• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

When Did You Realise Your Favourite Game Was Something Special?

playXray

Member
Or your favourite game(s).

I don't necessarily mean the best part of your favourite games, but simply the point at which you realised that this was going to be more than just a good game. I'll give you a couple of examples:

1) Half-Life 2 - Getting to Ravenholm. I loved HL2 from the word go, but it wasn't until Ravenholm that I realised it was something special. Until that point it was just like a better version of HL, with an awesome 1984-esque setting. Once I got to Ravenholm and the tone of the game changed to an atmosphere of pseudo-horror, a whole new level of fun opened up. The game then continued to change up right until the end, but it was at Ravenholm that I realised I was in for a real treat.

2) World of Warcraft - Getting the boat from Teldrassil to Darkshore. I literally had no idea how big WoW was when I first started playing it. I remember having a lot of fun playing in Shadowglen, and thinking that it seemed like quite a big gameplay map full of lots of cool stuff, including a giant capital city on the other side of the island. Someone then showed me how to get to the docks where the boat to Darkshore arrives, and I thought that was cool enough on its own. When actually I got to Darkshore, there was a moment when I took a look at the map and suddenly understood that everything I'd played so far was basically a training area, and the full game size was almost unimaginably big in comparison to this. It was around this time that some explained that the other boat docking in Darkshore took people to a whole other continent! I'm pretty sure that was the point where I became hopelessly addicted to the game, not just because it was very clever at using the old 'just a bit more' gameplay system, but because it was one of the most fun and amazing games I'd ever played.

There are probably a couple of other examples from Morrowind and Persona 4 that I can think of but I'm running out of time. So what are your favourite games, and when did you realise they would be special?

Or conversely, have there been games that you've really enjoyed but it's not until repeated playthroughs or simply upon reflection that you've realised it was your favourite game?
 
The feeling I got when I first killed Yian Kut-Ku in Monster Hunter 1. That primal feeling of besting my prey has kept me hooked for 10 years now.
 

Astrates

Member
Mass Effect for me and it started almost before it began, the menu music just sets a beautiful tone.

I was hooked after proving a certain character was a traitor and began the hunt to bring them down.

What I'd give to be able to play it again for the first time.
 

Gnome

Member
When I tried walking from Durotar to Mulgore at level 7, looking for a friend, and tried to get there by going through Stonetalon Mountains. It took me 4 hours to finally find the right way there, but it was fun just walking around. I actually felt like I was in a different world.
 

Monocle

Member
Before I'd even played it, actually. When I watched a partial playthrough of the second level of Halo: CE, I knew I was seeing something remarkable. I bought an Xbox just to play Halo and the game exceeded my expectations. What a great experience.

Another favorite of mine is Morrowind. I knew that game was special when I read a few of the in-game books and was blown away by the quality of the lore.

Lastly, there's Bayonetta. I'd played enough action games that I knew the game looked great just by the trailers, and I'm a big fan of Hideki Kamiya anyway, but trying the first couple minutes of the demo and actually feeling the insanely responsive controls confirmed all of my hopes.
 
When going into Dark Souls (my first souls game) completely blind,
this massive thing (Asylum Demon) suddenly jumps down and starts kicking my ass with a giant hammer.
 
When I climbed Gaius' column sword so I could stab his head and the music shifted to something that gave me huge chills.

When my crew was attacked and I was killed at the PROLOGUE.

When I hid in a box and a guard said "Huh!?".

When the ending came and the heroes set sail for the rising sun on a boat full of gold and the main theme started playing and I couldn't wipe the smile off of my face.

When I watched EVO Moment #37 (though it's more a genre/series than a game).

---

Man, I love games.
 
Before I'd even played it, actually. When I watched a partial playthrough of the second level of Halo: CE, I knew I was seeing something remarkable. I bought an Xbox just to play Halo and the game exceeded my expectations. What a great experience.

Another favorite of mine is Morrowind. I knew that game was special when I read a few of the in-game books and was blown away by the quality of the lore.

Both these games where why I got a 360.

However first game where I went FUNK WOW! Was playing resident evil on the PS1. Was a student in 96 and used my loan to get the resident evil deal.

The intro and then the zombie cut scene. Was in gamer spasms of joy and anticipation. Loved that game.

Nothing else was like it before
 
Persona 4 Golden- when 80hours went by in a flash and i was absolutely shocked that it felt like not even half that time passed. It didnt let up and i loved every second.

Demons Souls-
Getting to
toweroflatria1.jpg


MGS3- Finding out the truth about The Boss.
 

EVO

Member
I started playing MGS3 last night for the first time. I'm only a few hours in, but if that Bond film title sequence is anything to go by it's shaping up to be one of my all time favourites.
 

Bl@de

Member
1) Resident Evil: After the Intro with Kenneth's Zombie and the cutscene with Barry you stand alone in the middle of the mansion. When the music started playing (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HbH2nY_Dens) I knew shit got real and crawled through room by room scared as shit, never playing more than 30min (I was 10 back then^^). Took me a long time to complete the game. Love it and replay it to this day.

2) Gothic 2: No real moment. Just the best RPG of all time. I still wait for a game to top this. Nothing comes close. Witcher 3 is great but still far from the world, characters and feeling of Gothic 2. Even Piranha Bytes failed to beat their own masterpiece. Maybe ELEX will succeed. First interviews sound promising.
 
Nier is the best example of this for me - and I hadn't even started the game yet! This is the Nier launch trailer that plays when you boot the game up. Hearing Laura Bailey/Kaine's profanity filled monologue played over a black screen, the incredible building soundtrack, the horrifying creature design, the art direction... It was one of the oddest things I'd ever seen, and I'd never been intrigued so quickly.
 

Molemitts

Member
I'll talk about two of my favourites.

Dark Souls: The game completely hooked me after I first defeated The Bell Gargoyles. I was enjoying the game a lot up to that point, but when I came to the Gargoyles I knew the game was something else entirely. I was strugling with the first one on it's own, admittedly it's not a hard boss, but on your first playthrough it is still challenging. Then the second one appears and I'm thinking holy shit, this first guy was hard enough but now this is ridiculous, but I kept at it, until I did it and felt so accomplished. From there on I knew the game wasn't messing around and I continued on and on, such a brilliant experience.

There's more, though. When I finished the game, I instantly wanted to replay it. That never happens with a game, let alone a 60 hour RPG. On my second playthrough I looked up more lore, read about it online and experienced more content and it went on to become one of my favourite games of all time.

Shadow of the Colossus: This didn't actually become one of my favourites until my second playthrough. I liked the game a first, but on my second time I really came to appreciate the amount of personality and character in the game. The animations and the story completely amazed me in a way I didn't see before. When I got to the 5th colossus I started to realise how special the game was.
 

Tenck

Member
There's two things that made me realize I loved sleeping dogs. To me the way missions played out up until the end were great. I was never once bored of it and that's the first thing I picked up on. Second thing was I got to the end, felt satisfied with everything, and immediately booted up a new save and finished the game a second time. All within a week.

I've beat it a third time this year and I still love it.
 

BouncyFrag

Member
1)
2) Gothic 2: No real moment. Just the best RPG of all time. I still wait for a game to top this. Nothing comes close. Witcher 3 is great but still far from the world, characters and feeling of Gothic 2. Even Piranha Bytes failed to beat their own masterpiece. Maybe ELEX will succeed. First interviews sound promising.
How important is it to play the original Gothic first?
 

Nikodemos

Member
"The city exists in opposition to itself. It has set itself apart from the planes, yet it seeks to be everywhere at once. Its walls are doors, yet it keeps these doors locked. Such an existence tells of a thing that does not *know* itself. In not *knowing* itself, it is flawed."
 

Haunted

Member
Honestly? Basically immediately, as soon as I walked down that very first prologue level in Super Mario Galaxy.

Super_Mario_Galaxy.jpg


I had the grandest experience with it, but what it truly brought home for me was when my older brother (who hadn't been into games for decades at that point) simply could not stop playing it when I showed it to him, getting excited and happy and praising the designers, calling over his family (and eventually buying a Wii) just for this game.
 

Easy_D

never left the stone age
I can't list games for shit so have some examples of games that will never leave me

Ocarina of Time: Stepping out into Kokiri Forest and hearing the music, seeing all the little fireflies fly around, exploring and then BAM, Great Deku Tree dungeon. Zelda in 3D was amazing as fuck.

Super Mario Galaxy: I knew this one was special from the trailers, but the fact that I was actually playing it didn't hit me until Good Egg Galaxy and then it just clicked. One of the greatest platformers ever.

Final Fantasy VI: The intro sequence with Terra's theme, classic.

Metroid Prime: Doing all that stressful escaping from the space station and then landing on Tallon IV, hearing the classic Metroid theme remixed like that, raindrops on your visor, it was fucking amazing. Helped that I essentially went in cold as well.
 
World of Warcraft:

Leaving Mulgore and stepping into the Barrens with no loading screen in between.

Seriously, why don't more games (or mmos) go with the seamless world like WoW?
 

Achire

Member
Meeting The Sixth Saint Astraea and her knight Garl Vinland in Demon's Souls.
Using this a stepping stone for the "true" ending, I've always thought the Demon of the title refers to the player. Not the Old One.

Another great one was when everyone kept treating my half-orc character like shit in Arcanum, and I decided to make him a criminal because of that. Kind of "oh right, this is why racism is bad" moment for a younger me.
 

PsionBolt

Member
In Mega Man Legends, when you first reach the market. There's a can on the ground, and when you're in non-combat areas, the fire button makes you kick. So I kicked the can around a bunch. When you get it behind a counter, Mega Man does a fist pump, you get a monetary reward, and a message pops up telling you to keep your environment clean.

In Mega Man Legends, when you first reach the main town area. A truck drove towards me, I instinctively jumped straight up, and I landed on the back of the truck. The truck continued driving around without a care in the world, carrying me along. By jumping off of it, I could reach the tops of the buildings, and just chill out up there.

In Mega Man Legends, when you first enter the west section of town. You meet a troubled painter wondering what their painting is missing, and are given the dialogue options "A little red" and "A little talent". The ultimate solution to this sidequest is to bring the painter a stick of lipstick, which they use to complete their painting.

Mega Man Legends is a very special game.
 

Bl@de

Member
How important is it to play the original Gothic first?

I played 2 first back then. It's ok because you're hero has amnesia anyway^^ So everything is explained. If you played 1 you will know characters and factions because it's a direct sequel.

Don't forget to grab the D3D11/L'Hiver mods to make it look like a new game.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ctuhg8ym-Hk

But one big thing: My review is based on the german version. I don't know if G2 translates well into english because it has so many typical german quirks and the dialogue is hilarious.
 

NotLiquid

Member
The first three minutes of Killer7. And I don't mean from the moment you actually start playing, I mean from the moment you actually boot the game.

I'd never played a game up to that point that set up such an insidious atmosphere immediately, from the game's introduction, the logos, the way you navigate the menu, the chapter selection, the introduction cutscene etc. I had played Suda's following games but everyone who recounts their experience with his games kept citing Killer7 as his magnum opus. I went into this game with an incredible sense of curiosity but right before I was even asked to go through the tutorial I think I had already understood why the game was as highly revered. There was nothing like it.
 

Philippo

Member
When i reckoned i am still waiting for it with the same hype as the first day.

It still hasn't come up.

tip: it's FFXV

Also, when you enter Hyrule's Fields for the first time in OOT.
 

redcrayon

Member
Some of my favourites:

Zelda LTTP: the rainy night at the start, taking up the quest of your fallen uncle, and then the music of Hyrule castle. An hour later, the classic Zelda theme kicks in, and I'm hooked.

Etrian Odyssey: the first time I worked out where a secret door had to be down to my own stylus-drawn map eliminating all other possibilties.

Monster Hunter Tri: My first sighting of Lagiacruz at sea. I thought 'he looks scary!', then you get the 'you've been spotted!' Sound effect, and I'm running for my life, stopping to catch my breath on the beach. Then he bursts out of the water, the music kicks back in, and I end up making it back to the village with a sliver of health after his lightning attacks and tail sweep. Dozens of hours later I'm skinning the bastard, and that was about 500 hours of MH3/4 ago.
 
Top Bottom