091
Sorian 4098
No Lynch (1)
Natiko 4233
Sawneeks & Sorian (1)
rac 4264
Xbro & Karkador (1)
Ty4on 4235
Natiko & Nomadic Sparks (1)
franconp 4165
No active vote for Day 5: CrimsonFist, Dr. Worm, hey_monkey, Karkador, Royal_Flush (has previously voted), Sophia, Trigger, Xbro
Day 5 Postcount: acohrs 24, CrimsonFist 11, Dr. Worm 12, franconp 23, hey_monkey 32, Karkador 7, Natiko 25, Nomadic Sparks 22, rac 10, Royal_Flush 13, Sawneeks 11, Sophia 31, Sorian 23, Trigger 5, Ty4on 33, Xbro 11
Day 5 ends:
Automated vote tally here
9 votes for majority
hey_monkey
Banned
So what you're saying is that about a quarter of the game did not vote for the scum that got lynched that day but Flush is the suspicious one. Why, exactly? Whoops, people were wrong. We also all voted for a bunch of townies.
Look, man, I get it. I don't have a lot to latch onto in this game either. But Flush and I rolled out our claim, we've been open, there's nothing on the board to contradict our claim, and our role would be dumb for scum in this game. Obviously I'm biased, but if we're at all close to mylo, are we really the team you want to lynch out of everyone that's left? If so, more power to you. But this feels like really flimsy justification and when we flip town, you're gonna get... what... exactly from that? That we were silencers, that we had two shots, and that we were open about our targets? How will that advance the game?
Because we have to think about that, too. How are we gonna advance the game? I don't know that I would vote Sophist or Natiko Sparks today without a very good argument on the table for that very reason - they would not advance the game.
This is also why I'm reluctant to vote Sawrian. Unless they are scum, which is possible, a town flip there would not really be super great because there are legitimate reasons to push them. They have a suspect role and they're both good enough players to pull off a town appearance. Suspecting them just makes sense. It's good play. Flipping them might not be.
hey_monkey
Banned
^^would point this out, too.
So two things here. First, we talked so much about why we silenced OK. We thought they were scum and we hoped to hit the whole scum team. That's the purpose of our role. We were wrong. So was most of the game that day. We all fucked up.
But the second thing is - and this is to Sorian, maybe - yes, I agree that Nomadic Sparks does just play the way we've seen him play. But I will say, and it's a small thing, that I have seen these moments where he is making arguments and pushing things and that's new. I think I've been in all the games with him so far. So yeah, I'm reading him as town. But today, as we near the end, I am considering all possibilities, even wild ones, and I think there is a possibility that there's something else going on. Would I vote it? Nah. Will I talk about it? Yep.
This is basically why we just read them as town after that. As above, it's possible, but it just doesn't seem likely. There were opportunities there to disrupt that no one capitalized on and that would be a hell of a bus. Like I said, that could have been why fep seemed so frustrated but it feels like a stretch.
I keep re-reading Crimson and he hasn't physically disappeared (until today), as he's been quite involved. They just don't stand out. It's a red flag. But I don't see anything scummy from them otherwise and they've had some changes to sow some dissent. I end at being really uncertain on them.
as for racohrs, I really can't tell if they're just not invested because they came in at a weird position to follow a team that everyone had a read on or what.
I stand by no lynch, but if a lynch happens today and it doesn't land on one of the most active boats then you all fucked up. There is almost no chance that one or two of the highly active boats aren't scum. If we lynch a non-entity again and it's wrong we're going to be stuck in a real dicey position tomorrow.
hey_monkey
Banned
So all of that leads up to this:
Not on the table for me today:
Dr Fran: - if they are scum, well, shit, they deserve to win. Well played. But legit have no reason to suspect them. They've been clearly scum hunting and I think their claim sounds believable for this game and with their targets. Their posts today also answered the "but I have a theory!" issue that didn't get resolved yesterday, though I'm not sure anyone else really looked at that much.
Natiko Sparks - I don't really see any reason to categorize them as scum, either. Natiko has been working pretty hard to solve the game and what's more, their flip wouldn't reveal much to us at all.
Soft maybe on these:
xKark - Scum is possible here but I think the evidence is against it, with the day 2 silence at the events that followed. I would make it low odds, but there certainly have been some moments that would make one doubt. I do think day one was weird, but honestly, I wouldn't have scumread either OrbEdge OR xKark I don't think, not over that "gambit," so I have a hard time seeing the d1 lynch as a save.
Sophist - I think scum is possible here but it means they missed a lot of opportunities to stir shit. Could be they felt we were stirring enough on our own, could be just missed opportunities, but makes them feel more townie to me. However, they have been largely noncontroversial, moreso as the game has gone on, and there is some vote weirdness. A flip would be slightly more revealing than some, but not much. However, if they're scum, I'd wonder if they were in fact scum with xBro.
Much more possible:
Tygger - man, I have beaten this into the ground. I find Trigger scummy as hell - the lack of a real trail, some of the vote placements, the missing votes, the drive-by posts. Ty too has been inconsistent, shifty, working hard to appear town but not really doing much that's townie. Me, this is my top scum read, but the fact that I seem to be in the minority has sown doubt.
Sawrian - There's a hanging issue of scum not being able to disable the virgins. Now, our power, when it hits town, is not so great. Could be that's a theme here, that we have a town hooker who needed to play cautiously. There are certain things that point to Scumrian, too - they are still alive, for instance. But it could easily be calculated in this way - we lynch them for being sus and then scum gets to kill someone else. The problem here is that they are very good players who naturally garner suspicion and I've seen Sorian play a roleblocker before and seen Sawneeks play scum and look very town. Their lynch may also be the most revealing. It's certainly the most pragmatic choice for the day. But as with StarBro, I think it might be the wrong choice. I don't think I'd stand in the way if everything swung that way, but I'm just not sure.
racohrs - just a big ol' nothing here. It was easy to scumread their predecessors but it could have been newbie stuff. It's easy to scumread racohrs, but it could be a lack of investment. Failing anything else, though, they don't seem to be scumhunting in any consistent way meant to produce results, so this may be the safest choice today... or, if they're town, could be pretty bad for us. I'm also not sure it would be the most revealing flip - we'd have to look at the slight pushes they've been making and then back at schmuffin.
This is the first time in a game I've been at a point at which I legit felt all the choices were bad. Hats off to scum, I guess. Whoever you are, you're covering pretty well, but I really fucking hope we get you.
Not on the table for me today:
Dr Fran: - if they are scum, well, shit, they deserve to win. Well played. But legit have no reason to suspect them. They've been clearly scum hunting and I think their claim sounds believable for this game and with their targets. Their posts today also answered the "but I have a theory!" issue that didn't get resolved yesterday, though I'm not sure anyone else really looked at that much.
Natiko Sparks - I don't really see any reason to categorize them as scum, either. Natiko has been working pretty hard to solve the game and what's more, their flip wouldn't reveal much to us at all.
Soft maybe on these:
xKark - Scum is possible here but I think the evidence is against it, with the day 2 silence at the events that followed. I would make it low odds, but there certainly have been some moments that would make one doubt. I do think day one was weird, but honestly, I wouldn't have scumread either OrbEdge OR xKark I don't think, not over that "gambit," so I have a hard time seeing the d1 lynch as a save.
Sophist - I think scum is possible here but it means they missed a lot of opportunities to stir shit. Could be they felt we were stirring enough on our own, could be just missed opportunities, but makes them feel more townie to me. However, they have been largely noncontroversial, moreso as the game has gone on, and there is some vote weirdness. A flip would be slightly more revealing than some, but not much. However, if they're scum, I'd wonder if they were in fact scum with xBro.
Much more possible:
Tygger - man, I have beaten this into the ground. I find Trigger scummy as hell - the lack of a real trail, some of the vote placements, the missing votes, the drive-by posts. Ty too has been inconsistent, shifty, working hard to appear town but not really doing much that's townie. Me, this is my top scum read, but the fact that I seem to be in the minority has sown doubt.
Sawrian - There's a hanging issue of scum not being able to disable the virgins. Now, our power, when it hits town, is not so great. Could be that's a theme here, that we have a town hooker who needed to play cautiously. There are certain things that point to Scumrian, too - they are still alive, for instance. But it could easily be calculated in this way - we lynch them for being sus and then scum gets to kill someone else. The problem here is that they are very good players who naturally garner suspicion and I've seen Sorian play a roleblocker before and seen Sawneeks play scum and look very town. Their lynch may also be the most revealing. It's certainly the most pragmatic choice for the day. But as with StarBro, I think it might be the wrong choice. I don't think I'd stand in the way if everything swung that way, but I'm just not sure.
racohrs - just a big ol' nothing here. It was easy to scumread their predecessors but it could have been newbie stuff. It's easy to scumread racohrs, but it could be a lack of investment. Failing anything else, though, they don't seem to be scumhunting in any consistent way meant to produce results, so this may be the safest choice today... or, if they're town, could be pretty bad for us. I'm also not sure it would be the most revealing flip - we'd have to look at the slight pushes they've been making and then back at schmuffin.
This is the first time in a game I've been at a point at which I legit felt all the choices were bad. Hats off to scum, I guess. Whoever you are, you're covering pretty well, but I really fucking hope we get you.
I agree with you on the premise that something is up in the high posters. I thought the same too that it feels similar to DR. I don't think both teams are there though. Mostly because I'm not seeing you or Flush's boat as scum. The PoE there is obvious (Sophia/Crimson) but the question still remains of who the other team is because it likely is one of the "non-entities" (in quotes because I wouldn't put anyone's participation at that status anymore to be honest).
Royal_Flush
Member
Do you not count Ty4on as high activity?
Not really, no. i realize that sounds silly since I think he's had a lot of high post count days but I think of a lot of his posts being a lot of small pecks lately as opposed to actual lots of contributions.
hey_monkey
Banned
Which do you prefer and why?
hey_monkey
Banned
1. Should we consider discussing a mass claim?
2. I'd like to see everyone's (or every team's) #1 draft (scum) choice. If you had to pick one team right now and say THEY ARE SCUM, where would you land? I'm gonna go ask Flush but I'll post mine or ours later.
2. I'd like to see everyone's (or every team's) #1 draft (scum) choice. If you had to pick one team right now and say THEY ARE SCUM, where would you land? I'm gonna go ask Flush but I'll post mine or ours later.
I can't imagine a mass claim matters at this point. I'd be astounded if all the answers aren't "vanilla." The tracker claim fills in the investigative spot I was expecting and if they are lying, someone should have counter claimed them at this point anyway.
If I want to be right? Probably Sophia/Crimson. I'm still tossed up between Kark and Ty among the lower activity posters but from the high end, they are the only pair that makes sense to me.
CrimsonFist
Member
Who are we considering to be the high activity "pairs?"
I would say Sawrian, Natiko, Ty4on and Monkey stand out to me as people constantly present and contributing, but with Trigger, Nomadic and Royal as less present.
And I guess other people are saying Sophia and I.
Of those, I think I'd most want to lynch NatikoSparks, I'm still giving Ty a pass from his push on Kitsune on day 1 and 2, in a previous game (I think it was Danny Phantom), I recall Ty defending an overly scummy looking team mate day 1. Sawrian has been discussed to death, but blocking Ouro two days still only really makes sense as town. RoyalMonkey's PR could just as easily be scum, but again their targets make more sense if they're town and I think Monkey's contributions have been good since she subbed in.
So less a scum read on Natiko and more that everyone else I can find a case for being townier.
I would say Sawrian, Natiko, Ty4on and Monkey stand out to me as people constantly present and contributing, but with Trigger, Nomadic and Royal as less present.
And I guess other people are saying Sophia and I.
Of those, I think I'd most want to lynch NatikoSparks, I'm still giving Ty a pass from his push on Kitsune on day 1 and 2, in a previous game (I think it was Danny Phantom), I recall Ty defending an overly scummy looking team mate day 1. Sawrian has been discussed to death, but blocking Ouro two days still only really makes sense as town. RoyalMonkey's PR could just as easily be scum, but again their targets make more sense if they're town and I think Monkey's contributions have been good since she subbed in.
So less a scum read on Natiko and more that everyone else I can find a case for being townier.
It's kinda weird that you excluded us (dr. Worm and I) as, counting the votes as a pair, we should be one of the 2 or 3 top posters of the game.
The reason I could see two being among the more active boats is because I'm still skeptical that there's only two scum boats left.
We can, but I would bet almost everyone left claims vanilla.
This should be clear by now but Crimson/Sophia without a doubt on my end.
CrimsonFist
Member
Guess that's what I get for going off memory rather than actually checking vote counts.
You two are probably town due to the Kitsune reads stuff though, on top of your role claim, so that wouldn't change much.
hey_monkey
Banned
Why just high activity posters here?
CrimsonFist
Member
That was the previous topic of conversation, and I agree with the people saying that there's likely scum in that pool, especially with them shooting outside of that last night.
It covers most of the players anyway, racohrs and Xbrodor are the only two left out I think. Racohrs I don't think are scum, but for slightly meta reasons that make assumptions about the setup: The conversation a while back when they were talking about possible deleted posts in their chat, would be an odd thing to fake as scum. But only works if scum only have a single chat as with LB1.
Xbrodor I thought were semi confirmed by the silencer, but Xbro saying that "day 2" covers day and night where he normally plays goes against that, I think those two would be my other pick for scum at this point.
hey_monkey
Banned
Oh, scum doesn't have individual boats on top of scum chat? Hmm. I didn't even really think about that. I just went back and looked at the discussion around that (if anyone else wants to, it starts here)
They didn't in LB1 because it would be very redundant for no real reason, that would also make little sense with your power?
If there are really deleted posts,I'd think it would have to do more with the nature of the posts (it doesn't appear they left on the happiest terms if I remember right) than for any gameplay reasons.
hey_monkey
Banned
I just literally didn't think about it. Of course it makes sense; Burb ain't trying to lock 3-4-5 individual chats for whatever reason. Or I guess I just didn't think about the implications with missing posts from Schmuffin re: scum vs town.
hey_monkey
Banned
Yeah, I'm not trying to speculate on the circumstances but in terms of meta this is an interesting angle.
The argument would have more to do with the events happening in the thread at the time. Better to leave it to things in game that we can openly discuss though.
Sawrian because I genuinely just don't trust their claim. Giving Sorian the benefit of the doubt on an unorthodox claim hurt town in Batman, I thought. What would scum have to counter the virgins and roleblockers?
1). I don't see much value in a mass claim right now.
2). I kinda already answered this already.
Why does scum need to counter the virgins? One blocked kill doesn't mean much in this game, it changes lylo to mylo and that's about it. It doesn't change the number of mislynches needed.
It refers to the two states of endgame in a Mafia game, where town only has a slight majority over the Mafia.
Mylo = "Mislynch and Lose." If you lynch town, the game is over. In Mylo you (usually, barring any second kills) have the option of no lynching, however. Opting to no lynch in Mylo reduces the amount of players, and takes the game into...
Lylo = "Lynch or lose." If you lynch town or no lynch, the game is over. You MUST hit scum for town to continue on. Barring any lucky nights with no death, you're usually stuck in Lylo.
CrimsonFist
Member
I did think that there was a chance that one of the role claims could be scum due to the quantity of claims/flips, but I can't find any strong justifications for any pair.
Role blockers serve as both protective and investigative. On top of that we have another protective role (virgins) and another investigative role (trackers), but Sawrian's targets are proven and they point more to the pair being town, plus the role is somewhat neutered by the pair being hookers.
The same is true of the silencers, with their targets looking townie and the role having limited utility anyway along with generally town reading Monkey.
Trackers could be scum and their results were all already known or unprovable so it could (unlikely) be an entirely fake claim or lying because their actual targets makes them look scummier. But again there, without trackers, town's investigative powers are very weak and Fran and Kitsune's interactions point to them being town.
Role blockers serve as both protective and investigative. On top of that we have another protective role (virgins) and another investigative role (trackers), but Sawrian's targets are proven and they point more to the pair being town, plus the role is somewhat neutered by the pair being hookers.
The same is true of the silencers, with their targets looking townie and the role having limited utility anyway along with generally town reading Monkey.
Trackers could be scum and their results were all already known or unprovable so it could (unlikely) be an entirely fake claim or lying because their actual targets makes them look scummier. But again there, without trackers, town's investigative powers are very weak and Fran and Kitsune's interactions point to them being town.
Town has an overabundance of powers here. I just expect scum to have something more than Loved to counter us.
Assuming no lies, they have negative utility. Flush blocks teammates, Sorian could disable the virgin and fran could out Sorian or Flush and make us think they were scum. Darryl also had to guess the lynch the night before which is quite hard to get right. I'm kinda surprised they did (if fran is to be believed).
Similar threads
- Poll