JeffG
Member
Nothing like consistency for technical testing. lol
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
The Witcher 3: PS4 vs XB1 video (Gamersyde)
- Thread starter viveks86
- Start date
- Status
Nothing like consistency for technical testing. lol
Maybe I'm alone on this, but I tend to notice that camera jitter while scenes pan way less when I'm actually playing games on my television as opposed to watching these streamed videos. (Speaking about previous games where this was a concern of course.)
PS4 is definitely a touch sharper, as to be expected with the higher res, but both versions look gorgeous.
Can't wait for this puppy to unlock tomorrow afternoon.
PS4 is definitely a touch sharper, as to be expected with the higher res, but both versions look gorgeous.
Can't wait for this puppy to unlock tomorrow afternoon.
So wait... Xbox One has frame rate issues and stuttering even after patch? Is there another patch coming on the 19th?
Hendrick's
If only my penis was as big as my GamerScore!
I can't wait until DF tells me if I should like this game or not.
AZ Greg
Member
Because PC gamers are upset that the developers had to cater to the lowest common denominator (consoles). You know, the same thing you were upset about with regards to Batman:
You know for someone that complains a lot about console people on PC threads you sure keep an eye and post a lot on console threads.
Lion Heart
Banned
Thanks for the NXG link, they rock. DF sucks.
They both have frame rate issues, some reviews report better and more stable frame rate on XBO (Unlocked frame rate, stays above 30 for the most part, dropping coming out of cutscenes and loading times), better lighting on PS4.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vVphjF8XCFE
Blackthorn
"hello?" "this is vagina"
Why does anyone think AO was removed in cutscenes? It's quite clearly visible in the Gamersyde video. Look at the edge of the screen as the camera pans over objects and you can see the effect fading in and out.
Can you please link me to reviews that claims XB1 version performs better?
nelsonroyale
Member
Isn't that literally the only one that has mentioned what you said? We will have to wait for a more comprehensive analysis. I put more stock in Blims opinion over this guys at present.
EmptySpace
Banned
or it stays at 1600x900 most of the time?
dynamic results doesn't necessarily mean it'll be the higher resolution most of the time and switches to lower sometimes. could be the other way around.
93xfan
Banned
Does anything constructive ever come out of these types of threads? Why can't people just enjoy what they have and leave it at that.
I know, I know, its the Internet. It just seems like there should be an age requirement.
Simple. I have both systems and i want to know which version to get. Thread whining and off topic pc remarks are the main problem in threads like these.
Did he even say that FPS is smoother on XB1? I though he doesn't compare between the 2 versions in this video.
thought I just did :/
Lifejumper
Member
Did you even watch your own link? He doesnt compare the two versions.
Agree, waiting for DF analysis, buti wouldn't put one opinion over the other. They are just opinions.
Chobel
Member
Pre-patch.
Sorry but it's hard to take seriously some random dude from Youtube that has 500 views, Blim said PS4 felt smoother to him, other than him we don;t have any valid comparison.
No df tells you the difference no one could see if playing at home and not flipping back and forth between versions then you decide if you can like the game based off that lol
Whatever makes you feel better man.
Can you stop to invent things please? There are different people who reported too to have played both and xbone runs worse, I'd like to read what reviewer reported this assumption.
Could be there is no mention of that in the video but you could be right or wrong...
It's got nothing to do with "feeling better", I was just expecting a better source than this.
Ha!
read below that post, I posted the wrong link. Below i posted the correct one. Im not inventing things I just saw a review saying the XBO runs better that all. Stop acting so defensive lolol
Dictator93
Member
Wait a minute a random YouTube video now it's considered how different legitimate reviewers? Lolol wat?
It's not defensiveness you have reported some casual impressions acting like it was tech fact. Just stop it.
Like I said, I just posted a review that said XBO is has better performance. I understand that we need a more in depth analysis, DF analysis should be around the corner so we'll no for sure. You believe who you want to believe, me, I will remain skeptical until then, that's all.
Chobel
Member
Check 5:03
>-Baron-Spamedi-<
Member
Yes. But that's the last time I've really given much thought to Batman. I haven't worked myself up into an anguished froth over it.
in fact it's so far in the back of my thoughts I don't even know when it's out.
Remind me again why the PC 'Elites' need to come into console threads with their pointless bragging?
I haven't been in the downgrade thread laughing at all the whinging no matter how funny it has been.
These threads bring out the best in everyone, laugh out loud out loud.
Chobel
Member
smh...
A review is just an opinion just like any other, you choose to believe whoever opinion you identify the most. Like I said before to Mr. Gurish,
" I just posted a review that said XBO is has better performance. I understand that we need a more in depth analysis, DF analysis should be around the corner so we'll know for sure. You believe who you want to believe, me, I will remain skeptical until then, that's all.
That's not what you said in my quote but eh.
[Call-Me-G]
Banned
Allways the same joke : 'We' re waiting for DF'
Hey, guys, if you can't notice any difference, is there really a need of DF to tell you what to think ?
Just enjoy the game. I'm tired of these debates... Here on GAF, in French Forums... Everywhere I go there are the same arguments.
Hey, guys, if you can't notice any difference, is there really a need of DF to tell you what to think ?
Just enjoy the game. I'm tired of these debates... Here on GAF, in French Forums... Everywhere I go there are the same arguments.
Glomby
Member
Maybe someone can enlighten me but it seems like a bug that the xbox one version has an unlocked framerate AND dynamic resolution. If you have a dynamic resolution system, it means when the console can go above 30fps you bump up the resolution instead. But when the framerate is unlocked you will never ever get the higher resolution because the framerate goes up.
It seems like they have implemented the dynamic resolution without locking the frame rate and therfore rendering the system useless.
If the framerate is above 30fps most of the time the xbox version should be able to run at more the 900p most of the time as well. Thats good news I guess. CDPR just have to lock the frame rate again.
It seems like they have implemented the dynamic resolution without locking the frame rate and therfore rendering the system useless.
If the framerate is above 30fps most of the time the xbox version should be able to run at more the 900p most of the time as well. Thats good news I guess. CDPR just have to lock the frame rate again.
Good edit? What you mean? I haven't edited anything.Yeah good edit there
EmptySpace
Banned
oh so no.empirical evidence but rather mostly delusions?
not to mention they always come in an obviously console comparison thread and leave a snarky remark or two just to feel.good about themselves? pathetic.
they're the "mee too" crowd in these discussions. no one invites them so they let themselves in and add nothing at all to what's on topic.
DirgeExtinction
Member
You're saying this in a...graphics comparison thread?[Call-Me-G];164277730 said:
What I have edited exactly? I just correct some grammar error my friend
>-Baron-Spamedi-<
Member
It's jealousy I think.
He sees the simple console folk enjoying games and being enthusiastic about them on their simple consoles and he can't understand how he never feels happy or satisfied because there's always one more graphic setting to tweak, one more grass texture to be improved.
It's awful chasing the dragon of performance for its own sake. Tragically unfullfilling.
Just say no to Elitism, kids.
I don't get it but whatever you want.
[Call-Me-G]
Banned
When a graphic comparison comes to a 'tie', why don't close the thread and go on something else ? Dozens of pages for nothing and a 'Wait for DF'?
I have both consoles and a 4 fps difference won't change my life.
- Status